You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to notifications@superset.apache.org by "eschutho (via GitHub)" <gi...@apache.org> on 2026/02/20 23:16:16 UTC

[D] [Feature] Deck.gl Path: Support metric-based color scales (Fixed / Categorical / Breakpoints) [superset]

GitHub user eschutho created a discussion: [Feature] Deck.gl Path: Support metric-based color scales (Fixed / Categorical / Breakpoints)

[Feature] Deck.gl Path: Support metric-based color scales (Fixed / Categorical / Breakpoints)

Summary

Enhance the Deck.gl Path visualization to support metric-based color scaling options, matching behavior available in the Deck.gl Scatterplot chart.

Specifically, Path should support three color modes:
	1.	Fixed
	2.	Categorical
	3.	Breakpoints (threshold-based)

Currently, Path supports only a fixed color. This limits expressiveness for metric-driven visualizations.

⸻

Problem

The Path visualization allows users to render geographic paths (e.g., routes, flows, trajectories), but the line color is static.

Users need the ability to:
	•	Color paths dynamically based on a metric value.
	•	Define categorical color palettes.
	•	Define numeric breakpoints (e.g., thresholds) with associated colors.

Scatterplot already supports:
	•	Fixed color
	•	Categorical color mapping
	•	Breakpoints / threshold mapping

Path should provide the same capabilities for consistency and usability.

⸻

Proposed Solution

Extend Deck.gl Path visualization to support metric-driven color configuration, aligned with Scatterplot behavior.

1️⃣ Add Color Mode Selector

Add a new control:

Color Mode:
- Fixed
- Categorical
- Breakpoints

Default remains Fixed to preserve backward compatibility.

⸻

2️⃣ Behavior Per Mode

Fixed (existing behavior)
	•	Single color picker.
	•	Applies same color to all paths.

⸻

Categorical
	•	Select metric (or group-by column).
	•	Apply categorical palette.
	•	Color varies based on metric result.

Should reuse:
	•	Existing categorical palette infrastructure.
	•	Legend rendering behavior consistent with Scatterplot.

⸻

Breakpoints (Threshold-based)
Allow users to:
	•	Select metric.
	•	Define breakpoints (e.g., 0–100, 100–400, 400+).
	•	Assign a color to each range.

UI requirements:
	•	Add dynamic rows for:
	•	Lower bound
	•	Upper bound
	•	Color picker
	•	Support adding/removing breakpoint rows.

Behavior:
	•	Color for each path is determined by the metric value falling within the defined range.
	•	Boundaries should be clearly defined (inclusive/exclusive consistent with Scatterplot).

⸻

3️⃣ Control Panel Changes

In plugins/plugin-chart-deckgl/src/Path/controlPanel.ts:
	•	Add color mode selector control.
	•	Add conditional controls for:
	•	Metric selection (if not already present).
	•	Categorical palette selection.
	•	Breakpoint configuration.

Controls should match implementation patterns from:
	•	Scatter/controlPanel.ts

Avoid duplicating logic; reuse shared control configs where possible.

⸻

4️⃣ Rendering Logic

In the Path layer implementation:
	•	Update accessor logic for getColor to:
	•	Evaluate metric value per row
	•	Map to:
	•	Fixed color
	•	Categorical scale
	•	Breakpoint scale

Implementation should follow patterns used in:
	•	Deck.gl Scatterplot layer
	•	Other Deck.gl layers with metric-based coloring

Color computation must occur in the data-to-layer mapping step.

⸻

5️⃣ Legend Behavior
	•	Categorical mode → show categorical legend.
	•	Breakpoints mode → show range legend.
	•	Fixed mode → no legend change.

Legend styling and behavior must match other Deck.gl visualizations.

⸻

6️⃣ Backward Compatibility
	•	Existing charts must render identically.
	•	Default color mode = Fixed.
	•	No breaking changes to saved form_data.

⸻

Testing Requirements

Unit Tests

Add tests for:
	•	Control panel config (new controls appear conditionally).
	•	Color scale logic:
	•	Fixed mode returns constant color.
	•	Categorical mode maps distinct values correctly.
	•	Breakpoints mode maps values to correct color ranges.

Reuse testing patterns from Scatterplot tests.

⸻

Integration Tests (if applicable)
	•	Ensure saved charts with default (fixed) color still render.
	•	Ensure new modes correctly apply color scaling.

⸻

Acceptance Criteria
	•	Path visualization supports:
	•	Fixed color
	•	Categorical palette
	•	Breakpoints
	•	Behavior matches Scatterplot implementation.
	•	Legend renders correctly.
	•	No regression in existing Path charts.
	•	Tests added and passing.

⸻

Notes for Implementation
	•	Prefer reusing existing color scale utilities instead of reimplementing mapping logic.
	•	Ensure color logic is applied at the accessor level (getColor) and not precomputed in SQL.
	•	Keep parity with other Deck.gl chart types.
	•	Avoid introducing chart-type-specific scale implementations if shared utilities exist.

⸻

Labels (Suggested)
	•	feature
	•	deck.gl
	•	visualization
	•	frontend
	•	enhancement

⸻

GitHub link: https://github.com/apache/superset/discussions/38134

----
This is an automatically sent email for notifications@superset.apache.org.
To unsubscribe, please send an email to: notifications-unsubscribe@superset.apache.org


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: notifications-unsubscribe@superset.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: notifications-help@superset.apache.org


Re: [D] [Feature] Deck.gl Path: Support metric-based color scales (Fixed / Categorical / Breakpoints) [superset]

Posted by "eschutho (via GitHub)" <gi...@apache.org>.
GitHub user eschutho added a comment to the discussion: [Feature] Deck.gl Path: Support metric-based color scales (Fixed / Categorical / Breakpoints)

We're going to start working on this, fyi. 

GitHub link: https://github.com/apache/superset/discussions/38134#discussioncomment-15877120

----
This is an automatically sent email for notifications@superset.apache.org.
To unsubscribe, please send an email to: notifications-unsubscribe@superset.apache.org


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: notifications-unsubscribe@superset.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: notifications-help@superset.apache.org


Re: [D] [Feature] Deck.gl Path: Support metric-based color scales (Fixed / Categorical / Breakpoints) [superset]

Posted by "eschutho (via GitHub)" <gi...@apache.org>.
GitHub user eschutho edited a discussion: [Feature] Deck.gl Path: Support metric-based color scales (Fixed / Categorical / Breakpoints)

[Feature] Deck.gl Path: Support metric-based color scales (Fixed / Categorical / Breakpoints)

Summary

Enhance the Deck.gl Path visualization to support metric-based color scaling options, matching behavior available in the Deck.gl Scatterplot chart.

Specifically, Path should support three color modes:
	1.	Fixed
	2.	Categorical
	3.	Breakpoints (threshold-based)

Currently, Path supports only a fixed color. This limits expressiveness for metric-driven visualizations.

⸻

Problem

The Path visualization allows users to render geographic paths (e.g., routes, flows, trajectories), but the line color is static.

Users need the ability to:
	•	Color paths dynamically based on a metric value.
	•	Define categorical color palettes.
	•	Define numeric breakpoints (e.g., thresholds) with associated colors.

Scatterplot already supports:
	•	Fixed color
	•	Categorical color mapping
	•	Breakpoints / threshold mapping

Path should provide the same capabilities for consistency and usability.

⸻

Proposed Solution

Extend Deck.gl Path visualization to support metric-driven color configuration, aligned with Scatterplot behavior.

1️⃣ Add Color Mode Selector

Add a new control:

Color Scheme Type
- Fixed
- Categorical
- Breakpoints

Default remains Fixed to preserve backward compatibility.

⸻

2️⃣ Behavior Per Mode

Fixed (existing behavior)
	•	Single color picker.
	•	Applies same color to all paths.

⸻

Categorical
	•	Select metric (or group-by column).
	•	Apply categorical palette.
	•	Color varies based on metric result.

Should reuse:
	•	Existing categorical palette infrastructure.
	•	Legend rendering behavior consistent with Scatterplot.

⸻

Breakpoints (Threshold-based)
Allow users to:
	•	Select metric.
	•	Define breakpoints (e.g., 0–100, 100–400, 400+).
	•	Assign a color to each range.

UI requirements:
	•	Add dynamic rows for:
	•	Lower bound
	•	Upper bound
	•	Color picker
	•	Support adding/removing breakpoint rows.

Behavior:
	•	Color for each path is determined by the metric value falling within the defined range.
	•	Boundaries should be clearly defined (inclusive/exclusive consistent with Scatterplot).

⸻

3️⃣ Control Panel Changes

In plugins/plugin-chart-deckgl/src/Path/controlPanel.ts:
	•	Add color mode selector control.
	•	Add conditional controls for:
	•	Metric selection (if not already present).
	•	Categorical palette selection.
	•	Breakpoint configuration.

Controls should match implementation patterns from:
	•	Scatter/controlPanel.ts

Avoid duplicating logic; reuse shared control configs where possible.

⸻

4️⃣ Rendering Logic

In the Path layer implementation:
	•	Update accessor logic for getColor to:
	•	Evaluate metric value per row
	•	Map to:
	•	Fixed color
	•	Categorical scale
	•	Breakpoint scale

Implementation should follow patterns used in:
	•	Deck.gl Scatterplot layer
	•	Other Deck.gl layers with metric-based coloring

Color computation must occur in the data-to-layer mapping step.

<img width="613" height="442" alt="Screenshot 2026-02-23 at 3 40 15 PM" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/ef0df639-3c62-4ef5-80dd-2cc1fd50b6c5" />


⸻

5️⃣ Legend Behavior
	•	Categorical mode → show categorical legend.
	•	Breakpoints mode → show range legend.
	•	Fixed mode → no legend change.

Legend styling and behavior must match other Deck.gl visualizations.

⸻

6️⃣ Backward Compatibility
	•	Existing charts must render identically.
	•	Default color mode = Fixed.
	•	No breaking changes to saved form_data.

⸻

Testing Requirements

Unit Tests

Add tests for:
	•	Control panel config (new controls appear conditionally).
	•	Color scale logic:
	•	Fixed mode returns constant color.
	•	Categorical mode maps distinct values correctly.
	•	Breakpoints mode maps values to correct color ranges.

Reuse testing patterns from Scatterplot tests.

⸻

Integration Tests (if applicable)
	•	Ensure saved charts with default (fixed) color still render.
	•	Ensure new modes correctly apply color scaling.

⸻

Acceptance Criteria
	•	Path visualization supports:
	•	Fixed color
	•	Categorical palette
	•	Breakpoints
	•	Behavior matches Scatterplot implementation.
	•	Legend renders correctly.
	•	No regression in existing Path charts.
	•	Tests added and passing.

⸻

Notes for Implementation
	•	Prefer reusing existing color scale utilities instead of reimplementing mapping logic.
	•	Ensure color logic is applied at the accessor level (getColor) and not precomputed in SQL.
	•	Keep parity with other Deck.gl chart types.
	•	Avoid introducing chart-type-specific scale implementations if shared utilities exist.

⸻

Labels (Suggested)
	•	feature
	•	deck.gl
	•	visualization
	•	frontend
	•	enhancement

⸻

GitHub link: https://github.com/apache/superset/discussions/38134

----
This is an automatically sent email for notifications@superset.apache.org.
To unsubscribe, please send an email to: notifications-unsubscribe@superset.apache.org


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: notifications-unsubscribe@superset.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: notifications-help@superset.apache.org


Re: [D] [Feature] Deck.gl Path: Support metric-based color scales (Fixed / Categorical / Breakpoints) [superset]

Posted by "eschutho (via GitHub)" <gi...@apache.org>.
GitHub user eschutho edited a discussion: [Feature] Deck.gl Path: Support metric-based color scales (Fixed / Categorical / Breakpoints)

[Feature] Deck.gl Path: Support metric-based color scales (Fixed / Categorical / Breakpoints)

Summary

Enhance the Deck.gl Path visualization to support metric-based color scaling options, matching behavior available in the Deck.gl Scatterplot chart.

Specifically, Path should support three color modes:
	1.	Fixed
	2.	Categorical
	3.	Breakpoints (threshold-based)

Currently, Path supports only a fixed color. This limits expressiveness for metric-driven visualizations.

⸻

Problem

The Path visualization allows users to render geographic paths (e.g., routes, flows, trajectories), but the line color is static.

Users need the ability to:
	•	Color paths dynamically based on a metric value.
	•	Define categorical color palettes.
	•	Define numeric breakpoints (e.g., thresholds) with associated colors.

Scatterplot already supports:
	•	Fixed color
	•	Categorical color mapping
	•	Breakpoints / threshold mapping

Path should provide the same capabilities for consistency and usability.

⸻

Proposed Solution

Extend Deck.gl Path visualization to support metric-driven color configuration, aligned with Scatterplot behavior.

1️⃣ Add Color Mode Selector

Add a new control:

Color Scheme Type
- Fixed
- Categorical
- Breakpoints

Default remains Fixed to preserve backward compatibility.

⸻

2️⃣ Behavior Per Mode

Fixed (existing behavior)
	•	Single color picker.
	•	Applies same color to all paths.

⸻

Categorical
	•	Select metric (or group-by column).
	•	Apply categorical palette.
	•	Color varies based on metric result.

Should reuse:
	•	Existing categorical palette infrastructure.
	•	Legend rendering behavior consistent with Scatterplot.

⸻

Breakpoints (Threshold-based)
Allow users to:
	•	Select metric.
	•	Define breakpoints (e.g., 0–100, 100–400, 400+).
	•	Assign a color to each range.

UI requirements:
	•	Add dynamic rows for:
	•	Lower bound
	•	Upper bound
	•	Color picker
	•	Support adding/removing breakpoint rows.

Behavior:
	•	Color for each path is determined by the metric value falling within the defined range.
	•	Boundaries should be clearly defined (inclusive/exclusive consistent with Scatterplot).

⸻

3️⃣ Control Panel Changes

In plugins/plugin-chart-deckgl/src/Path/controlPanel.ts:
	•	Add color mode selector control.
	•	Add conditional controls for:
	•	Metric selection (if not already present).
	•	Categorical palette selection.
	•	Breakpoint configuration.

Controls should match implementation patterns from:
	•	Scatter/controlPanel.ts

Avoid duplicating logic; reuse shared control configs where possible.

⸻

4️⃣ Rendering Logic

In the Path layer implementation:
	•	Update accessor logic for getColor to:
	•	Evaluate metric value per row
	•	Map to:
	•	Fixed color
	•	Categorical scale
	•	Breakpoint scale

Implementation should follow patterns used in:
	•	Deck.gl Scatterplot layer
	•	Other Deck.gl layers with metric-based coloring

Color computation must occur in the data-to-layer mapping step.

<img width="613" height="442" alt="Screenshot 2026-02-23 at 3 40 15 PM" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/ef0df639-3c62-4ef5-80dd-2cc1fd50b6c5" />
<img width="471" height="233" alt="Screenshot 2026-02-25 at 2 45 37 PM" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/d22aacbf-7831-41a4-81b0-aab181b99574" />


⸻

5️⃣ Legend Behavior
	•	Categorical mode → show categorical legend.
	•	Breakpoints mode → show range legend.
	•	Fixed mode → no legend change.

Legend styling and behavior must match other Deck.gl visualizations.

⸻

6️⃣ Backward Compatibility
	•	Existing charts must render identically.
	•	Default color mode = Fixed.
	•	No breaking changes to saved form_data.

⸻

Testing Requirements

Unit Tests

Add tests for:
	•	Control panel config (new controls appear conditionally).
	•	Color scale logic:
	•	Fixed mode returns constant color.
	•	Categorical mode maps distinct values correctly.
	•	Breakpoints mode maps values to correct color ranges.

Reuse testing patterns from Scatterplot tests.

⸻

Integration Tests (if applicable)
	•	Ensure saved charts with default (fixed) color still render.
	•	Ensure new modes correctly apply color scaling.

⸻

Acceptance Criteria
	•	Path visualization supports:
	•	Fixed color
	•	Categorical palette
	•	Breakpoints
	•	Behavior matches Scatterplot implementation.
	•	Legend renders correctly.
	•	No regression in existing Path charts.
	•	Tests added and passing.

⸻

Notes for Implementation
	•	Prefer reusing existing color scale utilities instead of reimplementing mapping logic.
	•	Ensure color logic is applied at the accessor level (getColor) and not precomputed in SQL.
	•	Keep parity with other Deck.gl chart types.
	•	Avoid introducing chart-type-specific scale implementations if shared utilities exist.

⸻

Labels (Suggested)
	•	feature
	•	deck.gl
	•	visualization
	•	frontend
	•	enhancement

⸻

GitHub link: https://github.com/apache/superset/discussions/38134

----
This is an automatically sent email for notifications@superset.apache.org.
To unsubscribe, please send an email to: notifications-unsubscribe@superset.apache.org


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: notifications-unsubscribe@superset.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: notifications-help@superset.apache.org


Re: [D] [Feature] Deck.gl Path: Support metric-based color scales (Fixed / Categorical / Breakpoints) [superset]

Posted by "eschutho (via GitHub)" <gi...@apache.org>.
GitHub user eschutho edited a discussion: [Feature] Deck.gl Path: Support metric-based color scales (Fixed / Categorical / Breakpoints)

[Feature] Deck.gl Path: Support metric-based color scales (Fixed / Categorical / Breakpoints)

Summary

Enhance the Deck.gl Path visualization to support metric-based color scaling options, matching behavior available in the Deck.gl Scatterplot chart.

Specifically, Path should support three color modes:
	1.	Fixed
	2.	Categorical
	3.	Breakpoints (threshold-based)

Currently, Path supports only a fixed color. This limits expressiveness for metric-driven visualizations.

⸻

Problem

The Path visualization allows users to render geographic paths (e.g., routes, flows, trajectories), but the line color is static.

Users need the ability to:
	•	Color paths dynamically based on a metric value.
	•	Define categorical color palettes.
	•	Define numeric breakpoints (e.g., thresholds) with associated colors.

Scatterplot already supports:
	•	Fixed color
	•	Categorical color mapping
	•	Breakpoints / threshold mapping

Path should provide the same capabilities for consistency and usability.

⸻

Proposed Solution

Extend Deck.gl Path visualization to support metric-driven color configuration, aligned with Scatterplot behavior.

1️⃣ Add Color Mode Selector

Add a new control:

Color Scheme Type
- Fixed
- Categorical
- Breakpoints

Default remains Fixed to preserve backward compatibility.

⸻

2️⃣ Behavior Per Mode

Fixed (existing behavior)
	•	Single color picker.
	•	Applies same color to all paths.

⸻

Categorical
	•	Select metric (or group-by column).
	•	Apply categorical palette.
	•	Color varies based on metric result.

Should reuse:
	•	Existing categorical palette infrastructure.
	•	Legend rendering behavior consistent with Scatterplot.

⸻

Breakpoints (Threshold-based)
Allow users to:
	•	Select metric.
	•	Define breakpoints (e.g., 0–100, 100–400, 400+).
	•	Assign a color to each range.

UI requirements:
	•	Add dynamic rows for:
	•	Lower bound
	•	Upper bound
	•	Color picker
	•	Support adding/removing breakpoint rows.

Behavior:
	•	Color for each path is determined by the metric value falling within the defined range.
	•	Boundaries should be clearly defined (inclusive/exclusive consistent with Scatterplot).

⸻

3️⃣ Control Panel Changes

In plugins/plugin-chart-deckgl/src/Path/controlPanel.ts:
	•	Add color mode selector control.
	•	Add conditional controls for:
	•	Metric selection (if not already present).
	•	Categorical palette selection.
	•	Breakpoint configuration.

Controls should match implementation patterns from:
	•	Scatter/controlPanel.ts

Avoid duplicating logic; reuse shared control configs where possible.

⸻

4️⃣ Rendering Logic

In the Path layer implementation:
	•	Update accessor logic for getColor to:
	•	Evaluate metric value per row
	•	Map to:
	•	Fixed color
	•	Categorical scale
	•	Breakpoint scale

Implementation should follow patterns used in:
	•	Deck.gl Scatterplot layer
	•	Other Deck.gl layers with metric-based coloring

Color computation must occur in the data-to-layer mapping step.

<img width="613" height="442" alt="Screenshot 2026-02-23 at 3 40 15 PM" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/ef0df639-3c62-4ef5-80dd-2cc1fd50b6c5" />
⸻

<img width="471" height="233" alt="Screenshot 2026-02-25 at 2 45 37 PM" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/d22aacbf-7831-41a4-81b0-aab181b99574" />


⸻

5️⃣ Legend Behavior
	•	Categorical mode → show categorical legend.
	•	Breakpoints mode → show range legend.
	•	Fixed mode → no legend change.

Legend styling and behavior must match other Deck.gl visualizations.

⸻

6️⃣ Backward Compatibility
	•	Existing charts must render identically.
	•	Default color mode = Fixed.
	•	No breaking changes to saved form_data.

⸻

Testing Requirements

Unit Tests

Add tests for:
	•	Control panel config (new controls appear conditionally).
	•	Color scale logic:
	•	Fixed mode returns constant color.
	•	Categorical mode maps distinct values correctly.
	•	Breakpoints mode maps values to correct color ranges.

Reuse testing patterns from Scatterplot tests.

⸻

Integration Tests (if applicable)
	•	Ensure saved charts with default (fixed) color still render.
	•	Ensure new modes correctly apply color scaling.

⸻

Acceptance Criteria
	•	Path visualization supports:
	•	Fixed color
	•	Categorical palette
	•	Breakpoints
	•	Behavior matches Scatterplot implementation.
	•	Legend renders correctly.
	•	No regression in existing Path charts.
	•	Tests added and passing.

⸻

Notes for Implementation
	•	Prefer reusing existing color scale utilities instead of reimplementing mapping logic.
	•	Ensure color logic is applied at the accessor level (getColor) and not precomputed in SQL.
	•	Keep parity with other Deck.gl chart types.
	•	Avoid introducing chart-type-specific scale implementations if shared utilities exist.

⸻

Labels (Suggested)
	•	feature
	•	deck.gl
	•	visualization
	•	frontend
	•	enhancement

⸻

GitHub link: https://github.com/apache/superset/discussions/38134

----
This is an automatically sent email for notifications@superset.apache.org.
To unsubscribe, please send an email to: notifications-unsubscribe@superset.apache.org


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: notifications-unsubscribe@superset.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: notifications-help@superset.apache.org