You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to adffaces-user@incubator.apache.org by Jeremy Sager <js...@chessys.com> on 2006/03/29 16:44:55 UTC
Bug in ADF showOne components
Hi guys -
I've researched this pretty thoroughly and I don't think this is a mistake
on my part.
I'm worried that the general issue I'm demonstrating may extend beyond
showOne items, but they're all I've tested so far. The following bug is
demonstrated with showOneChoice, but I know for certain that it is also a
problem with showOneTab. I haven't tested it with other showOne components,
but am guessing we'll get similar results.
Basically, if you have a showOne component inside a form AND inside a facet,
it stops working properly. When you select an item from the showOne, it
automatically reverts back to the first item in the list no matter what you
selected.
I am certain this has nothing to do with the outputText component inside the
showDetailItem. I originally had different components in there, and only
substituted in the outputText because it's a simple small component that
makes testing easy.
Here is a sample setup:
<af:form>
<af:panelBorder>
<f:facet name="right">
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
</af:showOneChoice>
<f:facet>
</af:panelBorder>
</af:form>
If you replace the panelBorder with a panelPage (i.e. another component with
a facet), you get the same behavior.
<af:form id="someform">
<af:panelPage id="_adasd">
<f:facet name="menu1">
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
</af:showOneChoice>
</f:facet>
</af:panelPage>
</af:form>
Remove the form, and everything works fine:
<af:panelBorder>
<f:facet name="right">
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showOneChoice>
</f:facet>
</af:panelBorder>
Keep the form, but pull the showOne item OUT of the facet, everything works
fine:
<af:form id="someform">
<af:panelPage id="_adasd">
<f:facet name="menu1">
<af:outputText value="Facet requires a tag" id="asdsadaddsadsas"/>
</f:facet>
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
<af:showDetailItem>
</af:showOneChoice>
</af:panelPage>
</af:form>
It does not matter if the showOne item is a top level child of the facet or
not. This also fails:
<af:form id="someform">
<af:panelPage id="_adasd">
<f:facet name="menu1">
<af:panelBox id="box" text="header" background="medium">
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
</af:showOneChoice>
</af:panelBox>
</f:facet>
</af:panelPage>
</af:form>
I'm going to do more testing to determine if there are other types of
components that misfire inside a facet inside a form, and I'll let you guys
know. In the meantime, hopefully the ADF guys who know the code can spot the
problem.
I don't think this is relevant to the issue, but in the interests of full
disclosure I am using facelets for my view handler.
I am on the nightlies for facelets, MyFaces, and ADF Faces as of Monday
3/27. however I know for certain that this bug was around in earlier
versions, because I upgraded in an attempt to fix the bug, and was
previously using MyFaces 1.1.1, the original ADF Faces drop, and whatever
version of facelets was out there in December '05.
I'm copying this to the myfaces list because the adffaces list just came up
yesterday and people who have something to add may not have signed up yet.
Jeremy Sager
Data Communications Product Manager
Chesapeake System Solutions
410.356.6805 x120
JSager@chessys.com
Re: Bug in ADF showOne components
Posted by Matthias Wessendorf <mw...@gmail.com>.
right :-)
On 3/29/06, Jeremy Sager <js...@chessys.com> wrote:
> Ok should I take that to the ADF list only then? Not trying to be a
> smartass, just trying to clarify.
>
> Jeremy Sager
> Data Communications Product Manager
> Chesapeake System Solutions
> 410.356.6805 x120
> JSager@chessys.com
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Matthias Wessendorf [mailto:mwessendorf@gmail.com]
> Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2006 11:48 AM
> To: MyFaces Discussion
> Subject: Re: Bug in ADF showOne components
>
> Hi Jeremy,
>
> thanks for your interest in ADF Faces, but please don't do cross postings.
>
> Thanks,
> Matthias
>
> On 3/29/06, Jeremy Sager <js...@chessys.com> wrote:
> > By the way, I did my testing in firefox. In IE, I noticed that sometimes
> it
> > seems to sit at "loading" for great lengths of time instead of just
> > reverting.
> >
> > Jeremy Sager
> > Data Communications Product Manager
> > Chesapeake System Solutions
> > 410.356.6805 x120
> > JSager@chessys.com
> >
> > -----Original Message-----
> > From: Jeremy Sager [mailto:jsager@chessys.com]
> > Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2006 11:45 AM
> > To: 'MyFaces Discussion'
> > Cc: adffaces-user@incubator.apache.org
> > Subject: Bug in ADF showOne components
> >
> > Hi guys -
> >
> > I've researched this pretty thoroughly and I don't think this is a mistake
> > on my part.
> >
> > I'm worried that the general issue I'm demonstrating may extend beyond
> > showOne items, but they're all I've tested so far. The following bug is
> > demonstrated with showOneChoice, but I know for certain that it is also a
> > problem with showOneTab. I haven't tested it with other showOne
> components,
> > but am guessing we'll get similar results.
> >
> > Basically, if you have a showOne component inside a form AND inside a
> facet,
> > it stops working properly. When you select an item from the showOne, it
> > automatically reverts back to the first item in the list no matter what
> you
> > selected.
> >
> > I am certain this has nothing to do with the outputText component inside
> the
> > showDetailItem. I originally had different components in there, and only
> > substituted in the outputText because it's a simple small component that
> > makes testing easy.
> >
> > Here is a sample setup:
> >
> > <af:form>
> > <af:panelBorder>
> > <f:facet name="right">
> > <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> > <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> > <af:outputText value="Showing One"/>
> > </af:showDetailItem>
> > <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> > <af:outputText value="Showing Two"/>
> > </af:showDetailItem>
> > </af:showOneChoice>
> > <f:facet>
> > </af:panelBorder>
> > </af:form>
> >
> > If you replace the panelBorder with a panelPage (i.e. another component
> with
> > a facet), you get the same behavior.
> >
> > <af:form id="someform">
> > <af:panelPage id="_adasd">
> > <f:facet name="menu1">
> > <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> > <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> > <af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
> > </af:showDetailItem>
> > <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> > <af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
> > </af:showDetailItem>
> > </af:showOneChoice>
> > </f:facet>
> > </af:panelPage>
> > </af:form>
> >
> >
> > Remove the form, and everything works fine:
> >
> > <af:panelBorder>
> > <f:facet name="right">
> > <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> > <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> > <af:outputText value="Showing One"/>
> > </af:showDetailItem>
> > <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> > <af:outputText value="Showing Two"/>
> > </af:showDetailItem>
> > <af:showOneChoice>
> > </f:facet>
> > </af:panelBorder>
> >
> >
> > Keep the form, but pull the showOne item OUT of the facet, everything
> works
> > fine:
> >
> >
> > <af:form id="someform">
> > <af:panelPage id="_adasd">
> > <f:facet name="menu1">
> > <af:outputText value="Facet requires a tag" id="asdsadaddsadsas"/>
> > </f:facet>
> > <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> > <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> > <af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
> > </af:showDetailItem>
> > <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> > <af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
> > <af:showDetailItem>
> > </af:showOneChoice>
> > </af:panelPage>
> > </af:form>
> >
> > It does not matter if the showOne item is a top level child of the facet
> or
> > not. This also fails:
> >
> > <af:form id="someform">
> > <af:panelPage id="_adasd">
> > <f:facet name="menu1">
> > <af:panelBox id="box" text="header" background="medium">
> > <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> > <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> > <af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
> > </af:showDetailItem>
> > <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> > <af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
> > </af:showDetailItem>
> > </af:showOneChoice>
> > </af:panelBox>
> > </f:facet>
> > </af:panelPage>
> > </af:form>
> >
> > I'm going to do more testing to determine if there are other types of
> > components that misfire inside a facet inside a form, and I'll let you
> guys
> > know. In the meantime, hopefully the ADF guys who know the code can spot
> the
> > problem.
> >
> > I don't think this is relevant to the issue, but in the interests of full
> > disclosure I am using facelets for my view handler.
> >
> > I am on the nightlies for facelets, MyFaces, and ADF Faces as of Monday
> > 3/27. however I know for certain that this bug was around in earlier
> > versions, because I upgraded in an attempt to fix the bug, and was
> > previously using MyFaces 1.1.1, the original ADF Faces drop, and whatever
> > version of facelets was out there in December '05.
> >
> > I'm copying this to the myfaces list because the adffaces list just came
> up
> > yesterday and people who have something to add may not have signed up yet.
> >
> > Jeremy Sager
> > Data Communications Product Manager
> > Chesapeake System Solutions
> > 410.356.6805 x120
> > JSager@chessys.com
> >
> >
>
>
> --
> Matthias Wessendorf
> Zülpicher Wall 12, 239
> 50674 Köln
> http://www.wessendorf.net
> mwessendorf-at-gmail-dot-com
>
>
--
Matthias Wessendorf
Zülpicher Wall 12, 239
50674 Köln
http://www.wessendorf.net
mwessendorf-at-gmail-dot-com
Re: Bug in ADF showOne components
Posted by Jonas Jacobi <jo...@oracle.com>.
Hi Jeremy,
I tried your sample code and it worked fine (with ADF Faces that is
shipped with Oracle's JDeveloper, which is a more recent build of ADF
Faces). Anyone tried the same use case in the ADF Faces Apache drop?
Here is my page source:
<f:view>
<afh:html>
<afh:body>
<af:form id="someform">
<af:panelPage id="_adasd">
<f:facet name="menu1">
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
</af:showOneChoice>
</f:facet>
</af:panelPage>
</af:form>
</afh:body>
</afh:html>
</f:view>
I'll do some more testing to see if I can duplicate your issue.
Thanks,
Jonas
Jeremy Sager wrote:
> Ok should I take that to the ADF list only then? Not trying to be a
> smartass, just trying to clarify.
>
> Jeremy Sager
> Data Communications Product Manager
> Chesapeake System Solutions
> 410.356.6805 x120
> JSager@chessys.com
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Matthias Wessendorf [mailto:mwessendorf@gmail.com]
> Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2006 11:48 AM
> To: MyFaces Discussion
> Subject: Re: Bug in ADF showOne components
>
> Hi Jeremy,
>
> thanks for your interest in ADF Faces, but please don't do cross postings.
>
> Thanks,
> Matthias
>
> On 3/29/06, Jeremy Sager <js...@chessys.com> wrote:
>
>> By the way, I did my testing in firefox. In IE, I noticed that sometimes
>>
> it
>
>> seems to sit at "loading" for great lengths of time instead of just
>> reverting.
>>
>> Jeremy Sager
>> Data Communications Product Manager
>> Chesapeake System Solutions
>> 410.356.6805 x120
>> JSager@chessys.com
>>
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: Jeremy Sager [mailto:jsager@chessys.com]
>> Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2006 11:45 AM
>> To: 'MyFaces Discussion'
>> Cc: adffaces-user@incubator.apache.org
>> Subject: Bug in ADF showOne components
>>
>> Hi guys -
>>
>> I've researched this pretty thoroughly and I don't think this is a mistake
>> on my part.
>>
>> I'm worried that the general issue I'm demonstrating may extend beyond
>> showOne items, but they're all I've tested so far. The following bug is
>> demonstrated with showOneChoice, but I know for certain that it is also a
>> problem with showOneTab. I haven't tested it with other showOne
>>
> components,
>
>> but am guessing we'll get similar results.
>>
>> Basically, if you have a showOne component inside a form AND inside a
>>
> facet,
>
>> it stops working properly. When you select an item from the showOne, it
>> automatically reverts back to the first item in the list no matter what
>>
> you
>
>> selected.
>>
>> I am certain this has nothing to do with the outputText component inside
>>
> the
>
>> showDetailItem. I originally had different components in there, and only
>> substituted in the outputText because it's a simple small component that
>> makes testing easy.
>>
>> Here is a sample setup:
>>
>> <af:form>
>> <af:panelBorder>
>> <f:facet name="right">
>> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
>> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
>> <af:outputText value="Showing One"/>
>> </af:showDetailItem>
>> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
>> <af:outputText value="Showing Two"/>
>> </af:showDetailItem>
>> </af:showOneChoice>
>> <f:facet>
>> </af:panelBorder>
>> </af:form>
>>
>> If you replace the panelBorder with a panelPage (i.e. another component
>>
> with
>
>> a facet), you get the same behavior.
>>
>> <af:form id="someform">
>> <af:panelPage id="_adasd">
>> <f:facet name="menu1">
>> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
>> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
>> <af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
>> </af:showDetailItem>
>> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
>> <af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
>> </af:showDetailItem>
>> </af:showOneChoice>
>> </f:facet>
>> </af:panelPage>
>> </af:form>
>>
>>
>> Remove the form, and everything works fine:
>>
>> <af:panelBorder>
>> <f:facet name="right">
>> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
>> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
>> <af:outputText value="Showing One"/>
>> </af:showDetailItem>
>> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
>> <af:outputText value="Showing Two"/>
>> </af:showDetailItem>
>> <af:showOneChoice>
>> </f:facet>
>> </af:panelBorder>
>>
>>
>> Keep the form, but pull the showOne item OUT of the facet, everything
>>
> works
>
>> fine:
>>
>>
>> <af:form id="someform">
>> <af:panelPage id="_adasd">
>> <f:facet name="menu1">
>> <af:outputText value="Facet requires a tag" id="asdsadaddsadsas"/>
>> </f:facet>
>> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
>> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
>> <af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
>> </af:showDetailItem>
>> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
>> <af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
>> <af:showDetailItem>
>> </af:showOneChoice>
>> </af:panelPage>
>> </af:form>
>>
>> It does not matter if the showOne item is a top level child of the facet
>>
> or
>
>> not. This also fails:
>>
>> <af:form id="someform">
>> <af:panelPage id="_adasd">
>> <f:facet name="menu1">
>> <af:panelBox id="box" text="header" background="medium">
>> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
>> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
>> <af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
>> </af:showDetailItem>
>> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
>> <af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
>> </af:showDetailItem>
>> </af:showOneChoice>
>> </af:panelBox>
>> </f:facet>
>> </af:panelPage>
>> </af:form>
>>
>> I'm going to do more testing to determine if there are other types of
>> components that misfire inside a facet inside a form, and I'll let you
>>
> guys
>
>> know. In the meantime, hopefully the ADF guys who know the code can spot
>>
> the
>
>> problem.
>>
>> I don't think this is relevant to the issue, but in the interests of full
>> disclosure I am using facelets for my view handler.
>>
>> I am on the nightlies for facelets, MyFaces, and ADF Faces as of Monday
>> 3/27. however I know for certain that this bug was around in earlier
>> versions, because I upgraded in an attempt to fix the bug, and was
>> previously using MyFaces 1.1.1, the original ADF Faces drop, and whatever
>> version of facelets was out there in December '05.
>>
>> I'm copying this to the myfaces list because the adffaces list just came
>>
> up
>
>> yesterday and people who have something to add may not have signed up yet.
>>
>> Jeremy Sager
>> Data Communications Product Manager
>> Chesapeake System Solutions
>> 410.356.6805 x120
>> JSager@chessys.com
>>
>>
>>
>
>
> --
> Matthias Wessendorf
> Zülpicher Wall 12, 239
> 50674 Köln
> http://www.wessendorf.net
> mwessendorf-at-gmail-dot-com
>
>
--
*Author*: Pro JSF and Ajax: Building Rich Internet Components
<http://apress.com/book/bookDisplay.html?bID=10044>
*Blog*: http://www.orablogs.com/jjacobi
RE: Bug in ADF showOne components
Posted by Jeremy Sager <js...@chessys.com>.
Ok should I take that to the ADF list only then? Not trying to be a
smartass, just trying to clarify.
Jeremy Sager
Data Communications Product Manager
Chesapeake System Solutions
410.356.6805 x120
JSager@chessys.com
-----Original Message-----
From: Matthias Wessendorf [mailto:mwessendorf@gmail.com]
Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2006 11:48 AM
To: MyFaces Discussion
Subject: Re: Bug in ADF showOne components
Hi Jeremy,
thanks for your interest in ADF Faces, but please don't do cross postings.
Thanks,
Matthias
On 3/29/06, Jeremy Sager <js...@chessys.com> wrote:
> By the way, I did my testing in firefox. In IE, I noticed that sometimes
it
> seems to sit at "loading" for great lengths of time instead of just
> reverting.
>
> Jeremy Sager
> Data Communications Product Manager
> Chesapeake System Solutions
> 410.356.6805 x120
> JSager@chessys.com
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Jeremy Sager [mailto:jsager@chessys.com]
> Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2006 11:45 AM
> To: 'MyFaces Discussion'
> Cc: adffaces-user@incubator.apache.org
> Subject: Bug in ADF showOne components
>
> Hi guys -
>
> I've researched this pretty thoroughly and I don't think this is a mistake
> on my part.
>
> I'm worried that the general issue I'm demonstrating may extend beyond
> showOne items, but they're all I've tested so far. The following bug is
> demonstrated with showOneChoice, but I know for certain that it is also a
> problem with showOneTab. I haven't tested it with other showOne
components,
> but am guessing we'll get similar results.
>
> Basically, if you have a showOne component inside a form AND inside a
facet,
> it stops working properly. When you select an item from the showOne, it
> automatically reverts back to the first item in the list no matter what
you
> selected.
>
> I am certain this has nothing to do with the outputText component inside
the
> showDetailItem. I originally had different components in there, and only
> substituted in the outputText because it's a simple small component that
> makes testing easy.
>
> Here is a sample setup:
>
> <af:form>
> <af:panelBorder>
> <f:facet name="right">
> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing One"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing Two"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> </af:showOneChoice>
> <f:facet>
> </af:panelBorder>
> </af:form>
>
> If you replace the panelBorder with a panelPage (i.e. another component
with
> a facet), you get the same behavior.
>
> <af:form id="someform">
> <af:panelPage id="_adasd">
> <f:facet name="menu1">
> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> </af:showOneChoice>
> </f:facet>
> </af:panelPage>
> </af:form>
>
>
> Remove the form, and everything works fine:
>
> <af:panelBorder>
> <f:facet name="right">
> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing One"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing Two"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> <af:showOneChoice>
> </f:facet>
> </af:panelBorder>
>
>
> Keep the form, but pull the showOne item OUT of the facet, everything
works
> fine:
>
>
> <af:form id="someform">
> <af:panelPage id="_adasd">
> <f:facet name="menu1">
> <af:outputText value="Facet requires a tag" id="asdsadaddsadsas"/>
> </f:facet>
> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
> <af:showDetailItem>
> </af:showOneChoice>
> </af:panelPage>
> </af:form>
>
> It does not matter if the showOne item is a top level child of the facet
or
> not. This also fails:
>
> <af:form id="someform">
> <af:panelPage id="_adasd">
> <f:facet name="menu1">
> <af:panelBox id="box" text="header" background="medium">
> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> </af:showOneChoice>
> </af:panelBox>
> </f:facet>
> </af:panelPage>
> </af:form>
>
> I'm going to do more testing to determine if there are other types of
> components that misfire inside a facet inside a form, and I'll let you
guys
> know. In the meantime, hopefully the ADF guys who know the code can spot
the
> problem.
>
> I don't think this is relevant to the issue, but in the interests of full
> disclosure I am using facelets for my view handler.
>
> I am on the nightlies for facelets, MyFaces, and ADF Faces as of Monday
> 3/27. however I know for certain that this bug was around in earlier
> versions, because I upgraded in an attempt to fix the bug, and was
> previously using MyFaces 1.1.1, the original ADF Faces drop, and whatever
> version of facelets was out there in December '05.
>
> I'm copying this to the myfaces list because the adffaces list just came
up
> yesterday and people who have something to add may not have signed up yet.
>
> Jeremy Sager
> Data Communications Product Manager
> Chesapeake System Solutions
> 410.356.6805 x120
> JSager@chessys.com
>
>
--
Matthias Wessendorf
Zülpicher Wall 12, 239
50674 Köln
http://www.wessendorf.net
mwessendorf-at-gmail-dot-com
Re: Bug in ADF showOne components
Posted by Matthias Wessendorf <mw...@gmail.com>.
Hi Jeremy,
thanks for your interest in ADF Faces, but please don't do cross postings.
Thanks,
Matthias
On 3/29/06, Jeremy Sager <js...@chessys.com> wrote:
> By the way, I did my testing in firefox. In IE, I noticed that sometimes it
> seems to sit at "loading" for great lengths of time instead of just
> reverting.
>
> Jeremy Sager
> Data Communications Product Manager
> Chesapeake System Solutions
> 410.356.6805 x120
> JSager@chessys.com
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Jeremy Sager [mailto:jsager@chessys.com]
> Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2006 11:45 AM
> To: 'MyFaces Discussion'
> Cc: adffaces-user@incubator.apache.org
> Subject: Bug in ADF showOne components
>
> Hi guys -
>
> I've researched this pretty thoroughly and I don't think this is a mistake
> on my part.
>
> I'm worried that the general issue I'm demonstrating may extend beyond
> showOne items, but they're all I've tested so far. The following bug is
> demonstrated with showOneChoice, but I know for certain that it is also a
> problem with showOneTab. I haven't tested it with other showOne components,
> but am guessing we'll get similar results.
>
> Basically, if you have a showOne component inside a form AND inside a facet,
> it stops working properly. When you select an item from the showOne, it
> automatically reverts back to the first item in the list no matter what you
> selected.
>
> I am certain this has nothing to do with the outputText component inside the
> showDetailItem. I originally had different components in there, and only
> substituted in the outputText because it's a simple small component that
> makes testing easy.
>
> Here is a sample setup:
>
> <af:form>
> <af:panelBorder>
> <f:facet name="right">
> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing One"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing Two"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> </af:showOneChoice>
> <f:facet>
> </af:panelBorder>
> </af:form>
>
> If you replace the panelBorder with a panelPage (i.e. another component with
> a facet), you get the same behavior.
>
> <af:form id="someform">
> <af:panelPage id="_adasd">
> <f:facet name="menu1">
> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> </af:showOneChoice>
> </f:facet>
> </af:panelPage>
> </af:form>
>
>
> Remove the form, and everything works fine:
>
> <af:panelBorder>
> <f:facet name="right">
> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing One"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing Two"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> <af:showOneChoice>
> </f:facet>
> </af:panelBorder>
>
>
> Keep the form, but pull the showOne item OUT of the facet, everything works
> fine:
>
>
> <af:form id="someform">
> <af:panelPage id="_adasd">
> <f:facet name="menu1">
> <af:outputText value="Facet requires a tag" id="asdsadaddsadsas"/>
> </f:facet>
> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
> <af:showDetailItem>
> </af:showOneChoice>
> </af:panelPage>
> </af:form>
>
> It does not matter if the showOne item is a top level child of the facet or
> not. This also fails:
>
> <af:form id="someform">
> <af:panelPage id="_adasd">
> <f:facet name="menu1">
> <af:panelBox id="box" text="header" background="medium">
> <af:showOneChoice position="top">
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> <af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
> <af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
> </af:showDetailItem>
> </af:showOneChoice>
> </af:panelBox>
> </f:facet>
> </af:panelPage>
> </af:form>
>
> I'm going to do more testing to determine if there are other types of
> components that misfire inside a facet inside a form, and I'll let you guys
> know. In the meantime, hopefully the ADF guys who know the code can spot the
> problem.
>
> I don't think this is relevant to the issue, but in the interests of full
> disclosure I am using facelets for my view handler.
>
> I am on the nightlies for facelets, MyFaces, and ADF Faces as of Monday
> 3/27. however I know for certain that this bug was around in earlier
> versions, because I upgraded in an attempt to fix the bug, and was
> previously using MyFaces 1.1.1, the original ADF Faces drop, and whatever
> version of facelets was out there in December '05.
>
> I'm copying this to the myfaces list because the adffaces list just came up
> yesterday and people who have something to add may not have signed up yet.
>
> Jeremy Sager
> Data Communications Product Manager
> Chesapeake System Solutions
> 410.356.6805 x120
> JSager@chessys.com
>
>
--
Matthias Wessendorf
Zülpicher Wall 12, 239
50674 Köln
http://www.wessendorf.net
mwessendorf-at-gmail-dot-com
RE: Bug in ADF showOne components
Posted by Jeremy Sager <js...@chessys.com>.
By the way, I did my testing in firefox. In IE, I noticed that sometimes it
seems to sit at "loading" for great lengths of time instead of just
reverting.
Jeremy Sager
Data Communications Product Manager
Chesapeake System Solutions
410.356.6805 x120
JSager@chessys.com
-----Original Message-----
From: Jeremy Sager [mailto:jsager@chessys.com]
Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2006 11:45 AM
To: 'MyFaces Discussion'
Cc: adffaces-user@incubator.apache.org
Subject: Bug in ADF showOne components
Hi guys -
I've researched this pretty thoroughly and I don't think this is a mistake
on my part.
I'm worried that the general issue I'm demonstrating may extend beyond
showOne items, but they're all I've tested so far. The following bug is
demonstrated with showOneChoice, but I know for certain that it is also a
problem with showOneTab. I haven't tested it with other showOne components,
but am guessing we'll get similar results.
Basically, if you have a showOne component inside a form AND inside a facet,
it stops working properly. When you select an item from the showOne, it
automatically reverts back to the first item in the list no matter what you
selected.
I am certain this has nothing to do with the outputText component inside the
showDetailItem. I originally had different components in there, and only
substituted in the outputText because it's a simple small component that
makes testing easy.
Here is a sample setup:
<af:form>
<af:panelBorder>
<f:facet name="right">
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
</af:showOneChoice>
<f:facet>
</af:panelBorder>
</af:form>
If you replace the panelBorder with a panelPage (i.e. another component with
a facet), you get the same behavior.
<af:form id="someform">
<af:panelPage id="_adasd">
<f:facet name="menu1">
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
</af:showOneChoice>
</f:facet>
</af:panelPage>
</af:form>
Remove the form, and everything works fine:
<af:panelBorder>
<f:facet name="right">
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showOneChoice>
</f:facet>
</af:panelBorder>
Keep the form, but pull the showOne item OUT of the facet, everything works
fine:
<af:form id="someform">
<af:panelPage id="_adasd">
<f:facet name="menu1">
<af:outputText value="Facet requires a tag" id="asdsadaddsadsas"/>
</f:facet>
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
<af:showDetailItem>
</af:showOneChoice>
</af:panelPage>
</af:form>
It does not matter if the showOne item is a top level child of the facet or
not. This also fails:
<af:form id="someform">
<af:panelPage id="_adasd">
<f:facet name="menu1">
<af:panelBox id="box" text="header" background="medium">
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
</af:showOneChoice>
</af:panelBox>
</f:facet>
</af:panelPage>
</af:form>
I'm going to do more testing to determine if there are other types of
components that misfire inside a facet inside a form, and I'll let you guys
know. In the meantime, hopefully the ADF guys who know the code can spot the
problem.
I don't think this is relevant to the issue, but in the interests of full
disclosure I am using facelets for my view handler.
I am on the nightlies for facelets, MyFaces, and ADF Faces as of Monday
3/27. however I know for certain that this bug was around in earlier
versions, because I upgraded in an attempt to fix the bug, and was
previously using MyFaces 1.1.1, the original ADF Faces drop, and whatever
version of facelets was out there in December '05.
I'm copying this to the myfaces list because the adffaces list just came up
yesterday and people who have something to add may not have signed up yet.
Jeremy Sager
Data Communications Product Manager
Chesapeake System Solutions
410.356.6805 x120
JSager@chessys.com
RE: Bug in ADF showOne components
Posted by Jeremy Sager <js...@chessys.com>.
By the way, I did my testing in firefox. In IE, I noticed that sometimes it
seems to sit at "loading" for great lengths of time instead of just
reverting.
Jeremy Sager
Data Communications Product Manager
Chesapeake System Solutions
410.356.6805 x120
JSager@chessys.com
-----Original Message-----
From: Jeremy Sager [mailto:jsager@chessys.com]
Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2006 11:45 AM
To: 'MyFaces Discussion'
Cc: adffaces-user@incubator.apache.org
Subject: Bug in ADF showOne components
Hi guys -
I've researched this pretty thoroughly and I don't think this is a mistake
on my part.
I'm worried that the general issue I'm demonstrating may extend beyond
showOne items, but they're all I've tested so far. The following bug is
demonstrated with showOneChoice, but I know for certain that it is also a
problem with showOneTab. I haven't tested it with other showOne components,
but am guessing we'll get similar results.
Basically, if you have a showOne component inside a form AND inside a facet,
it stops working properly. When you select an item from the showOne, it
automatically reverts back to the first item in the list no matter what you
selected.
I am certain this has nothing to do with the outputText component inside the
showDetailItem. I originally had different components in there, and only
substituted in the outputText because it's a simple small component that
makes testing easy.
Here is a sample setup:
<af:form>
<af:panelBorder>
<f:facet name="right">
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
</af:showOneChoice>
<f:facet>
</af:panelBorder>
</af:form>
If you replace the panelBorder with a panelPage (i.e. another component with
a facet), you get the same behavior.
<af:form id="someform">
<af:panelPage id="_adasd">
<f:facet name="menu1">
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
</af:showOneChoice>
</f:facet>
</af:panelPage>
</af:form>
Remove the form, and everything works fine:
<af:panelBorder>
<f:facet name="right">
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showOneChoice>
</f:facet>
</af:panelBorder>
Keep the form, but pull the showOne item OUT of the facet, everything works
fine:
<af:form id="someform">
<af:panelPage id="_adasd">
<f:facet name="menu1">
<af:outputText value="Facet requires a tag" id="asdsadaddsadsas"/>
</f:facet>
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
<af:showDetailItem>
</af:showOneChoice>
</af:panelPage>
</af:form>
It does not matter if the showOne item is a top level child of the facet or
not. This also fails:
<af:form id="someform">
<af:panelPage id="_adasd">
<f:facet name="menu1">
<af:panelBox id="box" text="header" background="medium">
<af:showOneChoice position="top">
<af:showDetailItem text="Item One" id="_1234321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing One" id="sdasda"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
<af:showDetailItem text="Item Two" id="_12345654321" >
<af:outputText value="Showing Two" id="asdsadads"/>
</af:showDetailItem>
</af:showOneChoice>
</af:panelBox>
</f:facet>
</af:panelPage>
</af:form>
I'm going to do more testing to determine if there are other types of
components that misfire inside a facet inside a form, and I'll let you guys
know. In the meantime, hopefully the ADF guys who know the code can spot the
problem.
I don't think this is relevant to the issue, but in the interests of full
disclosure I am using facelets for my view handler.
I am on the nightlies for facelets, MyFaces, and ADF Faces as of Monday
3/27. however I know for certain that this bug was around in earlier
versions, because I upgraded in an attempt to fix the bug, and was
previously using MyFaces 1.1.1, the original ADF Faces drop, and whatever
version of facelets was out there in December '05.
I'm copying this to the myfaces list because the adffaces list just came up
yesterday and people who have something to add may not have signed up yet.
Jeremy Sager
Data Communications Product Manager
Chesapeake System Solutions
410.356.6805 x120
JSager@chessys.com