You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to issues@hawq.apache.org by wangbincmss <gi...@git.apache.org> on 2017/08/10 08:57:04 UTC

[GitHub] incubator-hawq pull request #1277: make hawq start cluster have "userinput.a...

GitHub user wangbincmss opened a pull request:

    https://github.com/apache/incubator-hawq/pull/1277

    make hawq  start cluster  have "userinput.ask_yesno"  like  hawq stop cluster 

    **The status quo:**
    [hawqdb@docker1 bin]$ hawq start cluster
    20170810:16:38:05:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Prepare to do 'hawq start'
    20170810:16:38:05:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-You can find log in:
    20170810:16:38:05:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-/home/hawqdb/hawqAdminLogs/hawq_start_20170810.log
    20170810:16:38:05:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-GPHOME is set to:
    20170810:16:38:05:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-/home/hawqdb/hawq
    20170810:16:38:05:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start hawq with args: ['start', 'cluster']
    20170810:16:38:05:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Gathering information and validating the environment...
    20170810:16:38:05:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-No standby host configured
    20170810:16:38:05:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start all the nodes in hawq cluster
    20170810:16:38:05:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Starting master node 'docker1.cmss.com'
    20170810:16:38:05:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start master service
    20170810:16:38:07:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Master started successfully
    20170810:16:38:07:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start all the segments in hawq cluster
    20170810:16:38:07:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start segments in list: ['docker4.cmss.com', 'docker5.cmss.com', 'docker2.cmss.com', 'docker3.cmss.com']
    20170810:16:38:07:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start segment service
    20170810:16:38:07:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Total segment number is: 4
    ....
    20170810:16:38:11:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-4 of 4 segments start successfully
    20170810:16:38:11:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Segments started successfully
    20170810:16:38:11:031474 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-HAWQ cluster started successfully
    
    [hawqdb@docker1 bin]$ hawq stop cluster
    20170810:16:47:24:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Prepare to do 'hawq stop'
    20170810:16:47:24:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-You can find log in:
    20170810:16:47:24:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-/home/hawqdb/hawqAdminLogs/hawq_stop_20170810.log
    20170810:16:47:24:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-GPHOME is set to:
    20170810:16:47:24:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-/home/hawqdb/hawq
    20170810:16:47:24:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Stop hawq with args: ['stop', 'cluster']
    
    Continue with HAWQ service stop Yy|Nn (default=N):
    > y
    20170810:16:47:26:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-No standby host configured
    20170810:16:47:26:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Stop hawq cluster
    20170810:16:47:26:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-There are 0 connections to the database
    20170810:16:47:26:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Commencing Master instance shutdown with mode='smart'
    20170810:16:47:26:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Master host=docker1.cmss.com
    20170810:16:47:26:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Stop hawq master
    20170810:16:47:27:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Master stopped successfully
    20170810:16:47:27:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Stop hawq segment
    20170810:16:47:27:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Stop segments in list: ['docker4.cmss.com', 'docker5.cmss.com', 'docker2.cmss.com', 'docker3.cmss.com']
    20170810:16:47:30:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Total segment number is: 4
    ...
    20170810:16:47:33:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-4 of 4 segments stop successfully
    20170810:16:47:33:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Segments stopped successfully
    20170810:16:47:33:003630 hawq_stop:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Cluster stopped successfully
    
    **Ther ringht expale:**
    [hawqdb@docker1 bin]$ hawq start  cluster
    20170810:14:09:52:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Prepare to do 'hawq start'
    20170810:14:09:52:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-You can find log in:
    20170810:14:09:52:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-/home/hawqdb/hawqAdminLogs/hawq_start_20170810.log
    20170810:14:09:52:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-GPHOME is set to:
    20170810:14:09:52:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-/home/hawqdb/hawq
    20170810:14:09:52:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start hawq with args: ['start', 'cluster']
    
    > 
    > Continue with HAWQ service start Yy|Nn (default=N):
    > > y
    
    20170810:14:09:54:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Gathering information and validating the environment...
    20170810:14:09:54:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-No standby host configured
    20170810:14:09:54:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start all the nodes in hawq cluster
    20170810:14:09:54:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Starting master node 'docker1.cmss.com'
    20170810:14:09:54:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start master service
    20170810:14:09:55:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Master started successfully
    20170810:14:09:55:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start all the segments in hawq cluster
    20170810:14:09:55:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start segments in list: ['docker4.cmss.com', 'docker5.cmss.com', 'docker2.cmss.com', 'docker3.cmss.com']
    20170810:14:09:55:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start segment service
    20170810:14:09:55:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Total segment number is: 4
    .....
    20170810:14:10:00:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-4 of 4 segments start successfully
    20170810:14:10:00:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Segments started successfully
    20170810:14:10:00:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-HAWQ cluster started successfully
    
    
    **I modified results:**
    
    20170810:14:09:52:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Prepare to do 'hawq start'
    20170810:14:09:52:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-You can find log in:
    20170810:14:09:52:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-/home/hawqdb/hawqAdminLogs/hawq_start_20170810.log
    20170810:14:09:52:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-GPHOME is set to:
    20170810:14:09:52:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-/home/hawqdb/hawq
    20170810:14:09:52:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start hawq with args: ['start', 'cluster']
    
    > Continue with HAWQ service start Yy|Nn (default=N):
    > > y
    
    20170810:14:09:54:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Gathering information and validating the environment...
    20170810:14:09:54:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-No standby host configured
    20170810:14:09:54:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start all the nodes in hawq cluster
    20170810:14:09:54:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Starting master node 'docker1.cmss.com'
    20170810:14:09:54:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start master service
    20170810:14:09:55:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Master started successfully
    20170810:14:09:55:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start all the segments in hawq cluster
    20170810:14:09:55:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start segments in list: ['docker4.cmss.com', 'docker5.cmss.com', 'docker2.cmss.com', 'docker3.cmss.com']
    20170810:14:09:55:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Start segment service
    20170810:14:09:55:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Total segment number is: 4
    .....
    20170810:14:10:00:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-4 of 4 segments start successfully
    20170810:14:10:00:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-Segments started successfully
    20170810:14:10:00:019805 hawq_start:docker1:hawqdb-[INFO]:-HAWQ cluster started successfully


You can merge this pull request into a Git repository by running:

    $ git pull https://github.com/wangbincmss/incubator-hawq master

Alternatively you can review and apply these changes as the patch at:

    https://github.com/apache/incubator-hawq/pull/1277.patch

To close this pull request, make a commit to your master/trunk branch
with (at least) the following in the commit message:

    This closes #1277
    
----
commit 1caa6a3f888625f3e0e8da88214b6843344349cf
Author: wangbincmss <30...@users.noreply.github.com>
Date:   2017-08-10T08:31:38Z

    Update hawq_ctl

----


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] incubator-hawq issue #1277: add hawq start "userinput.ask_yesno"

Posted by stanlyxiang <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user stanlyxiang commented on the issue:

    https://github.com/apache/incubator-hawq/pull/1277
  
    @wangbincmss  
    Since hawq opened source and use apache JIRA to tracker all the changes, so for every pull request please create a apache jira first for your pull request like other PRs. Use the jira to describe your problem and devs can discuss whether we should do the changes under the jira.
    
    For this pr, I don't think it's reasonable to add "userinput.ask_yesno" for "hawq start". IMO, "hawq init" or "hawq stop" will break the alive cluster if exists. "ask_yesno" will make users think twice for whether there is an alive cluster and whether to proceed. But there is no problem to proceed "hawq start" directly no matter how the cluster state is. "hawq start" will give corresponding hints for different errors.


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] incubator-hawq pull request #1277: add hawq start "userinput.ask_yesno"

Posted by wangbincmss <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user wangbincmss closed the pull request at:

    https://github.com/apache/incubator-hawq/pull/1277


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---