You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to java-user@axis.apache.org by COURTAULT Francois <Fr...@gemalto.com> on 2012/07/30 17:55:43 UTC
@OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
Hello guys,
I have read the JSR 181 spec and the @OneWay is not clear for me.
Just want to have your interpretation....
In the spec, it is said that: "Indicates that the given web method has only an input message and no output. Typically,
a oneway method returns the thread of control to the calling application prior to executing
the actual business method"
What typically means ? Does it mean MUST-SHALL, SHOULD or MAY according to you ?
Still about the OneWay what is the HTTP binding for this annotation ? I have seen that some implementation returns a 202.
Is it a standard HTTP status code value for OneWay ?
Best Regards.
RE: @OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
Posted by COURTAULT Francois <Fr...@gemalto.com>.
Hello,
I am happy that this subject is clear now :)
According some other discussions I had, it seems that there is 2 possibilities:
- Either the WS stack provides this kind of behavior
- Or it is up to the end point service developer to make this behavior happen
I am still confused and so still waiting for some clarifications regarding this topic ...
Best Regards.
From: Stadelmann Josef [mailto:josef.stadelmann@axa-winterthur.ch]
Sent: mardi 7 août 2012 13:41
To: java-user@axis.apache.org
Subject: AW: @OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
100% clear, thanks
Von: COURTAULT Francois [mailto:Francois.COURTAULT@gemalto.com]
Gesendet: Dienstag, 31. Juli 2012 14:21
An: java-user@axis.apache.org<ma...@axis.apache.org>
Betreff: RE: @OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
Hello Josef,
I already know that. My goal is not to test the behavior of Web Service stack.
For example, I have tested the following behavior stacks against @OneWay:
- Metro/Glassfish
- CXF
- Weblogic
Sorry I haven't enough time to test Axis 2 right now but I promise I will do so ;-)
And I have seen some differences :(
So, my goal is to see whether or not, a Web Service stack is compliant to the spec or not. This is why I want to know if it is mandatory or not (this is the question), for a Web Service stack, per spec, that "a oneway method returns the thread of control to the calling application prior to executing the actual business method"
Is it clear enough this time ?
Best Regards.
From: Stadelmann Josef [mailto:josef.stadelmann@axa-winterthur.ch]
Sent: mardi 31 juillet 2012 13:38
To: java-user@axis.apache.org<ma...@axis.apache.org>
Subject: AW: @OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
Guess you can find that easy.
Write a sleep(8*3600*1000) statement into your one way service method.
If you get back the thread-of-control at the client after 8 hours only
then you know the thread does not return up on delivery of the request
but after the method has executed, but this time just without any result
because it is a one way service.
Josef
Von: COURTAULT Francois [mailto:Francois.COURTAULT@gemalto.com]
Gesendet: Montag, 30. Juli 2012 17:56
An: java-user@axis.apache.org<ma...@axis.apache.org>
Betreff: @OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
Hello guys,
I have read the JSR 181 spec and the @OneWay is not clear for me.
Just want to have your interpretation....
In the spec, it is said that: "Indicates that the given web method has only an input message and no output. Typically,
a oneway method returns the thread of control to the calling application prior to executing
the actual business method"
What typically means ? Does it mean MUST-SHALL, SHOULD or MAY according to you ?
Still about the OneWay what is the HTTP binding for this annotation ? I have seen that some implementation returns a 202.
Is it a standard HTTP status code value for OneWay ?
Best Regards.
AW: @OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
Posted by Stadelmann Josef <jo...@axa-winterthur.ch>.
100% clear, thanks
Von: COURTAULT Francois [mailto:Francois.COURTAULT@gemalto.com]
Gesendet: Dienstag, 31. Juli 2012 14:21
An: java-user@axis.apache.org
Betreff: RE: @OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
Hello Josef,
I already know that. My goal is not to test the behavior of Web Service
stack.
For example, I have tested the following behavior stacks against
@OneWay:
- Metro/Glassfish
- CXF
- Weblogic
Sorry I haven't enough time to test Axis 2 right now but I promise I
will do so ;-)
And I have seen some differences L
So, my goal is to see whether or not, a Web Service stack is compliant
to the spec or not. This is why I want to know if it is mandatory or not
(this is the question), for a Web Service stack, per spec, that "a
oneway method returns the thread of control to the calling application
prior to executing the actual business method"
Is it clear enough this time ?
Best Regards.
From: Stadelmann Josef [mailto:josef.stadelmann@axa-winterthur.ch]
Sent: mardi 31 juillet 2012 13:38
To: java-user@axis.apache.org
Subject: AW: @OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
Guess you can find that easy.
Write a sleep(8*3600*1000) statement into your one way service method.
If you get back the thread-of-control at the client after 8 hours only
then you know the thread does not return up on delivery of the request
but after the method has executed, but this time just without any result
because it is a one way service.
Josef
Von: COURTAULT Francois [mailto:Francois.COURTAULT@gemalto.com]
Gesendet: Montag, 30. Juli 2012 17:56
An: java-user@axis.apache.org
Betreff: @OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
Hello guys,
I have read the JSR 181 spec and the @OneWay is not clear for me.
Just want to have your interpretation....
In the spec, it is said that: "Indicates that the given web method has
only an input message and no output. Typically,
a oneway method returns the thread of control to the calling application
prior to executing
the actual business method"
What typically means ? Does it mean MUST-SHALL, SHOULD or MAY according
to you ?
Still about the OneWay what is the HTTP binding for this annotation ? I
have seen that some implementation returns a 202.
Is it a standard HTTP status code value for OneWay ?
Best Regards.
RE: @OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
Posted by COURTAULT Francois <Fr...@gemalto.com>.
Hello Josef,
I already know that. My goal is not to test the behavior of Web Service stack.
For example, I have tested the following behavior stacks against @OneWay:
- Metro/Glassfish
- CXF
- Weblogic
Sorry I haven't enough time to test Axis 2 right now but I promise I will do so ;-)
And I have seen some differences :(
So, my goal is to see whether or not, a Web Service stack is compliant to the spec or not. This is why I want to know if it is mandatory or not (this is the question), for a Web Service stack, per spec, that "a oneway method returns the thread of control to the calling application prior to executing the actual business method"
Is it clear enough this time ?
Best Regards.
From: Stadelmann Josef [mailto:josef.stadelmann@axa-winterthur.ch]
Sent: mardi 31 juillet 2012 13:38
To: java-user@axis.apache.org
Subject: AW: @OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
Guess you can find that easy.
Write a sleep(8*3600*1000) statement into your one way service method.
If you get back the thread-of-control at the client after 8 hours only
then you know the thread does not return up on delivery of the request
but after the method has executed, but this time just without any result
because it is a one way service.
Josef
Von: COURTAULT Francois [mailto:Francois.COURTAULT@gemalto.com]
Gesendet: Montag, 30. Juli 2012 17:56
An: java-user@axis.apache.org<ma...@axis.apache.org>
Betreff: @OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
Hello guys,
I have read the JSR 181 spec and the @OneWay is not clear for me.
Just want to have your interpretation....
In the spec, it is said that: "Indicates that the given web method has only an input message and no output. Typically,
a oneway method returns the thread of control to the calling application prior to executing
the actual business method"
What typically means ? Does it mean MUST-SHALL, SHOULD or MAY according to you ?
Still about the OneWay what is the HTTP binding for this annotation ? I have seen that some implementation returns a 202.
Is it a standard HTTP status code value for OneWay ?
Best Regards.
AW: @OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
Posted by Stadelmann Josef <jo...@axa-winterthur.ch>.
Guess you can find that easy.
Write a sleep(8*3600*1000) statement into your one way service method.
If you get back the thread-of-control at the client after 8 hours only
then you know the thread does not return up on delivery of the request
but after the method has executed, but this time just without any result
because it is a one way service.
Josef
Von: COURTAULT Francois [mailto:Francois.COURTAULT@gemalto.com]
Gesendet: Montag, 30. Juli 2012 17:56
An: java-user@axis.apache.org
Betreff: @OneWay interpretation and HTTP binding
Hello guys,
I have read the JSR 181 spec and the @OneWay is not clear for me.
Just want to have your interpretation....
In the spec, it is said that: "Indicates that the given web method has
only an input message and no output. Typically,
a oneway method returns the thread of control to the calling application
prior to executing
the actual business method"
What typically means ? Does it mean MUST-SHALL, SHOULD or MAY according
to you ?
Still about the OneWay what is the HTTP binding for this annotation ? I
have seen that some implementation returns a 202.
Is it a standard HTTP status code value for OneWay ?
Best Regards.