You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@geronimo.apache.org by David Jencks <da...@yahoo.com> on 2007/07/25 03:00:57 UTC
Transaction and Connector jars untied from g. kernel
see GERONIMO-3344.
Following years of urging from activemq/jencks/servicemix and more
recent urging from openejb I finally split off the tx and connector
modules into bits that implement the functionality w/o geronimo fluff
and geronimo integration jars.
The functional bits are now under components/txmanager/trunk. I have
server/trunk compiling and appearing to work on my local machine.
If no one objects I'll commit my local changes to trunk later tonight
so g 2.1-SNAPSHOT will be using the new jars.
new jars have groupId org.apache.geronimo.components, and artifactIds
geronimo-transaction and geronimo-connector, and version 2.0-SNAPSHOT.
I'd really appreciate a review of the dir structure and poms from
e.g. jdillon since I suspect a better structure may be possible.
There is a dependency on the genesis 1.2-SNAPSHOT pom, this also is
in g. trunk.
if all goes well perhaps we can release the new jars in a day or two
and then openejb can release without a dependency on geronimo server.
thanks
david jencks
Re: Transaction and Connector jars untied from g. kernel
Posted by Jason Dillon <ja...@planet57.com>.
Sounds like positive direction. +1
I'm about to go out for dinner now, but I will review the bits in the
components/* tree later tonight or tomorrow.
Cheers,
--jason
On Jul 24, 2007, at 6:00 PM, David Jencks wrote:
> see GERONIMO-3344.
>
> Following years of urging from activemq/jencks/servicemix and more
> recent urging from openejb I finally split off the tx and connector
> modules into bits that implement the functionality w/o geronimo
> fluff and geronimo integration jars.
>
> The functional bits are now under components/txmanager/trunk. I
> have server/trunk compiling and appearing to work on my local machine.
>
> If no one objects I'll commit my local changes to trunk later
> tonight so g 2.1-SNAPSHOT will be using the new jars.
>
> new jars have groupId org.apache.geronimo.components, and
> artifactIds geronimo-transaction and geronimo-connector, and
> version 2.0-SNAPSHOT.
>
> I'd really appreciate a review of the dir structure and poms from
> e.g. jdillon since I suspect a better structure may be possible.
> There is a dependency on the genesis 1.2-SNAPSHOT pom, this also is
> in g. trunk.
>
> if all goes well perhaps we can release the new jars in a day or
> two and then openejb can release without a dependency on geronimo
> server.
>
> thanks
> david jencks
>
>
>
Re: Transaction and Connector jars untied from g. kernel
Posted by ja...@gmail.com.
I will take a look. We should prolly start using the remote-resources stuff. Will peep at it tomorrow.
--jason
-----Original Message-----
From: David Jencks <da...@yahoo.com>
Date: Wed, 25 Jul 2007 23:37:45
To:dev@geronimo.apache.org
Subject: Re: Transaction and Connector jars untied from g. kernel
On Jul 25, 2007, at 4:00 PM, Jason Dillon wrote:
So, looks okay from a initial peep through, though a few things I noticed right off the bat...
There is no pom.xml in the top-level tree under https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/geronimo/components/txmanager/trunk <https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/geronimo/components/txmanager/trunk> , and there should be. And the children modules should use that pom as their parent.
That root pom should also have dependencyManagement to remove the version number muck from the children.
OK, I added a parent pom, everything still seems to build.
One thing I remembered is that the connector tests jar isn't getting the legal files into it (note disabled check in the new parent pom). Do you know how to get them in?
thanks
david jencks
Or, unless you had intended to keep these 2 modules geronimo-connector and geronimo-transaction as separate releasables, which is fine too, but if that is the intention, then they really need to be moved up to components/connector/trunk and components/transaction/trunk.
But I don't really like to have too many fine grained modules as separate releasables like that. If these 2 modules are significantly related, then I'd like to see them released, versioned together, and in that case, the current svn structure is fine, but that top-level pom and the dependency/version muck needs to be added.
--jason
On 7/24/07, David Jencks <david_jencks@yahoo.com <ma...@yahoo.com> > wrote:see GERONIMO-3344.
Following years of urging from activemq/jencks/servicemix and more
recent urging from openejb I finally split off the tx and connector
modules into bits that implement the functionality w/o geronimo fluff
and geronimo integration jars.
The functional bits are now under components/txmanager/trunk. I have
server/trunk compiling and appearing to work on my local machine.
If no one objects I'll commit my local changes to trunk later tonight
so g 2.1-SNAPSHOT will be using the new jars.
new jars have groupId org.apache.geronimo.components, and artifactIds
geronimo-transaction and geronimo-connector, and version 2.0-SNAPSHOT.
I'd really appreciate a review of the dir structure and poms from
e.g. jdillon since I suspect a better structure may be possible.
There is a dependency on the genesis 1.2-SNAPSHOT pom, this also is
in g. trunk.
if all goes well perhaps we can release the new jars in a day or two
and then openejb can release without a dependency on geronimo server.
thanks
david jencks
Re: Transaction and Connector jars untied from g. kernel
Posted by David Jencks <da...@yahoo.com>.
On Jul 25, 2007, at 4:00 PM, Jason Dillon wrote:
> So, looks okay from a initial peep through, though a few things I
> noticed right off the bat...
>
> There is no pom.xml in the top-level tree under https://
> svn.apache.org/repos/asf/geronimo/components/txmanager/trunk, and
> there should be. And the children modules should use that pom as
> their parent.
>
> That root pom should also have dependencyManagement to remove the
> version number muck from the children.
OK, I added a parent pom, everything still seems to build.
One thing I remembered is that the connector tests jar isn't getting
the legal files into it (note disabled check in the new parent pom).
Do you know how to get them in?
thanks
david jencks
>
> Or, unless you had intended to keep these 2 modules geronimo-
> connector and geronimo-transaction as separate releasables, which
> is fine too, but if that is the intention, then they really need to
> be moved up to components/connector/trunk and components/
> transaction/trunk.
>
>
> But I don't really like to have too many fine grained modules as
> separate releasables like that. If these 2 modules are
> significantly related, then I'd like to see them released,
> versioned together, and in that case, the current svn structure is
> fine, but that top-level pom and the dependency/version muck needs
> to be added.
>
> --jason
>
>
> On 7/24/07, David Jencks <da...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> see GERONIMO-3344.
>
> Following years of urging from activemq/jencks/servicemix and more
> recent urging from openejb I finally split off the tx and connector
> modules into bits that implement the functionality w/o geronimo fluff
> and geronimo integration jars.
>
> The functional bits are now under components/txmanager/trunk. I have
> server/trunk compiling and appearing to work on my local machine.
>
> If no one objects I'll commit my local changes to trunk later tonight
> so g 2.1-SNAPSHOT will be using the new jars.
>
> new jars have groupId org.apache.geronimo.components, and artifactIds
> geronimo-transaction and geronimo-connector, and version 2.0-SNAPSHOT.
>
> I'd really appreciate a review of the dir structure and poms from
> e.g. jdillon since I suspect a better structure may be possible.
> There is a dependency on the genesis 1.2-SNAPSHOT pom, this also is
> in g. trunk.
>
> if all goes well perhaps we can release the new jars in a day or two
> and then openejb can release without a dependency on geronimo server.
>
> thanks
> david jencks
>
>
>
>
>
Re: Transaction and Connector jars untied from g. kernel
Posted by Jason Dillon <ja...@planet57.com>.
So, looks okay from a initial peep through, though a few things I noticed
right off the bat...
There is no pom.xml in the top-level tree under
https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/geronimo/components/txmanager/trunk, and
there should be. And the children modules should use that pom as their
parent.
That root pom should also have dependencyManagement to remove the version
number muck from the children.
Or, unless you had intended to keep these 2 modules geronimo-connector and
geronimo-transaction as separate releasables, which is fine too, but if that
is the intention, then they really need to be moved up to
components/connector/trunk and components/transaction/trunk.
But I don't really like to have too many fine grained modules
as separate releasables like that. If these 2 modules are significantly
related, then I'd like to see them released, versioned together, and in that
case, the current svn structure is fine, but that top-level pom and the
dependency/version muck needs to be added.
--jason
On 7/24/07, David Jencks <da...@yahoo.com> wrote:
>
> see GERONIMO-3344.
>
> Following years of urging from activemq/jencks/servicemix and more
> recent urging from openejb I finally split off the tx and connector
> modules into bits that implement the functionality w/o geronimo fluff
> and geronimo integration jars.
>
> The functional bits are now under components/txmanager/trunk. I have
> server/trunk compiling and appearing to work on my local machine.
>
> If no one objects I'll commit my local changes to trunk later tonight
> so g 2.1-SNAPSHOT will be using the new jars.
>
> new jars have groupId org.apache.geronimo.components, and artifactIds
> geronimo-transaction and geronimo-connector, and version 2.0-SNAPSHOT.
>
> I'd really appreciate a review of the dir structure and poms from
> e.g. jdillon since I suspect a better structure may be possible.
> There is a dependency on the genesis 1.2-SNAPSHOT pom, this also is
> in g. trunk.
>
> if all goes well perhaps we can release the new jars in a day or two
> and then openejb can release without a dependency on geronimo server.
>
> thanks
> david jencks
>
>
>
>
Re: Transaction and Connector jars untied from g. kernel
Posted by Dain Sundstrom <da...@iq80.com>.
Sweet!
Thanks,
-dain
On Jul 24, 2007, at 6:00 PM, David Jencks wrote:
> see GERONIMO-3344.
>
> Following years of urging from activemq/jencks/servicemix and more
> recent urging from openejb I finally split off the tx and connector
> modules into bits that implement the functionality w/o geronimo
> fluff and geronimo integration jars.
>
> The functional bits are now under components/txmanager/trunk. I
> have server/trunk compiling and appearing to work on my local machine.
>
> If no one objects I'll commit my local changes to trunk later
> tonight so g 2.1-SNAPSHOT will be using the new jars.
>
> new jars have groupId org.apache.geronimo.components, and
> artifactIds geronimo-transaction and geronimo-connector, and
> version 2.0-SNAPSHOT.
>
> I'd really appreciate a review of the dir structure and poms from
> e.g. jdillon since I suspect a better structure may be possible.
> There is a dependency on the genesis 1.2-SNAPSHOT pom, this also is
> in g. trunk.
>
> if all goes well perhaps we can release the new jars in a day or
> two and then openejb can release without a dependency on geronimo
> server.
>
> thanks
> david jencks
>
>
>
Re: Transaction and Connector jars untied from g. kernel
Posted by Guillaume Nodet <gn...@gmail.com>.
I wont be able to review until my vacations are over, but the idea is
really good. Thanks a lot David!
On 7/25/07, David Jencks <da...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> see GERONIMO-3344.
>
> Following years of urging from activemq/jencks/servicemix and more
> recent urging from openejb I finally split off the tx and connector
> modules into bits that implement the functionality w/o geronimo fluff
> and geronimo integration jars.
>
> The functional bits are now under components/txmanager/trunk. I have
> server/trunk compiling and appearing to work on my local machine.
>
> If no one objects I'll commit my local changes to trunk later tonight
> so g 2.1-SNAPSHOT will be using the new jars.
>
> new jars have groupId org.apache.geronimo.components, and artifactIds
> geronimo-transaction and geronimo-connector, and version 2.0-SNAPSHOT.
>
> I'd really appreciate a review of the dir structure and poms from
> e.g. jdillon since I suspect a better structure may be possible.
> There is a dependency on the genesis 1.2-SNAPSHOT pom, this also is
> in g. trunk.
>
> if all goes well perhaps we can release the new jars in a day or two
> and then openejb can release without a dependency on geronimo server.
>
> thanks
> david jencks
>
>
>
>
--
Cheers,
Guillaume Nodet
------------------------
Principal Engineer, IONA
Blog: http://gnodet.blogspot.com/