You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@cordova.apache.org by Andrea Tino <An...@microsoft.com> on 2015/01/23 09:10:25 UTC
Cordova issue 8080 - After migrating to 3.6.3 from 3.4.0, Appium
(Android) tests fail because of open dialog
Hello
My name is Andrea Tino. I am a Microsoft Developer in the Microsoft Dynamics NAV Team.
Recently we started using Cordova for building our apps.
All our tests fail
We moved to Cordova 3.6.3 from 3.4.0 and from there all our tests (more than 200) started failing. After investigating on possible causes, we could identify the problem as part of a Cordova checkin: https://github.com/apache/cordova-android/commit/aab47bd4532bfe8707d745638eb5695ac543c681. Looks like prompt() is causing the problem. However the checkin I reported lacks changes to cordova.js that were supposed to be included there but that have been checked-in later in https://github.com/apache/cordova-android/commit/ec47274fbd91d2f0b658da64f5d4d4dd6600f625. So to repro the problem you need both checkins.
The issue in JIRA documents details very good in comments: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CB-8080
Need for a fix
We assessed that trying to fix this here would be costly for us. The feature introduced spans across several areas of Cordova, thus high chances of breaking something. Also the feature is a security related one which we cannot revert. We need the Cordova Team to fix this problem which has been causing our test infrastructure to be broken for more than a month so far. We could also assess we are not the only one experiencing this issue whose repro is still not clear.
After an initial discussion with Andrew Grieve, we decided to try broadening the audience in order to move Cordova Team's attention on this problem which we consider quite serious. Could you please prioritize the issue in your bug-fixing plan? How much time would it require for fixing this problem?
Thank you for your availability
-Andrea Tino
[Description: MSFT_logo]
Andrea Tino
Software Development Engineer
Microsoft Development Center Copenhagen
Microsoft Dynamics NAV
Mobile: +45 29229860
E-Mail: andrea.tino@microsoft.com<ma...@microsoft.com>
RE: Cordova issue 8080 - After migrating to 3.6.3 from 3.4.0, Appium
(Android) tests fail because of open dialog
Posted by Chuck Lantz <cl...@microsoft.com>.
Andrea,
Some folks in the developer division may be able to help out here. I'll connect you with our Cordova contributors.
-Chuck
From: Andrea Tino [mailto:Andrea.Tino@microsoft.com]
Sent: Friday, January 23, 2015 12:10 AM
To: dev@cordova.apache.org
Cc: Vincent Nicolas; Michael Helligsø Svinth
Subject: Cordova issue 8080 - After migrating to 3.6.3 from 3.4.0, Appium (Android) tests fail because of open dialog
Hello
My name is Andrea Tino. I am a Microsoft Developer in the Microsoft Dynamics NAV Team.
Recently we started using Cordova for building our apps.
All our tests fail
We moved to Cordova 3.6.3 from 3.4.0 and from there all our tests (more than 200) started failing. After investigating on possible causes, we could identify the problem as part of a Cordova checkin: https://github.com/apache/cordova-android/commit/aab47bd4532bfe8707d745638eb5695ac543c681. Looks like prompt() is causing the problem. However the checkin I reported lacks changes to cordova.js that were supposed to be included there but that have been checked-in later in https://github.com/apache/cordova-android/commit/ec47274fbd91d2f0b658da64f5d4d4dd6600f625. So to repro the problem you need both checkins.
The issue in JIRA documents details very good in comments: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CB-8080
Need for a fix
We assessed that trying to fix this here would be costly for us. The feature introduced spans across several areas of Cordova, thus high chances of breaking something. Also the feature is a security related one which we cannot revert. We need the Cordova Team to fix this problem which has been causing our test infrastructure to be broken for more than a month so far. We could also assess we are not the only one experiencing this issue whose repro is still not clear.
After an initial discussion with Andrew Grieve, we decided to try broadening the audience in order to move Cordova Team's attention on this problem which we consider quite serious. Could you please prioritize the issue in your bug-fixing plan? How much time would it require for fixing this problem?
Thank you for your availability
-Andrea Tino
[Description: MSFT_logo]
Andrea Tino
Software Development Engineer
Microsoft Development Center Copenhagen
Microsoft Dynamics NAV
Mobile: +45 29229860
E-Mail: andrea.tino@microsoft.com<ma...@microsoft.com>