You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@nuttx.apache.org by Gregory Nutt <sp...@gmail.com> on 2019/12/11 00:40:36 UTC

Candidate Committers

Given that we want to open up the first committer spots to all 
significant NuttX contributors, I made a list.  I went through the top 
20 or so all time contributors to NuttX and made a list of potential 
committers.  I have excluded already identified initial committers.  I 
have also excluded anyone who has not contributed in a long time (i.e., 
essentially former NuttX users).

I have already contacted some people who were not interested in 
participating on the PMC or being committers.   Of the people I have 
contacted, the following have an interest in being a committer and/or a 
member of the PPMC.

    Masayuki Ishikawa <Ma...@sony.com>
    Kenneth Pettit <pe...@gmail.com>
    Brennan Ashton <ba...@brennanashton.com>

There are eight more people whom I have not yet contacted.   I have made 
no concerted effort to contact them individually, I am having the 
relevant conversations as targets of opportunity.  I prefer not to name 
them here without first contacting them.

I understand that for some projects, all committers are PPMC members, 
and other projects PPMC members are only a subset of the committers.  I 
leave this to the PPMC.

I did make a commitment to keep a low profile while the PPMC is forming 
and I will do that.  But there a a few topics that I must hand-off to 
the PPMC (like this one) and a few that I must deal with myself (like 
the hand-off of the Bitbucket repositories to INFRA).

Greg

Re: Candidate Committers

Posted by Gregory Nutt <sp...@gmail.com>.
> Hi, Greg. In ASF, usually the discussion about the committer candidates
> should happen in the private@nuttx mailing list...
>
> And also, the later vote for the new PPMC members and committers should
> also happen in the private mailing list.

Okay... thanks!  Still learning how things work.

Greg

Re: Candidate Committers

Posted by "张铎 (Duo Zhang)" <pa...@gmail.com>.
Hi, Greg. In ASF, usually the discussion about the committer candidates
should happen in the private@nuttx mailing list...

And also, the later vote for the new PPMC members and committers should
also happen in the private mailing list.

Thanks.

Ishikawa, Masayuki (SHES) <Ma...@sony.com> 于2019年12月11日周三
上午9:05写道：

> Dear Greg,
>
> Thanks for adding me to the list.
>
> On 2019/12/11 9:41, "Gregory Nutt" <sp...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
>     Given that we want to open up the first committer spots to all
>     significant NuttX contributors, I made a list.  I went through the top
>     20 or so all time contributors to NuttX and made a list of potential
>     committers.  I have excluded already identified initial committers.  I
>     have also excluded anyone who has not contributed in a long time
> (i.e.,
>     essentially former NuttX users).
>
>     I have already contacted some people who were not interested in
>     participating on the PMC or being committers.   Of the people I have
>     contacted, the following have an interest in being a committer and/or
> a
>     member of the PPMC.
>
>         Masayuki Ishikawa <Ma...@sony.com>
>         Kenneth Pettit <pe...@gmail.com>
>         Brennan Ashton <ba...@brennanashton.com>
>
>     There are eight more people whom I have not yet contacted.   I have
> made
>     no concerted effort to contact them individually, I am having the
>     relevant conversations as targets of opportunity.  I prefer not to
> name
>     them here without first contacting them.
>
>     I understand that for some projects, all committers are PPMC members,
>     and other projects PPMC members are only a subset of the committers.
> I
>     leave this to the PPMC.
>
>     I did make a commitment to keep a low profile while the PPMC is
> forming
>     and I will do that.  But there a a few topics that I must hand-off to
>     the PPMC (like this one) and a few that I must deal with myself (like
>     the hand-off of the Bitbucket repositories to INFRA).
>
>     Greg
>
>
>
>

Re: Candidate Committers

Posted by "Ishikawa, Masayuki (SHES)" <Ma...@sony.com>.
Dear Greg,

Thanks for adding me to the list.

On 2019/12/11 9:41, "Gregory Nutt" <sp...@gmail.com> wrote:

    Given that we want to open up the first committer spots to all 
    significant NuttX contributors, I made a list.  I went through the top 
    20 or so all time contributors to NuttX and made a list of potential 
    committers.  I have excluded already identified initial committers.  I 
    have also excluded anyone who has not contributed in a long time (i.e., 
    essentially former NuttX users).
    
    I have already contacted some people who were not interested in 
    participating on the PMC or being committers.   Of the people I have 
    contacted, the following have an interest in being a committer and/or a 
    member of the PPMC.
    
        Masayuki Ishikawa <Ma...@sony.com>
        Kenneth Pettit <pe...@gmail.com>
        Brennan Ashton <ba...@brennanashton.com>
    
    There are eight more people whom I have not yet contacted.   I have made 
    no concerted effort to contact them individually, I am having the 
    relevant conversations as targets of opportunity.  I prefer not to name 
    them here without first contacting them.
    
    I understand that for some projects, all committers are PPMC members, 
    and other projects PPMC members are only a subset of the committers.  I 
    leave this to the PPMC.
    
    I did make a commitment to keep a low profile while the PPMC is forming 
    and I will do that.  But there a a few topics that I must hand-off to 
    the PPMC (like this one) and a few that I must deal with myself (like 
    the hand-off of the Bitbucket repositories to INFRA).
    
    Greg

Re: Candidate Committers

Posted by Alan Carvalho de Assis <ac...@gmail.com>.
HI Greg,

I think these guys are good options and it is very nice to see them aboard!

BR,

Alan

On 12/10/19, Gregory Nutt <sp...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Given that we want to open up the first committer spots to all
> significant NuttX contributors, I made a list.  I went through the top
> 20 or so all time contributors to NuttX and made a list of potential
> committers.  I have excluded already identified initial committers.  I
> have also excluded anyone who has not contributed in a long time (i.e.,
> essentially former NuttX users).
>
> I have already contacted some people who were not interested in
> participating on the PMC or being committers.   Of the people I have
> contacted, the following have an interest in being a committer and/or a
> member of the PPMC.
>
>     Masayuki Ishikawa <Ma...@sony.com>
>     Kenneth Pettit <pe...@gmail.com>
>     Brennan Ashton <ba...@brennanashton.com>
>
> There are eight more people whom I have not yet contacted.   I have made
> no concerted effort to contact them individually, I am having the
> relevant conversations as targets of opportunity.  I prefer not to name
> them here without first contacting them.
>
> I understand that for some projects, all committers are PPMC members,
> and other projects PPMC members are only a subset of the committers.  I
> leave this to the PPMC.
>
> I did make a commitment to keep a low profile while the PPMC is forming
> and I will do that.  But there a a few topics that I must hand-off to
> the PPMC (like this one) and a few that I must deal with myself (like
> the hand-off of the Bitbucket repositories to INFRA).
>
> Greg
>
>

Re: Candidate Committers

Posted by Justin Mclean <ju...@classsoftware.com>.
Hi,

> Given that we want to open up the first committer spots to all significant NuttX contributors, I made a list.  I went through the top 20 or so all time contributors to NuttX and made a list of potential committers.  I have excluded already identified initial committers.  I have also excluded anyone who has not contributed in a long time (i.e., essentially former NuttX users).

This lis a little unusual, I'll explain why on the private list.

Thanks,
Justin