You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@camel.apache.org by dzielik1 <dz...@gmail.com> on 2017/07/06 17:58:36 UTC
Camel Hystrix rethrow exception in fallback
Hi,
I have route (pseudo cod):
from(direct:start)
.to("direct:a")
.process(Prepare response)
from(direct:a)
.doTry()
.process(...)
.to(callWebService)
.process(onWebServiceSuccess)
.doCatch()
.process(whenException)
now I try use Hystrix, so I made subflow (I wan't in hystrix only web
service, without .process(onWebServiceSuccess) execution) for line:
".to(callWebService)":
from(direct:a)
.doTry()
.process(...)
.to(direct:subflow)
.process(onWebServiceSuccess)
.doCatch()
.process(whenException)
from(direct:subflow)
.hystrix()
.to(callWebService)
.onFallback()
do what?
What can I do in onFallback() method?, because after onFallback(), subflow
(direct:subflow) ending, and next step is .process(onWebServiceSuccess) in
from(direct:a) flow, when there was an error and
.process(onWebServiceSuccess) can't execute.
I was trying throw exception in onFallback(), but then doCatch() in
(direct:a) don't catch me this exception:
from(direct:subflow)
.errorHandler(noErrorHandler()) //it's required here?
.hystrix()
.to(callWebService)
.onFallback()
.throwException(new RuntimeException)
Good solution will be execute code from .doCatch in .onFallback(), but then
I need stop parent flow: (direct:a), to don't execute
.process(onWebServiceSuccess), and continue execution in flow
(direct:start).
It's possible?
Also I was trying with .onException in parent flow: direct:a. Then, it catch
exception, thrown in (direct:subflow) onFallback(), don't execute
.process(onWebServiceSuccess), but after that, execution is stop,
.process(Prepare response) from (direct:start) not execute:
from(direct:a)
.onException(Exception.class)
.process(whenException)
.end()
.process(...)
.to(direct:subflow)
.process(onWebServiceSuccess)
from(direct:subflow)
.errorHandler(noErrorHandler())
.hystrix()
.to(callWebService)
.onFallback()
.throwException(new RuntimeException)
How can I resolve this problem?
Why exception thrown in onFallback not catched in parent try catch?
thanks, for help.
Daniel
--
View this message in context: http://camel.465427.n5.nabble.com/Camel-Hystrix-rethrow-exception-in-fallback-tp5806369.html
Sent from the Camel - Users mailing list archive at Nabble.com.
Re: Camel Hystrix rethrow exception in fallback
Posted by Claus Ibsen <cl...@gmail.com>.
If you want hystrix to fail with an exception then do not use onFallback
On Thu, Jul 6, 2017 at 7:58 PM, dzielik1 <dz...@gmail.com> wrote:
> Hi,
>
> I have route (pseudo cod):
>
> from(direct:start)
> .to("direct:a")
> .process(Prepare response)
>
> from(direct:a)
> .doTry()
> .process(...)
> .to(callWebService)
> .process(onWebServiceSuccess)
> .doCatch()
> .process(whenException)
>
> now I try use Hystrix, so I made subflow (I wan't in hystrix only web
> service, without .process(onWebServiceSuccess) execution) for line:
> ".to(callWebService)":
>
> from(direct:a)
> .doTry()
> .process(...)
> .to(direct:subflow)
> .process(onWebServiceSuccess)
> .doCatch()
> .process(whenException)
>
> from(direct:subflow)
> .hystrix()
> .to(callWebService)
> .onFallback()
> do what?
>
> What can I do in onFallback() method?, because after onFallback(), subflow
> (direct:subflow) ending, and next step is .process(onWebServiceSuccess) in
> from(direct:a) flow, when there was an error and
> .process(onWebServiceSuccess) can't execute.
>
> I was trying throw exception in onFallback(), but then doCatch() in
> (direct:a) don't catch me this exception:
> from(direct:subflow)
> .errorHandler(noErrorHandler()) //it's required here?
> .hystrix()
> .to(callWebService)
> .onFallback()
> .throwException(new RuntimeException)
>
> Good solution will be execute code from .doCatch in .onFallback(), but then
> I need stop parent flow: (direct:a), to don't execute
> .process(onWebServiceSuccess), and continue execution in flow
> (direct:start).
>
> It's possible?
>
> Also I was trying with .onException in parent flow: direct:a. Then, it catch
> exception, thrown in (direct:subflow) onFallback(), don't execute
> .process(onWebServiceSuccess), but after that, execution is stop,
> .process(Prepare response) from (direct:start) not execute:
>
> from(direct:a)
> .onException(Exception.class)
> .process(whenException)
> .end()
> .process(...)
> .to(direct:subflow)
> .process(onWebServiceSuccess)
>
> from(direct:subflow)
> .errorHandler(noErrorHandler())
> .hystrix()
> .to(callWebService)
> .onFallback()
> .throwException(new RuntimeException)
>
> How can I resolve this problem?
> Why exception thrown in onFallback not catched in parent try catch?
>
> thanks, for help.
> Daniel
>
>
>
> --
> View this message in context: http://camel.465427.n5.nabble.com/Camel-Hystrix-rethrow-exception-in-fallback-tp5806369.html
> Sent from the Camel - Users mailing list archive at Nabble.com.
--
Claus Ibsen
-----------------
http://davsclaus.com @davsclaus
Camel in Action 2: https://www.manning.com/ibsen2