You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to wsrp4j-user@portals.apache.org by Diego Louzán <dl...@apache.org> on 2005/07/01 03:00:57 UTC

Re: Broken CVS and an unfrequently asked question

It would be good for everybody if you left out that contemptuous tone. If you
want to **suggest** anything, you are welcome to do it.

The project has very little activity, and we are trying to improve that. We
have made a mistake, but the way things are done, at least in the ASF, is to
tell us we have made that mistake, not to blame us for it (nobody pays us for
doing this).

BTW, the FAQ clearly states that the only working portal environment with
ProxyPortlet is PlutoPortal.

Regards.
Diego.

Rickard Öberg wrote:
> Vishal Goenka wrote:
> 
>> Julie, thanks for fixing it before I got a chance to notice.
>> All, this is largely an mistake on my part. I submitted a patch for
>> Axis 1.2
>> upgrade and while I had tested it before, I regenerated the Java code
>> from
>> Axis to get a clean version, and did a diff against my working version.
>> Since outputs from the wsdl2java command do not match "exactly" from
>> one run
>> to another (the ordering on certain variable assignments isn’t same
>> from one
>> run to another) the diff is large and I did miss these one liner
>> replacements of the "return null" with the delegation to the WSRPEngine.
> 
> 
> In other words, you didn't test it at all before committing the code?
> Omitting the calls to WSRPEngine makes everything break in fairly
> glorious ways, so even a very simple test would have exposed the problem.
> 
> Fascinating. It seems this project doesn't need fixes or patches. It
> needs a strategy.
> 
> Which brings me back to the previous question: is any company on top of
> this project? Or are we in the Java world forced to use a WSRP reference
> implementation with basically no lead? Is IBM itself using the code, for
> but one example?
> 
> /Rickard


Re: Broken CVS and an unfrequently asked question

Posted by Diego Louzán <dl...@apache.org>.
Ok, things clear, I'm not opening a flame war. We'll try to resolve the issues
and I'll change the FAQ to be clearer.

Regards.
Diego.

Rickard Öberg wrote:
> Diego Louzán wrote:
> 
>> It would be good for everybody if you left out that contemptuous tone.
>> If you
>> want to **suggest** anything, you are welcome to do it.
> 
> 
> I'm not in contempt. I'm desperate, because Java-land is loosing
> momentum in this space because WSRP4J seems to have, **effectively**,
> sabotaged this spec. Everyone is waiting for a decent WSRP reference
> implementation that can be used, but it is not coming, and there doesn't
> seem to be a plan to make it so. We lost our first customer to a .Net
> competitor last week *specifically* because of WSRP support. I have
> waited and waited and waited for this project to get anywhere, and now
> that I try it out it is FUBAR. So no, I do not have a contemptous tone.
> I am on my bare knees pleading for you, or anyone really, to WAKE UP and
> fix it. Please!
> 
> Whether this sabotage is by intent or simply due to mismanagement I
> don't know, and don't care really. But it is the actual outcome. There
> is (as far as I know) no other OpenSource implementations, which is
> probably because this project was supposed to deliver a high-quality
> implementation under the Apache flag. How much better could it get?
> Theoretically, that is. So for the past year this project has "blocked"
> other implementations, without delivering. My suggestion is that you
> deal with that reality.
> 
>> The project has very little activity, and we are trying to improve
>> that. We
>> have made a mistake, but the way things are done, at least in the ASF,
>> is to
>> tell us we have made that mistake, not to blame us for it (nobody pays
>> us for
>> doing this).
> 
> 
> Oh cut the "nobody pays us" crap, please. I have written a shitload of
> OpenSource code (JBoss,WebWork,XDoclet, mainly) and when someone tells
> me that it doesn't work I do NOT pull the "I do this for fun, so don't
> complain" line. It is old and unprofessional.
> 
>> BTW, the FAQ clearly states that the only working portal environment with
>> ProxyPortlet is PlutoPortal.
> 
> 
> Sorry, I think I must have misinterpreted this then:
> "Theoretically you can use whichever portal environment you like most"
> 
> My bad.
> 
> /Rickard
> 


Re: Broken CVS and an unfrequently asked question

Posted by Rickard Öberg <ri...@dreambean.com>.
Diego Louzán wrote:
> It would be good for everybody if you left out that contemptuous tone. If you
> want to **suggest** anything, you are welcome to do it.

I'm not in contempt. I'm desperate, because Java-land is loosing 
momentum in this space because WSRP4J seems to have, **effectively**, 
sabotaged this spec. Everyone is waiting for a decent WSRP reference 
implementation that can be used, but it is not coming, and there doesn't 
seem to be a plan to make it so. We lost our first customer to a .Net 
competitor last week *specifically* because of WSRP support. I have 
waited and waited and waited for this project to get anywhere, and now 
that I try it out it is FUBAR. So no, I do not have a contemptous tone. 
I am on my bare knees pleading for you, or anyone really, to WAKE UP and 
fix it. Please!

Whether this sabotage is by intent or simply due to mismanagement I 
don't know, and don't care really. But it is the actual outcome. There 
is (as far as I know) no other OpenSource implementations, which is 
probably because this project was supposed to deliver a high-quality 
implementation under the Apache flag. How much better could it get? 
Theoretically, that is. So for the past year this project has "blocked" 
other implementations, without delivering. My suggestion is that you 
deal with that reality.

> The project has very little activity, and we are trying to improve that. We
> have made a mistake, but the way things are done, at least in the ASF, is to
> tell us we have made that mistake, not to blame us for it (nobody pays us for
> doing this).

Oh cut the "nobody pays us" crap, please. I have written a shitload of 
OpenSource code (JBoss,WebWork,XDoclet, mainly) and when someone tells 
me that it doesn't work I do NOT pull the "I do this for fun, so don't 
complain" line. It is old and unprofessional.

> BTW, the FAQ clearly states that the only working portal environment with
> ProxyPortlet is PlutoPortal.

Sorry, I think I must have misinterpreted this then:
"Theoretically you can use whichever portal environment you like most"

My bad.

/Rickard