You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@spamassassin.apache.org by Justin Mason <jm...@jmason.org> on 2005/08/18 03:53:34 UTC

creating a subproject -- how many votes?

an ASF procedural question. so, we now have 3 +1s for the Rules
subproject: me - Michael - Duncan.

*however* I think we may need a majority of the PMC to vote in favor for
it to be passed. This is what Daniel suggested a few weeks ago. That means
one more vote is required.  (ping!)

However, our wiki gives no indication either way; Jakarta reportedly
require even more than that (3/4s of the PMC!) so that's no help;
and I can't find any other online doco indicating what the ASF
guidelines are.

So, do we require:

  - (a) 3 +1s?  seems a bit low, in my opinion
  - (b) a majority of the PMC?   I think this is most appropriate
  - (c) 3/4s of the PMC, Jakarta style?  too much.

I'm hoping someone can say "oh yeah, we decided on (b) ages ago!"
here, btw.

--j.

Re: creating a subproject -- how many votes?

Posted by Theo Van Dinter <fe...@apache.org>.
On Wed, Aug 17, 2005 at 06:53:34PM -0700, Justin Mason wrote:
> However, our wiki gives no indication either way; Jakarta reportedly
> require even more than that (3/4s of the PMC!) so that's no help;
> and I can't find any other online doco indicating what the ASF
> guidelines are.

Well, the ASF guidelines in general seem to be: the PMC controls the
policies of their TLP.  So IMO, we should just come up with something
that works for us.

> So, do we require:
>   - (a) 3 +1s?  seems a bit low, in my opinion
>   - (b) a majority of the PMC?   I think this is most appropriate
>   - (c) 3/4s of the PMC, Jakarta style?  too much.
> I'm hoping someone can say "oh yeah, we decided on (b) ages ago!"
> here, btw.

(a) is 50% of the current PMC
(b) is 2/3 of the current PMC
(c) is 5 people of the 6 in the PMC

So given our current numbers, I think (a) or (b) is appropriate.
Moving forward, if the PMC numbers grow, I agree that (a) is too small.
I think requiring 1/2 to 2/3 is a good number.


BTW, I haven't had the time to read the docs and such regarding the
specific details, but I'm +1 on the idea of the subproject.

-- 
Randomly Generated Tagline:
 "I'm never gonna get used to the thirty-first century. Caffeinated bacon?
 Baconated grapefruit? Admiral Crunch?" -Fry 
  "Well if you don't like that, try some Archduke Chocula." -Leela