RE: proposed license - some questions

[Leo Simons <le...@apache.org>]

(modified repost, some answers figured out already)

Hi all!

I have some questions after reading

http://www.apache.org/licenses/proposed/

...my guess is that they'll all be FAQs...

Goals
-----
 > 4. Compatible with other licenses

Q: The big question of course: is this new license LPGL and/or 
GPL-compatible? Has the FSF been asked to comment on that yet? Have they 
made any kind of statement? Will there be?

A: Eben Moglen has submitted some comments on the draft on behalf of the 
FSF. The FSF believes the current section 5 is incompatible with the 
GPL, but there is some work being done on that section so that might be 
fixed. Furthermore, they've indicated they'll be taking (further) 
compatibility between ASL and GPL into account while drafting GPL 
version 3. The complete message is at:

http://nagoya.apache.org/eyebrowse/ReadMsg?listName=license@apache.org&msgNo=69

License
-------
 >   4. Contributor Grant of License. Subject to the terms and conditions
 >      of this License, each Contributor hereby grants to You:

Q: IIUC, the current license is an agreement between the ASF and "the 
rest of the world". This seems like an agreement between Contributors 
and "the rest of the world". Doesn't that affect the ability of the ASF 
to protect its members from being sued? If so, how?

A: none yet.

 >     C. A Contribution is "submitted" when any form of electronic,
 >     verbal, or written communication is sent to the Licensor,
 >     including but not limited to communication on electronic mailing
 >     lists, source code control systems, and issue tracking systems
 >     that are managed by, or on behalf of, the Licensor for the purpose
 >     of discussing and improving the Work, but excluding communication
 >     that is conspicuously marked or otherwise designated in writing by
 >     the Contributor as "Not a Contribution."

Q: I wonder...what if a contributor sends a patch to a committer via 
private e-mail, or posts it in a comment on a weblog, or something 
similar? Does this clause mean that we should be avoiding such things?

A: yes.

 >      (c) You must cause any modified files to carry prominent notices
 >          stating that You changed the files.

Q: IIUC this means that if you fork source code and change it, there 
should be a statement like "This file modified by Bla-Blah, Inc. from 
the ASF ones". Perhaps it would be good to have an example of a 
"prominent notice" in the appendix?

A: none yet.

Q: Also, does this mean that any change committed to the ASF CVS must 
include notices like this? That seems like a nightmare to ensure!

A: yes, it does.

Q: Would a cvs-generated changelog be appropriate?

A: none yet.

 >     You may add Your own copyright statement to such modifications and
 >     may provide (sublicense) additional or different license terms and
 >     conditions for use, reproduction, distribution or further
 >     modification of Your modifications, or for the Derivative Work as
 >     a whole, provided that the sublicense complies with the conditions
 >     stated in this License.

Q: an example of this would also be nice. I believe this says I may copy 
the apache license, change its name, add a few clauses about limiting 
distribution outside the US (for example), assume liability, call it the 
"Bla-Bla, Inc. Open Source License", and distribute ASF-created code 
under that license. Is that correct?

A: Nope. this says that you may add a copyright notice and additional 
license terms to the modified files, for example "This changed file 
copyright Leo Simons and licensed under the GPL". That does not mean you 
have the right to modify the Apache license itself. That's not necessary 
for this purpose. You can include your own license document and refer to 
the Apache license in there.



thanks!


- Leo Simons



---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@avalon.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@avalon.apache.org

Re: proposed license - some questions

[Leo Simons <le...@apache.org>]

please ignore, wrong list! Aargh!

Leo Simons wrote: <snip/>



---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@avalon.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@avalon.apache.org