You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@spamassassin.apache.org by Joe Quinn <jq...@pccc.com> on 2014/11/21 17:10:36 UTC

Honeypot email addresses

We are setting up some honeypot email addresses, and were wondering if 
anyone here had tips on how to include those addresses on webpages and 
other places.

We're currently going with a pretty simple <!-- honeypot@example.com --> 
HTML comment. Is that too obvious? Should we put it into a CSS invisible 
div as well? Any other ideas?

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Noel Butler <no...@ausics.net>.
 

On 25/11/2014 03:49, jdebert wrote: 

> No, let's not accomodate incompetent bulk mailers. It has never worked
> before. All it does is allow them to continue to make excuses to fail
> to do their job properly and it attracts spammers, politicians and
> other such ilk. Spammers always take advantage of negligent and
> incompetent mail admins. 
> 
> Blacklist, blocklist badly behaving mailservers, whether known
> spammers or not. That is the standard policy everywhere.

Exactly, those that care, quickly realise their error and correct their
setup, those that don't, clearly don't care, so we don't care about
them, why should we. Just like vmware in my case, it's only to me as far
as I know, so I ignore it, but one day I might just have a few too many
beers and change that ;) 

 

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net>.

On 11/25/2014 11:21 AM, Reindl Harald wrote:
>
> Am 25.11.2014 um 18:53 schrieb Ted Mittelstaedt:
>> I see people like you every day who are CONVINCED they can deal with
>> greyness in the world by a machine. Poor fools that they are, they are
>> the ones who construct elaborate voice auto responder "voice trees"
>> (press 1 for this press 2 for that) as if every single problem someone
>> could call in about falls into some neat hole.
>>
>> YO HAVE NO REASONABLE EXCUSE for condemning someone who runs honeypots
>> using addresses that you don't like when they TAKE THE TIME TO PICK UP
>> THE DANM PHONE when you call them
>
> piss in some other direction
>
> i am known as a hardliner if it comes to filters but with the intention
> to accept 100% legit mail and not throw away some percent to gain 100%
> junk catched
>
> i just explained that taking a previous existing valid address as
> honeypot-source is stuip  and why that is the case and frankly don't
> bother what you do - only if you block or mailserver because some
> customer did not cleanup / refresh his addressbook you will hear from me
> with a clear statement as well as your possible customer waiting for
> mails you block as result of "i build spamtraps with previous vaild
> addresses", that's plain stupid with no but and if
>

I have no control over what you tell YOUR customer.  Undoubtedly once 
you get ahold of me and I tell you that your customer is being blocked
BECAUSE HE IS EMAILING ADDRESSES ON MY SERVER THAT HAVE BEEN BOUNCING
MAILS FOR THE LAST DECADE you will realize that it's YOUR customers 
fault and you will help him to DELETE those stale addresses from his
address book - then you will manufacture some pie-in-the-sky reason 
about how it's my fault that he was dumb enough to IGNORE BOUNCES FOR 
TEN YEARS.

If that helps you sleep at night, so be it.  But I
think it's ridiculous and I think most people would think that also.

You might consider that once an email address is purged from my server 
that NOBODY in the world, including your customer, has ANY moral right 
to send more than ONE email to it.  They get ONE bounce mail to tell 
them to purge their address book.  But anything more than that, and what 
is going on is THEIR laziness and ignorance is NOW starting to cost me 
money, it is costing me server resources and bandwidth for them to open 
a connection to me.

In short, once they got a notification that the address is nonexistent,
they are now STEALING from me when they continue to email that address 
on my server.

> if you want to dirve honeypots create own RCPT's, domans/dubdomains and
> spread that targets hidden into websites - that's the way to go without
> risk collateral damage - feel free to ignore it but be prepared for
> complaints
>

Do you even understand what a honeypot is?  Seriously?

A honeypot is USELESS if it appears AT ALL DIFFERENT.

MY honeypots are addresses THAT ARE INDISTINGUISHABLE from all other 
LEGITIMATE addresses on my mailserver.  That's why they work.

Dumb spammers might be snookered by a bogus subdomain that is only for 
honeypots.

Dumb spammers might be snookered by an email address that only shows up 
on a webpage.

But the smarter spammers are likely going to ignore email addresses 
obtained from targets hidden in websites, and they are likely to figure 
out fake domains.

The only thing that really can fool the smarter spammer is an email 
address that is a REAL email address.  That is, an email address that 
WAS IN USE for a period of time.

When I review my logs and I see "unknown user" bounces for email 
addresses on my server that were cancelled a decade ago, in my view, 
anything sent to those addresses IS SPAM and it is going into the Bays 
learner.

After all it's not like I NEVER cycle through honeypot addresses.  As I 
said, it's an old domain.  My list of cancelled addresses goes back much 
longer than a decade. I have lots and lots of old email addresses that 
were cancelled well over a decade ago, and I only use a fraction of 
those at any time for my current honeypots.  I change them out from time 
to time.

Ted

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 25.11.2014 um 18:53 schrieb Ted Mittelstaedt:
> I see people like you every day who are CONVINCED they can deal with
> greyness in the world by a machine.  Poor fools that they are, they are
> the ones who construct elaborate voice auto responder "voice trees"
> (press 1 for this press 2 for that) as if every single problem someone
> could call in about falls into some neat hole.
>
> YO HAVE NO REASONABLE EXCUSE for condemning someone who runs honeypots
> using addresses that you don't like when they TAKE THE TIME TO PICK UP
> THE DANM PHONE when you call them

piss in some other direction

i am known as a hardliner if it comes to filters but with the intention 
to accept 100% legit mail and not throw away some percent to gain 100% 
junk catched

i just explained that taking a previous existing valid address as 
honeypot-source is stuip and why that is the case and frankly don't 
bother what you do - only if you block or mailserver because some 
customer did not cleanup / refresh his addressbook you will hear from me 
with a clear statement as well as your possible customer waiting for 
mails you block as result of "i build spamtraps with previous vaild 
addresses", that's plain stupid with no but and if

if you want to dirve honeypots create own RCPT's, domans/dubdomains and 
spread that targets hidden into websites - that's the way to go without 
risk collateral damage - feel free to ignore it but be prepared for 
complaints


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net>.

On 11/25/2014 11:24 AM, Reindl Harald wrote:
>
> Am 25.11.2014 um 18:53 schrieb Ted Mittelstaedt:
>> It is why ALL domain names that MY COMPANY accepts mail from HAVE
>> WEBSITES on them
>
> don't get me wrong but that is just stupid
>
> a website was enver, is not and will never be a prerequisite for a
> mail-domain (or mail subdomain) nor is it a MX record and if you
> *really* enforce that any sending domain needs a website at the same URL
> please refrain from maintain mailservers for the sake of mail-users
>

I don't enforce that for customers, but then again, my customers aren't
accepting email on their domains for MY company, they are accepting it
for THEIR company.

I think you badly misunderstand.  Badly.

I am not saying a website should be a prereq for receiving mail on a 
domain name nor is it a substitute for an MX - or a proper whois
record for that matter.

BUT, it is certainly something that is done by ANYONE who is NOT 
interested in CONCEALING who they are.

If a customer were to contact us and say:

"I want you to setup a domain name that we can quote-unquote "receive"
mail on, but I want our real name concealed in the whois record and I
do not want an HTTP referral on the domain name to refer to a website 
for us - and indeed we don't have a website"

I would tell them to blow it out their ass.

Because, virtually the ONLY REASON that someone wants to do this kind of 
thing is if they want to do something on the Internet that is illegal or 
highly immoral.

At least, illegal IN THE UNITED STATES and in much of Europe. 
Fortunately, I do NOT derive money from any customer in Red China or
North Korea or someplace like that where their own government is gunning 
for them.  And what I say does not apply in those countries.

But in any Free country, the are PLENTY of opportunities for a 
"whistleblower" or someone like that with a LEGITIMATE need to conceal 
themselves, to send email FOR FREE and WITHOUT INVOLVING ME.

They can go find some StarFlucks or MackyWhopper place and get 
themselves onto a free wifi then create a fake name on Hotmail or 
whatever, and send their stuff out that way.

Then when it turns out that what they are sending is stalking emails to 
some young nubile 17 year old co-ed, and the police start getting 
involved and sending subponeas, they will be bothering StarFlucks and 
MackyWhopper who might just decide that it isn't that good of an idea to 
allow any Tom Dick and Harry to get on their wifi.

Getting back to MY operation - and the operations of most of the people 
here - we are in business to MAKE MONEY.

The MORE people who know who we are THE BETTER.

We make money by SERVICING CUSTOMERS.  And that means HELPING THEM and 
THEIR FRIENDS who are trying to communicate with them.

If one of my customers has a business associate or a friend or whoever 
who is attempting to SEND THEM MAIL and it's FAILING then FOR DAMN SURE 
I want a call from that associate asking why.  So I can fix the problem, 
help my customer's friend or associate.  So I'm gonna plaster my contact 
info ANYWHERE that even an ignorant user can find it.

You sir, obviously don't view email like this.

I frankly don't know WHAT you view email as but FOR SURE it's NOT 
anything I want to be part of.

Ted

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 25.11.2014 um 18:53 schrieb Ted Mittelstaedt:
> It is why ALL domain names that MY COMPANY accepts mail from HAVE
> WEBSITES on them

don't get me wrong but that is just stupid

a website was enver, is not and will never be a prerequisite for a 
mail-domain (or mail subdomain) nor is it a MX record and if you 
*really* enforce that any sending domain needs a website at the same URL 
please refrain from maintain mailservers for the sake of mail-users


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net>.

On 11/24/2014 12:30 PM, Reindl Harald wrote:
>
>
> the world is not black and white and by *blindly* blacklist you gain
> nothing than damage
>

This is absolutely correct, Reindl.

It is why ALL domain names that MY COMPANY accepts mail from HAVE 
WEBSITES on them.

You send email to example@ipinc.net well there's a site on www.ipinc.net

You get a bounce from me or your friend on example@ipinc.net does not 
get your message - well you can go to my website and find a phone number
there to call a REAL LIVE HUMAN.  And if you have some anxiety 
psychological issue to where talking to another person terrifies you, 
why there's a webform you can post to that will go straight to a human.

That Human will take the time to explain to EDUCATE you either by email 
or on the phone JUST LIKE I'M DOING HERE about why you don't blindly 
send mail to lists your friends send you, and that by the way 
example@ipinc.net hasn't had services with us for the last decade and 
maybe you might pick up the phone and call him and get his email 
address.  AND if your a "commercial bulk mailer" we will politely tell 
you that OUR error messages ARE standardized and if you cannot handle 
bounce management by dealing with standardized errors, well we don't 
want mail from you AT ALL.

THIS is how you PROPERLY handle the greyness in the world - BY ACTUALLY 
TALKING TO A PERSON.

I see people like you every day who are CONVINCED they can deal with 
greyness in the world by a machine.  Poor fools that they are, they are 
the ones who construct elaborate voice auto responder "voice trees" 
(press 1 for this press 2 for that) as if every single problem someone 
could call in about falls into some neat hole.

YO HAVE NO REASONABLE EXCUSE for condemning someone who runs honeypots 
using addresses that you don't like when they TAKE THE TIME TO PICK UP 
THE DANM PHONE when you call them.

Ted


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 24.11.2014 um 18:49 schrieb jdebert:
> On Sun, 23 Nov 2014 11:12:58 +0100
> Aban Dokht <ml...@abando.de> wrote:
>
>>   From my opinion, this is not a good idea as you are going to put
>> those servers onto your list.
>> This way you'll blacklist bulk senders, with badly configured or even
>> not bounce management, but they are not all spammers!
>
> Oh, sure! Let's tolerate incompetent mass mailers. While we're at it,
> let's tolerate sites that can't properly manage their mail servers. And
> don't forget open relays, too! Just because they can't figure out
> how to make it work or are too lazy to do it right, we must excuse
> them. And, Free Speech, right?

nobod said that

but you need to draw a line between catch spam and force to catch any 
sender you don't know why and how the address went to the RCPT

that's far from the reality

i see again and again *living humans* continue to send to their outdated 
"best-friends" list from the MUA just because they don't understand a 
bounce, don't care enough or even be afraid remove somebody from his 
address book based on *not* understood automatic mail (bounce)

as tech user i don't understand that users behavior
at the same time i, we and our server did *nothing* wrong and if you 
setup a "spam trap" to catch that senders you just blacklist for no good 
reason

*frankly* a lot of reject messages are just too stupid for a automated 
bounce mamagement because some smart ass felt good by use non.default 
messages where even persons like me sit there wit no clue if this is a 
temporary local error at the RCPT too stupid reply with a 4xx code and 
so better *not remove it* automated

the world is not black and white and by *blindly* blacklist you gain 
nothing than damage


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by jdebert <jd...@garlic.com>.
On Sun, 23 Nov 2014 11:12:58 +0100
Aban Dokht <ml...@abando.de> wrote:

> 
>  From my opinion, this is not a good idea as you are going to put
> those servers onto your list.
> This way you'll blacklist bulk senders, with badly configured or even 
> not bounce management, but they are not all spammers!
> 
> 

Oh, sure! Let's tolerate incompetent mass mailers. While we're at it,
let's tolerate sites that can't properly manage their mail servers. And
don't forget open relays, too! Just because they can't figure out
how to make it work or are too lazy to do it right, we must excuse
them. And, Free Speech, right?

No, let's not accomodate incompetent bulk mailers. It has never worked
before. All it does is allow them to continue to make excuses to fail
to do their job properly and it attracts spammers, politicians and
other such ilk. Spammers always take advantage of negligent and
incompetent mail admins. 

Blacklist, blocklist badly behaving mailservers, whether known
spammers or not. That is the standard policy everywhere. 

You really should try admin-ing a internet facing mail server for a
while. You'll quickly realize that what you are saying here is totally
insane. Hopefully before YOU go insane.

jd


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net>.

On 11/23/2014 2:12 AM, Aban Dokht wrote:
>
>
> On 22.11.2014 22:05, Ted Mittelstaedt wrote:
>> That's a lot of work, there's a much easier way
>>
>> Just search your /var/log/maillog for user unknown messages, and
>> create email addresses for the unknown users which are showing up
>> multiple times over multiple days. It's a great trick because it gets
>> spammers who already have email addresses in their
>> spamlists and who are too lazy to remove them when they get a
>> user unknown message from the mailserver.
>>
>> I have a pretty old domain - I've seen user unknown messages for
>> users who cancelled mailboxes on the domain over a decade ago. I figure
>> 10 years of getting user unknown messages is long enough for any real
>> humans and for legitimate mailing lists to remove those entries.
>>
>
>  From my opinion, this is not a good idea as you are going to put those
> servers onto your list.
> This way you'll blacklist bulk senders, with badly configured or even
> not bounce management, but they are not all spammers!
>

Who are you I've never seen you post on this list before.  You sound 
like a spammer who is scared to death that more people will be putting 
up honeypots.

A bulk sender with no bounce management is a spammer, PERIOD.  I'll 
gladly invite any customer of mine who insists on receiving email from 
bulk senders who don't do bounce management to go find another email
provider.  Strange that I have NEVER had a customer complain about this.

I am VERY familiar with Gmails rules and Hotmail/Microsoft's rules for 
bulk senders to send mail into their network.  They mandate that anyone 
sending bulk mail to them IS REQUIRED to do bounce management or they 
will block them, end of story.

I am quite willing to accept mail from bulk mailers who follow CAN-SPAM 
act in the United States - which by the way REQUIRES bounce management -
bulk mailers who do NOT do bounce management are committing a felony in 
the United States.

Ted

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Noel Butler <no...@ausics.net>.
 

On 23/11/2014 20:12, Aban Dokht wrote: 

> On 22.11.2014 22:05, Ted Mittelstaedt wrote:
> 
>> domain - I've seen user unknown messages for users who cancelled mailboxes on the domain over a decade ago. I figure 10 years of getting user unknown messages is long enough for any real humans and for legitimate mailing lists to remove those entries.
> 
> From my opinion, this is not a good idea as you are going to put those servers onto your list.
> This way you'll blacklist bulk senders, with badly configured or even not bounce management, but they are not all spammers!

Surely though that is the senders problem. 

Also any sender - SOHO, medium or large business, government, or mass
mailing specialists, who have no, poor, or broken bounce management, do
deserve to be listed, to prompt them into getting their act together and
fixing their code. 

Yes it happens, VMware are a perfect example of this incompetence, they
still try send to an old list address of mine before I consolidated the
2 into this one, they have been getting user unknowns for about 8 years.


 

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Aban Dokht <ml...@abando.de>.

On 22.11.2014 22:05, Ted Mittelstaedt wrote:
> That's a lot of work, there's a much easier way
>
> Just search your /var/log/maillog for user unknown messages, and
> create email addresses for the unknown users which are showing up
> multiple times over multiple days.  It's a great trick because it gets
> spammers who already have email addresses in their
> spamlists and who are too lazy to remove them when they get a
> user unknown message from the mailserver.
>
> I have a pretty old domain - I've seen user unknown messages for
> users who cancelled mailboxes on the domain over a decade ago.  I figure
> 10 years of getting user unknown messages is long enough for any real
> humans and for legitimate mailing lists to remove those entries.
>

 From my opinion, this is not a good idea as you are going to put those 
servers onto your list.
This way you'll blacklist bulk senders, with badly configured or even 
not bounce management, but they are not all spammers!


-- 
  Aban Dokht                                   aban.dokht@abando.de
       system administrator of 0 day abusers DNSBL bl.dbrs.de
------------------------------------------------------------------


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 08.01.2015 um 22:57 schrieb Alex Regan:
> On 01/07/2015 02:31 PM, Reindl Harald wrote:
>>
>> Am 07.01.2015 um 20:23 schrieb Alex:
>>> I'm also wondering what exactly you're taking from these messages that
>>> are received? Are you blocking based on IP? Creating header/body
>>> rules? Those are usually transferable to other systems, but what about
>>> bayes? How can you use it for bayes when that doesn't transfer very
>>> easily to other systems?
>>
>> depends how you build your bayse
>>
>> mine is a phyiscal ham and a spam-folder with raw-mails and a script
>> calling sa-learn which makes it easy to transfer to other systems as
>> well as maintain the corpus over years
>
> It's not necessarily an issue with the bayes database itself, but rather
> the content of the database - emails comprising your ham database may
> not constitute ham for my company, for example.

your opinion

mine is
  * if it is ham and handselected than it is ham
  * if it is spam and handselected than it is spam

hence the *global* bayse i maintain for a few months for 1500 users with 
very different businesses with the help of some of them works that much 
better than the previous "light maintained" global and the mostly 
completly useless user-bayes which don't reach the 200/200 balance or 
are trained by people not understand how a bayes works

at the end of the day you need *as much as possible* samples for ham and 
spam where you trust the classification - currently newsletters are not 
marked as spam while a lot of similar *looking* messages are trustable 
blocked at milter level

>> * no databases
>> * no magic
>> * no auto learning
>> * just a global bayes with a corpus of 15000 hand-selected
>>    mails in the last 5 months with a nearly perfect hit-rate
>>    and zero false-positives highly scored


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Alex Regan <my...@gmail.com>.

On 01/07/2015 02:31 PM, Reindl Harald wrote:
>
> Am 07.01.2015 um 20:23 schrieb Alex:
>> I'm also wondering what exactly you're taking from these messages that
>> are received? Are you blocking based on IP? Creating header/body
>> rules? Those are usually transferable to other systems, but what about
>> bayes? How can you use it for bayes when that doesn't transfer very
>> easily to other systems?
>
> depends how you build your bayse
>
> mine is a phyiscal ham and a spam-folder with raw-mails and a script
> calling sa-learn which makes it easy to transfer to other systems as
> well as maintain the corpus over years

It's not necessarily an issue with the bayes database itself, but rather 
the content of the database - emails comprising your ham database may 
not constitute ham for my company, for example.

Thanks,
Alex


>
> * no databases
> * no magic
> * no auto learning
> * just a global bayes with a corpus of 15000 hand-selected
>    mails in the last 5 months with a nearly perfect hit-rate
>    and zero false-positives highly scored
>

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 07.01.2015 um 20:23 schrieb Alex:
> I'm also wondering what exactly you're taking from these messages that
> are received? Are you blocking based on IP? Creating header/body
> rules? Those are usually transferable to other systems, but what about
> bayes? How can you use it for bayes when that doesn't transfer very
> easily to other systems?

depends how you build your bayse

mine is a phyiscal ham and a spam-folder with raw-mails and a script 
calling sa-learn which makes it easy to transfer to other systems as 
well as maintain the corpus over years

* no databases
* no magic
* no auto learning
* just a global bayes with a corpus of 15000 hand-selected
   mails in the last 5 months with a nearly perfect hit-rate
   and zero false-positives highly scored


RE: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Marieke Janssen <mj...@myguard.nl>.
>>> How about using a domain specifically for creating a honeypot

>> you only need an email@address  no point in registering a domain soley 
>> for this, some might think its better, but I see no real advantage 

>This represents the largest problem I have, because any well-known existing
domain has zen running at SMTP level, which makes it impossible to whitelist
for a specific account.
>I'd have to disable RBLs at SMTP connect time, as well as greylisting...

That's one big plus for a dedicated spamtrap(sub)domain, you can move it
anywhere without postscreen/rbl's/spamassassin/whatever. Just plain mta,
accept everything and throw it in the analyzer. :)

/MJ


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.

Am 09.01.2015 um 02:01 schrieb David Flanigan:
> Excellent feature - I look forward to using it.
>
> It does lead me to another question however. Using a spam honeypot would
> lead to a large corpus of SPAM. My corpus of HAM, but its very nature,
> would be much smaller. Are there any negative implication to training
> the Bayesian filters with thousands (or tens of thousands) SPAM message
> but only a couple hundred HAM messages?

a perfect bayes has at least 50/50 percent, more ham in doubt is better, 
i would in any case re-view the messages before train them, most are 
open-relay-tests or 100% identical crap not worth to taint the bayes 
1000 times with the same copy and such crap here

below my current bayes-counts

the 1,3M "bayes_seen" is for sure a bug becuse it contains random 
message parts which leads also in not recognized already trained 
messages, hence a find with a 24 hour limt since i save the corpus forever
____________________________________

[root@mail-gw:~]$ sa-learn.sh
Replacing "Subject: [SPAM] " with "Subject: " (case sensitive) (partial 
words matched)
Replacing "Subject: [SPAM] " with "Subject: " (case sensitive) (partial 
words matched)

09-01-2015 02:32:19: Proceed SPAM Samples

09-01-2015 02:32:19: Proceed HAM Samples

09-01-2015 02:32:19: Done

0.000          0          3          0  non-token data: bayes db version
0.000          0       7511          0  non-token data: nspam
0.000          0       7565          0  non-token data: nham
0.000          0    1015029          0  non-token data: ntokens
0.000          0  993467899          0  non-token data: oldest atime
0.000          0 1420765927          0  non-token data: newest atime
0.000          0 1420765955          0  non-token data: last journal 
sync atime
0.000          0          0          0  non-token data: last expiry atime
0.000          0          0          0  non-token data: last expire 
atime delta
0.000          0          0          0  non-token data: last expire 
reduction count

insgesamt 27M
-rw------- 1 sa-milt sa-milt  13K 2015-01-09 02:30 bayes_journal
-rw------- 1 sa-milt sa-milt 1,3M 2015-01-09 00:59 bayes_seen
-rw------- 1 sa-milt sa-milt  39M 2015-01-09 02:12 bayes_toks
-rw------- 1 sa-milt sa-milt   98 2014-08-21 17:47 user_prefs


> On 2015-01-08 18:13, David B Funk wrote:
>
>> On Thu, 8 Jan 2015, Alex Regan wrote:
>>>>> How about using a domain specifically for creating a honeypot, of
>>>> you only need an email@address <ma...@address> no point in
>>>> registering a domain soley for this, some might think its better,
>>>> but I see no real advantage to it over using a well known existing
>>>> domain, infact if you examine your logs you might see one already
>>>> there you can use, for example, I use a few
>>> This represents the largest problem I have, because any well-known
>>> existing domain has zen running at SMTP level, which makes it
>>> impossible to whitelist for a specific account. I'd have to disable
>>> RBLs at SMTP connect time, as well as greylisting...
>> In sendmail, there's the "delay_checks" feature which if enabled
>> will postpone the RBL/blacklist & milter checks until after the 'RCPT to:'
>> SMTP phase. This enables things such as 'SPAMFRIENDS' filters
>> in your access DB making it possible to use RBL/blacklists/milters and
>> still let all senders get messages to specific selected recipients
>> (EG "postmaster" or selected spamtrap/honeypot addresses)


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by David Flanigan <da...@flanigan.net>.
 

Excellent feature - I look forward to using it. 

It does lead me to another question however. Using a spam honeypot would
lead to a large corpus of SPAM. My corpus of HAM, but its very nature,
would be much smaller. Are there any negative implication to training
the Bayesian filters with thousands (or tens of thousands) SPAM message
but only a couple hundred HAM messages? 

----
Kind Regards, 
David

David Flanigan
Mobile: +1.513.560.8231
E: dave<at>flanigan.net W: http://www.flanigan.net

On 2015-01-08 18:13, David B Funk wrote: 

> On Thu, 8 Jan 2015, Alex Regan wrote:
> How about using a domain specifically for creating a honeypot, of you only need an email@address no point in registering a domain soley for this, some might think its better, but I see no real advantage to it over using a well known existing domain, infact if you examine your logs you might see one already there you can use, for example, I use a few
 This represents the largest problem I have, because any well-known
existing domain has zen running at SMTP level, which makes it impossible
to whitelist for a specific account. I'd have to disable RBLs at SMTP
connect time, as well as greylisting... 

In sendmail, there's the "delay_checks" feature which if enabled
will postpone the RBL/blacklist & milter checks until after the 'RCPT
to:'
SMTP phase. This enables things such as 'SPAMFRIENDS' filters
in your access DB making it possible to use RBL/blacklists/milters and
still let all senders get messages to specific selected recipients
(EG "postmaster" or selected spamtrap/honeypot addresses).

-- 
Dave Funk University of Iowa
<dbfunk (at) engineering.uiowa.edu> College of Engineering
319/335-5751 FAX: 319/384-0549 1256 Seamans Center
Sys_admin/Postmaster/cell_admin Iowa City, IA 52242-1527
#include <std_disclaimer.h>
Better is not better, 'standard' is better. B{

 
-- 


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by David B Funk <db...@engineering.uiowa.edu>.
On Thu, 8 Jan 2015, Alex Regan wrote:

>
>>> How about using a domain specifically for creating a honeypot, of
>> 
>> you only need an email@address  no point in registering a domain soley
>> for this, some might think its better, but I see no real advantage to it
>> over using a well known existing domain, infact if you examine your logs
>> you might see one already there you can use, for example, I use a few
>
> This represents the largest problem I have, because any well-known existing 
> domain has zen running at SMTP level, which makes it impossible to whitelist 
> for a specific account.
>
> I'd have to disable RBLs at SMTP connect time, as well as greylisting...

In sendmail, there's the "delay_checks" feature which if enabled
will postpone the RBL/blacklist & milter checks until after the 'RCPT to:'
SMTP phase. This enables things such as 'SPAMFRIENDS' filters
in your access DB making it possible to use RBL/blacklists/milters and
still let all senders get messages to specific selected recipients
(EG "postmaster" or selected spamtrap/honeypot addresses).

-- 
Dave Funk                                  University of Iowa
<dbfunk (at) engineering.uiowa.edu>        College of Engineering
319/335-5751   FAX: 319/384-0549           1256 Seamans Center
Sys_admin/Postmaster/cell_admin            Iowa City, IA 52242-1527
#include <std_disclaimer.h>
Better is not better, 'standard' is better. B{

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Alex Regan <my...@gmail.com>.
>> How about using a domain specifically for creating a honeypot, of
>
> you only need an email@address  no point in registering a domain soley
> for this, some might think its better, but I see no real advantage to it
> over using a well known existing domain, infact if you examine your logs
> you might see one already there you can use, for example, I use a few

This represents the largest problem I have, because any well-known 
existing domain has zen running at SMTP level, which makes it impossible 
to whitelist for a specific account.

I'd have to disable RBLs at SMTP connect time, as well as greylisting...

Thanks so much for your help. I see now there were like 60 messages in 
this thread, so I probably should have started a new thread.

Thanks,
Alex

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Noel Butler <no...@ausics.net>.
On 08/01/2015 05:23, Alex wrote:

> 
> I have an old domain with a number of dormant accounts that I'd like
> to use. The domain also uses several RBLs, so a majority of the spam
> is rejected before it's ever received, so it's less than effective.

You need to whitelist at least the trap addresses to be effective.

> I'm also wondering what exactly you're taking from these messages that
> are received? Are you blocking based on IP? Creating header/body


Blocking by IP is the most common - providing the addresses you use as 
traps have never been used, in your case, maybe not such a good idea 
because you/someone once used them, and it might be an old friend who 
went grizzly adams for 10 years and came back trying to genuinely talk 
to you or the recipient.

> 
> Or are you only limited to gathering info based on the 'user unknown'
> messages,

Never ever do that! people make typos all the time.

> 
> Do you have scripts that parse your maillog?

twice daily, used to be hourly but thats not nice when they grow to gig 
a day per server, thinking about changing it to once a day before log 
rolls.

> 
> Do you have any type of revocation ability, to keep track of when they
> were added so they can be removed after some time?

its a bash script, that uses awk so can add dates with strftime()  so I 
know when it was added, I use this to go through and clean it up every 
once in a while (listings on trap hits stay for at least 1 yr unless I 
get delist request)

> 
> How about using a domain specifically for creating a honeypot, of

you only need an email@address  no point in registering a domain soley 
for this, some might think its better, but I see no real advantage to it 
over using a well known existing domain, infact if you examine your logs 
you might see one already there you can use, for example, I use a few 
email addresses, my private one only friends have, my list address (this 
one), my opensource contrib address (yeah its public too), work address 
(nobody has) and another for usenet, the usenet one was obviously 
botched by a spambot once and it repeated the user@ component, lets say 
it was  xyz@ausics so I always see hits in mail logs for  xyzxyz@ausics  
rather funny, but awesome, because in addition to my never-used long 
term trap addresses, I added that one too and it catches several hundred 
a week alone, obviouly spammers trade lists. So, like I said, you might 
already be seeing one you can use.

(footnote: that usenet address has been in use for well over 20 years, 
so YMMV)

> sorts? Would you create a basic webpage and populate that with email
> addresses? Then set up the mail system to accept all mail...

That can help, you'd only need a couple, and join usenet thats a good 
way to catch em. also pop  a fake email address in your sigs on some 
forums.


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Alex <my...@gmail.com>.
Hi,

I was hoping it was okay to resurrect a thread from a few months ago
and ask a few questions regarding creating some type of honeypot for
spammers.

> Just search your /var/log/maillog for user unknown messages, and
> create email addresses for the unknown users which are showing up
> multiple times over multiple days.  It's a great trick because it gets
> spammers who already have email addresses in their
> spamlists and who are too lazy to remove them when they get a
> user unknown message from the mailserver.

I have an old domain with a number of dormant accounts that I'd like
to use. The domain also uses several RBLs, so a majority of the spam
is rejected before it's ever received, so it's less than effective.

I'm also wondering what exactly you're taking from these messages that
are received? Are you blocking based on IP? Creating header/body
rules? Those are usually transferable to other systems, but what about
bayes? How can you use it for bayes when that doesn't transfer very
easily to other systems?

Or are you only limited to gathering info based on the 'user unknown'
messages, as you said?

Do you have scripts that parse your maillog?

Do you have any type of revocation ability, to keep track of when they
were added so they can be removed after some time?

Some tips were mentioned in this thread for seeding a user account to
receive spam, but there was a lot of back-and-forth, and it was
unclear to me which were really advisable. Is it advisable to use
'unsubscribe' links in spam sent to some address?

How about using a domain specifically for creating a honeypot, of
sorts? Would you create a basic webpage and populate that with email
addresses? Then set up the mail system to accept all mail...

I don't think I'm asking for anything that could cause spammers to
alter their tactics, but please do tell me if otherwise.

Sure appreciate any ideas.
Thanks,
Alex

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net>.

On 11/23/2014 2:17 AM, Aban Dokht wrote:
>
>
> On 22.11.2014 22:32, Dave Funk wrote:
>> Another way to seed spamtrap addresses is to make up some and
>> then feed them into "unsubscribe" links in spam sent to regular
>> users. I've got some of those I started that way 15 years ago
>> and they're still going strong.
>>
>
> Also no good idea, as some of them will send an unsubscribe mail to the
> trap then. The risk of false positives is very high.
>

If a bulk mailer is legitimate then they will do 2 things, first they
will verify that the email listed in the unsubscribe request exists
on their mailing list, (and if not, ignore it) and second when they
get a de-list request they should IMMEDIATELY honor it.  They should
NEVER send a confirmation email.  Sending an email saying "we just
de-listed you because of your de-list request" is perfectly fine and
if it was an accidental de-list the user can merely resubscribe.  But a
de-list request should be honored immediately.

If they can't do that, then they are just setting up barriers to 
unsubscribe email addresses from their lists, and that is what a spammer 
does.

We have a saying in the United States, Aban.  If it looks like a duck,
walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, it's a duck.

Ted

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by David B Funk <db...@engineering.uiowa.edu>.
On Sun, 23 Nov 2014, Reindl Harald wrote:

>
>
> Am 23.11.2014 um 11:17 schrieb Aban Dokht:
>> On 22.11.2014 22:32, Dave Funk wrote:
>>> Another way to seed spamtrap addresses is to make up some and
>>> then feed them into "unsubscribe" links in spam sent to regular
>>> users. I've got some of those I started that way 15 years ago
>>> and they're still going strong.
>>> 
>> Also no good idea, as some of them will send an unsubscribe mail to the
>> trap then. The risk of false positives is very high
>
> using real addresses as a honeypot is wrong, dangerous and reckless
>
> also there is no need for playing with firebecause by use virgin addresses 
> and not promote them visible or even subcribe them to porn newsletters (don't 
> laugh i heard proposals register a address to all porn newsletters you can 
> find and then start blacklisting)
>
> if you want to block all newsletters then just do it, you don't need to play 
> honeypot-games for that!

I guess I need to elaborate to make it clear exactly what I do and why there
is little to no danger of FPs.

When I said "to make up some (spamtrap addresses)" I mean make up some -new-
addresses that can -never- be used as legitmate user addresses.

In our organization we have some specific address formats that we use for
various purposes (first-last@domain.name shortname@sub.domain.name
service_address@domain.name ). However we also have some reserved address
spaces within those formats (which are administrativly enforced) so I can
create some addresses that look like first-last@domain.name but which I know
will never be used for real purposes (but the spammers won't know which they
are). I use those addresses for spamtrap addresses. (no danger of FPs there).

I then feed those particular spamtrap addresses into the "unsubscribe" links of
hand-verified spam. So only spammers will ever see those addresses anyplace
outside of our infrastructure. Thus they should almost never FP.

The only way that I can see any possibility of FPs is if a spammer is using
a semi-legit MSP and that MSP sends an unsubscribe-verify message to that
spam-trap address. That should only happen a few times at most and should -not-
have any new spam assocated with it.

So any spam sent to that spamtrap address is fair game.


-- 
Dave Funk                                  University of Iowa
<dbfunk (at) engineering.uiowa.edu>        College of Engineering
319/335-5751   FAX: 319/384-0549           1256 Seamans Center
Sys_admin/Postmaster/cell_admin            Iowa City, IA 52242-1527
#include <std_disclaimer.h>
Better is not better, 'standard' is better. B{

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.

Am 23.11.2014 um 11:17 schrieb Aban Dokht:
> On 22.11.2014 22:32, Dave Funk wrote:
>> Another way to seed spamtrap addresses is to make up some and
>> then feed them into "unsubscribe" links in spam sent to regular
>> users. I've got some of those I started that way 15 years ago
>> and they're still going strong.
>>
> Also no good idea, as some of them will send an unsubscribe mail to the
> trap then. The risk of false positives is very high

using real addresses as a honeypot is wrong, dangerous and reckless

also there is no need for playing with firebecause by use virgin 
addresses and not promote them visible or even subcribe them to porn 
newsletters (don't laugh i heard proposals register a address to all 
porn newsletters you can find and then start blacklisting)

if you want to block all newsletters then just do it, you don't need to 
play honeypot-games for that!




Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Aban Dokht <ml...@abando.de>.

On 22.11.2014 22:32, Dave Funk wrote:
> Another way to seed spamtrap addresses is to make up some and
> then feed them into "unsubscribe" links in spam sent to regular
> users. I've got some of those I started that way 15 years ago
> and they're still going strong.
>

Also no good idea, as some of them will send an unsubscribe mail to the 
trap then. The risk of false positives is very high.


-- 
  Aban Dokht                                   aban.dokht@abando.de
       system administrator of 0 day abusers DNSBL bl.dbrs.de
------------------------------------------------------------------


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.

Am 24.11.2014 um 13:51 schrieb RW:
> On Sat, 22 Nov 2014 15:32:26 -0600 (CST)
> Dave Funk wrote:
>
>> Another way to seed spamtrap addresses is to make up some and
>> then feed them into "unsubscribe" links in spam sent to regular
>> users. I've got some of those I started that way 15 years ago
>> and they're still going strong.
>
> Isn't there a danger that you get lower-grade spam that way, if spammers
> avoid unsubscribed addresses in their snowshoe lists.

<?php
  $file = file(__DIR__ . '/unsub.txt');
  foreach($file as $line)
  {
   $line = trim($line);
   if(!empty($line))
   {
    $line = str_replace('[email]', md5(microtime() . $line) . 
'@honeypot-domain.tld', $line);
    echo $line;
    usleep(1000);
    $out = @file_get_contents($line);
    if(!empty($out))
    {
     echo ': OK' . "\n";
    }
    else
    {
     echo ': FAILED' . "\n";
    }
   }
  }
?>


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by RW <rw...@googlemail.com>.
On Sat, 22 Nov 2014 15:32:26 -0600 (CST)
Dave Funk wrote:

> Another way to seed spamtrap addresses is to make up some and
> then feed them into "unsubscribe" links in spam sent to regular
> users. I've got some of those I started that way 15 years ago
> and they're still going strong.

Isn't there a danger that you get lower-grade spam that way, if spammers
avoid unsubscribed addresses in their snowshoe lists.

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Dave Funk <db...@engineering.uiowa.edu>.
Another way to seed spamtrap addresses is to make up some and
then feed them into "unsubscribe" links in spam sent to regular
users. I've got some of those I started that way 15 years ago
and they're still going strong.


On Sat, 22 Nov 2014, Ted Mittelstaedt wrote:

> That's a lot of work, there's a much easier way
>
> Just search your /var/log/maillog for user unknown messages, and
> create email addresses for the unknown users which are showing up
> multiple times over multiple days.  It's a great trick because it gets 
> spammers who already have email addresses in their
> spamlists and who are too lazy to remove them when they get a
> user unknown message from the mailserver.
>
> I have a pretty old domain - I've seen user unknown messages for
> users who cancelled mailboxes on the domain over a decade ago.  I figure
> 10 years of getting user unknown messages is long enough for any real
> humans and for legitimate mailing lists to remove those entries.
>
> Ted
>
> On 11/21/2014 8:10 AM, Joe Quinn wrote:
>> We are setting up some honeypot email addresses, and were wondering if
>> anyone here had tips on how to include those addresses on webpages and
>> other places.
>> 
>> We're currently going with a pretty simple <!-- honeypot@example.com -->
>> HTML comment. Is that too obvious? Should we put it into a CSS invisible
>> div as well? Any other ideas?
>
>

-- 
Dave Funk                                  University of Iowa
<dbfunk (at) engineering.uiowa.edu>        College of Engineering
319/335-5751   FAX: 319/384-0549           1256 Seamans Center
Sys_admin/Postmaster/cell_admin            Iowa City, IA 52242-1527
#include <std_disclaimer.h>
Better is not better, 'standard' is better. B{

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net>.
That's a lot of work, there's a much easier way

Just search your /var/log/maillog for user unknown messages, and
create email addresses for the unknown users which are showing up
multiple times over multiple days.  It's a great trick because it gets 
spammers who already have email addresses in their
spamlists and who are too lazy to remove them when they get a
user unknown message from the mailserver.

I have a pretty old domain - I've seen user unknown messages for
users who cancelled mailboxes on the domain over a decade ago.  I figure
10 years of getting user unknown messages is long enough for any real
humans and for legitimate mailing lists to remove those entries.

Ted

On 11/21/2014 8:10 AM, Joe Quinn wrote:
> We are setting up some honeypot email addresses, and were wondering if
> anyone here had tips on how to include those addresses on webpages and
> other places.
>
> We're currently going with a pretty simple <!-- honeypot@example.com -->
> HTML comment. Is that too obvious? Should we put it into a CSS invisible
> div as well? Any other ideas?

IPv6 mail (was Re: Honeypot email addresses)

Posted by "David F. Skoll" <df...@roaringpenguin.com>.
On Sat, 22 Nov 2014 13:15:29 +0100
Aban Dokht <ml...@abando.de> wrote:

> We also have honeypots with enabled IPv6 MX, but SPAM over IPv6 is
> very, very seldom.

We keep reputation reports from a large number of mailboxes and
they break down roughly as follows:

IPv4 mail: about 475 million reports of which 166 million were
reported back as spam.

IPv6 mail: about 9 million reports of which 145,000 were reported
as spam.

Conclusion: Not much mail travels over IPv6 and that which does is
more likely to be ham than mail travelling over IPv4.

On the other hand, IPv6 is bad news for some anti-spam technologies
like RBLs.  Even if the smallest RBL entry you make is a /64, there's
such a vast pool of addresses available that once IPv6 is ubiquitous,
spammers will be able to snowshoe much more effectively than over
IPv4.  Additionally, if your mail server tries to resolve the hostname
of incoming SMTP clients (most do), attackers can blow your DNS
server's cache by cycling through billions of IPv6 addresses from one
machine; I believe we will need to rethink the strategy of always
resolving host names when IPv6 is widespread.

Regards,

David.

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 26.11.2014 um 15:07 schrieb David F. Skoll:
> On Wed, 26 Nov 2014 14:10:04 +0100
> Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net> wrote:
>
>> the unbound stats on our inbound MX saying the opposite
>
> How much of those are DNSBL lookups against DNSBLs with short TTLs?

below the stats by RBL and keep in mind postscreen always asks *all* of 
the 18 dnsbl/dnswl and only logs the one with the highest score in case 
of a reject and *even* cachs results itself (in our config for 5 
minutes) and so not asking every time the local resolver

spamhaus.org               70980
barracudacentral.org       25851
inps.de                    23020
sorbs.net                   9069
thelounge.net               4676
mailspike.net                535
spamcop.net                  482
psbl.org                     344
uceprotect.net               258
manitu.net                    79
swinog.ch                     27
spameatingmonkey.net           4
=================================
Total DNSBL rejections:    135325


RBL and TTL

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 26.11.2014 um 15:07 schrieb David F. Skoll:
> On Wed, 26 Nov 2014 14:10:04 +0100
> Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net> wrote:
>
>> the unbound stats on our inbound MX saying the opposite
>
> How much of those are DNSBL lookups against DNSBLs with short TTLs?

looks like i realize the cause of your completly different expierience

* by default postscreen does RBL caching
   postconf -d postscreen_dnsbl_ttl
   postscreen_dnsbl_ttl = 1h
   postconf -n postscreen_dnsbl_ttl
   postscreen_dnsbl_ttl = 5m

* unbound supports min and max TTL
   cache-min-ttl: 270
   cache-max-ttl: 3600

well, i lowered the default 1 hour postscreen caching to 5 minutes 
because 1 hour feels too high given that a NXDOMAIN is also cached

i was even not aware that RBL's use *that* low TTLs of a few seconds to 
zero, but from my expierience around 5 minutes caching are for 99% of 
all cases accurate enough and the idea was more to keep things fast at 
high load

on the other hand the 3600 seconds max-ttl on the inbound MX (with it's 
own recursing caching nameserver forwarding some mirrored zones to a 
rbldnsd on 127.0.0.1:1053) is intented to get fixed DNS errors of the 
sending domain (PTR fixes after rejects and so on) earlier instead 
penalty them for 24 hours in the worst case

that this helps to not exceed RBL limits is a unintentional side-effect 
of other optimizings and considerations while i would *highly* recommend 
such settings - faced days with 500000 spam attempts and in that case 
fire up multiple dns queries to the WAN all the time is not funny :-)





Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by "David F. Skoll" <df...@roaringpenguin.com>.
On Wed, 26 Nov 2014 14:10:04 +0100
Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net> wrote:

> the unbound stats on our inbound MX saying the opposite

How much of those are DNSBL lookups against DNSBLs with short TTLs?

Regards,

David.

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 26.11.2014 um 14:06 schrieb David F. Skoll:
> On Wed, 26 Nov 2014 07:53:20 +0100
> Matthias Leisi <ma...@leisi.net> wrote:
>
>> Yes, such an approach might initially double the amount of queries
>> and has an increased risk of not getting DNS responses, but on the
>> other hand such "tree information" can be nicely cached with
>> reasonably long TTLs, even for the fast-paced DNSBLs out there.
>
> It's not worth the complexity.  I ran an analysis quite a few years
> ago on the cache efficiency of DNSBLs and they're shockingly low.
> I collected all the IPs seen on a very busy mail server and calculated
> how many cache hits we'd get with Spamhaus lookups --- I believe Spamhaus
> has a TTL of 15 minutes.  I'll have to dig up the exact numbers, but
> I recall something like a 90% cache *miss* rate.  Commercial DNSBLs
> count on a low cache hit rate; otherwise they wouldn't be able to
> detect heavy users as easily

the unbound stats on our inbound MX saying the opposite

cache-min-ttl: 300
cache-max-ttl: 3600

2014-11-25 23:05:27 	[663:1] info: server stats for thread 1: 200732 
queries, 101194 answers from cache, 99538 recursions, 2679 prefetch
2014-11-25 23:05:27 	[663:3] info: server stats for thread 3: 115076 
queries, 51667 answers from cache, 63409 recursions, 1060 prefetch
2014-11-25 23:05:27 	[663:2] info: server stats for thread 2: 125836 
queries, 59737 answers from cache, 66099 recursions, 1293 prefetch
2014-11-25 23:05:27 	[663:0] info: server stats for thread 0: 112853 
queries, 50909 answers from cache, 61944 recursions, 1132 prefetch


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by "David F. Skoll" <df...@roaringpenguin.com>.
On Wed, 26 Nov 2014 07:53:20 +0100
Matthias Leisi <ma...@leisi.net> wrote:

> Yes, such an approach might initially double the amount of queries
> and has an increased risk of not getting DNS responses, but on the
> other hand such "tree information" can be nicely cached with
> reasonably long TTLs, even for the fast-paced DNSBLs out there.

It's not worth the complexity.  I ran an analysis quite a few years
ago on the cache efficiency of DNSBLs and they're shockingly low.
I collected all the IPs seen on a very busy mail server and calculated
how many cache hits we'd get with Spamhaus lookups --- I believe Spamhaus
has a TTL of 15 minutes.  I'll have to dig up the exact numbers, but
I recall something like a 90% cache *miss* rate.  Commercial DNSBLs
count on a low cache hit rate; otherwise they wouldn't be able to
detect heavy users as easily.

DNS turns out not to be a very efficient way to distribute reputation
data because it changes too often.  Having a local authoritative DNS
server serving up the reputation zone is fine, but using public
caching DNS servers to query it is a waste of resources.

I'll try to dig up my results and also the Perl script I used for log
analysis.

Regards,

David.

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Christian Grunfeld <ch...@gmail.com>.
probably the same time it took to ipv4 become exhausted !

2014-11-27 3:59 GMT-03:00 John Wilcock <jo...@tradoc.fr>:

> Le 26/11/2014 19:56, Christian Grunfeld a écrit :
>
>> even /64 DNSxLs will be expensive !
>> /64 lists will have 2^32 times more entries than IPv4 lists.
>>
>
> /64 lists can *theoretically* have that many entries, yes, but it'll be a
> very long time before there are 2^32 times as many *allocated* IPv6 /64s as
> there are allocated IPv4 /32s!
>
> --
> John
>

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by John Wilcock <jo...@tradoc.fr>.
Le 26/11/2014 19:56, Christian Grunfeld a écrit :
> even /64 DNSxLs will be expensive !
> /64 lists will have 2^32 times more entries than IPv4 lists.

/64 lists can *theoretically* have that many entries, yes, but it'll be 
a very long time before there are 2^32 times as many *allocated* IPv6 
/64s as there are allocated IPv4 /32s!

-- 
John

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Christian Grunfeld <ch...@gmail.com>.
even /64 DNSxLs will be expensive !
/64 lists will have 2^32 times more entries than IPv4 lists.

2014-11-26 15:45 GMT-03:00 Franck Martin <fm...@linkedin.com>:

>
>  On Nov 26, 2014, at 10:19 AM, Matthias Leisi <ma...@leisi.net> wrote:
>
>
>
> On Wed, Nov 26, 2014 at 6:05 PM, Franck Martin <fm...@linkedin.com>
> wrote:
>
>
>> As for /64, yes there are hosting providers that have all their customers
>> in the same /64 and other cases like this where infrastructure is not
>> separated by /64 boundaries. I think IPv6 blocking list will be more last
>> resort, than first line of defense (but that’s just me). Note rbldnsd works
>> at /64 by default, with /128 exceptions.
>>
>
>  DNSxLs are still the "cheapest" way to determine reputation because it
> can happen at connection stage (or as a computationally cheap input to a
> scoring mechanism such as SpamAssassin) - so I believe there is still value
> in it, and it is important to get it as efficient as possible.
>
>
> Agreed, it is cheap in resources. However, it will be easier to add to a
> domain blocking list than to add to an IPv6 blocking list. May be first
> line of defense is the wrong naming. IPv6 blocking lists will be to remove
> the extreme badness of the Internet.
>
>

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Noel Butler <no...@ausics.net>.
 

On 02/12/2014 08:46, Franck Martin wrote: 

> On Nov 26, 2014, at 10:50 AM, Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net> wrote:
> Am 26.11.2014 um 19:45 schrieb Franck Martin: On Nov 26, 2014, at 10:19 AM, Matthias Leisi <matthias@leisi.net <ma...@leisi.net>> wrote:Agreed, it is cheap in resources. However, it will be easier to add to a domain blocking list than to add to an IPv6 blocking list. May be first line of defense is the wrong naming. IPv6 blocking lists will be to remove the extreme badness of the Internet "domain blocking list" is already done with SpamAssassins URIBL

only URLs found in the email, that's very limited.

> blocking sender domains blindly is error prone because you penalty a legit domain because some faced forged senders

You think that spamhaus, SURBL, URIBL, and any other reputable list
service would add in their blocking list a legit domain because some
faced forged sender?

I think they do know the difference, and even in the case they do
collateral damage, they provide public resolution forms, as long as the
sender knows how to resolve the block...

Have you tried to block based on the domain in the envelope from or
From: header? What is your experience?

My experience says it is very useful.

its useful to a point, but most spammers spoof, and you can spoof
envelope headers easily, so unless your blocking a specific yahoo or
gmail address, its pretty much a waste of resources blocking by
host/domain names now days 

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Dave Funk <db...@engineering.uiowa.edu>.
On Thu, 4 Dec 2014, Noel Butler wrote:

> 
> On 04/12/2014 00:54, Christian Grunfeld wrote:
>
>       "....It would be very rare, and if so you would ever more rare CC the entire list of addresses on your spam message -
>       sure this was a lot more common in years gone by, but I've not seen any such evidence of it in almost 10 years, and if
>       you did, well, that's not my problem, its the problem of your provider who obviously doesn't care enough to educate its
>       users of the dangers of spam, period......"
>
> 
>
>       lol ! ! ! is it possible to educate users against spam?
>
>       if that were the case this list would not be needed and we would be free ourselves from reading your posts, period !
>
> 
> 
> you must be doing it wrong, the users of today are far wiser than they were 5 years ago, even my almost 80yo dad knows to handle
> spam, although its hard to do, get your users to *read* their welcome emails, and dont have a lawyer write the stuff, write it so an
> 10yo kid can understand it, its also rare spam gets passed SA anyway with our myriad of custom rules, and we block at MTA level from
> multiple DNSBL's amongst many other milter tricks which I'm not going into in a public forum :)
> 
> So educate them well, and let SA do its job, and we wouldnt need to read your posts either.

I have to agree with Dave, Christian, et-all. It's not frequent but not
rare to see a reply-all "Take me off this list!!!".

Even if you've got the smartest, best educated users who will never make 
that mistake and a totally perfect spam filtering system that never has a 
FN there are other people/systems in the world which may be on that 
"shotgun" spam recpient list which may be less than perfect.


-- 
Dave Funk                                  University of Iowa
<dbfunk (at) engineering.uiowa.edu>        College of Engineering
319/335-5751   FAX: 319/384-0549           1256 Seamans Center
Sys_admin/Postmaster/cell_admin            Iowa City, IA 52242-1527
#include <std_disclaimer.h>
Better is not better, 'standard' is better. B{

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Noel Butler <no...@ausics.net>.
 

On 04/12/2014 00:54, Christian Grunfeld wrote: 

> "....It would be very rare, and if so you would ever more rare CC the entire list of addresses on your spam message - sure this was a lot more common in years gone by, but I've not seen any such evidence of it in almost 10 years, and if you did, well, that's not my problem, its the problem of your provider who obviously doesn't care enough to educate its users of the dangers of spam, period......" 
> 
> lol ! ! ! is it possible to educate users against spam? 
> 
> if that were the case this list would not be needed and we would be free ourselves from reading your posts, period !

you must be doing it wrong, the users of today are far wiser than they
were 5 years ago, even my almost 80yo dad knows to handle spam, although
its hard to do, get your users to *read* their welcome emails, and dont
have a lawyer write the stuff, write it so an 10yo kid can understand
it, its also rare spam gets passed SA anyway with our myriad of custom
rules, and we block at MTA level from multiple DNSBL's amongst many
other milter tricks which I'm not going into in a public forum :) 

So educate them well, and let SA do its job, and we wouldnt need to read
your posts either. 

 

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Christian Grunfeld <ch...@gmail.com>.
"....It would be very rare, and if so you would ever more rare CC the
entire list of addresses on your spam message - sure this was a lot more
common in years gone by, but I've not seen any such evidence of it in
almost 10 years, and if you did, well, that's not my problem, its the
problem of your provider who obviously doesn't care enough to educate its
users of the dangers of spam, period......"


lol ! ! ! is it possible to educate users against spam?

if that were the case this list would not be needed and we would be free
ourselves from reading your posts, period !

>

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Noel Butler <no...@ausics.net>.
 

read my reply to Chris, its rather simple - if you care (and we have
some pretty damn illiterate users, if they can get it right, anyone can)


Oh additional point, it also helps if your CSR's also have a clue, and
sound confident when talking to users, if they sound hesitant ummmm's
and arrrrrs, then the user will have less confidence, christ, it aint
rocket science. 

On 04/12/2014 01:02, Dave Pooser wrote: 

>> It would be very rare, and if so you would ever more rare CC the entire list of addresses on your spam message
> 
> Really? I see it all the time, often with a message body of "TAKE ME OFF
> THIS LIST!!!!" (because four exclamation points will convince a spammer to
> stop, while three just amuse the spammer). Also, typos happen.
> 
> In my opinion a honeypot is great for getting data in bulk, but it still
> has to be manually categorized before it's fed to the RBL generator or
> used for bayesian learning. The big advantage of a honeypot vs user-marked
> spam, IMO, is that you can be positive that the honeypot did NOT sign up
> for an email list and then start marking it as spam in lieu of the
> unsubscribe button.

 

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Dave Pooser <da...@pooserville.com>.
> It would be very rare, and if so you would ever more rare CC the entire
>list of addresses on your spam message

Really? I see it all the time, often with a message body of "TAKE ME OFF
THIS LIST!!!!" (because four exclamation points will convince a spammer to
stop, while three just amuse the spammer). Also, typos happen.

In my opinion a honeypot is great for getting data in bulk, but it still
has to be manually categorized before it's fed to the RBL generator or
used for bayesian learning. The big advantage of a honeypot vs user-marked
spam, IMO, is that you can be positive that the honeypot did NOT sign up
for an email list and then start marking it as spam in lieu of the
unsubscribe button.
-- 
Dave Pooser
Cat-Herder-in-Chief, Pooserville.com
"...Life is not a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving
safely in one pretty and well-preserved piece, but to slide across the
finish line broadside, thoroughly used up, worn out, leaking oil, and
shouting GERONIMO!!!" -- Bill McKenna



Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Noel Butler <no...@ausics.net>.
 

On 03/12/2014 09:18, Christian Grunfeld wrote: 

> ".....if *anyone* sends *anything* to that address it is unsolicited mail - spam, so that IP sender is blacklisted and placed in a DNSBL as well because there is no possible legitimate reason to send to that address....
> 
> ït is not really true. If a spammer sends to a list of addresses and among them is a spamtrap address a user might respond to that list and so you'd be blocking a legit ip or domain !

It would be very rare, and if so you would ever more rare CC the entire
list of addresses on your spam message - sure this was a lot more common
in years gone by, but I've not seen any such evidence of it in almost 10
years, and if you did, well, that's not my problem, its the problem of
your provider who obviously doesn't care enough to educate its users of
the dangers of spam, period. 

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Christian Grunfeld <ch...@gmail.com>.
".....if *anyone* sends *anything* to that address it is unsolicited mail -
spam, so that IP sender is blacklisted and placed in a DNSBL as well
because there is no possible legitimate reason to send to that address....

ït is not really true. If a spammer sends to a list of addresses and among them
is a spamtrap address a user might respond to that list and so you'd
be blocking
a legit ip or domain !

cheers

2014-12-02 20:04 GMT-03:00 Noel Butler <no...@ausics.net>:

>  On 03/12/2014 03:07, Matthias Leisi wrote:
>
>
> On Tue, Dec 2, 2014 at 3:19 PM, LuKreme <kr...@kreme.com> wrote:
>
>> On Dec 1, 2014, at 10:28 PM, Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net> wrote:
>> > This is assuming of course that your instantly blocking everything from
>> a sender that happens to email a honeypot.
>>
>> Right. That i the *point* of a honeypot. The only thing going to a
>> honeypot is going to be a spammer.
>
>
> Not necessarily. At dnswl.org, we use spamtraps as one input source to
> determine the trustworthiness of an IP - to list (and at what score) or if
> not to list.
>
> A single spamtrap hit over an extended period of time for a system with a
> high magnitude does not say much. And it's different if it's an ISP
> mailserver or an "email marketing provider".
>
>
>
>
> I see no difference, if I never have, never will, use say
> deletethis@ausics.net and its used as a trap address (actually used as
> examples in some of my pages/blog etc), *anyone* who sends to that address,
> has got it via means of scraping, it clearly means it was taken from a
> webpage, or a mailing list archive, if *anyone* sends *anything* to that
> address it is unsolicited mail - spam, so that IP sender is blacklisted and
> placed in a DNSBL as well because there is no possible legitimate reason to
> send to that address, and reputation, trust - my arse, again, no valid or
> legitimate reason to send to that trap address, its sole purpose in life is
> to catch those who spam, if one person sees it, they *will* be doing it to
> many many many others.
>
> Noel
>
> PS
>
> (for the spammers, since we know you scum read this list - that example is
> only 1 of 7 trap addresses over a couple of domains I use, exempt it, I'll
> still catch you out)
>
>
>

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Noel Butler <no...@ausics.net>.
 

On 03/12/2014 03:07, Matthias Leisi wrote: 

> On Tue, Dec 2, 2014 at 3:19 PM, LuKreme <kr...@kreme.com> wrote:
> 
>> On Dec 1, 2014, at 10:28 PM, Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net> wrote:
>>> This is assuming of course that your instantly blocking everything from a sender that happens to email a honeypot.
>> 
>> Right. That i the *point* of a honeypot. The only thing going to a honeypot is going to be a spammer.
> 
> Not necessarily. At dnswl.org [1], we use spamtraps as one input source to determine the trustworthiness of an IP - to list (and at what score) or if not to list. 
> 
> A single spamtrap hit over an extended period of time for a system with a high magnitude does not say much. And it's different if it's an ISP mailserver or an "email marketing provider".

I see no difference, if I never have, never will, use say
deletethis@ausics.net and its used as a trap address (actually used as
examples in some of my pages/blog etc), *anyone* who sends to that
address, has got it via means of scraping, it clearly means it was taken
from a webpage, or a mailing list archive, if *anyone* sends *anything*
to that address it is unsolicited mail - spam, so that IP sender is
blacklisted and placed in a DNSBL as well because there is no possible
legitimate reason to send to that address, and reputation, trust - my
arse, again, no valid or legitimate reason to send to that trap address,
its sole purpose in life is to catch those who spam, if one person sees
it, they *will* be doing it to many many many others. 

Noel 

PS 

(for the spammers, since we know you scum read this list - that example
is only 1 of 7 trap addresses over a couple of domains I use, exempt it,
I'll still catch you out) 

 

Links:
------
[1] http://dnswl.org

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Matthias Leisi <ma...@leisi.net>.
On Tue, Dec 2, 2014 at 3:19 PM, LuKreme <kr...@kreme.com> wrote:

> On Dec 1, 2014, at 10:28 PM, Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net> wrote:
> > This is assuming of course that your instantly blocking everything from
> a sender that happens to email a honeypot.
>
> Right. That i the *point* of a honeypot. The only thing going to a
> honeypot is going to be a spammer.
>

Not necessarily. At dnswl.org, we use spamtraps as one input source to
determine the trustworthiness of an IP - to list (and at what score) or if
not to list.

A single spamtrap hit over an extended period of time for a system with a
high magnitude does not say much. And it's different if it's an ISP
mailserver or an "email marketing provider".

A single spamtrap hit for an IP that has been seen for a few days only says
quite a lot.


> > Most honeypots are not used in such a draconian fashion.
>
> Every single one I’ve ever seen has.
>

Now you've seen one that doesn't :)

-- Matthias

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by LuKreme <kr...@kreme.com>.
> On Dec 2, 2014, at 10:24 AM, Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net> wrote:
> 
> 
> 
> On 12/2/2014 6:19 AM, LuKreme wrote:
>> On Dec 1, 2014, at 10:28 PM, Ted Mittelstaedt<te...@ipinc.net>  wrote:
>>> This is assuming of course that your instantly blocking everything from a sender that happens to email a honeypot.
>> 
>> Right. That i the *point* of a honeypot. The only thing going to a honeypot is going to be a spammer.
>> 
>>> Most honeypots are not used in such a draconian fashion.
>> 
>> Every single one I’ve ever seen has.
>> 
> 
> i see tons of spam relayed through throwaway accounts on Yahoo, and even some from Gmail and Microsoft's various domains.  This is to all manner of accounts, both valid and invalid, former accounts and accounts that never existed.  So your saying it's OK to block those because you get a piece of spam from them to a honeypot?

If a message claims to come from Yahoo and comes from xyz.tl it is already rejected.

> Or are you saying that with your honeypots that the large providers get a free pass to spam you when they email your honeypots?

I don’t recall ever saying I had my own honeypots.

-- 
Some books are undeservedly forgotten; none are undeservedly remembered


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net>.

On 12/2/2014 9:31 AM, Kevin A. McGrail wrote:
> On 12/2/2014 12:24 PM, Ted Mittelstaedt wrote:
>>
>>
>> On 12/2/2014 6:19 AM, LuKreme wrote:
>>> On Dec 1, 2014, at 10:28 PM, Ted Mittelstaedt<te...@ipinc.net> wrote:
>>>> This is assuming of course that your instantly blocking everything
>>>> from a sender that happens to email a honeypot.
>>>
>>> Right. That i the *point* of a honeypot. The only thing going to a
>>> honeypot is going to be a spammer.
>>>
>>>> Most honeypots are not used in such a draconian fashion.
>>>
>>> Every single one I’ve ever seen has.
>>>
>>
>> i see tons of spam relayed through throwaway accounts on Yahoo, and
>> even some from Gmail and Microsoft's various domains. This is to all
>> manner of accounts, both valid and invalid, former accounts and
>> accounts that never existed. So your saying it's OK to block those
>> because you get a piece of spam from them to a honeypot?
>>
>> Or are you saying that the spammers NEVER use throwaway accounts on
>> those large providers?
>>
>> Or are you saying that with your honeypots that the large providers
>> get a free pass to spam you when they email your honeypots?
> For me, spam is always about minimizing collateral damage but it is far
> from an exact science and subject to friendly debate to improve things
> for everyone.
>
> Let's remember who the bastards are (the spammers) and not attack
> people's honeypots/DNSWLs, etc. because if you don't like their
> policies, you don't have to use them.
>

Agreed, I will also point out I didn't start the attacks.

I do not agree with the logic that using email addresses on a domain 
that have been deactivated for a long period of time - years that is - 
as honeypots is going to result in blocking a valid sender.  My 
assertion got attacked - I refuted those attacks with logic - my 
assertion got attacked more with illogical statements like the one I 
just refuted a few minutes ago.

Data from a single honeypot has some value.  Data from hundreds of them 
has far, far more value.  If some of those hundreds of honeypots are old 
email addresses that were bouncing mail for the last 5 years with 
"unknown user" then it isn't logical to assert that those will result in 
blocking a legitimate sender.  At least, not in what I consider a 
reasonable filter.

Ted

> Regards,
> KAM

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by "Kevin A. McGrail" <KM...@PCCC.com>.
On 12/2/2014 12:24 PM, Ted Mittelstaedt wrote:
>
>
> On 12/2/2014 6:19 AM, LuKreme wrote:
>> On Dec 1, 2014, at 10:28 PM, Ted Mittelstaedt<te...@ipinc.net>  wrote:
>>> This is assuming of course that your instantly blocking everything 
>>> from a sender that happens to email a honeypot.
>>
>> Right. That i the *point* of a honeypot. The only thing going to a 
>> honeypot is going to be a spammer.
>>
>>> Most honeypots are not used in such a draconian fashion.
>>
>> Every single one I’ve ever seen has.
>>
>
> i see tons of spam relayed through throwaway accounts on Yahoo, and 
> even some from Gmail and Microsoft's various domains.  This is to all 
> manner of accounts, both valid and invalid, former accounts and 
> accounts that never existed.  So your saying it's OK to block those 
> because you get a piece of spam from them to a honeypot?
>
> Or are you saying that the spammers NEVER use throwaway accounts on 
> those large providers?
>
> Or are you saying that with your honeypots that the large providers 
> get a free pass to spam you when they email your honeypots? 
For me, spam is always about minimizing collateral damage but it is far 
from an exact science and subject to friendly debate to improve things 
for everyone.

Let's remember who the bastards are (the spammers) and not attack 
people's honeypots/DNSWLs, etc.  because if you don't like their 
policies, you don't have to use them.

Regards,
KAM

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net>.

On 12/2/2014 5:32 PM, LuKreme wrote:
>
>
> I have *never* considered Barracuda to be reliable. At least they have stopped their practice of listing my server and then sending me spam offering to sell me their crapware to keep it off blacklists for $$$$ per month.
>

I think there's a direct correlation between how reliable an RBL is and 
how easy it is to get de-listed!


Ted

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 03.12.2014 um 02:32 schrieb LuKreme:
>> another recent example:
>> Spamhaus blocked GMX/1&1/Web.de completly *by a mistake*, no problem in case of scoring, a ruined weekend if we had used it as only source
>
> The extremely occasional mistaken black is more than made up for by the vast quantities of spam that are blocked every day. I reject at SMTP based on zen. If zen is mistaken, at least the sender doesn’t think the mail as delivered and f they (and their MUA) are competent, they know WHY their mail didn’t go through.

what is "based on zen"?
that is a aggregate list and sensible to use it score-based

which the simple settings below you catch *much more* then with "zen" 
alone *and* reduce false-positives greatly

postscreen_dnsbl_ttl = 5m
postscreen_dnsbl_action = enforce
postscreen_greet_action = enforce
postscreen_dnsbl_sites =
  b.barracudacentral.org=127.0.0.2*7
  dnsbl.inps.de=127.0.0.2*7
  bl.mailspike.net=127.0.0.2*5
  bl.mailspike.net=127.0.0.[10;11;12]*4
  dnsbl.sorbs.net=127.0.0.10*8
  dnsbl.sorbs.net=127.0.0.5*6
  dnsbl.sorbs.net=127.0.0.7*3
  dnsbl.sorbs.net=127.0.0.8*2
  dnsbl.sorbs.net=127.0.0.6*2
  dnsbl.sorbs.net=127.0.0.9*2
  zen.spamhaus.org=127.0.0.[10;11]*8
  zen.spamhaus.org=127.0.0.[4..7]*6
  zen.spamhaus.org=127.0.0.3*4
  zen.spamhaus.org=127.0.0.2*3
  wl.mailspike.net=127.0.0.[18;19;20]*-2
  list.dnswl.org=127.0.[0..255].0*-2
  list.dnswl.org=127.0.[0..255].1*-3
  list.dnswl.org=127.0.[0..255].2*-4
  list.dnswl.org=127.0.[0..255].3*-5



Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by LuKreme <kr...@kreme.com>.
> On Dec 2, 2014, at 11:28 AM, Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net> wrote:
> 
> 
> Am 02.12.2014 um 19:22 schrieb Niamh Holding:
>> Hello Reindl,
>> 
>> Tuesday, December 2, 2014, 6:14:26 PM, you wrote:
>> 
>> RH> no, i am saying nobody right in his mind is rejecting mails because
>> RH> *one* RBL
>> 
>> You do say the sweetest things!
>> 
>> Should I be offended given that we block at SMTP time if an IP address
>> is listed in just one of a chosen selection of RBLs... known senders
>> are whitelisted prior to RBL checking.
> 
> you should re-consider that, your users problems
> 
> as said:
> the linux.com newsletter get blocked by "b.barracudacentral.org" which is normally a trustful blacklist (their URIBL's on the devices are crap playing lottery with email) a since we replaced the device i receive it again (b.barracudacentral.org is still used, but as *one* RBL in the postscreen mix)

I have *never* considered Barracuda to be reliable. At least they have stopped their practice of listing my server and then sending me spam offering to sell me their crapware to keep it off blacklists for $$$$ per month.

> another recent example:
> Spamhaus blocked GMX/1&1/Web.de completly *by a mistake*, no problem in case of scoring, a ruined weekend if we had used it as only source

The extremely occasional mistaken black is more than made up for by the vast quantities of spam that are blocked every day. I reject at SMTP based on zen. If zen is mistaken, at least the sender doesn’t think the mail as delivered and f they (and their MUA) are competent, they know WHY their mail didn’t go through.

-- 
Oh, the sweet wine of youth goes sour over time
Seems like the more that you lose, the more you ache to find


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 02.12.2014 um 19:22 schrieb Niamh Holding:
> Hello Reindl,
>
> Tuesday, December 2, 2014, 6:14:26 PM, you wrote:
>
> RH> no, i am saying nobody right in his mind is rejecting mails because
> RH> *one* RBL
>
> You do say the sweetest things!
>
> Should I be offended given that we block at SMTP time if an IP address
> is listed in just one of a chosen selection of RBLs... known senders
> are whitelisted prior to RBL checking.

you should re-consider that, your users problems

as said:
the linux.com newsletter get blocked by "b.barracudacentral.org" which 
is normally a trustful blacklist (their URIBL's on the devices are crap 
playing lottery with email) a since we replaced the device i receive it 
again (b.barracudacentral.org is still used, but as *one* RBL in the 
postscreen mix)

another recent example:
Spamhaus blocked GMX/1&1/Web.de completly *by a mistake*, no problem in 
case of scoring, a ruined weekend if we had used it as only source


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Axb <ax...@gmail.com>.
On 12/02/2014 07:22 PM, Niamh Holding wrote:
>
> Hello Reindl,
>
> Tuesday, December 2, 2014, 6:14:26 PM, you wrote:
>
> RH> no, i am saying nobody right in his mind is rejecting mails because
> RH> *one* RBL
>
> You do say the sweetest things!
>
> Should I be offended given that we block at SMTP time if an IP address
> is listed in just one of a chosen selection of RBLs... known senders
> are whitelisted prior to RBL checking.
>

Could we stop beating this dead horse?

There's way better places to discuss philosophy

for example
List Guidelines: http://www.new-spam-l.com/admin/faq.html
List Information: https://spammers.dontlike.us/mailman/listinfo/list

and the good old NANAE

news.admin.net-abuse.email


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Niamh Holding <ni...@fullbore.co.uk>.
Hello Reindl,

Tuesday, December 2, 2014, 6:14:26 PM, you wrote:

RH> no, i am saying nobody right in his mind is rejecting mails because 
RH> *one* RBL

You do say the sweetest things!

Should I be offended given that we block at SMTP time if an IP address
is listed in just one of a chosen selection of RBLs... known senders
are whitelisted prior to RBL checking.

-- 
Best regards,
 Niamh                            mailto:niamh@fullbore.co.uk

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.

Am 02.12.2014 um 18:24 schrieb Ted Mittelstaedt:
> On 12/2/2014 6:19 AM, LuKreme wrote:
>> On Dec 1, 2014, at 10:28 PM, Ted Mittelstaedt<te...@ipinc.net>  wrote:
>>> This is assuming of course that your instantly blocking everything
>>> from a sender that happens to email a honeypot.
>>
>> Right. That i the *point* of a honeypot. The only thing going to a
>> honeypot is going to be a spammer.
>>
>>> Most honeypots are not used in such a draconian fashion.
>>
>> Every single one I’ve ever seen has.
>
> i see tons of spam relayed through throwaway accounts on Yahoo, and even
> some from Gmail and Microsoft's various domains.  This is to all manner
> of accounts, both valid and invalid, former accounts and accounts that
> never existed.  So your saying it's OK to block those because you get a
> piece of spam from them to a honeypot?

surely, on *one* RBL

> Or are you saying that the spammers NEVER use throwaway accounts on
> those large providers?
>
> Or are you saying that with your honeypots that the large providers get
> a free pass to spam you when they email your honeypots?

no, i am saying nobody right in his mind is rejecting mails because 
*one* RBL but based on scores and with delisting after a few days - each 
honeypot one RBL

if you put a lot of RBL's  as well as a lot of DNSWL in the score mix 
you unlikely have false positives because *one* honeypot

it only becomes a problem when the maintainers of honeypot's are dumb as 
bread and re-use previous legit addresses as trap or what i heard crazy 
people suggest register on porn sites with trap addresses

the large ISP's like gmail are typically also on whitelists (including 
one of our internal) and so they need to hit a lot of honeypots within a 
short timeframe to get blocked, but if they do - so be it


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net>.

On 12/2/2014 6:19 AM, LuKreme wrote:
> On Dec 1, 2014, at 10:28 PM, Ted Mittelstaedt<te...@ipinc.net>  wrote:
>> This is assuming of course that your instantly blocking everything from a sender that happens to email a honeypot.
>
> Right. That i the *point* of a honeypot. The only thing going to a honeypot is going to be a spammer.
>
>> Most honeypots are not used in such a draconian fashion.
>
> Every single one I’ve ever seen has.
>

i see tons of spam relayed through throwaway accounts on Yahoo, and even 
some from Gmail and Microsoft's various domains.  This is to all manner 
of accounts, both valid and invalid, former accounts and accounts that 
never existed.  So your saying it's OK to block those because you get a 
piece of spam from them to a honeypot?

Or are you saying that the spammers NEVER use throwaway accounts on 
those large providers?

Or are you saying that with your honeypots that the large providers get 
a free pass to spam you when they email your honeypots?

Ted

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by LuKreme <kr...@kreme.com>.
On Dec 1, 2014, at 10:28 PM, Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net> wrote:
> This is assuming of course that your instantly blocking everything from a sender that happens to email a honeypot.

Right. That i the *point* of a honeypot. The only thing going to a honeypot is going to be a spammer.

> Most honeypots are not used in such a draconian fashion.

Every single one I’ve ever seen has.

-- 
"You're just impressed by any pretty girl who can walk and talk." "She
doesn't have to talk."


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by "Kevin A. McGrail" <KM...@PCCC.com>.
On 12/2/2014 12:28 AM, Ted Mittelstaedt wrote:
> For anyone else, this discussion about honeypots STARTED as a 
> discussion on where to find good Bayes feeding sources.

No, it started as a discussion about honeypots to help the SOUGHT 2.0 
project which could use more volunteers, BTW!

Regards,
KAM


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Noel Butler <no...@ausics.net>.
 

On 02/12/2014 15:28, Ted Mittelstaedt wrote: 

> On 12/1/2014 8:47 PM, Noel Butler wrote:
> On 02/12/2014 09:07, Reindl Harald wrote: Am 01.12.2014 um 23:46 schrieb Franck Martin: On Nov 26, 2014, at 10:50 AM, Reindl Harald <h.reindl@thelounge.net <ma...@thelounge.net>> wrote: Am 26.11.2014 um 19:45 schrieb Franck Martin: My experience says it is very useful
 my point in context of that thread is that using previous valid
addresses as honeypot is dangerous to stupid - you have no clue in most
cases about the context how the RCPT got chosen and i know a lot of
people sening once or twice a year some mail to their limited address
book congratulations if you in that case (you can't know) block the
whole sending server because one of your team memebers left not to
mention the number of people who run ancient backups, because they CBF
checking to see that their current backups still worked, and find they
are mailing a dead address. Harry and I rarely agree, but here we do, it
is a dangerous act - the only safe trap address are the ones never ever
used before, its only way you have 100% guaranteed zero FP's. 

This is assuming of course that your instantly blocking everything from
a sender that happens to email a honeypot.

Most honeypots are not used in such a draconian fashion.

But go ahead and be Draconian - I guess the only way you both can
justify a "win" on this argument is by assuming people use honeypots
in ways that simply are not done in reality.

For anyone else, this discussion about honeypots STARTED as a discussion
on where to find good Bays feeding sources. Don't bother engaging the
two Zealots, you will be wasting your time. <eyeroll>

Ted

most dont use it this way ? backup your statement with evidence. I await
your masses of proof 

do you even read what you dribble before click send? 

 

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Ted Mittelstaedt <te...@ipinc.net>.

On 12/1/2014 8:47 PM, Noel Butler wrote:
> On 02/12/2014 09:07, Reindl Harald wrote:
>
>> Am 01.12.2014 um 23:46 schrieb Franck Martin:
>>> On Nov 26, 2014, at 10:50 AM, Reindl Harald <h.reindl@thelounge.net
>>> <ma...@thelounge.net>> wrote:
>>>> Am 26.11.2014 um 19:45 schrieb Franck Martin:
>>>> My experience says it is very useful
>> my point in context of that thread is that using previous valid addresses as honeypot is dangerous to stupid - you have no clue in most cases about the context how the RCPT got chosen and i know a lot of people sening once or twice a year some mail to their limited address book
>>
>> congratulations if you in that case (you can't know) block the whole sending server because one of your team memebers left
>
> not to mention the number of people who run ancient backups, because
> they CBF checking to see that their current backups still worked, and
> find they are mailing a dead address.
>
> Harry and I rarely agree, but here we do, it is a dangerous act - the
> only safe trap address are the ones never ever used before, its only way
> you have 100% guaranteed zero FP's.
>

This is assuming of course that your instantly blocking everything from 
a sender that happens to email a honeypot.

Most honeypots are not used in such a draconian fashion.

But go ahead and be Draconian - I guess the only way you both can 
justify a "win" on this argument is by assuming people use honeypots
in ways that simply are not done in reality.

For anyone else, this discussion about honeypots STARTED as a discussion 
on where to find good Bays feeding sources.  Don't bother engaging the 
two Zealots, you will be wasting your time. <eyeroll>

Ted

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Noel Butler <no...@ausics.net>.
 

On 02/12/2014 09:07, Reindl Harald wrote: 

> Am 01.12.2014 um 23:46 schrieb Franck Martin:
> On Nov 26, 2014, at 10:50 AM, Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net> wrote: Am 26.11.2014 um 19:45 schrieb Franck Martin: My experience says it is very useful

> my point in context of that thread is that using previous valid addresses as honeypot is dangerous to stupid - you have no clue in most cases about the context how the RCPT got chosen and i know a lot of people sening once or twice a year some mail to their limited address book
> 
> congratulations if you in that case (you can't know) block the whole sending server because one of your team memebers left

not to mention the number of people who run ancient backups, because
they CBF checking to see that their current backups still worked, and
find they are mailing a dead address. 

Harry and I rarely agree, but here we do, it is a dangerous act - the
only safe trap address are the ones never ever used before, its only way
you have 100% guaranteed zero FP's. 

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 01.12.2014 um 23:46 schrieb Franck Martin:
> On Nov 26, 2014, at 10:50 AM, Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net> wrote:
>
>>
>> Am 26.11.2014 um 19:45 schrieb Franck Martin:
>>> On Nov 26, 2014, at 10:19 AM, Matthias Leisi <matthias@leisi.net
>>> <ma...@leisi.net>> wrote:
>>>>
>>>>
>>> Agreed, it is cheap in resources. However, it will be easier to add to a
>>> domain blocking list than to add to an IPv6 blocking list. May be first
>>> line of defense is the wrong naming. IPv6 blocking lists will be to
>>> remove the extreme badness of the Internet
>>
>> "domain blocking list" is already done with SpamAssassins URIBL
>
> only URLs found in the email, that’s very limited.

stats saying something different

>> blocking sender domains blindly is error prone because you penalty a legit domain because some faced forged senders
>>
> You think that spamhaus, SURBL, URIBL, and any other reputable list service would add in their blocking list a legit domain because some faced forged sender?

no, but many "i know enough" admins are error prone in that case

> I think they do know the difference, and even in the case they do collateral damage, they provide public resolution forms, as long as the sender knows how to resolve the block...
>
> Have you tried to block based on the domain in the envelope from or From: header? What is your experience?

that a good forged email is often hard to distinct

> My experience says it is very useful

my point in context of that thread is that using previous valid 
addresses as honeypot is dangerous to stupid - you have no clue in most 
cases about the context how the RCPT got chosen and i know a lot of 
people sening once or twice a year some mail to their limited address book

congratulations if you in that case (you can't know) block the whole 
sending server because one of your team memebers left

the point of spam filtering is get out the junk *but* the point of 
maintain a mailserver is to receive 100% legit mail and if that means 5 
junk mails get through - so what - block 5 legit important mails because 
you want to achieve 100% junk free does much more damage

i am coming from a commercial solution where the vendor more and more 
started to reahc 100% hit rate with growing collateral damage up to just 
inacceptable

a user can easily delete 5 junk mails
a user can impossible know and re-receive wrongly blocked mail

do what you want - i personally would use valid RCPT addresses only over 
my dead body as a honeyot some months after the address no longer is used


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 01.12.2014 um 23:46 schrieb Franck Martin:
> You think that spamhaus, SURBL, URIBL, and any other reputable list service would add in their blocking list a legit domain because some faced forged sender?

to make it clearer:

no, but *i know* for sure that *any* of that blacklists is not trustable 
enough to block incoming mail based one one list alone hence any 
sensible spamfilter is using scoring

* Spamhaus SBL -> blocking repeatly GMX/Web.de completly
* Barracuda RBL -> blocking for months the Linux foundation newsletter
   what i see only in the report headers

using a single source for blocking mail is wrong until someone only has 
it's own private server only with his own mailflow to maintain

disclaimer: yes, SA is blocking mail in context of a milter



Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Franck Martin <fm...@linkedin.com>.
On Nov 26, 2014, at 10:50 AM, Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net> wrote:

> 
> Am 26.11.2014 um 19:45 schrieb Franck Martin:
>> On Nov 26, 2014, at 10:19 AM, Matthias Leisi <matthias@leisi.net
>> <ma...@leisi.net>> wrote:
>>> 
>>> 
>> Agreed, it is cheap in resources. However, it will be easier to add to a
>> domain blocking list than to add to an IPv6 blocking list. May be first
>> line of defense is the wrong naming. IPv6 blocking lists will be to
>> remove the extreme badness of the Internet
> 
> "domain blocking list" is already done with SpamAssassins URIBL

only URLs found in the email, that’s very limited.

> 
> blocking sender domains blindly is error prone because you penalty a legit domain because some faced forged senders
> 


You think that spamhaus, SURBL, URIBL, and any other reputable list service would add in their blocking list a legit domain because some faced forged sender?

I think they do know the difference, and even in the case they do collateral damage, they provide public resolution forms, as long as the sender knows how to resolve the block...

Have you tried to block based on the domain in the envelope from or From: header? What is your experience?

My experience says it is very useful.

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 26.11.2014 um 19:45 schrieb Franck Martin:
> On Nov 26, 2014, at 10:19 AM, Matthias Leisi <matthias@leisi.net
> <ma...@leisi.net>> wrote:
>>
>> On Wed, Nov 26, 2014 at 6:05 PM, Franck Martin <fmartin@linkedin.com
>> <ma...@linkedin.com>> wrote:
>>
>>     As for /64, yes there are hosting providers that have all their
>>     customers in the same /64 and other cases like this where
>>     infrastructure is not separated by /64 boundaries. I think IPv6
>>     blocking list will be more last resort, than first line of defense
>>     (but that’s just me). Note rbldnsd works at /64 by default, with
>>     /128 exceptions.
>>
>>
>> DNSxLs are still the "cheapest" way to determine reputation because it
>> can happen at connection stage (or as a computationally cheap input to
>> a scoring mechanism such as SpamAssassin) - so I believe there is
>> still value in it, and it is important to get it as efficient as
>> possible.
> Agreed, it is cheap in resources. However, it will be easier to add to a
> domain blocking list than to add to an IPv6 blocking list. May be first
> line of defense is the wrong naming. IPv6 blocking lists will be to
> remove the extreme badness of the Internet

"domain blocking list" is already done with SpamAssassins URIBL

blocking sender domains blindly is error prone because you penalty a 
legit domain because some faced forged senders


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Franck Martin <fm...@linkedin.com>.
On Nov 26, 2014, at 10:19 AM, Matthias Leisi <ma...@leisi.net>> wrote:



On Wed, Nov 26, 2014 at 6:05 PM, Franck Martin <fm...@linkedin.com>> wrote:

As for /64, yes there are hosting providers that have all their customers in the same /64 and other cases like this where infrastructure is not separated by /64 boundaries. I think IPv6 blocking list will be more last resort, than first line of defense (but that’s just me). Note rbldnsd works at /64 by default, with /128 exceptions.

DNSxLs are still the "cheapest" way to determine reputation because it can happen at connection stage (or as a computationally cheap input to a scoring mechanism such as SpamAssassin) - so I believe there is still value in it, and it is important to get it as efficient as possible.

Agreed, it is cheap in resources. However, it will be easier to add to a domain blocking list than to add to an IPv6 blocking list. May be first line of defense is the wrong naming. IPv6 blocking lists will be to remove the extreme badness of the Internet.


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Matthias Leisi <ma...@leisi.net>.
On Wed, Nov 26, 2014 at 6:05 PM, Franck Martin <fm...@linkedin.com> wrote:


> As for /64, yes there are hosting providers that have all their customers
> in the same /64 and other cases like this where infrastructure is not
> separated by /64 boundaries. I think IPv6 blocking list will be more last
> resort, than first line of defense (but that’s just me). Note rbldnsd works
> at /64 by default, with /128 exceptions.
>

DNSxLs are still the "cheapest" way to determine reputation because it can
happen at connection stage (or as a computationally cheap input to a
scoring mechanism such as SpamAssassin) - so I believe there is still value
in it, and it is important to get it as efficient as possible.

For my project, dnswl.org, the situation may be a bit different, because
TTLs can be very long (at least in the range of hours) rather than mere
minutes for DNSBLs.

I'll try to hack together a plugin, I've reserved some time over the next
few days.

-- Matthias

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Franck Martin <fm...@linkedin.com>.
On Nov 26, 2014, at 2:15 AM, Kevin A. McGrail <KM...@PCCC.com>> wrote:

On 11/26/2014 1:53 AM, Matthias Leisi wrote:

On Wed, Nov 26, 2014 at 3:45 AM, Franck Martin <fm...@linkedin.com>> wrote:

You may want to read https://www.m3aawg.org/sites/maawg/files/news/M3AAWG_Inbound_IPv6_Policy_Issues-2014-09.pdf

I'm well aware of the issues of cache efficiency and query volumes due to the vast address space. The solution to just cut off at /64 is nice, but there will be many legitimate cases where this is will not be "good enough".

That's why I am convinced that in the end we will need something like a "tree walk" algorithm, where an "intelligent" algorithm starts at (let's say) a /32 boundary and then gets responses to the best fitting response.

Yes, such an approach might initially double the amount of queries and has an increased risk of not getting DNS responses, but on the other hand such "tree information" can be nicely cached with reasonably long TTLs, even for the fast-paced DNSBLs out there.

Maybe such a tree-walk algorithm is worth an experiment as a SpamAssassin plugin?

I could likely ramble about why I don't think the real-world implications will be that large because patterns will emerge.  As such, SA Plugins are very safe for experimental work and can be done without any impact on production systems in my experience.

I'd support and love to see some experiments in this realm.


I think may be you are missing the other point of this document, if there is no valid SPF or DKIM and the message was received over IPv6, then you reject it (or send it to spam). I think such rule can be easily implemented in SA. Just need to put a score of 10 on it :P

As for real case scenario, Google, Microsoft and others are already doing just this.

As for /64, yes there are hosting providers that have all their customers in the same /64 and other cases like this where infrastructure is not separated by /64 boundaries. I think IPv6 blocking list will be more last resort, than first line of defense (but that’s just me). Note rbldnsd works at /64 by default, with /128 exceptions.


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by "Kevin A. McGrail" <KM...@PCCC.com>.
On 11/26/2014 1:53 AM, Matthias Leisi wrote:
>
> On Wed, Nov 26, 2014 at 3:45 AM, Franck Martin <fmartin@linkedin.com 
> <ma...@linkedin.com>> wrote:
>
>     You may want to read
>     https://www.m3aawg.org/sites/maawg/files/news/M3AAWG_Inbound_IPv6_Policy_Issues-2014-09.pdf
>
>
> I'm well aware of the issues of cache efficiency and query volumes due 
> to the vast address space. The solution to just cut off at /64 is 
> nice, but there will be many legitimate cases where this is will not 
> be "good enough".
>
> That's why I am convinced that in the end we will need something like 
> a "tree walk" algorithm, where an "intelligent" algorithm starts at 
> (let's say) a /32 boundary and then gets responses to the best fitting 
> response.
>
> Yes, such an approach might initially double the amount of queries and 
> has an increased risk of not getting DNS responses, but on the other 
> hand such "tree information" can be nicely cached with reasonably long 
> TTLs, even for the fast-paced DNSBLs out there.
>
> Maybe such a tree-walk algorithm is worth an experiment as a 
> SpamAssassin plugin?
>
I could likely ramble about why I don't think the real-world 
implications will be that large because patterns will emerge.  As such, 
SA Plugins are very safe for experimental work and can be done without 
any impact on production systems in my experience.

I'd support and love to see some experiments in this realm.

regards,
kAM



Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Matthias Leisi <ma...@leisi.net>.
On Wed, Nov 26, 2014 at 3:45 AM, Franck Martin <fm...@linkedin.com> wrote:


> You may want to read
> https://www.m3aawg.org/sites/maawg/files/news/M3AAWG_Inbound_IPv6_Policy_Issues-2014-09.pdf


I'm well aware of the issues of cache efficiency and query volumes due to
the vast address space. The solution to just cut off at /64 is nice, but
there will be many legitimate cases where this is will not be "good
enough".

That's why I am convinced that in the end we will need something like a
"tree walk" algorithm, where an "intelligent" algorithm starts at (let's
say) a /32 boundary and then gets responses to the best fitting response.

Yes, such an approach might initially double the amount of queries and has
an increased risk of not getting DNS responses, but on the other hand such
"tree information" can be nicely cached with reasonably long TTLs, even for
the fast-paced DNSBLs out there.

Maybe such a tree-walk algorithm is worth an experiment as a SpamAssassin
plugin?

-- Matthias

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Franck Martin <fm...@linkedin.com>.
On Nov 22, 2014, at 4:15 AM, Aban Dokht <ml...@abando.de> wrote:

> 
> On 21.11.2014 18:17, Matthias Leisi wrote:
>> We are about to simplify the reporting we
>> previously had, and want to push this especially to detect spam coming
>> in over IPv6.
> 
> We also have honeypots with enabled IPv6 MX, but SPAM over IPv6 is very, very seldom. But pushing IPv6 anti spam is a good approach.
> 

You may want to read https://www.m3aawg.org/sites/maawg/files/news/M3AAWG_Inbound_IPv6_Policy_Issues-2014-09.pdf

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Aban Dokht <ml...@abando.de>.

On 21.11.2014 18:17, Matthias Leisi wrote:
> We are about to simplify the reporting we
> previously had, and want to push this especially to detect spam coming
> in over IPv6.

We also have honeypots with enabled IPv6 MX, but SPAM over IPv6 is very, 
very seldom. But pushing IPv6 anti spam is a good approach.


-- 
  Aban Dokht                                   aban.dokht@abando.de
       system administrator of 0 day abusers DNSBL bl.dbrs.de
------------------------------------------------------------------


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Matthias Leisi <ma...@leisi.net>.
Btw., the dnswl.org project is happy to receive whatever spamtrap hits. We
are about to simplify the reporting we previously had, and want to push
this especially to detect spam coming in over IPv6.

Details off list :)

-- Matthias

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Philip Prindeville <ph...@redfish-solutions.com>.
On Dec 4, 2014, at 2:30 PM, Dave Pooser <da...@pooserville.com> wrote:

> On 12/4/14, 3:10 PM, "Philip Prindeville"
> <ph...@redfish-solutions.com> wrote:
> 
>> Not necessarily.  If I post to a list with this address, and wait 60
>> days, I can assume that 99.999% of email that comes back after that date
>> is not related to the original posting.
>> 
>> Further, after 15 days, anything which doesn't also copy the list is
>> almost certainly Spam.
> 
> Eh, if I'm researching an odd bug, for instance, and find a 2-year old
> post from someone who had the same problem but don't see any resolution
> posted, I'll probably ping the OP offlist with a "Hey, did you ever find
> the fix for that problem $FOO you were having?" since I can't assume
> they're still subscribed to the list. I may or may not copy the list on
> that email, though I certainly will if I come up with an answer.
> 
> <obligatory http://xkcd.com/979/ reference here>

I’ll have to remember to make the posting sufficiently uninteresting to be remembered for any significant length of time.  ;-)

-Philip



Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Dave Pooser <da...@pooserville.com>.
On 12/4/14, 3:10 PM, "Philip Prindeville"
<ph...@redfish-solutions.com> wrote:

>Not necessarily.  If I post to a list with this address, and wait 60
>days, I can assume that 99.999% of email that comes back after that date
>is not related to the original posting.
>
>Further, after 15 days, anything which doesn't also copy the list is
>almost certainly Spam.

Eh, if I'm researching an odd bug, for instance, and find a 2-year old
post from someone who had the same problem but don't see any resolution
posted, I'll probably ping the OP offlist with a "Hey, did you ever find
the fix for that problem $FOO you were having?" since I can't assume
they're still subscribed to the list. I may or may not copy the list on
that email, though I certainly will if I come up with an answer.

<obligatory http://xkcd.com/979/ reference here>
-- 
Dave Pooser
Cat-Herder-in-Chief, Pooserville.com
"...Life is not a journey to the grave with the intention of arriving
safely in one pretty and well-preserved piece, but to slide across the
finish line broadside, thoroughly used up, worn out, leaking oil, and
shouting GERONIMO!!!" -- Bill McKenna





Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Philip Prindeville <ph...@redfish-solutions.com>.
On 12/04/2014 05:32 AM, Reindl Harald wrote:
>
> Am 03.12.2014 um 23:56 schrieb Philip Prindeville:
>> On 11/21/2014 09:49 AM, David F. Skoll wrote:
>>> On Fri, 21 Nov 2014 08:43:22 -0800 (PST)
>>> John Hardin <jh...@impsec.org> wrote:
>>>
>>>> On a public mailng list isn't a great place to discuss such tactics...
>>> I suspect spammers are dumb and will just vacuum up any address
>>> they can find.  Also, the scammers who sell CDs with millions of
>>> email addresses on them are unlikely to do anything but the most 
>>> cursory
>>> checking of the addresses.
>>>
>>> Make a honeypot subdomain, put up any web content with
>>> email addresses and I guarantee you'll start receiving email
>>> on those addresses within a few days.
>>>
>>> Regards,
>>>
>>> David.
>>
>> Having it appear in a resume on any of the job sites (dice, monster,
>> ladders, etc) is a good way to get it harvested.
>>
>> So is posting to mozilla-general@mozilla.org or 
>> netdev@vger.kernel.org ...
>
> and *that* is exactly hwat you should avoid: post a honeypot address 
> somewhere actively - a honeypot address should never be submitted 
> because you ask for troubles and false positives doing so
>

Not necessarily.  If I post to a list with this address, and wait 60 
days, I can assume that 99.999% of email that comes back after that date 
is not related to the original posting.

Further, after 15 days, anything which doesn't also copy the list is 
almost certainly Spam.

-Philip


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 03.12.2014 um 23:56 schrieb Philip Prindeville:
> On 11/21/2014 09:49 AM, David F. Skoll wrote:
>> On Fri, 21 Nov 2014 08:43:22 -0800 (PST)
>> John Hardin <jh...@impsec.org> wrote:
>>
>>> On a public mailng list isn't a great place to discuss such tactics...
>> I suspect spammers are dumb and will just vacuum up any address
>> they can find.  Also, the scammers who sell CDs with millions of
>> email addresses on them are unlikely to do anything but the most cursory
>> checking of the addresses.
>>
>> Make a honeypot subdomain, put up any web content with
>> email addresses and I guarantee you'll start receiving email
>> on those addresses within a few days.
>>
>> Regards,
>>
>> David.
>
> Having it appear in a resume on any of the job sites (dice, monster,
> ladders, etc) is a good way to get it harvested.
>
> So is posting to mozilla-general@mozilla.org or netdev@vger.kernel.org ...

and *that* is exactly hwat you should avoid: post a honeypot address 
somewhere actively - a honeypot address should never be submitted 
because you ask for troubles and false positives doing so


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Philip Prindeville <ph...@redfish-solutions.com>.
On 11/21/2014 09:49 AM, David F. Skoll wrote:
> On Fri, 21 Nov 2014 08:43:22 -0800 (PST)
> John Hardin <jh...@impsec.org> wrote:
>
>> On a public mailng list isn't a great place to discuss such tactics...
> I suspect spammers are dumb and will just vacuum up any address
> they can find.  Also, the scammers who sell CDs with millions of
> email addresses on them are unlikely to do anything but the most cursory
> checking of the addresses.
>
> Make a honeypot subdomain, put up any web content with
> email addresses and I guarantee you'll start receiving email
> on those addresses within a few days.
>
> Regards,
>
> David.

Having it appear in a resume on any of the job sites (dice, monster, 
ladders, etc) is a good way to get it harvested.

So is posting to mozilla-general@mozilla.org or netdev@vger.kernel.org ...


Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by "David F. Skoll" <df...@roaringpenguin.com>.
On Fri, 21 Nov 2014 08:43:22 -0800 (PST)
John Hardin <jh...@impsec.org> wrote:

> On a public mailng list isn't a great place to discuss such tactics...

I suspect spammers are dumb and will just vacuum up any address
they can find.  Also, the scammers who sell CDs with millions of
email addresses on them are unlikely to do anything but the most cursory
checking of the addresses.

Make a honeypot subdomain, put up any web content with
email addresses and I guarantee you'll start receiving email
on those addresses within a few days.

Regards,

David.

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by John Hardin <jh...@impsec.org>.
On Fri, 21 Nov 2014, Reindl Harald wrote:

>
> Am 21.11.2014 um 17:10 schrieb Joe Quinn:
>>  We are setting up some honeypot email addresses, and were wondering if
>>  anyone here had tips on how to include those addresses on webpages and
>>  other places.
>>
>>  We're currently going with a pretty simple <!-- honeypot@example.com -->
>>  HTML comment. Is that too obvious? Should we put it into a CSS invisible
>>  div as well? Any other ideas?
>
> use a dedicated domain or subdomain with a own MX record and link a 
> "pixel.gif" with regular changing addresses - finally avoid the word honeypot 
> to make it not obvious :-)
>
> these times the email inide a comment may be ignored by the smarter bots

On a public mailng list isn't a great place to discuss such tactics...

-- 
  John Hardin KA7OHZ                    http://www.impsec.org/~jhardin/
  jhardin@impsec.org    FALaholic #11174     pgpk -a jhardin@impsec.org
  key: 0xB8732E79 -- 2D8C 34F4 6411 F507 136C  AF76 D822 E6E6 B873 2E79
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
   The Tea Party wants to remove the Crony from Crony Capitalism.
   OWS wants to remove Capitalism from Crony Capitalism.
                                                     -- Astaghfirullah
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
  904 days since the first successful private support mission to ISS (SpaceX)

Re: Honeypot email addresses

Posted by Reindl Harald <h....@thelounge.net>.
Am 21.11.2014 um 17:10 schrieb Joe Quinn:
> We are setting up some honeypot email addresses, and were wondering if
> anyone here had tips on how to include those addresses on webpages and
> other places.
>
> We're currently going with a pretty simple <!-- honeypot@example.com -->
> HTML comment. Is that too obvious? Should we put it into a CSS invisible
> div as well? Any other ideas?

use a dedicated domain or subdomain with a own MX record and link a 
"pixel.gif" with regular changing addresses - finally avoid the word 
honeypot to make it not obvious :-)

these times the email inide a comment may be ignored by the smarter bots