You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to general@commons.apache.org by gs...@apache.org on 2002/11/04 20:24:33 UTC
cvs commit: commons STATUS
gstein 2002/11/04 11:24:33
Modified: . STATUS
Log:
forward motion
Revision Changes Path
1.52 +16 -40 commons/STATUS
Index: STATUS
===================================================================
RCS file: /home/cvs/commons/STATUS,v
retrieving revision 1.51
retrieving revision 1.52
diff -u -r1.51 -r1.52
--- STATUS 28 Oct 2002 15:16:45 -0000 1.51
+++ STATUS 4 Nov 2002 19:24:32 -0000 1.52
@@ -20,6 +20,10 @@
Resolved Issues:
+ o Commons is a parent of reusable code projects. These projects
+ may be used by other projects of the ASF, but it is not a
+ requirement.
+
o The Commons will be language-agnostic.
o Projects that are "in scope" are defined as:
@@ -33,6 +37,13 @@
of last refuge if the component does not match the Apache
Commons' goals.
+ - Reusable libraries
+ [ gstein: we should expand this definition for the mission
+ statement; examples provided were serf and regexp ]
+
+ - Components that do not fit cleanly into any other top-level
+ project, but they do fit the goals of Commons.
+
o Voting will follow the "standard Apache voting guidelines"
[ be nice to refer to an Incubator doc here ]
@@ -98,7 +109,7 @@
o Style for the mailing lists:
One community mailing list, with specific breakouts:
- +1: fitz, jerenkrantz, sanders,
+ +1: fitz, jerenkrantz, sanders, coar,
donaldp (lets start here and evolve)
+0.5: mas
-0: aaron (too early)
@@ -107,11 +118,12 @@
+1: gstein, scolebourne, acoliver, striker
-0: aaron (too early), jerenkrantz
-0.1: mas, sanders (too early for this), donaldp
+ -1: coar
Per-language mailing lists:
-0: aaron (too early)
-0.1: mas
- -1: gstein, sanders, fitz, jerenkrantz, striker
+ -1: gstein, sanders, fitz, jerenkrantz, striker, coar
Per-component mailing lists as a default (breakouts will create
these as a matter of course, this is about the default)
@@ -125,6 +137,7 @@
deal with each of these, in terms of new components and
how those components will contain code projects. This list
is only meant to keep record of all the issues:
+
- Releasable pieces
- Release rules
- Voting scope
@@ -166,19 +179,6 @@
and broken; gstein notes that we're refining the board-provided
charter)
- o Should it be a parent of reusable code projects used by other
- parts of the ASF?
- +1: coar, donaldp (if compatible communities), gstein,
- striker (but not excluded to), sanders (non-binding), aaron
- +0: fitz
- -0: jerenkrantz, jim
- CLOSE THIS? (as "passed")
-
- o Can it contain components which are NOT used by other ASF
- projects?
- +1: gstein, mas (non-binding), jerenkrantz, sanders (non-binding)
- donaldp, striker, aaron
-
o Should commons have an sandbox component to ease infrastructure
burden on smaller code bases?
+1: coar, donaldp, jerenkrantz, gstein, sanders (non-binding)
@@ -196,15 +196,6 @@
-0: donaldp (prefer a tools PMC for that)
-1: aaron (too broad, don't belong here)
- - Reusable libraries?
- Hypothetical: serf, regexp
- +1: jerenkrantz, gstein, striker, donaldp, fitz,
- sanders (non-binding)
- -0: aaron (not directly, but +1 for each being part of
- a larger funtional unit)
- -1:
- CLOSE THIS? (as "passed") (I'd like to see more votes)
-
- Development frameworks?
Hypothetical: avalon
+1: fitz
@@ -212,21 +203,6 @@
accept it if it was new?)
-1: gstein (the avalon components, but not the whole bugger),
striker, sanders (non-binding)
-
- - Components that do not fit cleanly into any other top-level project,
- but they do fit the (TBD) goals of Commons?
- +1: gstein, jerenkrantz, striker, fitz, sanders (non-binding),
- donaldp
-
- FOLD BELOW VOTES INTO ABOVE? (i.e. eliminate the "donation" wording)
- - Donations that don't cleanly fit into any other projects, but
- do fit the goals of the commons?
- +1: coar, jerenkrantz, fitz (incubator gets 1st dibs),
- donaldp (if it fits the community reqs),
- gstein (but the Incubator can claim a donation first; it
- only arrives here if the Incubator says it is worthy),
- striker (but expand the wording greg proposes above)
- -1: aaron, jim (otherwise commons becomes a junk drawer)
- Components that fit the (TBD) goals of Commons, have a more
"logical" home elsewhere in the ASF, but were rejected by that