[jira] [Commented] (KAFKA-7556) KafkaConsumer.beginningOffsets does not return actual first offsets

["Robert V (JIRA)" <ji...@apache.org>]

    [ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KAFKA-7556?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=16672962#comment-16672962 ] 

Robert V commented on KAFKA-7556:
---------------------------------

I didn't see this issue with a non-compacted topics, but that topic has a very long retention set so messages were never deleted.

> KafkaConsumer.beginningOffsets does not return actual first offsets
> -------------------------------------------------------------------
>
>                 Key: KAFKA-7556
>                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KAFKA-7556
>             Project: Kafka
>          Issue Type: Bug
>          Components: clients, consumer
>    Affects Versions: 1.0.0
>            Reporter: Robert V
>            Priority: Critical
>              Labels: documentation, usability
>             Fix For: 2.2.0
>
>
> h2. Description of the problem
> The method `org.apache.kafka.clients.consumer.KafkaConsumer.beginningOffsets` claims in its Javadoc documentation that it would 'Get the first offset for the given partitions.'.
> I used it with a compacted topic, and it always returned offset 0 for all partitions.
>  Not sure if using a compacted topic actually matters, but I'm enclosing this information anyway.
> Given a Kafka topic with retention set, and old log files being removed as a result of that, the effective start offset of those partitions move further; it simply will be greater than offset 0.
> However, calling the `beginningOffsets` method always returns offset 0 as the first offset.
> In contrast, when the method `org.apache.kafka.clients.consumer.KafkaConsumer.offsetsForTimes` is called with a timestamp of 0L (UNIX epoch 1st Jan, 1970), it correctly returns the effective start offsets for each partitions.
> Output of using `org.apache.kafka.clients.consumer.KafkaConsumer.beginningOffsets`: 
> {code:java}
> {test.topic-87=0, test.topic-54=0, test.topic-21=0, test.topic-79=0, test.topic-46=0, test.topic-13=0, test.topic-70=0, test.topic-37=0, test.topic-12=0, test.topic-95=0, test.topic-62=0, test.topic-29=0, test.topic-4=0, test.topic-88=0, test.topic-55=0, test.topic-22=0, test.topic-80=0, test.topic-47=0, test.topic-14=0, test.topic-71=0, test.topic-38=0, test.topic-5=0, test.topic-96=0, test.topic-63=0, test.topic-30=0, test.topic-56=0, test.topic-23=0, test.topic-89=0, test.topic-48=0, test.topic-15=0, test.topic-81=0, test.topic-72=0, test.topic-39=0, test.topic-6=0, test.topic-64=0, test.topic-31=0, test.topic-97=0, test.topic-24=0, test.topic-90=0, test.topic-57=0, test.topic-16=0, test.topic-82=0, test.topic-49=0, test.topic-40=0, test.topic-7=0, test.topic-73=0, test.topic-32=0, test.topic-98=0, test.topic-65=0, test.topic-91=0, test.topic-58=0, test.topic-25=0, test.topic-83=0, test.topic-50=0, test.topic-17=0, test.topic-8=0, test.topic-74=0, test.topic-41=0, test.topic-0=0, test.topic-99=0, test.topic-66=0, test.topic-33=0, test.topic-92=0, test.topic-59=0, test.topic-26=0, test.topic-84=0, test.topic-51=0, test.topic-18=0, test.topic-75=0, test.topic-42=0, test.topic-9=0, test.topic-67=0, test.topic-34=0, test.topic-1=0, test.topic-85=0, test.topic-60=0, test.topic-27=0, test.topic-77=0, test.topic-52=0, test.topic-19=0, test.topic-76=0, test.topic-43=0, test.topic-10=0, test.topic-93=0, test.topic-68=0, test.topic-35=0, test.topic-2=0, test.topic-86=0, test.topic-53=0, test.topic-28=0, test.topic-78=0, test.topic-45=0, test.topic-20=0, test.topic-69=0, test.topic-44=0, test.topic-11=0, test.topic-94=0, test.topic-61=0, test.topic-36=0, test.topic-3=0}
> {code}
> Output of using `org.apache.kafka.clients.consumer.KafkaConsumer.offsetsForTimes`:
> {code:java}
> {test.topic-87=(timestamp=1511264434285, offset=289), test.topic-54=(timestamp=1511265134993, offset=45420), test.topic-21=(timestamp=1511265534207, offset=63643), test.topic-79=(timestamp=1511270338275, offset=380750), test.topic-46=(timestamp=1511266883588, offset=266379), test.topic-13=(timestamp=1511265900538, offset=98512), test.topic-70=(timestamp=1511266972452, offset=118522), test.topic-37=(timestamp=1511264396370, offset=763), test.topic-12=(timestamp=1511265504886, offset=61108), test.topic-95=(timestamp=1511289492800, offset=847647), test.topic-62=(timestamp=1511265831298, offset=68299), test.topic-29=(timestamp=1511278767417, offset=548361), test.topic-4=(timestamp=1511269316679, offset=144855), test.topic-88=(timestamp=1511265608468, offset=107831), test.topic-55=(timestamp=1511267449288, offset=129241), test.topic-22=(timestamp=1511283134114, offset=563095), test.topic-80=(timestamp=1511277334877, offset=534859), test.topic-47=(timestamp=1511265530689, offset=71608), test.topic-14=(timestamp=1511266308829, offset=80962), test.topic-71=(timestamp=1511265474740, offset=83607), test.topic-38=(timestamp=1511268268259, offset=166460), test.topic-5=(timestamp=1511276243850, offset=294307), test.topic-96=(timestamp=1511276749138, offset=483237), test.topic-63=(timestamp=1511276798188, offset=441051), test.topic-30=(timestamp=1511269265206, offset=151727), test.topic-56=(timestamp=1511267813861, offset=171045), test.topic-23=(timestamp=1511268644790, offset=103736), test.topic-89=(timestamp=1511270771269, offset=276851), test.topic-48=(timestamp=1511279335687, offset=696518), test.topic-15=(timestamp=1511265886647, offset=82049), test.topic-81=(timestamp=1511272770367, offset=426329), test.topic-72=(timestamp=1511265783620, offset=76346), test.topic-39=(timestamp=1511265444819, offset=39325), test.topic-6=(timestamp=1511343902830, offset=501911), test.topic-64=(timestamp=1511276754029, offset=517845), test.topic-31=(timestamp=1511265905957, offset=68886), test.topic-97=(timestamp=1511271052868, offset=378159), test.topic-24=(timestamp=1511268471118, offset=185533), test.topic-90=(timestamp=1511265280669, offset=54403), test.topic-57=(timestamp=1511266299095, offset=154119), test.topic-16=(timestamp=1511266140680, offset=91612), test.topic-82=(timestamp=1511266586862, offset=158657), test.topic-49=(timestamp=1511265550828, offset=67356), test.topic-40=(timestamp=1511266374225, offset=133092), test.topic-7=(timestamp=1511270077779, offset=178568), test.topic-73=(timestamp=1511324184866, offset=1897104), test.topic-32=(timestamp=1511269989097, offset=291600), test.topic-98=(timestamp=1511282897007, offset=813386), test.topic-65=(timestamp=1511265848788, offset=97431), test.topic-91=(timestamp=1511270007091, offset=302858), test.topic-58=(timestamp=1511273273743, offset=416483), test.topic-25=(timestamp=1511266304470, offset=85250), test.topic-83=(timestamp=1511272177062, offset=426855), test.topic-50=(timestamp=1511266726637, offset=151059), test.topic-17=(timestamp=1511265892637, offset=71425), test.topic-8=(timestamp=1511276315670, offset=386542), test.topic-74=(timestamp=1511265671808, offset=79210), test.topic-41=(timestamp=1511265957561, offset=84127), test.topic-0=(timestamp=1511265529344, offset=56920), test.topic-99=(timestamp=1511265343408, offset=34036), test.topic-66=(timestamp=1511268683052, offset=285773), test.topic-33=(timestamp=1511292268724, offset=627169), test.topic-92=(timestamp=1511265745483, offset=67471), test.topic-59=(timestamp=1511275909747, offset=398275), test.topic-26=(timestamp=1511268821082, offset=167519), test.topic-84=(timestamp=1511320800595, offset=1820740), test.topic-51=(timestamp=1511267699931, offset=201574), test.topic-18=(timestamp=1511277137591, offset=447521), test.topic-75=(timestamp=1511266718159, offset=101415), test.topic-42=(timestamp=1511268280357, offset=102338), test.topic-9=(timestamp=1511321331900, offset=1012234), test.topic-67=(timestamp=1511266755881, offset=157516), test.topic-34=(timestamp=1511265028871, offset=18917), test.topic-1=(timestamp=1511269548372, offset=114164), test.topic-85=(timestamp=1511265426041, offset=59734), test.topic-60=(timestamp=1511299615444, offset=1395047), test.topic-27=(timestamp=1511284039796, offset=567605), test.topic-77=(timestamp=1511265412189, offset=45907), test.topic-52=(timestamp=1511268603935, offset=212559), test.topic-19=(timestamp=1511266992878, offset=98667), test.topic-76=(timestamp=1511269937877, offset=304288), test.topic-43=(timestamp=1511267795292, offset=130635), test.topic-10=(timestamp=1511265000373, offset=26730), test.topic-93=(timestamp=1511275532751, offset=545451), test.topic-68=(timestamp=1511266797346, offset=160989), test.topic-35=(timestamp=1511279364499, offset=694191), test.topic-2=(timestamp=1511270517080, offset=79696), test.topic-86=(timestamp=1511266816638, offset=142042), test.topic-53=(timestamp=1511265524531, offset=44083), test.topic-28=(timestamp=1511266431654, offset=97500), test.topic-78=(timestamp=1511266431145, offset=95872), test.topic-45=(timestamp=1511273274002, offset=346044), test.topic-20=(timestamp=1511268405607, offset=166317), test.topic-69=(timestamp=1511266953570, offset=143188), test.topic-44=(timestamp=1511289270173, offset=870214), test.topic-11=(timestamp=1511271446913, offset=182125), test.topic-94=(timestamp=1511290978907, offset=1022343), test.topic-61=(timestamp=1511303529222, offset=1204397), test.topic-36=(timestamp=1511266872111, offset=172640), test.topic-3=(timestamp=1511266312670, offset=98632)}
> {code}
> h2. Proposed fix
>  * If the intention is to return what the beginning offset ever was, the Javadoc documentation should be explicit about it and another method should be added to query the effective start offsets.
>  * Alternatively, the method should return the actual start offset of the partitions at the time of calling this method. Which, for topics with retention policy set, is not equal to what the start offsets were before removing log files.



--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v7.6.3#76005)