You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@directory.apache.org by Trustin Lee <tr...@gmail.com> on 2005/10/13 17:32:07 UTC

Re: Adding a new Project on Jakarta

Hello Joao,

2005/10/13, jlopes@br.ibm.com <jl...@br.ibm.com>:
>
> The JFTP4I is a new idea for the concept of using FTP for integration
> purposes. Here in Brasil (and i think very much in the rest of the world),
> all the legacy systems are basically using FTP as a way of integrating
> different platforms running under TCP/IP. Example: we have a lot of cases
> of programs running in the mainframe that are actually using FTP to
> transmit data to the lower-platform. The JFTP4I is actually an application
> server that can support a number of deployed application inside the FTP
> engine. A general flow will be: The user(system) makes a put (or read)
> file request to the JFTP4I, the FTP engine then recognizes (using the XML
> configuration file) the actual FTPAction to be executed, and then
> delegates the flow to the right method inside the action - The framework
> uses the PODA/MVC II patterns, and is very similar to the Jakarta Struts
> framework (request -> controller -> Action). This framework can do a lot
> of things, like generate files dinamically (files that do not actually
> exist on disk, files that are created dinamically), implement personalized
> responses between systems, manage a secure exchange of files using
> detailed transactions, trace, and so forth.


Sounds very interesting and it is similar to what was in our MINA roadmap.
MINA project team will provide protocol handlers for well-known protocols
such FTP, HTTP, and SMTP on top of MINA. I guess your team has implemented
it without any network framework. It could be much better if we cooperate.
And perhaps we could cooperate with 'ftpserver' team who is already in
incubation.

Please take a look around MINA web site:

http://directory.apache.org/subprojects/network/

'Getting Started' section will provide you enough information. It would be
great if you let me know what you think.

Cheers,
Trustin
--
what we call human nature is actually human habit
--
http://gleamynode.net/

Re: Adding a new Project on Jakarta

Posted by Donald <fl...@gmail.com>.
Sorry,I don't know what's jason?
Is it a JBI implement?

2005/10/17, Trustin Lee <tr...@gmail.com>:
> Hi Donald,
>
> 2005/10/14, Donald <fl...@gmail.com>:
> > Sounds great!
> > Can we implement a JBI spec on the top of MINA?
> > I think MINA has a good foundation for it.
>
> Yes, that's also possible.  What I have in my mind is to implement
> Jason-based filter first to gain maximum benefit in short term.  WDYT?
>
> Trustin
> --
> what we call human nature is actually human habit
> --
> http://gleamynode.net/

Re: Adding a new Project on Jakarta

Posted by Trustin Lee <tr...@gmail.com>.
Hi Donald,

2005/10/14, Donald <fl...@gmail.com>:
>
> Sounds great!
> Can we implement a JBI spec on the top of MINA?
> I think MINA has a good foundation for it.


Yes, that's also possible. What I have in my mind is to implement
Jason-based filter first to gain maximum benefit in short term. WDYT?

Trustin
--
what we call human nature is actually human habit
--
http://gleamynode.net/

Re: Adding a new Project on Jakarta

Posted by Donald <fl...@gmail.com>.
Sounds great!
Can we implement a JBI spec on the top of MINA?
I think MINA has a good foundation for it.

2005/10/14, jlopes@br.ibm.com <jl...@br.ibm.com>:
>
>
> >Hello Joao,
>
> >2005/10/13, jlopes@br.ibm.com <jl...@br.ibm.com>:
> >>
> >> The JFTP4I is a new idea for the concept of using FTP for integration
> >> purposes. Here in Brasil (and i think very much in the rest of the
> world),
> >> all the legacy systems are basically using FTP as a way of integrating
> >> different platforms running under TCP/IP. Example: we have a lot of cases
> >> of programs running in the mainframe that are actually using FTP to
> >> transmit data to the lower-platform. The JFTP4I is actually an
> application
> >> server that can support a number of deployed application inside the FTP
> >> engine. A general flow will be: The user(system) makes a put (or read)
> >> file request to the JFTP4I, the FTP engine then recognizes (using the XML
> >> configuration file) the actual FTPAction to be executed, and then
> >> delegates the flow to the right method inside the action - The framework
> >> uses the PODA/MVC II patterns, and is very similar to the Jakarta Struts
> >> framework (request -> controller -> Action). This framework can do a lot
> >> of things, like generate files dinamically (files that do not actually
> >> exist on disk, files that are created dinamically), implement
> personalized
> >> responses between systems, manage a secure exchange of files using
> >> detailed transactions, trace, and so forth.
> >
> >
> >Sounds very interesting and it is similar to what was in our MINA roadmap.
> >MINA project team will provide protocol handlers for well-known protocols
> >such FTP, HTTP, and SMTP on top of MINA. I guess your team has implemented
> >it without any network framework. It could be much better if we cooperate.
> >And perhaps we could cooperate with 'ftpserver' team who is already in
> >incubation.
>
> I love the idea, how can we organize this? Yes (kkkk) we had implemented the
> standart FTP commands :-P(PI and DTP) defined in the rfc959, just i
> nightmare to understand and use. Maybe we can join forces, why not.
>
>         []s, João
>
>
> >Please take a look around MINA web site:
>
> >http://directory.apache.org/subprojects/network/
>
> >'Getting Started' section will provide you enough information. It would be
> >great if you let me know what you think.
>
> >Cheers,
> >Trustin
> >--
> >what we call human nature is actually human habit
> >--
> >http://gleamynode.net/
>
>

Re: Adding a new Project on Jakarta

Posted by jl...@br.ibm.com.
>On 10/17/05, Trustin Lee <tr...@gmail.com> wrote:
>:
>> Hi Joao
>>
>> 2005/10/14, jlopes@br.ibm.com <jl...@br.ibm.com>:
>> >
>> > >Sounds very interesting and it is similar to what was in our MINA
>> > roadmap.
>> > >MINA project team will provide protocol handlers for well-known
>> protocols
>> > >such FTP, HTTP, and SMTP on top of MINA. I guess your team has
>> > implemented
>> > >it without any network framework. It could be much better if we
>> > cooperate.
>> > >And perhaps we could cooperate with 'ftpserver' team who is already 
in
>> > >incubation.
>> >
>> > I love the idea, how can we organize this? Yes (kkkk) we had 
implemented
>> > the standart FTP commands :-P(PI and DTP) defined in the rfc959, just 
i
>> > nightmare to understand and use. Maybe we can join forces, why not.
>>
>>
>> OK, it sounds like you're interested enough. Then what about 
contributing
>> your team's work by providing us some patches? It will help us to
>> considering letting you and your team in to us. WDYT, Noel? Would there 
be
>> any issue with doing this?
>>

>IMO patches from outside developers really need to original contributions 
of
>a manageable size. contributing an existing codebase through patches 
makes
>it hard to trace the origins of the code and may lead to legal doubts 
over
>the code. if ftpserver is interested in the code, then this needs to be
>imported corrected by obtaining the C/CLAs and so on.

>however, without a community to support and develop the code, large code
>contributions are just dead burdens. with a healthy community, it's easy 
to
>rewrite bad code whereas even if a project has good code, a unhealthy
>community will drag it down. a healthy community can usually add original
>code quicker that it can assimilate code without a community. so, it's
>usually best to try to import the community with the code.

>João's project is already at sourceforce so the ftpserver folks can 
easily
>take a look at what's already there. after a little discussion, it's 
usually
>pretty easy to work out whether the communities are congurent enough to
>successfully merge so my recommendation would be for João and the rest of
>the developers to hop over to the ftpserver lists and continue the
>discussion there. if things look positive, then the ftpserver project 
could
>let us know and then the required documents for the code and for the
>communities could be done together.

>- robert

Hello Robert,

        i agree with you, our intentions are to add something, to give 
some values for the common static/stateless FTP Servers that already 
exists in the market. I, my self, and my friends have NO intentions on 
corrupting (or drag it down) good things that may already exists. Even 
because, we wouldn´t start this if that was the reason (just to much 
trouble and no gain). As i said, we are only hoping to aggregate something 
that we understand as a need and as a value to the open source community, 
just that.

        []s,

        João

Re: Adding a new Project on Jakarta

Posted by jl...@br.ibm.com.
>On 10/17/05, Trustin Lee <tr...@gmail.com> wrote:
>:
>> Hi Joao
>>
>> 2005/10/14, jlopes@br.ibm.com <jl...@br.ibm.com>:
>> >
>> > >Sounds very interesting and it is similar to what was in our MINA
>> > roadmap.
>> > >MINA project team will provide protocol handlers for well-known
>> protocols
>> > >such FTP, HTTP, and SMTP on top of MINA. I guess your team has
>> > implemented
>> > >it without any network framework. It could be much better if we
>> > cooperate.
>> > >And perhaps we could cooperate with 'ftpserver' team who is already 
in
>> > >incubation.
>> >
>> > I love the idea, how can we organize this? Yes (kkkk) we had 
implemented
>> > the standart FTP commands :-P(PI and DTP) defined in the rfc959, just 
i
>> > nightmare to understand and use. Maybe we can join forces, why not.
>>
>>
>> OK, it sounds like you're interested enough. Then what about 
contributing
>> your team's work by providing us some patches? It will help us to
>> considering letting you and your team in to us. WDYT, Noel? Would there 
be
>> any issue with doing this?
>>

>IMO patches from outside developers really need to original contributions 
of
>a manageable size. contributing an existing codebase through patches 
makes
>it hard to trace the origins of the code and may lead to legal doubts 
over
>the code. if ftpserver is interested in the code, then this needs to be
>imported corrected by obtaining the C/CLAs and so on.

>however, without a community to support and develop the code, large code
>contributions are just dead burdens. with a healthy community, it's easy 
to
>rewrite bad code whereas even if a project has good code, a unhealthy
>community will drag it down. a healthy community can usually add original
>code quicker that it can assimilate code without a community. so, it's
>usually best to try to import the community with the code.

>João's project is already at sourceforce so the ftpserver folks can 
easily
>take a look at what's already there. after a little discussion, it's 
usually
>pretty easy to work out whether the communities are congurent enough to
>successfully merge so my recommendation would be for João and the rest of
>the developers to hop over to the ftpserver lists and continue the
>discussion there. if things look positive, then the ftpserver project 
could
>let us know and then the required documents for the code and for the
>communities could be done together.

>- robert

Hello Robert,

        i agree with you, our intentions are to add something, to give 
some values for the common static/stateless FTP Servers that already 
exists in the market. I, my self, and my friends have NO intentions on 
corrupting (or drag it down) good things that may already exists. Even 
because, we wouldn´t start this if that was the reason (just to much 
trouble and no gain). As i said, we are only hoping to aggregate something 
that we understand as a need and as a value to the open source community, 
just that.

        []s,

        João

Re: Adding a new Project on Jakarta

Posted by robert burrell donkin <ro...@gmail.com>.
On 10/17/05, Trustin Lee <tr...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> Hi Joao
>
> 2005/10/14, jlopes@br.ibm.com <jl...@br.ibm.com>:
> >
> > >Sounds very interesting and it is similar to what was in our MINA
> > roadmap.
> > >MINA project team will provide protocol handlers for well-known
> protocols
> > >such FTP, HTTP, and SMTP on top of MINA. I guess your team has
> > implemented
> > >it without any network framework. It could be much better if we
> > cooperate.
> > >And perhaps we could cooperate with 'ftpserver' team who is already in
> > >incubation.
> >
> > I love the idea, how can we organize this? Yes (kkkk) we had implemented
> > the standart FTP commands :-P(PI and DTP) defined in the rfc959, just i
> > nightmare to understand and use. Maybe we can join forces, why not.
>
>
> OK, it sounds like you're interested enough. Then what about contributing
> your team's work by providing us some patches? It will help us to
> considering letting you and your team in to us. WDYT, Noel? Would there be
> any issue with doing this?
>

IMO patches from outside developers really need to original contributions of
a manageable size. contributing an existing codebase through patches makes
it hard to trace the origins of the code and may lead to legal doubts over
the code. if ftpserver is interested in the code, then this needs to be
imported corrected by obtaining the C/CLAs and so on.

however, without a community to support and develop the code, large code
contributions are just dead burdens. with a healthy community, it's easy to
rewrite bad code whereas even if a project has good code, a unhealthy
community will drag it down. a healthy community can usually add original
code quicker that it can assimilate code without a community. so, it's
usually best to try to import the community with the code.

João's project is already at sourceforce so the ftpserver folks can easily
take a look at what's already there. after a little discussion, it's usually
pretty easy to work out whether the communities are congurent enough to
successfully merge so my recommendation would be for João and the rest of
the developers to hop over to the ftpserver lists and continue the
discussion there. if things look positive, then the ftpserver project could
let us know and then the required documents for the code and for the
communities could be done together.

- robert

Re: Adding a new Project on Jakarta

Posted by jl...@br.ibm.com.
>Hi Joao

>>2005/10/14, jlopes@br.ibm.com <jl...@br.ibm.com>:
>>
>> >Sounds very interesting and it is similar to what was in our MINA
>> roadmap.
>> >MINA project team will provide protocol handlers for well-known 
protocols
>> >such FTP, HTTP, and SMTP on top of MINA. I guess your team has
>> implemented
>> >it without any network framework. It could be much better if we
>> cooperate.
>> >And perhaps we could cooperate with 'ftpserver' team who is already in
>> >incubation.
>>
>> I love the idea, how can we organize this? Yes (kkkk) we had 
implemented
>> the standart FTP commands :-P(PI and DTP) defined in the rfc959, just i
>> nightmare to understand and use. Maybe we can join forces, why not.

...

>OK, it sounds like you're interested enough. Then what about contributing
>your team's work by providing us some patches? It will help us to
>considering letting you and your team in to us. WDYT, Noel? Would there 
be
>any issue with doing this?

...

>Hi,

>   We have one API set called ftplet bundled with the
>Incubator FTPServer. The basic objective is to
>integrate other applications with the FTP server. We
>will be more than happy to work together.

>Thanks,
>Rana Bhattacharyya

...

Hi to you both (Rana, Trustin),

        Okey, i think that a good way to start, is to you guys examine the 
code that we have developed (sorry, part of the documentation are still in 
Português (Portuguese, we are working on that), but we can understand each 
other through the code - kkkk), then we can start from there (How we can 
merge the ideas and so forth). I will enter the FTPServer mailling list, 
because i think it's appropriate from this point to continue discussing 
the jftp4i from there.

        []s,    :-)

        João

Re: Adding a new Project on Jakarta

Posted by Trustin Lee <tr...@gmail.com>.
Hi Joao

2005/10/14, jlopes@br.ibm.com <jl...@br.ibm.com>:
>
> >Sounds very interesting and it is similar to what was in our MINA
> roadmap.
> >MINA project team will provide protocol handlers for well-known protocols
> >such FTP, HTTP, and SMTP on top of MINA. I guess your team has
> implemented
> >it without any network framework. It could be much better if we
> cooperate.
> >And perhaps we could cooperate with 'ftpserver' team who is already in
> >incubation.
>
> I love the idea, how can we organize this? Yes (kkkk) we had implemented
> the standart FTP commands :-P(PI and DTP) defined in the rfc959, just i
> nightmare to understand and use. Maybe we can join forces, why not.


OK, it sounds like you're interested enough. Then what about contributing
your team's work by providing us some patches? It will help us to
considering letting you and your team in to us. WDYT, Noel? Would there be
any issue with doing this?

Trustin
--
what we call human nature is actually human habit
--
http://gleamynode.net/

Re: Adding a new Project on Jakarta

Posted by jl...@br.ibm.com.
>Hello Joao,

>2005/10/13, jlopes@br.ibm.com <jl...@br.ibm.com>:
>>
>> The JFTP4I is a new idea for the concept of using FTP for integration
>> purposes. Here in Brasil (and i think very much in the rest of the 
world),
>> all the legacy systems are basically using FTP as a way of integrating
>> different platforms running under TCP/IP. Example: we have a lot of 
cases
>> of programs running in the mainframe that are actually using FTP to
>> transmit data to the lower-platform. The JFTP4I is actually an 
application
>> server that can support a number of deployed application inside the FTP
>> engine. A general flow will be: The user(system) makes a put (or read)
>> file request to the JFTP4I, the FTP engine then recognizes (using the 
XML
>> configuration file) the actual FTPAction to be executed, and then
>> delegates the flow to the right method inside the action - The 
framework
>> uses the PODA/MVC II patterns, and is very similar to the Jakarta 
Struts
>> framework (request -> controller -> Action). This framework can do a 
lot
>> of things, like generate files dinamically (files that do not actually
>> exist on disk, files that are created dinamically), implement 
personalized
>> responses between systems, manage a secure exchange of files using
>> detailed transactions, trace, and so forth.
>
>
>Sounds very interesting and it is similar to what was in our MINA 
roadmap.
>MINA project team will provide protocol handlers for well-known protocols
>such FTP, HTTP, and SMTP on top of MINA. I guess your team has 
implemented
>it without any network framework. It could be much better if we 
cooperate.
>And perhaps we could cooperate with 'ftpserver' team who is already in
>incubation.

I love the idea, how can we organize this? Yes (kkkk) we had implemented 
the standart FTP commands :-P(PI and DTP) defined in the rfc959, just i 
nightmare to understand and use. Maybe we can join forces, why not.

        []s, João

>Please take a look around MINA web site:

>http://directory.apache.org/subprojects/network/

>'Getting Started' section will provide you enough information. It would 
be
>great if you let me know what you think.

>Cheers,
>Trustin
>--
>what we call human nature is actually human habit
>--
>http://gleamynode.net/


Re: Adding a new Project on Jakarta

Posted by jl...@br.ibm.com.
>Hello Joao,

>2005/10/13, jlopes@br.ibm.com <jl...@br.ibm.com>:
>>
>> The JFTP4I is a new idea for the concept of using FTP for integration
>> purposes. Here in Brasil (and i think very much in the rest of the 
world),
>> all the legacy systems are basically using FTP as a way of integrating
>> different platforms running under TCP/IP. Example: we have a lot of 
cases
>> of programs running in the mainframe that are actually using FTP to
>> transmit data to the lower-platform. The JFTP4I is actually an 
application
>> server that can support a number of deployed application inside the FTP
>> engine. A general flow will be: The user(system) makes a put (or read)
>> file request to the JFTP4I, the FTP engine then recognizes (using the 
XML
>> configuration file) the actual FTPAction to be executed, and then
>> delegates the flow to the right method inside the action - The 
framework
>> uses the PODA/MVC II patterns, and is very similar to the Jakarta 
Struts
>> framework (request -> controller -> Action). This framework can do a 
lot
>> of things, like generate files dinamically (files that do not actually
>> exist on disk, files that are created dinamically), implement 
personalized
>> responses between systems, manage a secure exchange of files using
>> detailed transactions, trace, and so forth.
>
>
>Sounds very interesting and it is similar to what was in our MINA 
roadmap.
>MINA project team will provide protocol handlers for well-known protocols
>such FTP, HTTP, and SMTP on top of MINA. I guess your team has 
implemented
>it without any network framework. It could be much better if we 
cooperate.
>And perhaps we could cooperate with 'ftpserver' team who is already in
>incubation.

I love the idea, how can we organize this? Yes (kkkk) we had implemented 
the standart FTP commands :-P(PI and DTP) defined in the rfc959, just i 
nightmare to understand and use. Maybe we can join forces, why not.

        []s, João

>Please take a look around MINA web site:

>http://directory.apache.org/subprojects/network/

>'Getting Started' section will provide you enough information. It would 
be
>great if you let me know what you think.

>Cheers,
>Trustin
>--
>what we call human nature is actually human habit
>--
>http://gleamynode.net/