You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to general@incubator.apache.org by "Jean T. Anderson" <jt...@bristowhill.com> on 2006/03/15 05:04:53 UTC

[doc] Incubation Policy -> "Acceptance of Proposal by Sponsor"

I'm resurrecting the thread that fell off into /dev/null after
http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/incubator-general/200603.mbox/%3cf470f68e0603091122m65e764f7k204e1cb12271f5cd@mail.gmail.com%3e

So this sentence in
http://incubator.apache.org/incubation/Incubation_Policy.html#Acceptance+of+Proposal+by+Sponsor
doesn't match current reality and confuses TLP sponsors who think they
need to wait for an Incubator PMC vote:

> The Incubator PMC MAY immediately accept the Candidate, or may (at the discretion of the Incubator PMC) require a successful VOTE by the Incubator PMC. 

Here are a couple replacement suggestions that give the Incubator PMC an
opportunity to voice any objections:

 a) Sponsor may proceed with podling creation if the Incubator PMC
raises no issues within three days.

- or -

 b) Sponsor may proceed with podling creation after the Incubator PMC
acknowleges the request.


Which would work best? Or feel free to toss both out and offer a better
suggestion.

This sentence is also a problem, but I'll re-raise it once the
discussion about minimum # mentors shakes out:

> The nominated Mentors MAY be immediately accepted by the Incubator PMC. However the Incubator PMC MAY also suggest replacement Mentors. The Incubator PMC has the final choice of Mentors. 

thanks,

-jean

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@incubator.apache.org


Re: [doc] Incubation Policy -> "Acceptance of Proposal by Sponsor"

Posted by "Jean T. Anderson" <jt...@bristowhill.com>.
Justin Erenkrantz wrote:
> On 3/14/06, Jean T. Anderson <jt...@bristowhill.com> wrote:
> 
>>I'm resurrecting the thread that fell off into /dev/null after
>>http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/incubator-general/200603.mbox/%3cf470f68e0603091122m65e764f7k204e1cb12271f5cd@mail.gmail.com%3e
>>
>>So this sentence in
>>http://incubator.apache.org/incubation/Incubation_Policy.html#Acceptance+of+Proposal+by+Sponsor
>>doesn't match current reality and confuses TLP sponsors who think they
>>need to wait for an Incubator PMC vote:
>>
>>
>>>The Incubator PMC MAY immediately accept the Candidate, or may (at the discretion of the Incubator PMC) require a successful VOTE by the Incubator PMC.
>>
>>Here are a couple replacement suggestions that give the Incubator PMC an
>>opportunity to voice any objections:
>>
>> a) Sponsor may proceed with podling creation if the Incubator PMC
>>raises no issues within three days.
>>
>>- or -
>>
>> b) Sponsor may proceed with podling creation after the Incubator PMC
>>acknowleges the request.
> 
> 
> a+b.  =)
> 
> How about following the board's system for acknowledging new PMC members:
> 1. PMC *chair* of Sponsor sends in notification to general@incubator.
> 1. Any Incubator PMC member can then send an ACK and start a 72hr clock.
> 2. If any PMC member says "hold" before 72hrs are up, a formal
> discussion/vote is then conducted.
> 3. If no PMC member has any negative comment at the end of 72hr clock,
> then the PMC chair can commit the status file and 'start' the podling.
> 
> How does that sound?  -- justin

I like it -- it's sane and uses another established procedure.

If there aren't any objections, I'll change the docs to reflect this on
Saturday, giving everyone adequate time to comment.

 -jean

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@incubator.apache.org


Re: [doc] Incubation Policy -> "Acceptance of Proposal by Sponsor"

Posted by "Jean T. Anderson" <jt...@bristowhill.com>.
Justin Erenkrantz wrote:
> On 3/14/06, Jean T. Anderson <jt...@bristowhill.com> wrote:
> 
>>I'm resurrecting the thread that fell off into /dev/null after
>>http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/incubator-general/200603.mbox/%3cf470f68e0603091122m65e764f7k204e1cb12271f5cd@mail.gmail.com%3e
>>
>>So this sentence in
>>http://incubator.apache.org/incubation/Incubation_Policy.html#Acceptance+of+Proposal+by+Sponsor
>>doesn't match current reality and confuses TLP sponsors who think they
>>need to wait for an Incubator PMC vote:
>>
>>
>>>The Incubator PMC MAY immediately accept the Candidate, or may (at the discretion of the Incubator PMC) require a successful VOTE by the Incubator PMC.
>>
>>Here are a couple replacement suggestions that give the Incubator PMC an
>>opportunity to voice any objections:
>>
[snip]

> a+b.  =)
> 
> How about following the board's system for acknowledging new PMC members:
> 1. PMC *chair* of Sponsor sends in notification to general@incubator.
> 1. Any Incubator PMC member can then send an ACK and start a 72hr clock.
> 2. If any PMC member says "hold" before 72hrs are up, a formal
> discussion/vote is then conducted.
> 3. If no PMC member has any negative comment at the end of 72hr clock,
> then the PMC chair can commit the status file and 'start' the podling.
> 
> How does that sound?  -- justin

I committed pretty much what Justin wrote, but worked in some wording
from http://www.apache.org/dev/pmc.html#newpmc . Also, instead of "the
PMC chair can commit the status file and 'start' the podling', I put
"the status file may be committed and the podling started" -- once
approved, is there any reason for a mentor on that project to not commit
the status file?

 -jean

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@incubator.apache.org


Re: [doc] Incubation Policy -> "Acceptance of Proposal by Sponsor"

Posted by Justin Erenkrantz <ju...@erenkrantz.com>.
On 3/15/06, Alan D. Cabrera <li...@toolazydogs.com> wrote:
> I can extrapolate from past behavior on important podling votes.  My
> reservations are fair and based on past behavior.

No one other than an Incubator PMC member can acknowledge receipt of a
message intended for the Incubator PMC.  The notice message should be
sent to general@incubator.  If tardiness of the entire PMC becomes an
issue, we deal with it at that point.  However, I disagree that
tardiness is a pervasive issue.

> I agree with your statement about code imports but I didn't realize that
> they could stop a podling from being created.  IIUC, the Incubator PMC
> has final say on graduation but not on initiation.  Am I wrong in this
> understanding?

The Incubator PMC exists to ensure that all policies and procedures
are enforced for code donations and imports.  If a PMC member has a
procedural question, it must be cleared up before the podling is
created.  For example, the sponsoring PMC may state that they want to
import code into Subversion under the GPL.  That's clearly a no-no and
should be stopped sooner rather than later.

> While I agree that this would be unlikely and that common sense should
> govern the behavior of good cooperative communities, are we not writing
> policy?

Your suggestion removes the Incubator PMC's ability to perform oversight.

In the hypothetical example above with importing GPL (or some other
procedural/policy violation), the Incubator PMC can and should have
the authority to stop the sponsoring PMC from creating such a podling.

Now, what I am stating (and perhaps confusing the issue for you) is
that the Incubator PMC shouldn't be making technical judgments (such
as "no one wants X" or "I don't like Y") - but it has the
responsibility to ensure policies and procuedres are followed.  This
is why podlings can't perform any releases without the explicit
approval of the Incubator PMC.  The Incubator was created by the Board
to ensure our policies are followed.  -- justin

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@incubator.apache.org


Re: [doc] Incubation Policy -> "Acceptance of Proposal by Sponsor"

Posted by "Alan D. Cabrera" <li...@toolazydogs.com>.
Justin Erenkrantz wrote:
> On 3/15/06, Alan D. Cabrera <li...@toolazydogs.com> wrote:
>   
>> I have a concern about item 2.  It has been my experience that the Incubator PMC can be a bit tardy in replying to emails.  May I suggest that the 72 hour window starts w/ item 1?  Given that, then item 2 seems superfluous.
>>     
>
> Well, given that we haven't tried this policy, I don't think it's fair
> to say that the Incubator PMC will be tardy on issuing the ACK -
> that'd be a fine complaint to make if you witness it after the policy
> is in effect.
>   

I can extrapolate from past behavior on important podling votes.  My 
reservations are fair and based on past behavior.

> The Incubator PMC is delegated with the authority to approve code
> imports.  No other PMCs have the authority to approve code imports or
> podling creation.
>   

I agree with your statement about code imports but I didn't realize that 
they could stop a podling from being created.  IIUC, the Incubator PMC 
has final say on graduation but not on initiation.  Am I wrong in this 
understanding?

>> My next concern is in regard to 3.  It implies that if the Incubator PMC does not positively vote for the incubation, then it does not get incubated.  IIUC, the Incubator PMC cannot block the start of the incubation of a project that has been sponsored by another PMC.  Maybe that changed, I may have missed that exchange.
>>     
>
> By and large, I would not expect #3 (someone saying 'no') to happen
> very much.  The only valid complaints are about the form and
> procedures being followed.  All other complaints by Incubator PMC
> members about a podling (such as that they don't like technology
> 'foo') should be bit-bucketed.  If people try to vote against a
> podling sponsored by another PMC because of personal non-procedural
> reasons, they're going to get hit with a cluebat.  -- justin
>   

While I agree that this would be unlikely and that common sense should 
govern the behavior of good cooperative communities, are we not writing 
policy?



Regards,
Alan




Re: [doc] Incubation Policy -> "Acceptance of Proposal by Sponsor"

Posted by Justin Erenkrantz <ju...@erenkrantz.com>.
On 3/15/06, Alan D. Cabrera <li...@toolazydogs.com> wrote:
> I have a concern about item 2.  It has been my experience that the Incubator PMC can be a bit tardy in replying to emails.  May I suggest that the 72 hour window starts w/ item 1?  Given that, then item 2 seems superfluous.

Well, given that we haven't tried this policy, I don't think it's fair
to say that the Incubator PMC will be tardy on issuing the ACK -
that'd be a fine complaint to make if you witness it after the policy
is in effect.

The Incubator PMC is delegated with the authority to approve code
imports.  No other PMCs have the authority to approve code imports or
podling creation.

> My next concern is in regard to 3.  It implies that if the Incubator PMC does not positively vote for the incubation, then it does not get incubated.  IIUC, the Incubator PMC cannot block the start of the incubation of a project that has been sponsored by another PMC.  Maybe that changed, I may have missed that exchange.

By and large, I would not expect #3 (someone saying 'no') to happen
very much.  The only valid complaints are about the form and
procedures being followed.  All other complaints by Incubator PMC
members about a podling (such as that they don't like technology
'foo') should be bit-bucketed.  If people try to vote against a
podling sponsored by another PMC because of personal non-procedural
reasons, they're going to get hit with a cluebat.  -- justin

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@incubator.apache.org


Re: [doc] Incubation Policy -> "Acceptance of Proposal by Sponsor"

Posted by "Alan D. Cabrera" <li...@toolazydogs.com>.
Justin Erenkrantz wrote:
> On 3/14/06, Jean T. Anderson <jt...@bristowhill.com> wrote:
>   
>> I'm resurrecting the thread that fell off into /dev/null after
>> http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/incubator-general/200603.mbox/%3cf470f68e0603091122m65e764f7k204e1cb12271f5cd@mail.gmail.com%3e
>>
>> So this sentence in
>> http://incubator.apache.org/incubation/Incubation_Policy.html#Acceptance+of+Proposal+by+Sponsor
>> doesn't match current reality and confuses TLP sponsors who think they
>> need to wait for an Incubator PMC vote:
>>
>>     
>>> The Incubator PMC MAY immediately accept the Candidate, or may (at the discretion of the Incubator PMC) require a successful VOTE by the Incubator PMC.
>>>       
>> Here are a couple replacement suggestions that give the Incubator PMC an
>> opportunity to voice any objections:
>>
>>  a) Sponsor may proceed with podling creation if the Incubator PMC
>> raises no issues within three days.
>>
>> - or -
>>
>>  b) Sponsor may proceed with podling creation after the Incubator PMC
>> acknowleges the request.
>>     
>
> a+b.  =)
>
>   
We're talking about two PMCs so I've made it a little more explicit:

How about following the board's system for acknowledging new PMC members:
1. The *chair* of the Sponsoring PMC sends in notification to general@incubator.
2. Any Incubator PMC member can then send an ACK and start a 72hr clock.
3. If any Incubator PMC member says "hold" before 72hrs are up, a formal
discussion/vote is then conducted.
4. If no Incubator PMC member has any negative comment at the end of 72hr clock,  then the Sponsor PMC chair can commit the status file and 'start' the podling.


I have a concern about item 2.  It has been my experience that the Incubator PMC can be a bit tardy in replying to emails.  May I suggest that the 72 hour window starts w/ item 1?  Given that, then item 2 seems superfluous.

My next concern is in regard to 3.  It implies that if the Incubator PMC does not positively vote for the incubation, then it does not get incubated.  IIUC, the Incubator PMC cannot block the start of the incubation of a project that has been sponsored by another PMC.  Maybe that changed, I may have missed that exchange.


If my understanding is correct, I propose:

1. The *chair* of the Sponsoring PMC sends in notification to general@incubator.  At that time a 72 hour clock starts.

2. If any Incubator PMC member says "hold" before 72 hours are up, a formal
discussion is then conducted with the goal of consensus.  In the unfortunate circumstance that a consensus cannot be built, the Sponsoring PMC is free to proceed to start the podling; this should only be done in extreme cases.

3. If no Incubator PMC member has any negative comment at the end of 72 hour clock,  then the Sponsor PMC chair can commit the status file and 'start' the podling.



Regards,
Alan




Re: [doc] Incubation Policy -> "Acceptance of Proposal by Sponsor"

Posted by Justin Erenkrantz <ju...@erenkrantz.com>.
On 3/14/06, Jean T. Anderson <jt...@bristowhill.com> wrote:
> I'm resurrecting the thread that fell off into /dev/null after
> http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/incubator-general/200603.mbox/%3cf470f68e0603091122m65e764f7k204e1cb12271f5cd@mail.gmail.com%3e
>
> So this sentence in
> http://incubator.apache.org/incubation/Incubation_Policy.html#Acceptance+of+Proposal+by+Sponsor
> doesn't match current reality and confuses TLP sponsors who think they
> need to wait for an Incubator PMC vote:
>
> > The Incubator PMC MAY immediately accept the Candidate, or may (at the discretion of the Incubator PMC) require a successful VOTE by the Incubator PMC.
>
> Here are a couple replacement suggestions that give the Incubator PMC an
> opportunity to voice any objections:
>
>  a) Sponsor may proceed with podling creation if the Incubator PMC
> raises no issues within three days.
>
> - or -
>
>  b) Sponsor may proceed with podling creation after the Incubator PMC
> acknowleges the request.

a+b.  =)

How about following the board's system for acknowledging new PMC members:
1. PMC *chair* of Sponsor sends in notification to general@incubator.
1. Any Incubator PMC member can then send an ACK and start a 72hr clock.
2. If any PMC member says "hold" before 72hrs are up, a formal
discussion/vote is then conducted.
3. If no PMC member has any negative comment at the end of 72hr clock,
then the PMC chair can commit the status file and 'start' the podling.

How does that sound?  -- justin

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscribe@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-help@incubator.apache.org