You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to solr-user@lucene.apache.org by "Fitzpatrick, Adrian" <ad...@revenue.ie> on 2015/12/08 18:52:03 UTC
solrconfig.xml - configuration scope
Hi,
This is probably a very basic question that has been asked many times before - apologies in advance if so!
I'm looking to validate whether something I **think** I have observed when using Solr is a known behaviour:
>From my read of the docs etc. it was my understanding that solrconfig.xml was the configuration for a core, and that if I had multiple cores in my Solr server, each would have their own version of that file with their own settings. However, in practice, when working with such a multiple core setup, what I have observed suggests that some (perhaps many?) of the settings within solrconfig.xml can have a system-wide impact. I.e. I change a setting in core A and I see behaviour in other cores B,C which suggests they are obeying the changed value from the core A rather than the setting value from their own copy of solrconfig.xml
So, as I said, main question is this known/expected behaviour, or am I imagining things! If the former, is there any documentation etc. that provides any clarification around how the configuration scope operates?
Thanks,
Adrian
Please note that Revenue cannot guarantee that any personal and sensitive data, sent in plain text via standard email, is fully secure. Customers who choose to use this channel are deemed to have accepted any risk involved. The alternative communication methods offered by Revenue include standard post and the option to use our (encrypted) MyEnquiries service which is available within myAccount and ROS. You can register for either myAccount or ROS on the Revenue website.
Tabhair faoi deara nach féidir leis na Coimisinéirí Ioncaim ráthaíocht a thabhairt go bhfuil aon sonraí pearsanta agus íogair a gcuirtear isteach i ngnáth-théacs trí r-phost caighdeánach go huile is go hiomlán slán. Meastar go nglacann custaiméirí a úsáideann an cainéal seo le haon riosca bainteach. I measc na modhanna cumarsáide eile atá ag na Coimisinéirí ná post caighdeánach agus an rogha ár seirbhís (criptithe) M'Fhiosruithe a úsáid, tá sí ar fáil laistigh de MoChúrsaí agus ROS. Is féidir leat clárú le haghaidh ceachtar MoChúrsaí nó ROS ar shuíomh gréasáin na gCoimisinéirí.
RE: solrconfig.xml - configuration scope
Posted by "Cario, Elaine" <El...@wolterskluwer.com>.
I know this is an old post, but I've seen the same behavior as well, specifically in setting invariants. We had 2 cores with different schema/solrconfig, but they both had a (differently configured) request handler named /search. The invariants set in one core leached into requests for the other core. I never drilled down further to see if it was because of the matching request handler names, we just worked around the issue in some other way (which was a bit of a hack and we're working on a better solution for the original problem we were trying solve, in any case). This was with 4.10.
-----Original Message-----
From: Erick Erickson [mailto:erickerickson@gmail.com]
Sent: Tuesday, December 08, 2015 3:09 PM
To: solr-user <so...@lucene.apache.org>
Subject: Re: solrconfig.xml - configuration scope
What specifically are you seeing? Most things are per-core as you surmised.
There are a few things which, through interaction with Lucene global variables affect multiple cores, the one that comes to mind is maxBooleanClauses, where the value in the last core loaded "wins".
There might be some others though, that's the one that I remember.
What version of Solr are you running?
Best,
Erick
On Tue, Dec 8, 2015 at 9:52 AM, Fitzpatrick, Adrian <ad...@revenue.ie> wrote:
> Hi,
>
> This is probably a very basic question that has been asked many times before - apologies in advance if so!
>
> I'm looking to validate whether something I **think** I have observed when using Solr is a known behaviour:
>
> From my read of the docs etc. it was my understanding that
> solrconfig.xml was the configuration for a core, and that if I had
> multiple cores in my Solr server, each would have their own version of
> that file with their own settings. However, in practice, when working
> with such a multiple core setup, what I have observed suggests that
> some (perhaps many?) of the settings within solrconfig.xml can have a
> system-wide impact. I.e. I change a setting in core A and I see
> behaviour in other cores B,C which suggests they are obeying the
> changed value from the core A rather than the setting value from their
> own copy of solrconfig.xml
>
> So, as I said, main question is this known/expected behaviour, or am I imagining things! If the former, is there any documentation etc. that provides any clarification around how the configuration scope operates?
>
> Thanks,
>
> Adrian
>
> Please note that Revenue cannot guarantee that any personal and sensitive data, sent in plain text via standard email, is fully secure. Customers who choose to use this channel are deemed to have accepted any risk involved. The alternative communication methods offered by Revenue include standard post and the option to use our (encrypted) MyEnquiries service which is available within myAccount and ROS. You can register for either myAccount or ROS on the Revenue website.
>
> Tabhair faoi deara nach féidir leis na Coimisinéirí Ioncaim ráthaíocht a thabhairt go bhfuil aon sonraí pearsanta agus íogair a gcuirtear isteach i ngnáth-théacs trí r-phost caighdeánach go huile is go hiomlán slán. Meastar go nglacann custaiméirí a úsáideann an cainéal seo le haon riosca bainteach. I measc na modhanna cumarsáide eile atá ag na Coimisinéirí ná post caighdeánach agus an rogha ár seirbhís (criptithe) M'Fhiosruithe a úsáid, tá sí ar fáil laistigh de MoChúrsaí agus ROS. Is féidir leat clárú le haghaidh ceachtar MoChúrsaí nó ROS ar shuíomh gréasáin na gCoimisinéirí.
Re: solrconfig.xml - configuration scope
Posted by Erick Erickson <er...@gmail.com>.
What specifically are you seeing? Most things are per-core as you surmised.
There are a few things which, through interaction with Lucene global
variables affect multiple cores, the one that comes to mind is
maxBooleanClauses, where the value in the last core loaded "wins".
There might be some others though, that's the one that I remember.
What version of Solr are you running?
Best,
Erick
On Tue, Dec 8, 2015 at 9:52 AM, Fitzpatrick, Adrian <ad...@revenue.ie> wrote:
> Hi,
>
> This is probably a very basic question that has been asked many times before - apologies in advance if so!
>
> I'm looking to validate whether something I **think** I have observed when using Solr is a known behaviour:
>
> From my read of the docs etc. it was my understanding that solrconfig.xml was the configuration for a core, and that if I had multiple cores in my Solr server, each would have their own version of that file with their own settings. However, in practice, when working with such a multiple core setup, what I have observed suggests that some (perhaps many?) of the settings within solrconfig.xml can have a system-wide impact. I.e. I change a setting in core A and I see behaviour in other cores B,C which suggests they are obeying the changed value from the core A rather than the setting value from their own copy of solrconfig.xml
>
> So, as I said, main question is this known/expected behaviour, or am I imagining things! If the former, is there any documentation etc. that provides any clarification around how the configuration scope operates?
>
> Thanks,
>
> Adrian
>
> Please note that Revenue cannot guarantee that any personal and sensitive data, sent in plain text via standard email, is fully secure. Customers who choose to use this channel are deemed to have accepted any risk involved. The alternative communication methods offered by Revenue include standard post and the option to use our (encrypted) MyEnquiries service which is available within myAccount and ROS. You can register for either myAccount or ROS on the Revenue website.
>
> Tabhair faoi deara nach féidir leis na Coimisinéirí Ioncaim ráthaíocht a thabhairt go bhfuil aon sonraí pearsanta agus íogair a gcuirtear isteach i ngnáth-théacs trí r-phost caighdeánach go huile is go hiomlán slán. Meastar go nglacann custaiméirí a úsáideann an cainéal seo le haon riosca bainteach. I measc na modhanna cumarsáide eile atá ag na Coimisinéirí ná post caighdeánach agus an rogha ár seirbhís (criptithe) M'Fhiosruithe a úsáid, tá sí ar fáil laistigh de MoChúrsaí agus ROS. Is féidir leat clárú le haghaidh ceachtar MoChúrsaí nó ROS ar shuíomh gréasáin na gCoimisinéirí.