You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to wsif-dev@ws.apache.org by Nirmal Mukhi <nm...@us.ibm.com> on 2003/02/20 12:29:30 UTC

Fw: ASF Board Meeting Summary for February 19, 2003

Hi,

Item (2) below would be relevant for us as concerns whether we can include 
jms.jar (and others) with our distribution, or have it in our CVS tree for 
building etc. so we should look out for the page Dirk will be making.

Nirmal.
----- Forwarded by Nirmal Mukhi/Watson/IBM on 02/20/2003 06:28 AM -----


Greg Stein <gs...@apache.org>
02/19/2003 10:05 PM
 
        To:     committers@apache.org
        cc: 
        Subject:        ASF Board Meeting Summary for February 19, 2003


ASF Committers,

The Board had its regularly-scheduled board meeting today. Since we won't
have any approved minutes until some future meeting, I like to send these
emails to keep people informed of what the Board is doing. In some cases,
this may affect you and your work at the ASF. In other cases, it could be
quite inconsequential, possibly interesting, possibly not. Whatever the
case, I hope these summaries are generally useful.

* We discussed a number of license and patent-related issues, which were
  brought up by the XML and the Web Services PMCs. In particular, the XML
  PMC asked us for resolution on a couple questions:

  1. is it okay to use the short license [in source files]
 
     "short license" in this case meant a *reference* to the license, 
rather
     than a copy of the license.

     Answer: no. The full text of the Apache Software License, version 
1.1,
                      should be included in all source files. 
Incorporation by
                      reference does not properly preserve the ASF's 
rights, nor our
                      intent for the licensing of our software.

     Note: there may be a different answer when we roll out the 2.0 
license,
           but we'll have to wait and see; that license is still a few
                    months away from rollout, I believe.

  2. Can we include software that uses license foo
 
     Answer: Dirk is going to start preparing a page on www.apache.org to
             answer this question on a license-by-license basis, as they
                      arise. The page will cover, for each license, things 
like
                      whether it is acceptable to have it in our CVS 
repository,
                      whether we can redistribute it from the ASF servers, 
whether we
                      can "link" against it, etc.

  The Web Services PMC raised the issue of RSA patents that are touched 
upon
  by the OpenSAML project. We don't have enough information at this time 
to
  act intelligently, but we'll keep an eye on the situation. The Board 
also
  took this as an indication that we should develop a patent policy; this
  will most likely happen *after* the 2.0 license work (although: note 
that
  the 2.0 license does have some patent considerations in it, but that is
  mostly a reflection of an implicit policy, rather than a statement).
 
  Licensing and patent discussions should occur on the 
licensing@apache.org
  mailing list. I believe that list is (currently) a closed list; please 
use
  your @apache.org address so the moderator knows you're "okay".

* The Board briefly discussed Mr Donald's committer status suspension,
  noting that it has expired and that the Avalon team has reinstated his
  commit privileges to that project. At this point, the Board has no 
further
  action plans or items w.r.t the suspension.

* The XML-Security (sub)project was moved from the Web Services PMC back 
to
  the XML PMC (at the community's request; they got swept up in the 
project
  migration).

* Chuck Murcko noted that we have a PayPal account now, and the 
contribution
  page now reflects that: 
http://www.apache.org/foundation/contributing.html

* The Board spent some time discussing the legal relationship between the
  PHP project and the ASF. This item has been hanging around for a while,
  and its resolution is a bit overdue. We're going to work with the PHP
  Group to figure out what the proper and best relationship is, to the
  benefit of all of us.

* There was a resolution to create a new PMC for the Maven project. We 
were
  already 20 minutes over our schedule, so we tabled this discussion. We
  don't want to table this for a whole month, though, so I'm going to be
  calling a Special Meeting of the Board, early next week, to wrap up this
  one item.


If you have any questions or concerns, then please feel free to direct 
them
to myself, other Directors, or (preferably) to board@apache.org. General
followups to this summary should be held on community@apache.org.

Cheers,
-g

-- 
gstein@apache.org ... ASF Chairman ... http://www.apache.org/