You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@drill.apache.org by James Turton <dz...@apache.org> on 2021/12/08 15:40:27 UTC
[LAZY VOTE] Drill 1.20 freeze delay
Dear dev community
Please reply if you *object* to us pushing out the freeze date by one
week to 2021-12-16. The motivation to delay is to try to include more
of the open PRs that we are tracking below, a number of which are
essentially dev-complete but not yet over the line.
*Closed*
DRILL-1282 Parquet v2 read+write
DRILL-7863 Phoenix storage
DRILL-8027 Iceberg format
DRILL-8009 JDBC isValid()
*Open*
DRILL-7978 Fixed width format
DRILL-7983 Get running/completed profiles from REST API
DRILL-8015 MongoDB Metastore
DRILL-8028 PDF format
DRILL-8057 INFORMATION_SCHEMA filter push down is inefficient
(feasibility not yet clear)
*
*Thank you
James
Re: [LAZY VOTE] Drill 1.20 freeze delay
Posted by James Turton <dz...@apache.org>.
In fact, since format plugins can be built and added to an existing
Drill installation, I'll be in touch to reassess as soon as 8061 is
done. If we can't bundle the PDF format plugin with 1.20, users who
need it can still build it and add it to their clusters later.
On 2021/12/17 16:35, James Turton wrote:
> Hi all
>
> Thank you everyone for pushing to get us to where we are now, you can
> see the results of these efforts below (not to mention other work that
> got merged). We've got just three tracked Jiras outstanding. 8057 is
> sitting with me and I haven't found an approach that works yet so
> there's a fair chance it will need to be cut (it's old defect, not a
> blocker). 8028 and 8061 are very nearly done and their developers are
> active and reachable daily so, unless there is disagreement, I propose
> to hold off the freeze while we track these two to completion.
> *
> Closed*
>
> DRILL-1282 Parquet v2 read+write
> DRILL-7863 Phoenix storage
> DRILL-7983 Get running/completed profiles from REST API
> DRILL-8009 JDBC isValid()
> DRILL-8015 MongoDB Metastore
> DRILL-8027 Iceberg format
> DRILL-8067 Web UI tries to fetch CSS from Google
> DRILL-8069 Remove use of excel sheet getLastRowNum
> DRILL-8073 Add support for persistent table and storage aliases
>
> *Cut
>
> * DRILL-7978 Fixed width format (waiting for some missing EVF v2 code
> to be merged)
>
> *Under review*
>
> DRILL-8028 PDF format
>
> *Under development*
>
> DRILL-8057 INFORMATION_SCHEMA filter push down is inefficient
> (feasibility not yet clear)
> DRILL-8061 Impersonation support for Phoenix plugin (only unit tests
> outstanding)
>
>
> On 2021/12/09 11:03, James Turton wrote:
>> Apologies, I was aiming for next week Friday and had an off-by-one
>> error. So we've agreed to delay until 2021-12-17 and we're tracking
>> the following.
>>
>>
>>
>> On 2021/12/08 17:40, James Turton wrote:
>>> Dear dev community
>>>
>>> Please reply if you *object* to us pushing out the freeze date by
>>> one week to 2021-12-16. The motivation to delay is to try to
>>> include more of the open PRs that we are tracking below, a number of
>>> which are essentially dev-complete but not yet over the line.
>>>
>>> *Closed*
>>>
>>> DRILL-1282 Parquet v2 read+write
>>> DRILL-7863 Phoenix storage
>>> DRILL-8027 Iceberg format
>>> DRILL-8009 JDBC isValid()
>>>
>>> *Open*
>>>
>>> DRILL-7978 Fixed width format
>>> DRILL-7983 Get running/completed profiles from REST API
>>> DRILL-8015 MongoDB Metastore
>>> DRILL-8028 PDF format
>>> DRILL-8057 INFORMATION_SCHEMA filter push down is inefficient
>>> (feasibility not yet clear)
>>> *
>>> *Thank you
>>> James
>>>
>>
>
Re: [LAZY VOTE] Drill 1.20 freeze delay
Posted by James Turton <dz...@apache.org>.
Hi all
Thank you everyone for pushing to get us to where we are now, you can
see the results of these efforts below (not to mention other work that
got merged). We've got just three tracked Jiras outstanding. 8057 is
sitting with me and I haven't found an approach that works yet so
there's a fair chance it will need to be cut (it's old defect, not a
blocker). 8028 and 8061 are very nearly done and their developers are
active and reachable daily so, unless there is disagreement, I propose
to hold off the freeze while we track these two to completion.
*
Closed*
DRILL-1282 Parquet v2 read+write
DRILL-7863 Phoenix storage
DRILL-7983 Get running/completed profiles from REST API
DRILL-8009 JDBC isValid()
DRILL-8015 MongoDB Metastore
DRILL-8027 Iceberg format
DRILL-8067 Web UI tries to fetch CSS from Google
DRILL-8069 Remove use of excel sheet getLastRowNum
DRILL-8073 Add support for persistent table and storage aliases
*Cut
* DRILL-7978 Fixed width format (waiting for some missing EVF v2 code to
be merged)
*Under review*
DRILL-8028 PDF format
*Under development*
DRILL-8057 INFORMATION_SCHEMA filter push down is inefficient
(feasibility not yet clear)
DRILL-8061 Impersonation support for Phoenix plugin (only unit tests
outstanding)
On 2021/12/09 11:03, James Turton wrote:
> Apologies, I was aiming for next week Friday and had an off-by-one
> error. So we've agreed to delay until 2021-12-17 and we're tracking
> the following.
>
>
>
> On 2021/12/08 17:40, James Turton wrote:
>> Dear dev community
>>
>> Please reply if you *object* to us pushing out the freeze date by one
>> week to 2021-12-16. The motivation to delay is to try to include
>> more of the open PRs that we are tracking below, a number of which
>> are essentially dev-complete but not yet over the line.
>>
>> *Closed*
>>
>> DRILL-1282 Parquet v2 read+write
>> DRILL-7863 Phoenix storage
>> DRILL-8027 Iceberg format
>> DRILL-8009 JDBC isValid()
>>
>> *Open*
>>
>> DRILL-7978 Fixed width format
>> DRILL-7983 Get running/completed profiles from REST API
>> DRILL-8015 MongoDB Metastore
>> DRILL-8028 PDF format
>> DRILL-8057 INFORMATION_SCHEMA filter push down is inefficient
>> (feasibility not yet clear)
>> *
>> *Thank you
>> James
>>
>
Re: AW: Re: [LAZY VOTE] Drill 1.20 freeze delay
Posted by James Turton <dz...@apache.org>.
Already in! Thank you for this great first contribution. Separately,
note that the list of tracked PRs is not the exhaustive set of what will
be merged before 1.20. It's just a subset of work in progress that the
community identified as being significant, and which has a major bearing
on the freeze date that is finally settled on.
On 2021/12/11 14:35, Z0ltrix wrote:
> Hi James,
>
> what do you think about DRILL-8055 ?
> I finished the implementation and if the review goes well the users
> were able to use newest Druid Version with Drill from 1.20 on.
> For one of my customers it would be great to include this because we
> want to add Druid 0.22 in our Cluster next Year and without this
> Ticket we were not be able to use Drill in front of Druid.
>
> Regards,
> Christian
>
> ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ Original Message ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐
> James Turton <dz...@apache.org> schrieb am Donnerstag, 9. Dezember
> 2021 um 10:03:
>
>> Apologies, I was aiming for next week Friday and had an off-by-one
>> error. So we've agreed to delay until 2021-12-17 and we're tracking
>> the following.
>>
>> *Closed*
>>
>> DRILL-1282 Parquet v2 read+write
>> DRILL-7863 Phoenix storage
>> DRILL-7983 Get running/completed profiles from REST API
>> DRILL-8027 Iceberg format
>> DRILL-8009 JDBC isValid()
>> DRILL-8067 Web UI tries to fetch CSS from Google
>> DRILL-8069 Remove use of excel sheet getLastRowNum
>>
>> *Under review*
>>
>> DRILL-8015 MongoDB Metastore
>> DRILL-8028 PDF format
>> DRILL-8073 Add support for persistent table and storage aliases
>>
>> *Under development
>> *
>> DRILL-7978 Fixed width format
>> DRILL-8057 INFORMATION_SCHEMA filter push down is inefficient
>> (feasibility not yet clear)
>> DRILL-8061 Impersonation support for Phoenix plugin
>>
>>
>> On 2021/12/08 17:40, James Turton wrote:
>>> Dear dev community
>>>
>>> Please reply if you *object* to us pushing out the freeze date by
>>> one week to 2021-12-16. The motivation to delay is to try to include
>>> more of the open PRs that we are tracking below, a number of which
>>> are essentially dev-complete but not yet over the line.
>>>
>>> *Closed*
>>>
>>> DRILL-1282 Parquet v2 read+write
>>> DRILL-7863 Phoenix storage
>>> DRILL-8027 Iceberg format
>>> DRILL-8009 JDBC isValid()
>>>
>>> *Open*
>>>
>>> DRILL-7978 Fixed width format
>>> DRILL-7983 Get running/completed profiles from REST API
>>> DRILL-8015 MongoDB Metastore
>>> DRILL-8028 PDF format
>>> DRILL-8057 INFORMATION_SCHEMA filter push down is inefficient
>>> (feasibility not yet clear)
>>> *
>>> *Thank you
>>> James
>>>
>>
AW: Re: [LAZY VOTE] Drill 1.20 freeze delay
Posted by Z0ltrix <z0...@pm.me.INVALID>.
Hi James,
what do you think about DRILL-8055 ?
I finished the implementation and if the review goes well the users were able to use newest Druid Version with Drill from 1.20 on.
For one of my customers it would be great to include this because we want to add Druid 0.22 in our Cluster next Year and without this Ticket we were not be able to use Drill in front of Druid.
Regards,
Christian
‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ Original Message ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐
James Turton <dz...@apache.org> schrieb am Donnerstag, 9. Dezember 2021 um 10:03:
> Apologies, I was aiming for next week Friday and had an off-by-one error. So we've agreed to delay until 2021-12-17 and we're tracking the following.
>
> Closed
>
> DRILL-1282 Parquet v2 read+write
>
> DRILL-7863 Phoenix storage
>
> DRILL-7983 Get running/completed profiles from REST API
>
> DRILL-8027 Iceberg format
>
> DRILL-8009 JDBC isValid()
>
> DRILL-8067 Web UI tries to fetch CSS from Google
>
> DRILL-8069 Remove use of excel sheet getLastRowNum
>
> Under review
>
> DRILL-8015 MongoDB Metastore
>
> DRILL-8028 PDF format
>
> DRILL-8073 Add support for persistent table and storage aliases
>
> Under development
>
> DRILL-7978 Fixed width format
>
> DRILL-8057 INFORMATION_SCHEMA filter push down is inefficient (feasibility not yet clear)
>
> DRILL-8061 Impersonation support for Phoenix plugin
>
> On 2021/12/08 17:40, James Turton wrote:
>
> > Dear dev community
> >
> > Please reply if you *object* to us pushing out the freeze date by one week to 2021-12-16. The motivation to delay is to try to include more of the open PRs that we are tracking below, a number of which are essentially dev-complete but not yet over the line.
> >
> > Closed
> >
> > DRILL-1282 Parquet v2 read+write
> >
> > DRILL-7863 Phoenix storage
> >
> > DRILL-8027 Iceberg format
> >
> > DRILL-8009 JDBC isValid()
> >
> > Open
> >
> > DRILL-7978 Fixed width format
> >
> > DRILL-7983 Get running/completed profiles from REST API
> >
> > DRILL-8015 MongoDB Metastore
> >
> > DRILL-8028 PDF format
> >
> > DRILL-8057 INFORMATION_SCHEMA filter push down is inefficient (feasibility not yet clear)
> >
> > Thank you
> >
> > James
Re: [LAZY VOTE] Drill 1.20 freeze delay
Posted by James Turton <dz...@apache.org>.
Apologies, I was aiming for next week Friday and had an off-by-one
error. So we've agreed to delay until 2021-12-17 and we're tracking the
following.
*Closed*
DRILL-1282 Parquet v2 read+write
DRILL-7863 Phoenix storage
DRILL-7983 Get running/completed profiles from REST API
DRILL-8027 Iceberg format
DRILL-8009 JDBC isValid()
DRILL-8067 Web UI tries to fetch CSS from Google
DRILL-8069 Remove use of excel sheet getLastRowNum
*Under review***
DRILL-8015 MongoDB Metastore
DRILL-8028 PDF format
DRILL-8073 Add support for persistent table and storage aliases
*Under development
*
DRILL-7978 Fixed width format
DRILL-8057 INFORMATION_SCHEMA filter push down is inefficient
(feasibility not yet clear)
DRILL-8061 Impersonation support for Phoenix plugin
On 2021/12/08 17:40, James Turton wrote:
> Dear dev community
>
> Please reply if you *object* to us pushing out the freeze date by one
> week to 2021-12-16. The motivation to delay is to try to include more
> of the open PRs that we are tracking below, a number of which are
> essentially dev-complete but not yet over the line.
>
> *Closed*
>
> DRILL-1282 Parquet v2 read+write
> DRILL-7863 Phoenix storage
> DRILL-8027 Iceberg format
> DRILL-8009 JDBC isValid()
>
> *Open*
>
> DRILL-7978 Fixed width format
> DRILL-7983 Get running/completed profiles from REST API
> DRILL-8015 MongoDB Metastore
> DRILL-8028 PDF format
> DRILL-8057 INFORMATION_SCHEMA filter push down is inefficient
> (feasibility not yet clear)
> *
> *Thank you
> James
>
Re: [LAZY VOTE] Drill 1.20 freeze delay
Posted by luoc <lu...@apache.org>.
I accept that.
And I see that DRILL-8015 and DRILL-7983 have made good progress in the code review, this cut date(12.16) should be the last time.
> 2021年12月8日 下午11:51，Charles Givre <cg...@gmail.com> 写道：
>
> I think it's worth extending a week. I'd like to see DRILL-8073, 8069 and 8067 added to the list as they seem fairly important.
> -- C
>
>
>> On Dec 8, 2021, at 10:40 AM, James Turton <dz...@apache.org> wrote:
>>
>> Dear dev community
>>
>> Please reply if you *object* to us pushing out the freeze date by one week to 2021-12-16. The motivation to delay is to try to include more of the open PRs that we are tracking below, a number of which are essentially dev-complete but not yet over the line.
>>
>> Closed
>>
>> DRILL-1282 Parquet v2 read+write
>> DRILL-7863 Phoenix storage
>> DRILL-8027 Iceberg format
>> DRILL-8009 JDBC isValid()
>>
>> Open
>>
>> DRILL-7978 Fixed width format
>> DRILL-7983 Get running/completed profiles from REST API
>> DRILL-8015 MongoDB Metastore
>> DRILL-8028 PDF format
>> DRILL-8057 INFORMATION_SCHEMA filter push down is inefficient (feasibility not yet clear)
>>
>> Thank you
>> James
>>
>> <dzamo.vcf>
>
Re: [LAZY VOTE] Drill 1.20 freeze delay
Posted by Charles Givre <cg...@gmail.com>.
I think it's worth extending a week. I'd like to see DRILL-8073, 8069 and 8067 added to the list as they seem fairly important.
-- C
> On Dec 8, 2021, at 10:40 AM, James Turton <dz...@apache.org> wrote:
>
> Dear dev community
>
> Please reply if you *object* to us pushing out the freeze date by one week to 2021-12-16. The motivation to delay is to try to include more of the open PRs that we are tracking below, a number of which are essentially dev-complete but not yet over the line.
>
> Closed
>
> DRILL-1282 Parquet v2 read+write
> DRILL-7863 Phoenix storage
> DRILL-8027 Iceberg format
> DRILL-8009 JDBC isValid()
>
> Open
>
> DRILL-7978 Fixed width format
> DRILL-7983 Get running/completed profiles from REST API
> DRILL-8015 MongoDB Metastore
> DRILL-8028 PDF format
> DRILL-8057 INFORMATION_SCHEMA filter push down is inefficient (feasibility not yet clear)
>
> Thank you
> James
>
> <dzamo.vcf>