You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@jena.apache.org by Nick Khamis <sy...@gmail.com> on 2011/11/07 20:17:32 UTC

Re: [jena-dev] Re: OWL APIs, Triple Stores, OWL DL Rasoners Reply More|

Hello Everyone,

We are looking for a solution that would allow us to transfer our OWL2
knowledge base to a full fledged application.
What we are looking for are:

* An OWL API capable of creating OWL 2 models: The Protege API is
great however comes with much to much overhead,
i.e., the editor related implemanation. Is the Jena api capable of
creating OWL 2 ontology models? Are there any new,
and active ontology APIs currently out there?

* A triple store capable of storing OWL 2 expressions, and performing
deduction using the widely used reasoners. It is
important for us to support OWL or OWL 2 reasoning on the triple store
level. Much like Sesame does with OWLIM.
The triple store must also be able to inteface with the Pellet reasoner.

* Interface between the reasoners and the triple stores. I would
assume at this early stage that deduction on the triple
store level using a pellet would be done through an interface of some
sort (e.g., Triple Store -> Jena -> Pellet). If I am
not mistaken, what are some of the soultions used out there for this.

I have looked into projects such as PelletDB and Allegrograph which
look great however, we are looking for actively
developed open source solutions

Thanks in Advnace,

Ninus.

>> Have you looked at Stardog from Clark&Parsia?

Hello Alex,

Thank you so much for your response. Part of the requirements is to use
only open source projects.
It seems like Stardog is a commercial product?

Thanks in Advance,

Ninus.

Re: [jena-dev] Re: OWL APIs, Triple Stores, OWL DL Rasoners Reply More|

Posted by Dave Reynolds <da...@gmail.com>.
On 07/11/2011 19:17, Nick Khamis wrote:
> Hello Everyone,
>
> We are looking for a solution that would allow us to transfer our OWL2
> knowledge base to a full fledged application.
> What we are looking for are:
>
> * An OWL API capable of creating OWL 2 models: The Protege API is
> great however comes with much to much overhead,
> i.e., the editor related implemanation. Is the Jena api capable of
> creating OWL 2 ontology models?

Sort of. There is, as yet, no convenience API for OWL 2 in Jena. 
However, the OWL 2 RDF encoding is backward compatible so you can use 
the Jena OntModels OWL interface for the OWL 1 subset of features and 
then create your own wrapper methods to construct the RDF triples which 
make up the OWL 2 features that are not in OWL 1.

Not ideal but it can work and we do know of people constructing OWL 2 
models this way.

> * A triple store capable of storing OWL 2 expressions, and performing
> deduction using the widely used reasoners. It is
> important for us to support OWL or OWL 2 reasoning on the triple store
> level. Much like Sesame does with OWLIM.
> The triple store must also be able to inteface with the Pellet reasoner.

All Jena triple stores can store OWL 2 expressions since they are just RDF.

Both Pellet and OWLIM offer a Jena bridge. I believe StarDog offers some 
Jena integration as well.

> * Interface between the reasoners and the triple stores. I would
> assume at this early stage that deduction on the triple
> store level using a pellet would be done through an interface of some
> sort (e.g., Triple Store -> Jena -> Pellet). If I am
> not mistaken, what are some of the soultions used out there for this.

The way inference works in Jena, by default, is a Reasoner creates an 
inference model (InfModel or OntModel) which wraps some underlying store 
and creates (or at least acts as if it creates) the deductive closure of 
the base data. This means that any Jena Reasoner can work with any Jena 
store but that does have the disadvantage that the reasoner can't use 
special features of the underlying store.

Pellet implements the Jena reasoner interface and so can be used with 
any Jena Model implementation - though if the Model is backed by some 
database (as opposed to having been materialized in memory) then the 
inference will be slower.

I don't know the details of the OWLIM Jena interface but I would guess 
that they have a tight coupling between the store and inference rather 
than packaging the latter as a Jena Reasoner.

Dave

Re: [jena-dev] Re: OWL APIs, Triple Stores, OWL DL Rasoners Reply More|

Posted by Nick Khamis <sy...@gmail.com>.
Hello Robert,

Thank you so much for your response. It's not so much about the costs
associated with the licences, it's a
requirement put forth by those funding the project.

Kind Regards,

Ninus.

On Mon, Nov 7, 2011 at 2:24 PM, Robert Vesse <rv...@cray.com> wrote:
> Yes Stardog may be a commercial product but it is my understanding that like other triple stores (AllegroGraph, OWLIM, Virtuoso etc) it will have a free community edition that will have a limited feature set.
>
> Is open source a hard and fast requirement or do you just not want to pay for the triple store?  Depending on the amount of data you have and the features you need the free version of one of the mentioned triple stores may be suitable for your use case
>
> Rob
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Nick Khamis [mailto:symack@gmail.com]
> Sent: Monday, November 07, 2011 11:18 AM
> To: jena-dev@yahoogroups.com; jena-users@incubator.apache.org
> Subject: Re: [jena-dev] Re: OWL APIs, Triple Stores, OWL DL Rasoners Reply More|
>
> Hello Everyone,
>
> We are looking for a solution that would allow us to transfer our OWL2
> knowledge base to a full fledged application.
> What we are looking for are:
>
> * An OWL API capable of creating OWL 2 models: The Protege API is
> great however comes with much to much overhead,
> i.e., the editor related implemanation. Is the Jena api capable of
> creating OWL 2 ontology models? Are there any new,
> and active ontology APIs currently out there?
>
> * A triple store capable of storing OWL 2 expressions, and performing
> deduction using the widely used reasoners. It is
> important for us to support OWL or OWL 2 reasoning on the triple store
> level. Much like Sesame does with OWLIM.
> The triple store must also be able to inteface with the Pellet reasoner.
>
> * Interface between the reasoners and the triple stores. I would
> assume at this early stage that deduction on the triple
> store level using a pellet would be done through an interface of some
> sort (e.g., Triple Store -> Jena -> Pellet). If I am
> not mistaken, what are some of the soultions used out there for this.
>
> I have looked into projects such as PelletDB and Allegrograph which
> look great however, we are looking for actively
> developed open source solutions
>
> Thanks in Advnace,
>
> Ninus.
>
>>> Have you looked at Stardog from Clark&Parsia?
>
> Hello Alex,
>
> Thank you so much for your response. Part of the requirements is to use
> only open source projects.
> It seems like Stardog is a commercial product?
>
> Thanks in Advance,
>
> Ninus.
>

RE: [jena-dev] Re: OWL APIs, Triple Stores, OWL DL Rasoners Reply More|

Posted by Robert Vesse <rv...@cray.com>.
Yes Stardog may be a commercial product but it is my understanding that like other triple stores (AllegroGraph, OWLIM, Virtuoso etc) it will have a free community edition that will have a limited feature set.

Is open source a hard and fast requirement or do you just not want to pay for the triple store?  Depending on the amount of data you have and the features you need the free version of one of the mentioned triple stores may be suitable for your use case

Rob

-----Original Message-----
From: Nick Khamis [mailto:symack@gmail.com] 
Sent: Monday, November 07, 2011 11:18 AM
To: jena-dev@yahoogroups.com; jena-users@incubator.apache.org
Subject: Re: [jena-dev] Re: OWL APIs, Triple Stores, OWL DL Rasoners Reply More|

Hello Everyone,

We are looking for a solution that would allow us to transfer our OWL2
knowledge base to a full fledged application.
What we are looking for are:

* An OWL API capable of creating OWL 2 models: The Protege API is
great however comes with much to much overhead,
i.e., the editor related implemanation. Is the Jena api capable of
creating OWL 2 ontology models? Are there any new,
and active ontology APIs currently out there?

* A triple store capable of storing OWL 2 expressions, and performing
deduction using the widely used reasoners. It is
important for us to support OWL or OWL 2 reasoning on the triple store
level. Much like Sesame does with OWLIM.
The triple store must also be able to inteface with the Pellet reasoner.

* Interface between the reasoners and the triple stores. I would
assume at this early stage that deduction on the triple
store level using a pellet would be done through an interface of some
sort (e.g., Triple Store -> Jena -> Pellet). If I am
not mistaken, what are some of the soultions used out there for this.

I have looked into projects such as PelletDB and Allegrograph which
look great however, we are looking for actively
developed open source solutions

Thanks in Advnace,

Ninus.

>> Have you looked at Stardog from Clark&Parsia?

Hello Alex,

Thank you so much for your response. Part of the requirements is to use
only open source projects.
It seems like Stardog is a commercial product?

Thanks in Advance,

Ninus.