You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to solr-user@lucene.apache.org by Ian Rose <ia...@fullstory.com> on 2015/04/09 05:18:57 UTC

Help understanding addreplica error message re: maxShardsPerNode

On my local machine I have the following test setup:

* 2 "nodes" (JVMs)
* 1 collection named "testdrive", that was originally created with
numShards=1 and maxShardsPerNode=1.
* After a series of SPLITSHARD commands, I now have 4 shards, as follows:

testdrive_shard1_0_0_replica1 (L) Active 115
testdrive_shard1_0_1_replica1 (L) Active 0
testdrive_shard1_1_0_replica1 (L) Active 5
testdrive_shard1_1_1_replica1 (L) Active 88

The number in the last column is the number of documents.  The 4 shards are
all on the same node; the second node holds nothing for this collection.

Already, this situation is a little strange because I have 4 shards on one
node, despite the fact that maxShardsPerNode is 1.  My guess is that
SPLITSHARD ignores the maxShardsPerNode value - is that right?

Now, if I issue an ADDREPLICA command
with collection=testdrive&shard=shard1_0_0, I get the following error:

"Cannot create shards testdrive. Value of maxShardsPerNode is 1, and the
number of live nodes is 2. This allows a maximum of 2 to be created. Value
of numShards is 4 and value of replicationFactor is 1. This requires 4
shards to be created (higher than the allowed number)"

I don't totally understand this.

Re: Help understanding addreplica error message re: maxShardsPerNode

Posted by Ian Rose <ia...@fullstory.com>.
Wups - sorry folks, I send this prematurely.  After typing this out I think
I have it figured out - although SPLITSHARD ignores maxShardsPerNode,
ADDREPLICA does not.  So ADDREPLICA fails because I already have too many
shards on a single node.

On Wed, Apr 8, 2015 at 11:18 PM, Ian Rose <ia...@fullstory.com> wrote:

> On my local machine I have the following test setup:
>
> * 2 "nodes" (JVMs)
> * 1 collection named "testdrive", that was originally created with
> numShards=1 and maxShardsPerNode=1.
> * After a series of SPLITSHARD commands, I now have 4 shards, as follows:
>
> testdrive_shard1_0_0_replica1 (L) Active 115
> testdrive_shard1_0_1_replica1 (L) Active 0
> testdrive_shard1_1_0_replica1 (L) Active 5
> testdrive_shard1_1_1_replica1 (L) Active 88
>
> The number in the last column is the number of documents.  The 4 shards
> are all on the same node; the second node holds nothing for this collection.
>
> Already, this situation is a little strange because I have 4 shards on one
> node, despite the fact that maxShardsPerNode is 1.  My guess is that
> SPLITSHARD ignores the maxShardsPerNode value - is that right?
>
> Now, if I issue an ADDREPLICA command
> with collection=testdrive&shard=shard1_0_0, I get the following error:
>
> "Cannot create shards testdrive. Value of maxShardsPerNode is 1, and the
> number of live nodes is 2. This allows a maximum of 2 to be created. Value
> of numShards is 4 and value of replicationFactor is 1. This requires 4
> shards to be created (higher than the allowed number)"
>
> I don't totally understand this.
>
>
>