You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@cloudstack.apache.org by Chip Childers <ch...@sungard.com> on 2012/08/10 15:09:06 UTC
[ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
Specific individuals that have open questions to them below: Prachi,
Frank, Ewan
Updated RAT report:
https://github.com/chipchilders/asf_cloudstack_RAT_results/blob/master/_all.txt?raw=true
Outstanding Issues:
EC2 WSDL files:
Prachi, can you remove these 2 as well?
incubator-cloudstack/awsapi/resource/AmazonEC2/AmazonEC2.wsdl
incubator-cloudstack/awsapi/resource/AmazonEC2/services.xml
XenServerJava:
Ewan noted that the Citrix team is currently working to get this
re-licensed. Alex confirmed that Ewan is working on this. Ewan - any
update on progress?
incubator-cloudstack/deps/XenServerJava/GPL-2
incubator-cloudstack/deps/XenServerJava/Makefile
Patches in the OVM folder:
Pending Frank. Any updates Frank?:
incubator-cloudstack/plugins/hypervisors/ovm/scripts/vm/hypervisor/ovm/Fixget_storage_reposExceptionDueToWrongReturnValueCheck.patch
incubator-cloudstack/plugins/hypervisors/ovm/scripts/vm/hypervisor/ovm/OvmDontTouchOCFS2ClusterWhenAgentStart.patch
incubator-cloudstack/plugins/hypervisors/ovm/scripts/vm/hypervisor/ovm/OvmPatch.patch
JQuery, FLOT, QUnit:
We need to include the various JQuery components in the
appropriate top level LICENSE and NOTICE files. I own this still (did
not complete yesterday):
incubator-cloudstack/console-proxy/js/jquery.js
incubator-cloudstack/ui/lib/jquery*
incubator-cloudstack/ui/lib/flot/*
incubator-cloudstack/ui/lib/jquery-ui/*
incubator-cloudstack/ui/lib/qunit/*
Documentation folder:
Joe's making great progress on this folder. Thanks Joe!
incubator-cloudstack/docs/*
Patches folder:
There is an ongoing thread about this topic, with David driving it.
incubator-cloudstack/patches/systemvm/debian/*
Known Exceptions (items that we know can't have a license header, and
don't need one):
Deb files:
incubator-cloudstack/awsapi/packages/config/debian/control
incubator-cloudstack/awsapi/packages/config/debian/rules
incubator-cloudstack/debian/compat
incubator-cloudstack/debian/control
incubator-cloudstack/debian/dirs
incubator-cloudstack/debian/rules
Certificates and keys:
incubator-cloudstack/console-proxy/certs/localhost.crt
incubator-cloudstack/console-proxy/certs/localhost.key
incubator-cloudstack/console-proxy/certs/realhostip.crt
incubator-cloudstack/console-proxy/certs/realhostip.csr
incubator-cloudstack/console-proxy/certs/realhostip.key
incubator-cloudstack/scripts/vm/systemvm/id_rsa.cloud
WAF scripts:
Added to the LICENSE and NOTICE files.
incubator-cloudstack/waf
incubator-cloudstack/awsapi/waf
SLF4J:
This is listed in the NOTICE and LICENSE files.
incubator-cloudstack/deps/awsapi-lib/rampart-lib/slf4j-api-LICENSE.txt
incubator-cloudstack/deps/awsapi-lib/rampart-lib/slf4j-jdk14-LICENSE.txt
Re: [ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
Posted by Chip Childers <ch...@sungard.com>.
On Fri, Aug 10, 2012 at 3:34 PM, Ewan Mellor <Ew...@eu.citrix.com> wrote:
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: Chip Childers [mailto:chip.childers@sungard.com]
>>
>> [Snip]
>>
>> >
>> > At present it isn't, (Xenserverjava is copyleft) and no one from
>> > upstream XenServer is answering my emails regarding the status of
>> > their proposed relicensing.
>> >
>> > --David
>> >
>>
>> Ewan,
>>
>> You've stated previously that you were working on this, and we've been
>> anxiously waiting to hear back from you. Have you been able to get
>> anywhere with the XenServer team?
>>
>> Even an indication that they are considering the change would help
>> immensely!
>
> Yes, I've just had that confirmation, actually. They have approval to switch to BSD and to republish the old SDK for us. So we'll be able to use the same code that we're using now, just with a new license. We're good to go.
>
> Ewan.
>
>
Very cool! What's the schedule for re-publishing?
-chip
RE: [ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
Posted by Ewan Mellor <Ew...@eu.citrix.com>.
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Chip Childers [mailto:chip.childers@sungard.com]
>
> [Snip]
>
> >
> > At present it isn't, (Xenserverjava is copyleft) and no one from
> > upstream XenServer is answering my emails regarding the status of
> > their proposed relicensing.
> >
> > --David
> >
>
> Ewan,
>
> You've stated previously that you were working on this, and we've been
> anxiously waiting to hear back from you. Have you been able to get
> anywhere with the XenServer team?
>
> Even an indication that they are considering the change would help
> immensely!
Yes, I've just had that confirmation, actually. They have approval to switch to BSD and to republish the old SDK for us. So we'll be able to use the same code that we're using now, just with a new license. We're good to go.
Ewan.
Re: [ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
Posted by Chip Childers <ch...@sungard.com>.
On Aug 10, 2012, at 3:04 PM, David Nalley <da...@gnsa.us> wrote:
> On Fri, Aug 10, 2012 at 12:01 PM, Alex Huang <Al...@citrix.com> wrote:
>>
>>
>>> -----Original Message-----
>>> From: David Nalley [mailto:david@gnsa.us]
>>> Sent: Friday, August 10, 2012 7:12 AM
>>> To: cloudstack-dev@incubator.apache.org
>>> Cc: Chip Childers (chip.childers@sungard.com); Ewan Mellor; Alex Huang
>>> Subject: Re: [ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
>>>
>>>> For XenServerJava, my suggestion is this. The reason why we modify it is to
>>> put in client timeouts so that CloudStack is decoupled from Xapi when Xapi
>>> behaves badly. For normal operations, it's not necessary. We should just
>>> remove the directory and use the one from XenServer and force our changes
>>> to be upstreamed to XenServer. Is the XenServer java client stub license
>>> compatible with apache?
>>>>
>>>
>>> I tried this with the native xenserverjava packages (both 5.6.100 and
>>> 6.0) and it breaks the build.
>>
>> If it's worthwhile (library license is compatible), I'll spend some time tonight to fix it.
>>
>> --Alex
>>>
>>> --David
>
> At present it isn't, (Xenserverjava is copyleft) and no one from
> upstream XenServer is answering my emails regarding the status of
> their proposed relicensing.
>
> --David
>
Ewan,
You've stated previously that you were working on this, and we've been
anxiously waiting to hear back from you. Have you been able to get
anywhere with the XenServer team?
Even an indication that they are considering the change would help immensely!
Re: [ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
Posted by David Nalley <da...@gnsa.us>.
On Fri, Aug 10, 2012 at 12:01 PM, Alex Huang <Al...@citrix.com> wrote:
>
>
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: David Nalley [mailto:david@gnsa.us]
>> Sent: Friday, August 10, 2012 7:12 AM
>> To: cloudstack-dev@incubator.apache.org
>> Cc: Chip Childers (chip.childers@sungard.com); Ewan Mellor; Alex Huang
>> Subject: Re: [ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
>>
>> > For XenServerJava, my suggestion is this. The reason why we modify it is to
>> put in client timeouts so that CloudStack is decoupled from Xapi when Xapi
>> behaves badly. For normal operations, it's not necessary. We should just
>> remove the directory and use the one from XenServer and force our changes
>> to be upstreamed to XenServer. Is the XenServer java client stub license
>> compatible with apache?
>> >
>>
>> I tried this with the native xenserverjava packages (both 5.6.100 and
>> 6.0) and it breaks the build.
>
> If it's worthwhile (library license is compatible), I'll spend some time tonight to fix it.
>
> --Alex
>>
>> --David
At present it isn't, (Xenserverjava is copyleft) and no one from
upstream XenServer is answering my emails regarding the status of
their proposed relicensing.
--David
RE: [ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
Posted by Alex Huang <Al...@citrix.com>.
> -----Original Message-----
> From: David Nalley [mailto:david@gnsa.us]
> Sent: Friday, August 10, 2012 7:12 AM
> To: cloudstack-dev@incubator.apache.org
> Cc: Chip Childers (chip.childers@sungard.com); Ewan Mellor; Alex Huang
> Subject: Re: [ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
>
> > For XenServerJava, my suggestion is this. The reason why we modify it is to
> put in client timeouts so that CloudStack is decoupled from Xapi when Xapi
> behaves badly. For normal operations, it's not necessary. We should just
> remove the directory and use the one from XenServer and force our changes
> to be upstreamed to XenServer. Is the XenServer java client stub license
> compatible with apache?
> >
>
> I tried this with the native xenserverjava packages (both 5.6.100 and
> 6.0) and it breaks the build.
If it's worthwhile (library license is compatible), I'll spend some time tonight to fix it.
--Alex
>
> --David
Re: [ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
Posted by David Nalley <da...@gnsa.us>.
> For XenServerJava, my suggestion is this. The reason why we modify it is to put in client timeouts so that CloudStack is decoupled from Xapi when Xapi behaves badly. For normal operations, it's not necessary. We should just remove the directory and use the one from XenServer and force our changes to be upstreamed to XenServer. Is the XenServer java client stub license compatible with apache?
>
I tried this with the native xenserverjava packages (both 5.6.100 and
6.0) and it breaks the build.
--David
Re: [ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
Posted by Chip Childers <ch...@sungard.com>.
On Fri, Aug 10, 2012 at 9:52 AM, Alex Huang <Al...@citrix.com> wrote:
>>
>> So question on that. If someone edits the project's classpath in Eclipse, does
>> that file get re-generated? Or does it simply modify the file as-is? If it gets
>> re-generated, then I think we should simply consider those files to be
>> "accepted exceptions". If it modifies the file and respects comments, then
>> I'd say we keep the license headers in there.
>>
>> I'm hoping to eventually figure out how to add exceptions to RAT, and then
>> configure the report generation as a Jenkins job. If we can do that, then we'll
>> be able to catch problems as they occur (without me doing it daily!).
>
> It's automatically re-generated. That's exactly how I lost the license on those two files. If we can add exceptions to RAT, that's the best.
>
> --Alex
>
>
Got it... OK, .project and .classpath files will be considered
accepted exceptions from here on out... I'll see what I can do with
RAT.
RE: [ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
Posted by Alex Huang <Al...@citrix.com>.
>
> So question on that. If someone edits the project's classpath in Eclipse, does
> that file get re-generated? Or does it simply modify the file as-is? If it gets
> re-generated, then I think we should simply consider those files to be
> "accepted exceptions". If it modifies the file and respects comments, then
> I'd say we keep the license headers in there.
>
> I'm hoping to eventually figure out how to add exceptions to RAT, and then
> configure the report generation as a Jenkins job. If we can do that, then we'll
> be able to catch problems as they occur (without me doing it daily!).
It's automatically re-generated. That's exactly how I lost the license on those two files. If we can add exceptions to RAT, that's the best.
--Alex
Re: [ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
Posted by Chip Childers <ch...@sungard.com>.
On Fri, Aug 10, 2012 at 9:25 AM, Alex Huang <Al...@citrix.com> wrote:
> Chip,
>
> I checked in my two changes.
>
> 1. Removed Base64.java from test directory.
> 2. Added the license back in the two classpath files.
Thanks!
> I do have one concern about license in the .classpath. It's not urgent but maybe we can address it post 4.0. These .classpath files are eclipse files and they will get updated by others. I doubt anyone will remember to put licenses on them. We either need to figure out a way to not checkin eclipse files or simply just ignore missing licenses in eclipse related files.
So question on that. If someone edits the project's classpath in
Eclipse, does that file get re-generated? Or does it simply modify
the file as-is? If it gets re-generated, then I think we should
simply consider those files to be "accepted exceptions". If it
modifies the file and respects comments, then I'd say we keep the
license headers in there.
I'm hoping to eventually figure out how to add exceptions to RAT, and
then configure the report generation as a Jenkins job. If we can do
that, then we'll be able to catch problems as they occur (without me
doing it daily!).
-chip
RE: [ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
Posted by Alex Huang <Al...@citrix.com>.
Chip,
I checked in my two changes.
1. Removed Base64.java from test directory.
2. Added the license back in the two classpath files.
I do have one concern about license in the .classpath. It's not urgent but maybe we can address it post 4.0. These .classpath files are eclipse files and they will get updated by others. I doubt anyone will remember to put licenses on them. We either need to figure out a way to not checkin eclipse files or simply just ignore missing licenses in eclipse related files.
Ewan,
For XenServerJava, my suggestion is this. The reason why we modify it is to put in client timeouts so that CloudStack is decoupled from Xapi when Xapi behaves badly. For normal operations, it's not necessary. We should just remove the directory and use the one from XenServer and force our changes to be upstreamed to XenServer. Is the XenServer java client stub license compatible with apache?
--Alex
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Chip Childers [mailto:chip.childers@sungard.com]
> Sent: Friday, August 10, 2012 6:09 AM
> To: cloudstack-dev@incubator.apache.org; Prachi Damle; Ewan Mellor; Frank
> Zhang
> Subject: [ASF40] License header update for Friday August 10
>
> Specific individuals that have open questions to them below: Prachi, Frank,
> Ewan
>
> Updated RAT report:
> https://github.com/chipchilders/asf_cloudstack_RAT_results/blob/master/_
> all.txt?raw=true
>
> Outstanding Issues:
>
> EC2 WSDL files:
> Prachi, can you remove these 2 as well?
> incubator-cloudstack/awsapi/resource/AmazonEC2/AmazonEC2.wsdl
> incubator-cloudstack/awsapi/resource/AmazonEC2/services.xml
>
> XenServerJava:
> Ewan noted that the Citrix team is currently working to get this re-licensed.
> Alex confirmed that Ewan is working on this. Ewan - any update on progress?
> incubator-cloudstack/deps/XenServerJava/GPL-2
> incubator-cloudstack/deps/XenServerJava/Makefile
>
> Patches in the OVM folder:
> Pending Frank. Any updates Frank?:
> incubator-
> cloudstack/plugins/hypervisors/ovm/scripts/vm/hypervisor/ovm/Fixget_sto
> rage_reposExceptionDueToWrongReturnValueCheck.patch
> incubator-
> cloudstack/plugins/hypervisors/ovm/scripts/vm/hypervisor/ovm/OvmDontT
> ouchOCFS2ClusterWhenAgentStart.patch
> incubator-
> cloudstack/plugins/hypervisors/ovm/scripts/vm/hypervisor/ovm/OvmPatch.
> patch
>
> JQuery, FLOT, QUnit:
> We need to include the various JQuery components in the appropriate top
> level LICENSE and NOTICE files. I own this still (did not complete yesterday):
> incubator-cloudstack/console-proxy/js/jquery.js
> incubator-cloudstack/ui/lib/jquery*
> incubator-cloudstack/ui/lib/flot/*
> incubator-cloudstack/ui/lib/jquery-ui/*
> incubator-cloudstack/ui/lib/qunit/*
>
> Documentation folder:
> Joe's making great progress on this folder. Thanks Joe!
> incubator-cloudstack/docs/*
>
> Patches folder:
> There is an ongoing thread about this topic, with David driving it.
> incubator-cloudstack/patches/systemvm/debian/*
>
>
> Known Exceptions (items that we know can't have a license header, and
> don't need one):
>
> Deb files:
> incubator-cloudstack/awsapi/packages/config/debian/control
> incubator-cloudstack/awsapi/packages/config/debian/rules
> incubator-cloudstack/debian/compat
> incubator-cloudstack/debian/control
> incubator-cloudstack/debian/dirs
> incubator-cloudstack/debian/rules
>
> Certificates and keys:
> incubator-cloudstack/console-proxy/certs/localhost.crt
> incubator-cloudstack/console-proxy/certs/localhost.key
> incubator-cloudstack/console-proxy/certs/realhostip.crt
> incubator-cloudstack/console-proxy/certs/realhostip.csr
> incubator-cloudstack/console-proxy/certs/realhostip.key
> incubator-cloudstack/scripts/vm/systemvm/id_rsa.cloud
>
> WAF scripts:
> Added to the LICENSE and NOTICE files.
> incubator-cloudstack/waf
> incubator-cloudstack/awsapi/waf
>
> SLF4J:
> This is listed in the NOTICE and LICENSE files.
> incubator-cloudstack/deps/awsapi-lib/rampart-lib/slf4j-api-LICENSE.txt
> incubator-cloudstack/deps/awsapi-lib/rampart-lib/slf4j-jdk14-LICENSE.txt