You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to user@olingo.apache.org by mibo <mi...@apache.org> on 2026/01/21 21:00:31 UTC

Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Hi Shane and all reading here,

Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half year to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an explanation).
Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part not easier.

> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!

Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a bit too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).

Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project, driving it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still active and interested.

One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before the repo is set to 'read only'?
I wanted to do the Olingo V2 release in version 3.0.0 (https://github.com/apache/olingo-odata2/pull/58), before the final move to the attic.
I started working on it more than half a year ago. But first, I struggled with the new GitHub Actions based release process, second there was no response from any PMC member (https://lists.apache.org/thread/496wz49qzwc2gm8fybt803jz9kfmgljb) to the voting, and finally, I did not have enough spare time (because of the private reasons mentioned), so I never finished it.
However, it would be nice to have it.

Let me please know if it would be possible, and I would then spend time on it the last weekend in January.

Kind Regards, Michael

> Am 11.12.2025 um 20:45 schrieb Shane Curcuru <as...@shanecurcuru.org>:
> 
> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> 
> What this means in practical terms is that the Apache Olingo project will be turned read-only at it's existing URLs - code, websites, mail archives, everything.  While that shutters the active community here at the ASF, all the resources are available for anyone who wants to fork them, and users are free to continue using the software or improving it themselves.
> 
>  https://attic.apache.org/
> 
> For perspective: the ASF requires that PMCs have at least three active PMC members, such that (for example) someone would notice if a vulnerability were reported, and that the PMC could then make a release with any needed fixes.  This is important, because end users expect that any "Apache GoodStuff" project would at least provide a basic level of security or other major fixes if needed.
> 
> Thanks especially to the PMC members who have done the extra work in past years to manage the project and make formal releases.
> 
> -- 
> - Shane
>  Director
>  The Apache Software Foundation
> 


Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Posted by Dave Fisher <wa...@apache.org>.

> On Jan 21, 2026, at 1:00 PM, mibo <mi...@apache.org> wrote:
> 
> Hi Shane and all reading here,
> 
> Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half year to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an explanation).
> Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part not easier.
> 
>> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> 
> Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
> I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a bit too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).
> 
> Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project, driving it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
> And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still active and interested.
> 
> One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before the repo is set to 'read only'?
> I wanted to do the Olingo V2 release in version 3.0.0 (https://github.com/apache/olingo-odata2/pull/58 <https://github.com/apache/olingo-odata2/pull/58>), before the final move to the attic.
> I started working on it more than half a year ago. But first, I struggled with the new GitHub Actions based release process, second there was no response from any PMC member (https://lists.apache.org/thread/496wz49qzwc2gm8fybt803jz9kfmgljb) to the voting, and finally, I did not have enough spare time (because of the private reasons mentioned), so I never finished it.
> However, it would be nice to have it.
> 
> Let me please know if it would be possible, and I would then spend time on it the last weekend in January.

As an Olingo PMC member I would help with this process should the board decide to give Olingo one more month before going to the attic.

Best,
Dave

> 
> Kind Regards, Michael
> 
>> Am 11.12.2025 um 20:45 schrieb Shane Curcuru <as...@shanecurcuru.org>:
>> 
>> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
>> 
>> What this means in practical terms is that the Apache Olingo project will be turned read-only at it's existing URLs - code, websites, mail archives, everything.  While that shutters the active community here at the ASF, all the resources are available for anyone who wants to fork them, and users are free to continue using the software or improving it themselves.
>> 
>>  https://attic.apache.org/
>> 
>> For perspective: the ASF requires that PMCs have at least three active PMC members, such that (for example) someone would notice if a vulnerability were reported, and that the PMC could then make a release with any needed fixes.  This is important, because end users expect that any "Apache GoodStuff" project would at least provide a basic level of security or other major fixes if needed.
>> 
>> Thanks especially to the PMC members who have done the extra work in past years to manage the project and make formal releases.
>> 
>> -- 
>> - Shane
>>  Director
>>  The Apache Software Foundation
>> 
> 


Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Posted by Hervé Boutemy <hb...@apache.org>.
no news from Olingo since we paused Attic workflow

we just had a useful ping from INFRA Jira ticket
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-27574

If no news in the next 72h, we'll "un-pause": we tried to adapt as much as 
possible, but we can't stay in this state

Best Regards,

Hervé, from the Attic

Le lundi 2 février 2026, 11:49:22 CET Niall Pemberton a écrit :
> On Fri, 23 Jan 2026 at 08:16, Hervé Boutemy <he...@free.fr> wrote:
> > Attic work on marking everything in the Attic has been done, but
> > infrastructure has not been cleaned up yet
> > https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-27574
> > 
> > as you can see, I asked for not cleaning up your infra for now: if you
> > think
> > you can do a normal vote for a normal release (even if the PMC is
> > officially
> > disbanded, but Shane does not see an objection that the binding votes from
> > the
> > PMC are still binding), you can do a normal final release
> 
> The Olingo PMC no longer exists - it was terminated by the Board on 17th
> December:
>     https://whimsy.apache.org/board/minutes/Olingo.html#2025-12-17
> 
> Since an official ASF release is an “act of the PMC”, it’s therefore not
> possible for the Olingo PMC to do a release. I guess theoretically the
> Attic PMC could approve a release, but I doubt we want to go down that road.
> 
> 
> Please tell us if you want to do an official release or not, so Attic can
> 
> > update
> > our ask to infra on cleaning up the project assets (switch everything R/O,
> > delete CI, ...)
> 
> As Hervé has said, the resources have not yet been shutdown by Infra, so
> you still have write access to the source repository. So you are still able
> to make changes that you wanted to do for a release and tag/label it. If
> you get that done, then there we could discuss whether the Attic is
> prepared to release or you host an external release somewhere and we
> reference it from either the Attic or Olingo website.
> 
> If you’re wanting to proceed with working on Olingo, then I think you need
> to do this soon. If we don’t see any activity on this, then I think we need
> to finish the Attic process
> 
> Niall
> 
> if you decide NOT to do an official release, because it's too late
> 
> > Attic can point project retirement data to "related project".
> > Like for example:
> > https://attic.apache.org/projects/cocoon.html
> > 
> > 
> > Just tell us your choices, and Attic can adapt :)
> > 
> > Best Regards,
> > 
> > Hervé, from the Attic team
> > 
> > Le jeudi 22 janvier 2026, 19:37:38 CET Shane Curcuru a écrit :
> > > (Note mixed private/public lists)
> > > 
> > > Dear Attic: Olingo might have enough people to finalize their last
> > > release now - which is sadly after the board officially relegated Olingo
> > > to the Attic in the December meeting.
> > > 
> > > If mibo and others can indeed roll a final release, do we have any way
> > > to either put that on the attic site, or point to some external release
> > > made by past community members?
> > > 
> > > This is one of those unfortunate timing issues.
> > > 
> > > mibo wrote on 1/21/26 16:00:
> > > > Hi Shane and all reading here,
> > > > 
> > > > Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that
> > > > resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half
> > 
> > year
> > 
> > > > to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an
> > > > explanation).
> > > > Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part
> > > > not easier.
> > > 
> > > Please don't worry; you don't need an excuse.  The ASF understands that
> > > we are all volunteers here, and our real lives come first.  This exact
> > > kind of private issue (in my case, several health complications) has
> > > been making me absent the past month myself, so I very much understand.
> > > 
> > > >> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache
> > > >> Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those
> > > >> who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> > > > 
> > > > Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic
> > > > (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
> > > > I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a
> > > > bit
> > > > too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).
> > > > 
> > > > Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project,
> > 
> > driving
> > 
> > > > it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
> > > > And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still
> > > > active and interested.
> > > 
> > > Indeed - sometimes we don't spend enough time in the Attic process
> > > celebrating the community that's built such a great product.  Even if
> > > there isn't an active and growing tool to work on, all ASF tools have,
> > > and continue to be, useful to all sorts of people around the world.
> > > Celebrate the long life of your project!
> > > 
> > > > One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before
> > > > the
> > > > repo is set to 'read only'?
> > > 
> > > ...snip...
> > > 
> > > I've included the Attic discussion list above, who are now formally
> > > responsible for the Olingo project's assets here at the ASF.  They have
> > > already started the process of Attic'ing, as seen here:
> > > 
> > > https://lists.apache.org/thread/4wmgoohthb8ohj8wx2068w4rkd14r221
> > > 
> > > Note that even if Apache Olingo truly is read-only, my bet is that if
> > > you can produce your own not-technically-ASF release elsewhere, we can
> > > find a way to point future users at it.  (I hope!).
> > > 
> > > Thanks all,





Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Posted by Hervé Boutemy <hb...@apache.org>.
no news from Olingo since we paused Attic workflow

we just had a useful ping from INFRA Jira ticket
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-27574

If no news in the next 72h, we'll "un-pause": we tried to adapt as much as 
possible, but we can't stay in this state

Best Regards,

Hervé, from the Attic

Le lundi 2 février 2026, 11:49:22 CET Niall Pemberton a écrit :
> On Fri, 23 Jan 2026 at 08:16, Hervé Boutemy <he...@free.fr> wrote:
> > Attic work on marking everything in the Attic has been done, but
> > infrastructure has not been cleaned up yet
> > https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-27574
> > 
> > as you can see, I asked for not cleaning up your infra for now: if you
> > think
> > you can do a normal vote for a normal release (even if the PMC is
> > officially
> > disbanded, but Shane does not see an objection that the binding votes from
> > the
> > PMC are still binding), you can do a normal final release
> 
> The Olingo PMC no longer exists - it was terminated by the Board on 17th
> December:
>     https://whimsy.apache.org/board/minutes/Olingo.html#2025-12-17
> 
> Since an official ASF release is an “act of the PMC”, it’s therefore not
> possible for the Olingo PMC to do a release. I guess theoretically the
> Attic PMC could approve a release, but I doubt we want to go down that road.
> 
> 
> Please tell us if you want to do an official release or not, so Attic can
> 
> > update
> > our ask to infra on cleaning up the project assets (switch everything R/O,
> > delete CI, ...)
> 
> As Hervé has said, the resources have not yet been shutdown by Infra, so
> you still have write access to the source repository. So you are still able
> to make changes that you wanted to do for a release and tag/label it. If
> you get that done, then there we could discuss whether the Attic is
> prepared to release or you host an external release somewhere and we
> reference it from either the Attic or Olingo website.
> 
> If you’re wanting to proceed with working on Olingo, then I think you need
> to do this soon. If we don’t see any activity on this, then I think we need
> to finish the Attic process
> 
> Niall
> 
> if you decide NOT to do an official release, because it's too late
> 
> > Attic can point project retirement data to "related project".
> > Like for example:
> > https://attic.apache.org/projects/cocoon.html
> > 
> > 
> > Just tell us your choices, and Attic can adapt :)
> > 
> > Best Regards,
> > 
> > Hervé, from the Attic team
> > 
> > Le jeudi 22 janvier 2026, 19:37:38 CET Shane Curcuru a écrit :
> > > (Note mixed private/public lists)
> > > 
> > > Dear Attic: Olingo might have enough people to finalize their last
> > > release now - which is sadly after the board officially relegated Olingo
> > > to the Attic in the December meeting.
> > > 
> > > If mibo and others can indeed roll a final release, do we have any way
> > > to either put that on the attic site, or point to some external release
> > > made by past community members?
> > > 
> > > This is one of those unfortunate timing issues.
> > > 
> > > mibo wrote on 1/21/26 16:00:
> > > > Hi Shane and all reading here,
> > > > 
> > > > Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that
> > > > resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half
> > 
> > year
> > 
> > > > to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an
> > > > explanation).
> > > > Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part
> > > > not easier.
> > > 
> > > Please don't worry; you don't need an excuse.  The ASF understands that
> > > we are all volunteers here, and our real lives come first.  This exact
> > > kind of private issue (in my case, several health complications) has
> > > been making me absent the past month myself, so I very much understand.
> > > 
> > > >> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache
> > > >> Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those
> > > >> who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> > > > 
> > > > Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic
> > > > (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
> > > > I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a
> > > > bit
> > > > too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).
> > > > 
> > > > Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project,
> > 
> > driving
> > 
> > > > it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
> > > > And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still
> > > > active and interested.
> > > 
> > > Indeed - sometimes we don't spend enough time in the Attic process
> > > celebrating the community that's built such a great product.  Even if
> > > there isn't an active and growing tool to work on, all ASF tools have,
> > > and continue to be, useful to all sorts of people around the world.
> > > Celebrate the long life of your project!
> > > 
> > > > One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before
> > > > the
> > > > repo is set to 'read only'?
> > > 
> > > ...snip...
> > > 
> > > I've included the Attic discussion list above, who are now formally
> > > responsible for the Olingo project's assets here at the ASF.  They have
> > > already started the process of Attic'ing, as seen here:
> > > 
> > > https://lists.apache.org/thread/4wmgoohthb8ohj8wx2068w4rkd14r221
> > > 
> > > Note that even if Apache Olingo truly is read-only, my bet is that if
> > > you can produce your own not-technically-ASF release elsewhere, we can
> > > find a way to point future users at it.  (I hope!).
> > > 
> > > Thanks all,





Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Posted by Hervé Boutemy <hb...@apache.org>.
no news from Olingo since we paused Attic workflow

we just had a useful ping from INFRA Jira ticket
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-27574

If no news in the next 72h, we'll "un-pause": we tried to adapt as much as 
possible, but we can't stay in this state

Best Regards,

Hervé, from the Attic

Le lundi 2 février 2026, 11:49:22 CET Niall Pemberton a écrit :
> On Fri, 23 Jan 2026 at 08:16, Hervé Boutemy <he...@free.fr> wrote:
> > Attic work on marking everything in the Attic has been done, but
> > infrastructure has not been cleaned up yet
> > https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-27574
> > 
> > as you can see, I asked for not cleaning up your infra for now: if you
> > think
> > you can do a normal vote for a normal release (even if the PMC is
> > officially
> > disbanded, but Shane does not see an objection that the binding votes from
> > the
> > PMC are still binding), you can do a normal final release
> 
> The Olingo PMC no longer exists - it was terminated by the Board on 17th
> December:
>     https://whimsy.apache.org/board/minutes/Olingo.html#2025-12-17
> 
> Since an official ASF release is an “act of the PMC”, it’s therefore not
> possible for the Olingo PMC to do a release. I guess theoretically the
> Attic PMC could approve a release, but I doubt we want to go down that road.
> 
> 
> Please tell us if you want to do an official release or not, so Attic can
> 
> > update
> > our ask to infra on cleaning up the project assets (switch everything R/O,
> > delete CI, ...)
> 
> As Hervé has said, the resources have not yet been shutdown by Infra, so
> you still have write access to the source repository. So you are still able
> to make changes that you wanted to do for a release and tag/label it. If
> you get that done, then there we could discuss whether the Attic is
> prepared to release or you host an external release somewhere and we
> reference it from either the Attic or Olingo website.
> 
> If you’re wanting to proceed with working on Olingo, then I think you need
> to do this soon. If we don’t see any activity on this, then I think we need
> to finish the Attic process
> 
> Niall
> 
> if you decide NOT to do an official release, because it's too late
> 
> > Attic can point project retirement data to "related project".
> > Like for example:
> > https://attic.apache.org/projects/cocoon.html
> > 
> > 
> > Just tell us your choices, and Attic can adapt :)
> > 
> > Best Regards,
> > 
> > Hervé, from the Attic team
> > 
> > Le jeudi 22 janvier 2026, 19:37:38 CET Shane Curcuru a écrit :
> > > (Note mixed private/public lists)
> > > 
> > > Dear Attic: Olingo might have enough people to finalize their last
> > > release now - which is sadly after the board officially relegated Olingo
> > > to the Attic in the December meeting.
> > > 
> > > If mibo and others can indeed roll a final release, do we have any way
> > > to either put that on the attic site, or point to some external release
> > > made by past community members?
> > > 
> > > This is one of those unfortunate timing issues.
> > > 
> > > mibo wrote on 1/21/26 16:00:
> > > > Hi Shane and all reading here,
> > > > 
> > > > Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that
> > > > resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half
> > 
> > year
> > 
> > > > to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an
> > > > explanation).
> > > > Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part
> > > > not easier.
> > > 
> > > Please don't worry; you don't need an excuse.  The ASF understands that
> > > we are all volunteers here, and our real lives come first.  This exact
> > > kind of private issue (in my case, several health complications) has
> > > been making me absent the past month myself, so I very much understand.
> > > 
> > > >> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache
> > > >> Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those
> > > >> who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> > > > 
> > > > Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic
> > > > (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
> > > > I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a
> > > > bit
> > > > too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).
> > > > 
> > > > Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project,
> > 
> > driving
> > 
> > > > it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
> > > > And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still
> > > > active and interested.
> > > 
> > > Indeed - sometimes we don't spend enough time in the Attic process
> > > celebrating the community that's built such a great product.  Even if
> > > there isn't an active and growing tool to work on, all ASF tools have,
> > > and continue to be, useful to all sorts of people around the world.
> > > Celebrate the long life of your project!
> > > 
> > > > One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before
> > > > the
> > > > repo is set to 'read only'?
> > > 
> > > ...snip...
> > > 
> > > I've included the Attic discussion list above, who are now formally
> > > responsible for the Olingo project's assets here at the ASF.  They have
> > > already started the process of Attic'ing, as seen here:
> > > 
> > > https://lists.apache.org/thread/4wmgoohthb8ohj8wx2068w4rkd14r221
> > > 
> > > Note that even if Apache Olingo truly is read-only, my bet is that if
> > > you can produce your own not-technically-ASF release elsewhere, we can
> > > find a way to point future users at it.  (I hope!).
> > > 
> > > Thanks all,





Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Posted by Niall Pemberton <ni...@gmail.com>.
On Fri, 23 Jan 2026 at 08:16, Hervé Boutemy <he...@free.fr> wrote:

> Attic work on marking everything in the Attic has been done, but
> infrastructure has not been cleaned up yet
> https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-27574
>
> as you can see, I asked for not cleaning up your infra for now: if you
> think
> you can do a normal vote for a normal release (even if the PMC is
> officially
> disbanded, but Shane does not see an objection that the binding votes from
> the
> PMC are still binding), you can do a normal final release


The Olingo PMC no longer exists - it was terminated by the Board on 17th
December:
    https://whimsy.apache.org/board/minutes/Olingo.html#2025-12-17

Since an official ASF release is an “act of the PMC”, it’s therefore not
possible for the Olingo PMC to do a release. I guess theoretically the
Attic PMC could approve a release, but I doubt we want to go down that road.


Please tell us if you want to do an official release or not, so Attic can
> update
> our ask to infra on cleaning up the project assets (switch everything R/O,
> delete CI, ...)


As Hervé has said, the resources have not yet been shutdown by Infra, so
you still have write access to the source repository. So you are still able
to make changes that you wanted to do for a release and tag/label it. If
you get that done, then there we could discuss whether the Attic is
prepared to release or you host an external release somewhere and we
reference it from either the Attic or Olingo website.

If you’re wanting to proceed with working on Olingo, then I think you need
to do this soon. If we don’t see any activity on this, then I think we need
to finish the Attic process

Niall

if you decide NOT to do an official release, because it's too late
>
> Attic can point project retirement data to "related project".
> Like for example:
> https://attic.apache.org/projects/cocoon.html
>
>
> Just tell us your choices, and Attic can adapt :)
>
> Best Regards,
>
> Hervé, from the Attic team
>
> Le jeudi 22 janvier 2026, 19:37:38 CET Shane Curcuru a écrit :
> > (Note mixed private/public lists)
> >
> > Dear Attic: Olingo might have enough people to finalize their last
> > release now - which is sadly after the board officially relegated Olingo
> > to the Attic in the December meeting.
> >
> > If mibo and others can indeed roll a final release, do we have any way
> > to either put that on the attic site, or point to some external release
> > made by past community members?
> >
> > This is one of those unfortunate timing issues.
> >
> > mibo wrote on 1/21/26 16:00:
> > > Hi Shane and all reading here,
> > >
> > > Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that
> > > resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half
> year
> > > to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an
> > > explanation).
> > > Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part
> > > not easier.
> >
> > Please don't worry; you don't need an excuse.  The ASF understands that
> > we are all volunteers here, and our real lives come first.  This exact
> > kind of private issue (in my case, several health complications) has
> > been making me absent the past month myself, so I very much understand.
> >
> > >> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache
> > >> Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those
> > >> who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> > >
> > > Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic
> > > (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
> > > I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a bit
> > > too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).
> > >
> > > Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project,
> driving
> > > it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
> > > And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still
> > > active and interested.
> >
> > Indeed - sometimes we don't spend enough time in the Attic process
> > celebrating the community that's built such a great product.  Even if
> > there isn't an active and growing tool to work on, all ASF tools have,
> > and continue to be, useful to all sorts of people around the world.
> > Celebrate the long life of your project!
> >
> > > One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before the
> > > repo is set to 'read only'?
> >
> > ...snip...
> >
> > I've included the Attic discussion list above, who are now formally
> > responsible for the Olingo project's assets here at the ASF.  They have
> > already started the process of Attic'ing, as seen here:
> >
> > https://lists.apache.org/thread/4wmgoohthb8ohj8wx2068w4rkd14r221
> >
> > Note that even if Apache Olingo truly is read-only, my bet is that if
> > you can produce your own not-technically-ASF release elsewhere, we can
> > find a way to point future users at it.  (I hope!).
> >
> > Thanks all,
>
>
>
>
>

Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Posted by Niall Pemberton <ni...@gmail.com>.
On Fri, 23 Jan 2026 at 08:16, Hervé Boutemy <he...@free.fr> wrote:

> Attic work on marking everything in the Attic has been done, but
> infrastructure has not been cleaned up yet
> https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-27574
>
> as you can see, I asked for not cleaning up your infra for now: if you
> think
> you can do a normal vote for a normal release (even if the PMC is
> officially
> disbanded, but Shane does not see an objection that the binding votes from
> the
> PMC are still binding), you can do a normal final release


The Olingo PMC no longer exists - it was terminated by the Board on 17th
December:
    https://whimsy.apache.org/board/minutes/Olingo.html#2025-12-17

Since an official ASF release is an “act of the PMC”, it’s therefore not
possible for the Olingo PMC to do a release. I guess theoretically the
Attic PMC could approve a release, but I doubt we want to go down that road.


Please tell us if you want to do an official release or not, so Attic can
> update
> our ask to infra on cleaning up the project assets (switch everything R/O,
> delete CI, ...)


As Hervé has said, the resources have not yet been shutdown by Infra, so
you still have write access to the source repository. So you are still able
to make changes that you wanted to do for a release and tag/label it. If
you get that done, then there we could discuss whether the Attic is
prepared to release or you host an external release somewhere and we
reference it from either the Attic or Olingo website.

If you’re wanting to proceed with working on Olingo, then I think you need
to do this soon. If we don’t see any activity on this, then I think we need
to finish the Attic process

Niall

if you decide NOT to do an official release, because it's too late
>
> Attic can point project retirement data to "related project".
> Like for example:
> https://attic.apache.org/projects/cocoon.html
>
>
> Just tell us your choices, and Attic can adapt :)
>
> Best Regards,
>
> Hervé, from the Attic team
>
> Le jeudi 22 janvier 2026, 19:37:38 CET Shane Curcuru a écrit :
> > (Note mixed private/public lists)
> >
> > Dear Attic: Olingo might have enough people to finalize their last
> > release now - which is sadly after the board officially relegated Olingo
> > to the Attic in the December meeting.
> >
> > If mibo and others can indeed roll a final release, do we have any way
> > to either put that on the attic site, or point to some external release
> > made by past community members?
> >
> > This is one of those unfortunate timing issues.
> >
> > mibo wrote on 1/21/26 16:00:
> > > Hi Shane and all reading here,
> > >
> > > Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that
> > > resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half
> year
> > > to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an
> > > explanation).
> > > Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part
> > > not easier.
> >
> > Please don't worry; you don't need an excuse.  The ASF understands that
> > we are all volunteers here, and our real lives come first.  This exact
> > kind of private issue (in my case, several health complications) has
> > been making me absent the past month myself, so I very much understand.
> >
> > >> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache
> > >> Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those
> > >> who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> > >
> > > Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic
> > > (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
> > > I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a bit
> > > too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).
> > >
> > > Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project,
> driving
> > > it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
> > > And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still
> > > active and interested.
> >
> > Indeed - sometimes we don't spend enough time in the Attic process
> > celebrating the community that's built such a great product.  Even if
> > there isn't an active and growing tool to work on, all ASF tools have,
> > and continue to be, useful to all sorts of people around the world.
> > Celebrate the long life of your project!
> >
> > > One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before the
> > > repo is set to 'read only'?
> >
> > ...snip...
> >
> > I've included the Attic discussion list above, who are now formally
> > responsible for the Olingo project's assets here at the ASF.  They have
> > already started the process of Attic'ing, as seen here:
> >
> > https://lists.apache.org/thread/4wmgoohthb8ohj8wx2068w4rkd14r221
> >
> > Note that even if Apache Olingo truly is read-only, my bet is that if
> > you can produce your own not-technically-ASF release elsewhere, we can
> > find a way to point future users at it.  (I hope!).
> >
> > Thanks all,
>
>
>
>
>

Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Posted by Niall Pemberton <ni...@gmail.com>.
On Fri, 23 Jan 2026 at 08:16, Hervé Boutemy <he...@free.fr> wrote:

> Attic work on marking everything in the Attic has been done, but
> infrastructure has not been cleaned up yet
> https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-27574
>
> as you can see, I asked for not cleaning up your infra for now: if you
> think
> you can do a normal vote for a normal release (even if the PMC is
> officially
> disbanded, but Shane does not see an objection that the binding votes from
> the
> PMC are still binding), you can do a normal final release


The Olingo PMC no longer exists - it was terminated by the Board on 17th
December:
    https://whimsy.apache.org/board/minutes/Olingo.html#2025-12-17

Since an official ASF release is an “act of the PMC”, it’s therefore not
possible for the Olingo PMC to do a release. I guess theoretically the
Attic PMC could approve a release, but I doubt we want to go down that road.


Please tell us if you want to do an official release or not, so Attic can
> update
> our ask to infra on cleaning up the project assets (switch everything R/O,
> delete CI, ...)


As Hervé has said, the resources have not yet been shutdown by Infra, so
you still have write access to the source repository. So you are still able
to make changes that you wanted to do for a release and tag/label it. If
you get that done, then there we could discuss whether the Attic is
prepared to release or you host an external release somewhere and we
reference it from either the Attic or Olingo website.

If you’re wanting to proceed with working on Olingo, then I think you need
to do this soon. If we don’t see any activity on this, then I think we need
to finish the Attic process

Niall

if you decide NOT to do an official release, because it's too late
>
> Attic can point project retirement data to "related project".
> Like for example:
> https://attic.apache.org/projects/cocoon.html
>
>
> Just tell us your choices, and Attic can adapt :)
>
> Best Regards,
>
> Hervé, from the Attic team
>
> Le jeudi 22 janvier 2026, 19:37:38 CET Shane Curcuru a écrit :
> > (Note mixed private/public lists)
> >
> > Dear Attic: Olingo might have enough people to finalize their last
> > release now - which is sadly after the board officially relegated Olingo
> > to the Attic in the December meeting.
> >
> > If mibo and others can indeed roll a final release, do we have any way
> > to either put that on the attic site, or point to some external release
> > made by past community members?
> >
> > This is one of those unfortunate timing issues.
> >
> > mibo wrote on 1/21/26 16:00:
> > > Hi Shane and all reading here,
> > >
> > > Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that
> > > resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half
> year
> > > to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an
> > > explanation).
> > > Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part
> > > not easier.
> >
> > Please don't worry; you don't need an excuse.  The ASF understands that
> > we are all volunteers here, and our real lives come first.  This exact
> > kind of private issue (in my case, several health complications) has
> > been making me absent the past month myself, so I very much understand.
> >
> > >> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache
> > >> Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those
> > >> who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> > >
> > > Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic
> > > (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
> > > I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a bit
> > > too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).
> > >
> > > Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project,
> driving
> > > it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
> > > And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still
> > > active and interested.
> >
> > Indeed - sometimes we don't spend enough time in the Attic process
> > celebrating the community that's built such a great product.  Even if
> > there isn't an active and growing tool to work on, all ASF tools have,
> > and continue to be, useful to all sorts of people around the world.
> > Celebrate the long life of your project!
> >
> > > One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before the
> > > repo is set to 'read only'?
> >
> > ...snip...
> >
> > I've included the Attic discussion list above, who are now formally
> > responsible for the Olingo project's assets here at the ASF.  They have
> > already started the process of Attic'ing, as seen here:
> >
> > https://lists.apache.org/thread/4wmgoohthb8ohj8wx2068w4rkd14r221
> >
> > Note that even if Apache Olingo truly is read-only, my bet is that if
> > you can produce your own not-technically-ASF release elsewhere, we can
> > find a way to point future users at it.  (I hope!).
> >
> > Thanks all,
>
>
>
>
>

Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Posted by Hervé Boutemy <he...@free.fr>.
Attic work on marking everything in the Attic has been done, but 
infrastructure has not been cleaned up yet
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-27574

as you can see, I asked for not cleaning up your infra for now: if you think 
you can do a normal vote for a normal release (even if the PMC is officially 
disbanded, but Shane does not see an objection that the binding votes from the 
PMC are still binding), you can do a normal final release

Please tell us if you want to do an official release or not, so Attic can update 
our ask to infra on cleaning up the project assets (switch everything R/O, 
delete CI, ...)


if you decide NOT to do an official release, because it's too late

Attic can point project retirement data to "related project".
Like for example:
https://attic.apache.org/projects/cocoon.html


Just tell us your choices, and Attic can adapt :)

Best Regards,

Hervé, from the Attic team

Le jeudi 22 janvier 2026, 19:37:38 CET Shane Curcuru a écrit :
> (Note mixed private/public lists)
> 
> Dear Attic: Olingo might have enough people to finalize their last
> release now - which is sadly after the board officially relegated Olingo
> to the Attic in the December meeting.
> 
> If mibo and others can indeed roll a final release, do we have any way
> to either put that on the attic site, or point to some external release
> made by past community members?
> 
> This is one of those unfortunate timing issues.
> 
> mibo wrote on 1/21/26 16:00:
> > Hi Shane and all reading here,
> > 
> > Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that
> > resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half year
> > to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an
> > explanation).
> > Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part
> > not easier.
> 
> Please don't worry; you don't need an excuse.  The ASF understands that
> we are all volunteers here, and our real lives come first.  This exact
> kind of private issue (in my case, several health complications) has
> been making me absent the past month myself, so I very much understand.
> 
> >> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache
> >> Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those
> >> who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> > 
> > Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic
> > (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
> > I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a bit
> > too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).
> > 
> > Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project, driving
> > it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
> > And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still
> > active and interested.
> 
> Indeed - sometimes we don't spend enough time in the Attic process
> celebrating the community that's built such a great product.  Even if
> there isn't an active and growing tool to work on, all ASF tools have,
> and continue to be, useful to all sorts of people around the world.
> Celebrate the long life of your project!
> 
> > One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before the
> > repo is set to 'read only'?
> 
> ...snip...
> 
> I've included the Attic discussion list above, who are now formally
> responsible for the Olingo project's assets here at the ASF.  They have
> already started the process of Attic'ing, as seen here:
> 
> https://lists.apache.org/thread/4wmgoohthb8ohj8wx2068w4rkd14r221
> 
> Note that even if Apache Olingo truly is read-only, my bet is that if
> you can produce your own not-technically-ASF release elsewhere, we can
> find a way to point future users at it.  (I hope!).
> 
> Thanks all,





Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Posted by Hervé Boutemy <he...@free.fr>.
Attic work on marking everything in the Attic has been done, but 
infrastructure has not been cleaned up yet
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-27574

as you can see, I asked for not cleaning up your infra for now: if you think 
you can do a normal vote for a normal release (even if the PMC is officially 
disbanded, but Shane does not see an objection that the binding votes from the 
PMC are still binding), you can do a normal final release

Please tell us if you want to do an official release or not, so Attic can update 
our ask to infra on cleaning up the project assets (switch everything R/O, 
delete CI, ...)


if you decide NOT to do an official release, because it's too late

Attic can point project retirement data to "related project".
Like for example:
https://attic.apache.org/projects/cocoon.html


Just tell us your choices, and Attic can adapt :)

Best Regards,

Hervé, from the Attic team

Le jeudi 22 janvier 2026, 19:37:38 CET Shane Curcuru a écrit :
> (Note mixed private/public lists)
> 
> Dear Attic: Olingo might have enough people to finalize their last
> release now - which is sadly after the board officially relegated Olingo
> to the Attic in the December meeting.
> 
> If mibo and others can indeed roll a final release, do we have any way
> to either put that on the attic site, or point to some external release
> made by past community members?
> 
> This is one of those unfortunate timing issues.
> 
> mibo wrote on 1/21/26 16:00:
> > Hi Shane and all reading here,
> > 
> > Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that
> > resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half year
> > to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an
> > explanation).
> > Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part
> > not easier.
> 
> Please don't worry; you don't need an excuse.  The ASF understands that
> we are all volunteers here, and our real lives come first.  This exact
> kind of private issue (in my case, several health complications) has
> been making me absent the past month myself, so I very much understand.
> 
> >> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache
> >> Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those
> >> who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> > 
> > Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic
> > (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
> > I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a bit
> > too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).
> > 
> > Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project, driving
> > it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
> > And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still
> > active and interested.
> 
> Indeed - sometimes we don't spend enough time in the Attic process
> celebrating the community that's built such a great product.  Even if
> there isn't an active and growing tool to work on, all ASF tools have,
> and continue to be, useful to all sorts of people around the world.
> Celebrate the long life of your project!
> 
> > One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before the
> > repo is set to 'read only'?
> 
> ...snip...
> 
> I've included the Attic discussion list above, who are now formally
> responsible for the Olingo project's assets here at the ASF.  They have
> already started the process of Attic'ing, as seen here:
> 
> https://lists.apache.org/thread/4wmgoohthb8ohj8wx2068w4rkd14r221
> 
> Note that even if Apache Olingo truly is read-only, my bet is that if
> you can produce your own not-technically-ASF release elsewhere, we can
> find a way to point future users at it.  (I hope!).
> 
> Thanks all,





Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Posted by Hervé Boutemy <he...@free.fr>.
Attic work on marking everything in the Attic has been done, but 
infrastructure has not been cleaned up yet
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA-27574

as you can see, I asked for not cleaning up your infra for now: if you think 
you can do a normal vote for a normal release (even if the PMC is officially 
disbanded, but Shane does not see an objection that the binding votes from the 
PMC are still binding), you can do a normal final release

Please tell us if you want to do an official release or not, so Attic can update 
our ask to infra on cleaning up the project assets (switch everything R/O, 
delete CI, ...)


if you decide NOT to do an official release, because it's too late

Attic can point project retirement data to "related project".
Like for example:
https://attic.apache.org/projects/cocoon.html


Just tell us your choices, and Attic can adapt :)

Best Regards,

Hervé, from the Attic team

Le jeudi 22 janvier 2026, 19:37:38 CET Shane Curcuru a écrit :
> (Note mixed private/public lists)
> 
> Dear Attic: Olingo might have enough people to finalize their last
> release now - which is sadly after the board officially relegated Olingo
> to the Attic in the December meeting.
> 
> If mibo and others can indeed roll a final release, do we have any way
> to either put that on the attic site, or point to some external release
> made by past community members?
> 
> This is one of those unfortunate timing issues.
> 
> mibo wrote on 1/21/26 16:00:
> > Hi Shane and all reading here,
> > 
> > Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that
> > resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half year
> > to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an
> > explanation).
> > Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part
> > not easier.
> 
> Please don't worry; you don't need an excuse.  The ASF understands that
> we are all volunteers here, and our real lives come first.  This exact
> kind of private issue (in my case, several health complications) has
> been making me absent the past month myself, so I very much understand.
> 
> >> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache
> >> Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those
> >> who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> > 
> > Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic
> > (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
> > I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a bit
> > too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).
> > 
> > Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project, driving
> > it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
> > And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still
> > active and interested.
> 
> Indeed - sometimes we don't spend enough time in the Attic process
> celebrating the community that's built such a great product.  Even if
> there isn't an active and growing tool to work on, all ASF tools have,
> and continue to be, useful to all sorts of people around the world.
> Celebrate the long life of your project!
> 
> > One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before the
> > repo is set to 'read only'?
> 
> ...snip...
> 
> I've included the Attic discussion list above, who are now formally
> responsible for the Olingo project's assets here at the ASF.  They have
> already started the process of Attic'ing, as seen here:
> 
> https://lists.apache.org/thread/4wmgoohthb8ohj8wx2068w4rkd14r221
> 
> Note that even if Apache Olingo truly is read-only, my bet is that if
> you can produce your own not-technically-ASF release elsewhere, we can
> find a way to point future users at it.  (I hope!).
> 
> Thanks all,





Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Posted by Shane Curcuru <as...@shanecurcuru.org>.
(Note mixed private/public lists)

Dear Attic: Olingo might have enough people to finalize their last 
release now - which is sadly after the board officially relegated Olingo 
to the Attic in the December meeting.

If mibo and others can indeed roll a final release, do we have any way 
to either put that on the attic site, or point to some external release 
made by past community members?

This is one of those unfortunate timing issues.

mibo wrote on 1/21/26 16:00:
> Hi Shane and all reading here,
> 
> Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that 
> resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half year 
> to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an 
> explanation).
> Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part 
> not easier.

Please don't worry; you don't need an excuse.  The ASF understands that 
we are all volunteers here, and our real lives come first.  This exact 
kind of private issue (in my case, several health complications) has 
been making me absent the past month myself, so I very much understand.

> 
>> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache 
>> Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those 
>> who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> 
> Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic 
> (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
> I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a bit 
> too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).
> 
> Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project, driving 
> it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
> And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still 
> active and interested.

Indeed - sometimes we don't spend enough time in the Attic process 
celebrating the community that's built such a great product.  Even if 
there isn't an active and growing tool to work on, all ASF tools have, 
and continue to be, useful to all sorts of people around the world. 
Celebrate the long life of your project!

> One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before the 
> repo is set to 'read only'?
...snip...

I've included the Attic discussion list above, who are now formally 
responsible for the Olingo project's assets here at the ASF.  They have 
already started the process of Attic'ing, as seen here:

https://lists.apache.org/thread/4wmgoohthb8ohj8wx2068w4rkd14r221

Note that even if Apache Olingo truly is read-only, my bet is that if 
you can produce your own not-technically-ASF release elsewhere, we can 
find a way to point future users at it.  (I hope!).

Thanks all,

-- 
- Shane
   Director
   The Apache Software Foundation

Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Posted by Shane Curcuru <as...@shanecurcuru.org>.
(Note mixed private/public lists)

Dear Attic: Olingo might have enough people to finalize their last 
release now - which is sadly after the board officially relegated Olingo 
to the Attic in the December meeting.

If mibo and others can indeed roll a final release, do we have any way 
to either put that on the attic site, or point to some external release 
made by past community members?

This is one of those unfortunate timing issues.

mibo wrote on 1/21/26 16:00:
> Hi Shane and all reading here,
> 
> Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that 
> resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half year 
> to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an 
> explanation).
> Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part 
> not easier.

Please don't worry; you don't need an excuse.  The ASF understands that 
we are all volunteers here, and our real lives come first.  This exact 
kind of private issue (in my case, several health complications) has 
been making me absent the past month myself, so I very much understand.

> 
>> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache 
>> Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those 
>> who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> 
> Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic 
> (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
> I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a bit 
> too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).
> 
> Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project, driving 
> it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
> And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still 
> active and interested.

Indeed - sometimes we don't spend enough time in the Attic process 
celebrating the community that's built such a great product.  Even if 
there isn't an active and growing tool to work on, all ASF tools have, 
and continue to be, useful to all sorts of people around the world. 
Celebrate the long life of your project!

> One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before the 
> repo is set to 'read only'?
...snip...

I've included the Attic discussion list above, who are now formally 
responsible for the Olingo project's assets here at the ASF.  They have 
already started the process of Attic'ing, as seen here:

https://lists.apache.org/thread/4wmgoohthb8ohj8wx2068w4rkd14r221

Note that even if Apache Olingo truly is read-only, my bet is that if 
you can produce your own not-technically-ASF release elsewhere, we can 
find a way to point future users at it.  (I hope!).

Thanks all,

-- 
- Shane
   Director
   The Apache Software Foundation

Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Posted by Dave Fisher <wa...@apache.org>.

> On Jan 21, 2026, at 1:00 PM, mibo <mi...@apache.org> wrote:
> 
> Hi Shane and all reading here,
> 
> Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half year to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an explanation).
> Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part not easier.
> 
>> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> 
> Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
> I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a bit too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).
> 
> Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project, driving it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
> And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still active and interested.
> 
> One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before the repo is set to 'read only'?
> I wanted to do the Olingo V2 release in version 3.0.0 (https://github.com/apache/olingo-odata2/pull/58 <https://github.com/apache/olingo-odata2/pull/58>), before the final move to the attic.
> I started working on it more than half a year ago. But first, I struggled with the new GitHub Actions based release process, second there was no response from any PMC member (https://lists.apache.org/thread/496wz49qzwc2gm8fybt803jz9kfmgljb) to the voting, and finally, I did not have enough spare time (because of the private reasons mentioned), so I never finished it.
> However, it would be nice to have it.
> 
> Let me please know if it would be possible, and I would then spend time on it the last weekend in January.

As an Olingo PMC member I would help with this process should the board decide to give Olingo one more month before going to the attic.

Best,
Dave

> 
> Kind Regards, Michael
> 
>> Am 11.12.2025 um 20:45 schrieb Shane Curcuru <as...@shanecurcuru.org>:
>> 
>> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
>> 
>> What this means in practical terms is that the Apache Olingo project will be turned read-only at it's existing URLs - code, websites, mail archives, everything.  While that shutters the active community here at the ASF, all the resources are available for anyone who wants to fork them, and users are free to continue using the software or improving it themselves.
>> 
>>  https://attic.apache.org/
>> 
>> For perspective: the ASF requires that PMCs have at least three active PMC members, such that (for example) someone would notice if a vulnerability were reported, and that the PMC could then make a release with any needed fixes.  This is important, because end users expect that any "Apache GoodStuff" project would at least provide a basic level of security or other major fixes if needed.
>> 
>> Thanks especially to the PMC members who have done the extra work in past years to manage the project and make formal releases.
>> 
>> -- 
>> - Shane
>>  Director
>>  The Apache Software Foundation
>> 
> 


Re: Apache Olingo will be heading for the Apache Attic shortly

Posted by Shane Curcuru <as...@shanecurcuru.org>.
(Note mixed private/public lists)

Dear Attic: Olingo might have enough people to finalize their last 
release now - which is sadly after the board officially relegated Olingo 
to the Attic in the December meeting.

If mibo and others can indeed roll a final release, do we have any way 
to either put that on the attic site, or point to some external release 
made by past community members?

This is one of those unfortunate timing issues.

mibo wrote on 1/21/26 16:00:
> Hi Shane and all reading here,
> 
> Sorry for my late reply, but I had some serious private issues that 
> resulted in slow response time and not enough time in the last half year 
> to drive the Olingo project (this shouldn't be an excuse, but an 
> explanation).
> Unfortunately, there were also no other PMCs left, which made my part 
> not easier.

Please don't worry; you don't need an excuse.  The ASF understands that 
we are all volunteers here, and our real lives come first.  This exact 
kind of private issue (in my case, several health complications) has 
been making me absent the past month myself, so I very much understand.

> 
>> After a long 10 years, the board will likely be voting to move Apache 
>> Olingo to the Attic at our meeting next month.  Thanks to all those 
>> who have contributed to this ASF project over the years!
> 
> Over the last six months, I also considered moving Olingo to the attic 
> (and mentioned it in the last board reports).
> I think it is the right decision, but as it is now real, it feels a bit 
> too early (and I have a small tear in my eye).
> 
> Nevertheless, I really enjoyed being part of the Olingo project, driving 
> it and keeping it (somehow) alive in the last years.
> And BIG Kudos to everyone who contributed to the project and is still 
> active and interested.

Indeed - sometimes we don't spend enough time in the Attic process 
celebrating the community that's built such a great product.  Even if 
there isn't an active and growing tool to work on, all ASF tools have, 
and continue to be, useful to all sorts of people around the world. 
Celebrate the long life of your project!

> One last question, would it be possible to do a last release before the 
> repo is set to 'read only'?
...snip...

I've included the Attic discussion list above, who are now formally 
responsible for the Olingo project's assets here at the ASF.  They have 
already started the process of Attic'ing, as seen here:

https://lists.apache.org/thread/4wmgoohthb8ohj8wx2068w4rkd14r221

Note that even if Apache Olingo truly is read-only, my bet is that if 
you can produce your own not-technically-ASF release elsewhere, we can 
find a way to point future users at it.  (I hope!).

Thanks all,

-- 
- Shane
   Director
   The Apache Software Foundation