You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@continuum.apache.org by tz...@s-und-n.de on 2007/04/20 11:51:15 UTC
nice to have features
hi guys,
i've been using continuum now for about 4 month. several projects are
running on it. overall it is a nice continuous integration server but
there are still a few key features missing.
- project based acl (access for users with the possibility to allow
usergroups to access only specific projects)
- user must be allowed to change his password independently from
usermanagement role
- any notifier should have the opion of sending a successful build result
only on result change - the successful build report is only sent if the
previous build result != successful
- ssl support for frontend (not sure about this - might already be
integrated)
are any of these features planned to be integrated into continuum? and
what do you guys think of these features in general?
thx in advance,
Freundliche Grüße / With kind regards
Thomas Zirke
S&N AG
Klingenderstr. 5
D 33100 Paderborn
voice +49 5251/1581-984
fax +49 5251/1581-71
eMail tzirke@s-und-n.de
Web http://www.s-und-n.de
Vorstand
Klaus Beverungen
Josef Tillmann
Vorsitzender des Aufsichtsrates
Heinz-Dieter Wendorff
Handelsregister
Amtsgericht Paderborn HRB 3270
Re: Re: nice to have features
Posted by tz...@s-und-n.de.
hi emmanuel,
thx for the quick reply. its nice to know that all of this is coming
rather soon :-)
as for the notifier: i do experience the effect, that a successful build
result is always propagated though the configured notifier effectively
ignoring any previous build result. i'm using mail-notifiers only - the
alwaysSend option is set to "false" in the configuration xml file of the
continuum server. any idea why i do get all "successful" build results?
i'm still running continuum 1.0.3.
thx again
Freundliche Grüße / With kind regards
Thomas Zirke
S&N AG
Klingenderstr. 5
D 33100 Paderborn
voice +49 5251/1581-984
fax +49 5251/1581-71
eMail tzirke@s-und-n.de
Web http://www.s-und-n.de
Vorstand
Klaus Beverungen
Josef Tillmann
Vorsitzender des Aufsichtsrates
Heinz-Dieter Wendorff
Handelsregister
Amtsgericht Paderborn HRB 3270
Emmanuel Venisse <em...@venisse.net>
20.04.2007 11:57
Bitte antworten an continuum-dev
An: continuum-dev@maven.apache.org
Kopie:
Thema: Re: nice to have features
hehe, you'll be happy with continuum 1.1. We'll release a first alpha next
week and it integrate all your points.
About the notifier, it send a report only if the state change. If your
project is always in success the report is sent only the first time but if
your project is always in failure, the report is
always sent
Emmanuel
tzirke@s-und-n.de a écrit :
> hi guys,
>
> i've been using continuum now for about 4 month. several projects are
> running on it. overall it is a nice continuous integration server but
> there are still a few key features missing.
>
> - project based acl (access for users with the possibility to allow
> usergroups to access only specific projects)
> - user must be allowed to change his password independently from
> usermanagement role
> - any notifier should have the opion of sending a successful build
result
> only on result change - the successful build report is only sent if the
> previous build result != successful
> - ssl support for frontend (not sure about this - might already be
> integrated)
>
> are any of these features planned to be integrated into continuum? and
> what do you guys think of these features in general?
> thx in advance,
>
> Freundliche Grüße / With kind regards
> Thomas Zirke
>
> S&N AG
> Klingenderstr. 5
> D 33100 Paderborn
>
> voice +49 5251/1581-984
> fax +49 5251/1581-71
> eMail tzirke@s-und-n.de
> Web http://www.s-und-n.de
>
> Vorstand
> Klaus Beverungen
> Josef Tillmann
>
> Vorsitzender des Aufsichtsrates
> Heinz-Dieter Wendorff
>
> Handelsregister
> Amtsgericht Paderborn HRB 3270
Re: nice to have features
Posted by Wendy Smoak <ws...@gmail.com>.
On 4/20/07, Vivek_Nakeesan@logitech.com <Vi...@logitech.com> wrote:
> I hope that I am not asking for more features as you are finalizing 1.1
> 3) When a build fails contiuum must trigger another build in X minutes
> (configurable), based on the 2nd build the notification should be send out.
> This will avoid errors due to partial check-ins
The problem was addressed in a slightly different way. Continuum 1.1
has a 'quiet period'. If there have been changes in the last X
minutes (configurable), Continuum will skip that scheduled build,
thinking you migh be in the middle of a check-in.
--
Wendy
Re: nice to have features
Posted by Emmanuel Venisse <em...@venisse.net>.
Vivek_Nakeesan@logitech.com a écrit :
> I hope that I am not asking for more features as you are finalizing 1.1
>
>
>
> 1) - Build success/Failure
> Continuum 1.0.3 has the feature but, I am looking for to give summary of
> successful ,failure and total builds. Get the trend of continuous
> integration.
This feature is planned but maybe for 1.2
>
> 2) - Unit test successes/Failure (Able to dig in to details)
> After the each build when continuum triggers the unit test, the results of
> the unit test should published under unit test results section. Cruise
> control has a reporting section called Unit Test. Some commercial tools
> give summary of the unit test results and when you click on the summary you
> can see the individual unit test results with descriptions
We already have a test report in 1.1
>
> 3) When a build fails contiuum must trigger another build in X minutes
> (configurable), based on the 2nd build the notification should be send out.
> This will avoid errors due to partial check-ins
A new build start with the next shedule if the project wasn't in success.
Emmanuel
>
> If you have more questions please let me know.
>
> ~nakees
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Emmanuel Venisse To
> <emmanuel@venisse continuum-dev@maven.apache.org
> .net> cc
>
> Subject
> 20/04/2007 07:51 Re: nice to have features
> AM
>
>
> Please respond to
> continuum-dev@mav
> en.apache.org
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Can you add more explanantions?
>
> Vivek_Nakeesan@logitech.com a écrit :
>> Some more suggestions
>>
>> Separate reporting sections for
>> - Build success/Failure
>> - Unit test successes/Failure (Able to dig in to details)
>>
>> ~nakees
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>
>
>
>> Emmanuel Venisse
> To
>> <emmanuel@venisse continuum-dev@maven.apache.org
>
>> .net>
> cc
>
> Subject
>> 20/04/2007 05:57 Re: nice to have features
>
>> AM
>
>
>
>> Please respond to
>
>> continuum-dev@mav
>
>> en.apache.org
>
>
>
>>
>>
>>
>> hehe, you'll be happy with continuum 1.1. We'll release a first alpha
> next
>> week and it integrate all your points.
>> About the notifier, it send a report only if the state change. If your
>> project is always in success the report is sent only the first time but
> if
>> your project is always in failure, the report is
>> always sent
>>
>> Emmanuel
>>
>> tzirke@s-und-n.de a écrit :
>>> hi guys,
>>>
>>> i've been using continuum now for about 4 month. several projects are
>>> running on it. overall it is a nice continuous integration server but
>>> there are still a few key features missing.
>>>
>>> - project based acl (access for users with the possibility to allow
>>> usergroups to access only specific projects)
>>> - user must be allowed to change his password independently from
>>> usermanagement role
>>> - any notifier should have the opion of sending a successful build
> result
>>> only on result change - the successful build report is only sent if the
>>> previous build result != successful
>>> - ssl support for frontend (not sure about this - might already be
>>> integrated)
>>>
>>> are any of these features planned to be integrated into continuum? and
>>> what do you guys think of these features in general?
>>> thx in advance,
>>>
>>> Freundliche Grüße / With kind regards
>>> Thomas Zirke
>>>
>>> S&N AG
>>> Klingenderstr. 5
>>> D 33100 Paderborn
>>>
>>> voice +49 5251/1581-984
>>> fax +49 5251/1581-71
>>> eMail tzirke@s-und-n.de
>>> Web http://www.s-und-n.de
>>>
>>> Vorstand
>>> Klaus Beverungen
>>> Josef Tillmann
>>>
>>> Vorsitzender des Aufsichtsrates
>>> Heinz-Dieter Wendorff
>>>
>>> Handelsregister
>>> Amtsgericht Paderborn HRB 3270
>>
>>
>>
>>
>
>
>
>
>
Re: nice to have features
Posted by Vi...@logitech.com.
I hope that I am not asking for more features as you are finalizing 1.1
1) - Build success/Failure
Continuum 1.0.3 has the feature but, I am looking for to give summary of
successful ,failure and total builds. Get the trend of continuous
integration.
2) - Unit test successes/Failure (Able to dig in to details)
After the each build when continuum triggers the unit test, the results of
the unit test should published under unit test results section. Cruise
control has a reporting section called Unit Test. Some commercial tools
give summary of the unit test results and when you click on the summary you
can see the individual unit test results with descriptions
3) When a build fails contiuum must trigger another build in X minutes
(configurable), based on the 2nd build the notification should be send out.
This will avoid errors due to partial check-ins
If you have more questions please let me know.
~nakees
Emmanuel Venisse To
<emmanuel@venisse continuum-dev@maven.apache.org
.net> cc
Subject
20/04/2007 07:51 Re: nice to have features
AM
Please respond to
continuum-dev@mav
en.apache.org
Can you add more explanantions?
Vivek_Nakeesan@logitech.com a écrit :
> Some more suggestions
>
> Separate reporting sections for
> - Build success/Failure
> - Unit test successes/Failure (Able to dig in to details)
>
> ~nakees
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Emmanuel Venisse
To
> <emmanuel@venisse continuum-dev@maven.apache.org
> .net>
cc
>
>
Subject
> 20/04/2007 05:57 Re: nice to have features
> AM
>
>
> Please respond to
> continuum-dev@mav
> en.apache.org
>
>
>
>
>
>
> hehe, you'll be happy with continuum 1.1. We'll release a first alpha
next
> week and it integrate all your points.
> About the notifier, it send a report only if the state change. If your
> project is always in success the report is sent only the first time but
if
> your project is always in failure, the report is
> always sent
>
> Emmanuel
>
> tzirke@s-und-n.de a écrit :
>> hi guys,
>>
>> i've been using continuum now for about 4 month. several projects are
>> running on it. overall it is a nice continuous integration server but
>> there are still a few key features missing.
>>
>> - project based acl (access for users with the possibility to allow
>> usergroups to access only specific projects)
>> - user must be allowed to change his password independently from
>> usermanagement role
>> - any notifier should have the opion of sending a successful build
result
>
>> only on result change - the successful build report is only sent if the
>> previous build result != successful
>> - ssl support for frontend (not sure about this - might already be
>> integrated)
>>
>> are any of these features planned to be integrated into continuum? and
>> what do you guys think of these features in general?
>> thx in advance,
>>
>> Freundliche Grüße / With kind regards
>> Thomas Zirke
>>
>> S&N AG
>> Klingenderstr. 5
>> D 33100 Paderborn
>>
>> voice +49 5251/1581-984
>> fax +49 5251/1581-71
>> eMail tzirke@s-und-n.de
>> Web http://www.s-und-n.de
>>
>> Vorstand
>> Klaus Beverungen
>> Josef Tillmann
>>
>> Vorsitzender des Aufsichtsrates
>> Heinz-Dieter Wendorff
>>
>> Handelsregister
>> Amtsgericht Paderborn HRB 3270
>
>
>
>
>
Re: nice to have features
Posted by Emmanuel Venisse <em...@venisse.net>.
Can you add more explanantions?
Vivek_Nakeesan@logitech.com a écrit :
> Some more suggestions
>
> Separate reporting sections for
> - Build success/Failure
> - Unit test successes/Failure (Able to dig in to details)
>
> ~nakees
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Emmanuel Venisse To
> <emmanuel@venisse continuum-dev@maven.apache.org
> .net> cc
>
> Subject
> 20/04/2007 05:57 Re: nice to have features
> AM
>
>
> Please respond to
> continuum-dev@mav
> en.apache.org
>
>
>
>
>
>
> hehe, you'll be happy with continuum 1.1. We'll release a first alpha next
> week and it integrate all your points.
> About the notifier, it send a report only if the state change. If your
> project is always in success the report is sent only the first time but if
> your project is always in failure, the report is
> always sent
>
> Emmanuel
>
> tzirke@s-und-n.de a écrit :
>> hi guys,
>>
>> i've been using continuum now for about 4 month. several projects are
>> running on it. overall it is a nice continuous integration server but
>> there are still a few key features missing.
>>
>> - project based acl (access for users with the possibility to allow
>> usergroups to access only specific projects)
>> - user must be allowed to change his password independently from
>> usermanagement role
>> - any notifier should have the opion of sending a successful build result
>
>> only on result change - the successful build report is only sent if the
>> previous build result != successful
>> - ssl support for frontend (not sure about this - might already be
>> integrated)
>>
>> are any of these features planned to be integrated into continuum? and
>> what do you guys think of these features in general?
>> thx in advance,
>>
>> Freundliche Grüße / With kind regards
>> Thomas Zirke
>>
>> S&N AG
>> Klingenderstr. 5
>> D 33100 Paderborn
>>
>> voice +49 5251/1581-984
>> fax +49 5251/1581-71
>> eMail tzirke@s-und-n.de
>> Web http://www.s-und-n.de
>>
>> Vorstand
>> Klaus Beverungen
>> Josef Tillmann
>>
>> Vorsitzender des Aufsichtsrates
>> Heinz-Dieter Wendorff
>>
>> Handelsregister
>> Amtsgericht Paderborn HRB 3270
>
>
>
>
>
Re: nice to have features
Posted by Vi...@logitech.com.
Some more suggestions
Separate reporting sections for
- Build success/Failure
- Unit test successes/Failure (Able to dig in to details)
~nakees
Emmanuel Venisse To
<emmanuel@venisse continuum-dev@maven.apache.org
.net> cc
Subject
20/04/2007 05:57 Re: nice to have features
AM
Please respond to
continuum-dev@mav
en.apache.org
hehe, you'll be happy with continuum 1.1. We'll release a first alpha next
week and it integrate all your points.
About the notifier, it send a report only if the state change. If your
project is always in success the report is sent only the first time but if
your project is always in failure, the report is
always sent
Emmanuel
tzirke@s-und-n.de a écrit :
> hi guys,
>
> i've been using continuum now for about 4 month. several projects are
> running on it. overall it is a nice continuous integration server but
> there are still a few key features missing.
>
> - project based acl (access for users with the possibility to allow
> usergroups to access only specific projects)
> - user must be allowed to change his password independently from
> usermanagement role
> - any notifier should have the opion of sending a successful build result
> only on result change - the successful build report is only sent if the
> previous build result != successful
> - ssl support for frontend (not sure about this - might already be
> integrated)
>
> are any of these features planned to be integrated into continuum? and
> what do you guys think of these features in general?
> thx in advance,
>
> Freundliche Grüße / With kind regards
> Thomas Zirke
>
> S&N AG
> Klingenderstr. 5
> D 33100 Paderborn
>
> voice +49 5251/1581-984
> fax +49 5251/1581-71
> eMail tzirke@s-und-n.de
> Web http://www.s-und-n.de
>
> Vorstand
> Klaus Beverungen
> Josef Tillmann
>
> Vorsitzender des Aufsichtsrates
> Heinz-Dieter Wendorff
>
> Handelsregister
> Amtsgericht Paderborn HRB 3270
Re: nice to have features
Posted by Emmanuel Venisse <em...@venisse.net>.
hehe, you'll be happy with continuum 1.1. We'll release a first alpha next week and it integrate all your points.
About the notifier, it send a report only if the state change. If your project is always in success the report is sent only the first time but if your project is always in failure, the report is
always sent
Emmanuel
tzirke@s-und-n.de a écrit :
> hi guys,
>
> i've been using continuum now for about 4 month. several projects are
> running on it. overall it is a nice continuous integration server but
> there are still a few key features missing.
>
> - project based acl (access for users with the possibility to allow
> usergroups to access only specific projects)
> - user must be allowed to change his password independently from
> usermanagement role
> - any notifier should have the opion of sending a successful build result
> only on result change - the successful build report is only sent if the
> previous build result != successful
> - ssl support for frontend (not sure about this - might already be
> integrated)
>
> are any of these features planned to be integrated into continuum? and
> what do you guys think of these features in general?
> thx in advance,
>
> Freundliche Grüße / With kind regards
> Thomas Zirke
>
> S&N AG
> Klingenderstr. 5
> D 33100 Paderborn
>
> voice +49 5251/1581-984
> fax +49 5251/1581-71
> eMail tzirke@s-und-n.de
> Web http://www.s-und-n.de
>
> Vorstand
> Klaus Beverungen
> Josef Tillmann
>
> Vorsitzender des Aufsichtsrates
> Heinz-Dieter Wendorff
>
> Handelsregister
> Amtsgericht Paderborn HRB 3270