You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to issues@flink.apache.org by dawidwys <gi...@git.apache.org> on 2017/07/23 12:27:39 UTC

[GitHub] flink pull request #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, fli...

GitHub user dawidwys opened a pull request:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384

    [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, flink-java, flink-opti…

    …mizer per package
    
    Thanks for contributing to Apache Flink. Before you open your pull request, please take the following check list into consideration.
    If your changes take all of the items into account, feel free to open your pull request. For more information and/or questions please refer to the [How To Contribute guide](http://flink.apache.org/how-to-contribute.html).
    In addition to going through the list, please provide a meaningful description of your changes.
    
    - [ ] General
      - The pull request references the related JIRA issue ("[FLINK-XXX] Jira title text")
      - The pull request addresses only one issue
      - Each commit in the PR has a meaningful commit message (including the JIRA id)
    
    - [ ] Documentation
      - Documentation has been added for new functionality
      - Old documentation affected by the pull request has been updated
      - JavaDoc for public methods has been added
    
    - [ ] Tests & Build
      - Functionality added by the pull request is covered by tests
      - `mvn clean verify` has been executed successfully locally or a Travis build has passed


You can merge this pull request into a Git repository by running:

    $ git pull https://github.com/dawidwys/flink checkstyle-suppressions

Alternatively you can review and apply these changes as the patch at:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384.patch

To close this pull request, make a commit to your master/trunk branch
with (at least) the following in the commit message:

    This closes #4384
    
----
commit 26ab6dee90f907c54b17a4c8e707134faecd1f0e
Author: Dawid Wysakowicz <dw...@apache.org>
Date:   2017-07-23T12:12:46Z

    [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, flink-java, flink-optimizer per package

----


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink issue #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, flink-java...

Posted by zentol <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user zentol commented on the issue:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384
  
    Looks good to me, +1 once travis gives green light.


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink pull request #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, fli...

Posted by asfgit <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user asfgit closed the pull request at:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink pull request #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, fli...

Posted by zentol <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user zentol commented on a diff in the pull request:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384#discussion_r129042176
  
    --- Diff: tools/maven/suppressions-optimizer.xml ---
    @@ -56,4 +56,32 @@ under the License.
     	<suppress
     		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]([^/\\]*\.java)"
     		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]testfunctions[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]programs[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]java[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport|NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]dataexchange[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport|NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]custompartition[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport|NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]([^/\\]*\.java)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]operators[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport"/>
    --- End diff --
    
    HMM....let's keep it as it is, but add a comment why it looks that way.
    
    FYI; i just noticed that we're also excluding test files for flink-runtime, which is why this issue didn't pop up earlier...


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink issue #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, flink-java...

Posted by dawidwys <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user dawidwys commented on the issue:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384
  
    Yes, unfortunately in the poms for those modules, the checkstyle was disabled for test sources. That is why I forgot about tests. I enabled them and will prepared fixed version of suppression files.


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink issue #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, flink-java...

Posted by zentol <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user zentol commented on the issue:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384
  
    hmm...but the build is still passing...


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink pull request #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, fli...

Posted by zentol <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user zentol commented on a diff in the pull request:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384#discussion_r129044374
  
    --- Diff: tools/maven/suppressions-optimizer.xml ---
    @@ -56,4 +56,32 @@ under the License.
     	<suppress
     		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]([^/\\]*\.java)"
     		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]testfunctions[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]programs[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]java[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport|NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]dataexchange[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport|NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]custompartition[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport|NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]([^/\\]*\.java)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]operators[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport"/>
    --- End diff --
    
    For clarity purposes I would also suggest to group main/test suppressions by package, instead of first having all main suppressions and then all test suppressions.


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink pull request #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, fli...

Posted by zentol <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user zentol commented on a diff in the pull request:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384#discussion_r129015817
  
    --- Diff: tools/maven/suppressions-java.xml ---
    @@ -24,6 +24,27 @@ under the License.
     
     <suppressions>
     	<suppress
    -		files=".*"
    +		files="(.*)java[/\\]io[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)java[/\\]sca[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)java[/\\]summarize[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)java[/\\]aggregation[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)java[/\\]operators[/\\]join[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)java[/\\]operators[/\\]translation[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)java[/\\]operators[/\\]([^/\\]*\.java)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)java[/\\]([^/\\]*\.java)"
     		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
     </suppressions>
    --- End diff --
    
    i think you missed the "java.operator" and "java.tuple" packages.


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink issue #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, flink-java...

Posted by dawidwys <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user dawidwys commented on the issue:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384
  
    @zentol @greghogan Would be nice if you could have a look at it. If we merge it, I could rebase the remaining PRs for flink-java checkstyle changes and remove appropriate suppressions in them.


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink issue #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, flink-java...

Posted by zentol <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user zentol commented on the issue:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384
  
    Its on my list for today ;)


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink pull request #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, fli...

Posted by zentol <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user zentol commented on a diff in the pull request:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384#discussion_r129015415
  
    --- Diff: tools/maven/suppressions-core.xml ---
    @@ -24,6 +24,63 @@ under the License.
     
     <suppressions>
     	<suppress
    -		files=".*"
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]java[/\\]functions[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]java[/\\]tuple[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]java[/\\]typeutils[/\\]runtime[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]java[/\\]typeutils[/\\]([^/\\]*\.java)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]accumulators[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]aggregators[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]functions[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]io[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]operators[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]state[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]typeutils[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\](cache|distributions|restartstrategy|time|typeinfo)[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]([^/\\]*\.java)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)configuration[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)core[/\\]fs[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)core[/\\]io[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)core[/\\]memory[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)migration[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)types[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)util[/\\](.*)"
     		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
     </suppressions>
    --- End diff --
    
    You missed the `testutils` package.


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink pull request #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, fli...

Posted by zentol <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user zentol commented on a diff in the pull request:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384#discussion_r129034227
  
    --- Diff: tools/maven/suppressions-optimizer.xml ---
    @@ -56,4 +56,32 @@ under the License.
     	<suppress
     		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]([^/\\]*\.java)"
     		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]testfunctions[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]programs[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]java[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport|NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]dataexchange[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport|NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]custompartition[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport|NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]([^/\\]*\.java)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]operators[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport"/>
    --- End diff --
    
    Are these the only required suppressions?


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink pull request #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, fli...

Posted by dawidwys <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user dawidwys commented on a diff in the pull request:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384#discussion_r129036125
  
    --- Diff: tools/maven/suppressions-optimizer.xml ---
    @@ -56,4 +56,32 @@ under the License.
     	<suppress
     		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]([^/\\]*\.java)"
     		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]testfunctions[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]programs[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]java[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport|NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]dataexchange[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport|NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]custompartition[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport|NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]([^/\\]*\.java)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)test[/\\](.*)optimizer[/\\]operators[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="AvoidStarImport"/>
    --- End diff --
    
    No they are not. The rules with regex `files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]operators[/\\](.*)"` is also applied. 
    
    I divided it though, so not to apply e.g. `AvoidStarImport` to `src` as in the old checkstyle("pre-strict") it was already prohibited (but not applied to test sources). 
    
    Do you think it would be better to split the `test` and `src` completely by the `files` regex and apply complete set of suppressions?


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink pull request #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, fli...

Posted by zentol <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user zentol commented on a diff in the pull request:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384#discussion_r129015090
  
    --- Diff: tools/maven/suppressions-core.xml ---
    @@ -24,6 +24,63 @@ under the License.
     
     <suppressions>
     	<suppress
    -		files=".*"
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]java[/\\]functions[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]java[/\\]tuple[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]java[/\\]typeutils[/\\]runtime[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]java[/\\]typeutils[/\\]([^/\\]*\.java)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]accumulators[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]aggregators[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]functions[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]io[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]operators[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]state[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\]typeutils[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)api[/\\]common[/\\](cache|distributions|restartstrategy|time|typeinfo)[/\\](.*)"
    --- End diff --
    
    I think typeinfo could have it's own rule, the rest are fine since they are all between 1-3 files


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink issue #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, flink-java...

Posted by zentol <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user zentol commented on the issue:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384
  
    It appears you're missing suppressions for a number of test packages.


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---

[GitHub] flink pull request #4384: [FLINK-7202] Split supressions for flink-core, fli...

Posted by zentol <gi...@git.apache.org>.
Github user zentol commented on a diff in the pull request:

    https://github.com/apache/flink/pull/4384#discussion_r129016101
  
    --- Diff: tools/maven/suppressions-optimizer.xml ---
    @@ -24,6 +24,36 @@ under the License.
     
     <suppressions>
     	<suppress
    -		files=".*"
    +		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]costs[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]dag[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]dataproperties[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]operators[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]plan[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]plandump[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]plantranslate[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]postpass[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]traversals[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]util[/\\](.*)"
    +		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
    +	<suppress
    +		files="(.*)optimizer[/\\]([^/\\]*\.java)"
     		checks="NewlineAtEndOfFile|RegexpSingleline|TodoComment|RedundantImport|ImportOrder|RedundantModifier|JavadocMethod|JavadocParagraph|JavadocType|JavadocStyle|PackageName|TypeNameCheck|ConstantNameCheck|StaticVariableNameCheck|MemberNameCheck|MethodNameCheck|ParameterName|LocalFinalVariableName|LocalVariableName|LeftCurly|UpperEll|FallThrough|reliefPattern|SimplifyBooleanExpression|EmptyStatement|ModifierOrder|EmptyLineSeparator|WhitespaceAround|WhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceAfter|NoWhitespaceBefore|OperatorWrap|ParenPad"/>
     </suppressions>
    --- End diff --
    
    missing test packages:
    * custompartition
    * dataexchange
    * java
    * programs
    * testfunctions


---
If your project is set up for it, you can reply to this email and have your
reply appear on GitHub as well. If your project does not have this feature
enabled and wishes so, or if the feature is enabled but not working, please
contact infrastructure at infrastructure@apache.org or file a JIRA ticket
with INFRA.
---