You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to user@syncope.apache.org by Andrea Patricelli <an...@apache.org> on 2018/02/13 14:36:57 UTC
Re: Issue SYNCOPE-1235 dynamic group memberships
Hi Mikael,
I made a check. I confirm you that there is a bug about dynamic
memberhsip conditions. But I've been experiencing a bit different
behavior: the dynamic membership conditions are voided after assigning
or linking the resource to the group.
I've *not* experienced the viceversa, i.e. your problem and what is
exposed in SYNCOPE-1235.
BTW I've opened [1].
Best regards,
Andrea
[1] https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SYNCOPE-1276
Il 12/02/2018 16:24, Mikael Ekblom ha scritto:
>
> Hi,
>
> Issue SYNCOPE-1235
>
> I’m sorry to be a party pooper, but this issue with disappearing
> dynamic group memberships happened to us now again when de unassigned
> an external resource from a group. Are you sure that it is 100 %
> fixed? The scenario was as before: unassign an external resource from
> the group-> no more dynamic memberships and the memberships also.
>
> Fortunately, this was for a smaller subproject, but this could
> potentially be disastrous for us if people suddenly get unassigned
> from groups and the resource assignments also disappears.
>
> This should be a clean 2.0.7-version that I’m testing it on.
>
> Regards,
>
> Mikael
>
> *Mikael Ekblom *
>
> IT-Service manager
>
> Arcada, IT
>
> Jan-Magnus Janssons plats 1,
>
> FIN-00560 Helsingfors,
>
> Finland
>
> TFn: +358 207 699 467
>
> Mobil: +358 207 699 467
>
> *From:*Francesco Chicchiriccò [mailto:ilgrosso@apache.org]
> *Sent:* keskiviikko 15. marraskuuta 2017 10.21
> *To:* user@syncope.apache.org
> *Subject:* Re: Question regarding resource assignment through groups
>
> Hi Mikael,
> bug confirmed:
>
> https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SYNCOPE-1235
>
> Thanks for reporting.
> Regards.
>
> On 07/11/2017 13:45, Mikael Ekblom wrote:
>
> Hi,
>
> Now I got it reproduced. I created a group arcadaTest and
> assigned this group to a resource, resource-testdb within your
> test environment. Everything went smooth. After that, I then went
> via the logical interface/user interface and performed an unlink
> of the assigned resource from the arcadaTest group. When I edited
> the group itself after that operation, I noticed that the dynamic
> rule was gone.
>
> Maybe I could see some logic to that, but then again maybe not…JI
> think that group membership dynamic rules should be preserved even
> though we are un-assigning a resource?
>
> Regards,
>
> Mikael
>
> *Mikael Ekblom *
>
> System developer
>
> Arcada, IT
>
> Jan-Magnus Janssons plats 1,
>
> FIN-00560 Helsingfors,
>
> Finland
>
> TFn: +358 207 699 467
>
> Mobil: +358 207 699 467
>
> *From:*Francesco Chicchiriccò [mailto:ilgrosso@apache.org]
> *Sent:* torstai 2. marraskuuta 2017 15.26
> *To:* user@syncope.apache.org <ma...@syncope.apache.org>
> *Subject:* Re: Question regarding resource assignment through groups
>
> On 01/11/2017 10:34, Mikael Ekblom wrote:
>
> Hi,
>
> We are quite close now to the actual deployment of our
> solution based on Syncope. It has been quite a search for the
> right implementations.
>
>
> Hi Mikael, nice to hear that.
>
> I'd recommend to stay in touch with upgrades and ensure to always
> run the latest 2.0.X version.
>
>
>
> Anyhow, I noticed that if you had assigned an external
> resource to a group for provision purposes and then removed
> this same resource again from the assigned group, then the
> dynamic rules for the group membership were also removed at
> the same time. We were quite surprised by this when we saw
> very different results between runs and noticed that well,
> users were not part of that group anymore and thus not
> assigned to the external resource as a consequence of that.
>
> Is this really part of the implementation as a reaction to the
> change of assigned external resources?
>
>
> Could you please summarize with a concrete example? Or, if
> possible, attempt to reproduce the problem via
>
> http://syncope-vm.apache.org:9080/syncope-console/
>
> ?
> Thanks.
> Regards.
>
> --
> Francesco Chicchiriccò
> Tirasa - Open Source Excellence
> http://www.tirasa.net/
> Member at The Apache Software Foundation
> Syncope, Cocoon, Olingo, CXF, OpenJPA, PonyMail
> http://home.apache.org/~ilgrosso/ <http://home.apache.org/%7Eilgrosso/>
--
Dott. Andrea Patricelli
Tel. +39 3204524292
Developer @ Tirasa S.r.l.
Viale D'Annunzio 267 - 65127 Pescara
Tel +39 0859116307 / FAX +39 0859111173
http://www.tirasa.net
Apache Syncope PMC Member
RE: Issue SYNCOPE-1235 dynamic group memberships
Posted by Mikael Ekblom <mi...@arcada.fi>.
Hi,
Now when you mention it, you are right! It is when you have a group with an already assigned external resource and link another external resource to the same group that the dynamic membership ruleset is voided.
So the scenario is different. OK, good to hear that you also confirmed the same bug.
Mikael Ekblom
IT-Service manager
Arcada, IT
Jan-Magnus Janssons plats 1,
FIN-00560 Helsingfors,
Finland
TFn: +358 207 699 467
Mobil: +358 207 699 467
From: Andrea Patricelli [mailto:andreapatricelli@apache.org]
Sent: tiistai 13. helmikuuta 2018 16.37
To: user@syncope.apache.org
Subject: Re: Issue SYNCOPE-1235 dynamic group memberships
Hi Mikael,
I made a check. I confirm you that there is a bug about dynamic memberhsip conditions. But I've been experiencing a bit different behavior: the dynamic membership conditions are voided after assigning or linking the resource to the group.
I've not experienced the viceversa, i.e. your problem and what is exposed in SYNCOPE-1235.
BTW I've opened [1].
Best regards,
Andrea
[1] https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SYNCOPE-1276
Il 12/02/2018 16:24, Mikael Ekblom ha scritto:
Hi,
Issue SYNCOPE-1235
I’m sorry to be a party pooper, but this issue with disappearing dynamic group memberships happened to us now again when de unassigned an external resource from a group. Are you sure that it is 100 % fixed? The scenario was as before: unassign an external resource from the group-> no more dynamic memberships and the memberships also.
Fortunately, this was for a smaller subproject, but this could potentially be disastrous for us if people suddenly get unassigned from groups and the resource assignments also disappears.
This should be a clean 2.0.7-version that I’m testing it on.
Regards,
Mikael
Mikael Ekblom
IT-Service manager
Arcada, IT
Jan-Magnus Janssons plats 1,
FIN-00560 Helsingfors,
Finland
TFn: +358 207 699 467
Mobil: +358 207 699 467
From: Francesco Chicchiriccò [mailto:ilgrosso@apache.org]
Sent: keskiviikko 15. marraskuuta 2017 10.21
To: user@syncope.apache.org<ma...@syncope.apache.org>
Subject: Re: Question regarding resource assignment through groups
Hi Mikael,
bug confirmed:
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SYNCOPE-1235
Thanks for reporting.
Regards.
On 07/11/2017 13:45, Mikael Ekblom wrote:
Hi,
Now I got it reproduced. I created a group arcadaTest and assigned this group to a resource, resource-testdb within your test environment. Everything went smooth. After that, I then went via the logical interface/user interface and performed an unlink of the assigned resource from the arcadaTest group. When I edited the group itself after that operation, I noticed that the dynamic rule was gone.
Maybe I could see some logic to that, but then again maybe not…☺ I think that group membership dynamic rules should be preserved even though we are un-assigning a resource?
Regards,
Mikael
Mikael Ekblom
System developer
Arcada, IT
Jan-Magnus Janssons plats 1,
FIN-00560 Helsingfors,
Finland
TFn: +358 207 699 467
Mobil: +358 207 699 467
From: Francesco Chicchiriccò [mailto:ilgrosso@apache.org]
Sent: torstai 2. marraskuuta 2017 15.26
To: user@syncope.apache.org<ma...@syncope.apache.org>
Subject: Re: Question regarding resource assignment through groups
On 01/11/2017 10:34, Mikael Ekblom wrote:
Hi,
We are quite close now to the actual deployment of our solution based on Syncope. It has been quite a search for the right implementations.
Hi Mikael, nice to hear that.
I'd recommend to stay in touch with upgrades and ensure to always run the latest 2.0.X version.
Anyhow, I noticed that if you had assigned an external resource to a group for provision purposes and then removed this same resource again from the assigned group, then the dynamic rules for the group membership were also removed at the same time. We were quite surprised by this when we saw very different results between runs and noticed that well, users were not part of that group anymore and thus not assigned to the external resource as a consequence of that.
Is this really part of the implementation as a reaction to the change of assigned external resources?
Could you please summarize with a concrete example? Or, if possible, attempt to reproduce the problem via
http://syncope-vm.apache.org:9080/syncope-console/
?
Thanks.
Regards.
--
Francesco Chicchiriccò
Tirasa - Open Source Excellence
http://www.tirasa.net/
Member at The Apache Software Foundation
Syncope, Cocoon, Olingo, CXF, OpenJPA, PonyMail
http://home.apache.org/~ilgrosso/<http://home.apache.org/%7Eilgrosso/>
--
Dott. Andrea Patricelli
Tel. +39 3204524292
Developer @ Tirasa S.r.l.
Viale D'Annunzio 267 - 65127 Pescara
Tel +39 0859116307 / FAX +39 0859111173
http://www.tirasa.net
Apache Syncope PMC Member