You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@hive.apache.org by Alan Gates <ga...@yahoo-inc.com> on 2011/06/22 01:21:49 UTC

A question on how to mark Hive for HCatalog releases

All,

I have a question of how we should manage marking Hive source code for  
HCatalog releases.  For HCatalog 0.1 we used the the 0.7 version of  
Hive.  But we will get to HCatalog 0.2 before the Hive community gets  
to 0.8.  We have added features to Hive since 0.7 that we need in  
HCatalog 0.2.   In general, it is not reasonable to assume that Hive  
and HCatalog releases will line up such that HCatalog can always  
depend on a released version of Hive.

So how should we mark the proper version of Hive code for an HCatalog  
release?  The only thing that comes to mind is tagging a particular  
revision, with the option to branch at that revision if necessary.  We  
would only need a branch if something got checked in post tag that  
HCatalog needed or wanted, but there were other intervening check ins  
we did not want.  In that case we would need to ask you to branch and  
port the needed change(s).

Are you okay with this approach?  Are there other approaches you would  
suggest or prefer?

Alan.

Re: A question on how to mark Hive for HCatalog releases

Posted by Alan Gates <ga...@yahoo-inc.com>.
Alright, qui tacit consentit (except for John, who explicitly  
agreed).  We'll go with this plan.

Alan.

On Jun 22, 2011, at 12:46 PM, John Sichi wrote:

> Sounds good to me.
>
> JVS
>
> On Jun 21, 2011, at 4:21 PM, Alan Gates wrote:
>
>> All,
>>
>> I have a question of how we should manage marking Hive source code  
>> for HCatalog releases.  For HCatalog 0.1 we used the the 0.7  
>> version of Hive.  But we will get to HCatalog 0.2 before the Hive  
>> community gets to 0.8.  We have added features to Hive since 0.7  
>> that we need in HCatalog 0.2.   In general, it is not reasonable to  
>> assume that Hive and HCatalog releases will line up such that  
>> HCatalog can always depend on a released version of Hive.
>>
>> So how should we mark the proper version of Hive code for an  
>> HCatalog release?  The only thing that comes to mind is tagging a  
>> particular revision, with the option to branch at that revision if  
>> necessary.  We would only need a branch if something got checked in  
>> post tag that HCatalog needed or wanted, but there were other  
>> intervening check ins we did not want.  In that case we would need  
>> to ask you to branch and port the needed change(s).
>>
>> Are you okay with this approach?  Are there other approaches you  
>> would suggest or prefer?
>>
>> Alan.
>


Re: A question on how to mark Hive for HCatalog releases

Posted by John Sichi <js...@fb.com>.
Sounds good to me.

JVS

On Jun 21, 2011, at 4:21 PM, Alan Gates wrote:

> All,
> 
> I have a question of how we should manage marking Hive source code for HCatalog releases.  For HCatalog 0.1 we used the the 0.7 version of Hive.  But we will get to HCatalog 0.2 before the Hive community gets to 0.8.  We have added features to Hive since 0.7 that we need in HCatalog 0.2.   In general, it is not reasonable to assume that Hive and HCatalog releases will line up such that HCatalog can always depend on a released version of Hive.
> 
> So how should we mark the proper version of Hive code for an HCatalog release?  The only thing that comes to mind is tagging a particular revision, with the option to branch at that revision if necessary.  We would only need a branch if something got checked in post tag that HCatalog needed or wanted, but there were other intervening check ins we did not want.  In that case we would need to ask you to branch and port the needed change(s).
> 
> Are you okay with this approach?  Are there other approaches you would suggest or prefer?
> 
> Alan.