Bug in MyFaces?

[CupertinoIndian <Cu...@yahoo.com>]

(reposting as the old thread is too old and nobody is reading it)

I have written a web application using JSF. The application runs when I 
use SunRI but it breaks when I use MyFaces. I have tested it on 
websphere as well as weblogic on multiple systems. Now I am convinced 
that it is a problem with MyFaces.

I couldn't attach my project zip file here, I posted it to this location 
http://www.geocities.com/cupertinoindian/MyFacesTest.zip

Install this web project (it is a WSAD/Websphere project but can easily 
be installed in eclipse/weblogic). Go to URL 
http://localhost/myFacesTest/jsf/start.faces
click next, dummy.faces is displayed
click next, dummy.faces is displayed again (which is correct) but this 
time there is no data. The application works if you try it with Sun's 
Reference Implementation.

Note that the bean clientTaskHandler is configured to be request scope. 
If you change it to session scope, try the test again and this time the 
dummy.faces always has the data.

Alternatively, if you replace myfaces jars with Sun's RI jars, the 
application works as well.

Any insight is appreciated.
Thanks
CupertinoIndian

Re: Bug in MyFaces?

[CupertinoIndian <Cu...@yahoo.com>]

Please refer back to an old thread titled "Navigation not working in 
MyFaces (works with Sun's RI)" dated 4/5/2005.

I had many suggestions/responses and I tried many things. It does not work.


Sean Schofield wrote:

> Can you briefly summarize your problem?  It might be possible for
> someone to answer your question without having to install your webapp
> and become familiar with it.  Try to distill it down to a simple
> example to illustrate your point.
> 
> sean 
> 

Re: Bug in MyFaces?

[Sean Schofield <se...@gmail.com>]

Can you briefly summarize your problem?  It might be possible for
someone to answer your question without having to install your webapp
and become familiar with it.  Try to distill it down to a simple
example to illustrate your point.

sean 

On 4/22/05, CupertinoIndian <Cu...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> 
> (reposting as the old thread is too old and nobody is reading it)
> 
> I have written a web application using JSF. The application runs when I
> use SunRI but it breaks when I use MyFaces. I have tested it on
> websphere as well as weblogic on multiple systems. Now I am convinced
> that it is a problem with MyFaces.
> 
> I couldn't attach my project zip file here, I posted it to this location
> http://www.geocities.com/cupertinoindian/MyFacesTest.zip
> 
> Install this web project (it is a WSAD/Websphere project but can easily
> be installed in eclipse/weblogic). Go to URL
> http://localhost/myFacesTest/jsf/start.faces
> click next, dummy.faces is displayed
> click next, dummy.faces is displayed again (which is correct) but this
> time there is no data. The application works if you try it with Sun's
> Reference Implementation.
> 
> Note that the bean clientTaskHandler is configured to be request scope.
> If you change it to session scope, try the test again and this time the
> dummy.faces always has the data.
> 
> Alternatively, if you replace myfaces jars with Sun's RI jars, the
> application works as well.
> 
> Any insight is appreciated.
> Thanks
> CupertinoIndian
> 
>