You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@mina.apache.org by Trustin Lee <tr...@gmail.com> on 2006/02/24 00:43:54 UTC

Re: [mina] MINA compared to QuickServer

Hi Michael,

On 2/24/06, Michael Link <mi...@onlinehome.de> wrote:
>
> Hi,
>
> I'm currently evaluating MINA for usage in a .NET-Java-Communication
> scenario. It looks very promising, I just wondered how MINA compares to
> QuickServer (http://www.quickserver.org). What do you think is the
> essential difference between those two products ?


Thank for the information about another network application framework.  I
found a few differences:

* QuickServer supports blocking mode.  (MINA supports only non-blocking
mode, but you can make your operation block at your will.)
* QuickServer provides GUI-based admin.  (MINA doesn't have one yet, but
will have full JMX support soon, which is a standard.)
* QuickServer uses java.util.logging.  (MINA uses SLF4J, which is a safe
replacement of commons-logging.)
* QuickServer uses its own XML settings.  (MINA provides Spring framework
integration instead.)
* QuickServer can specify maximum number of clients allowed.  (MINA can do
this using a filter, but not implemented by default.  Of course, this will
be implemented as an overload prevention filter.)
* QuickServer team has one crew.  (MINA has three crews.)
* QuickServer project started in 2003.  (MINA started in 2005.)
* QuickServer has a difference event handler interface from MINA.  (You'll
have to compare it by yourself.  IMHO, MINA has one simple enough handler
which covers all QuickServer provides.)
* QuickServer doesn't support UDP at all.  (MINA does)
* QuickServer doesn't support client-side API at all.  (MINA does)
* QuickServer integrated authentication and text protocol in its core.
(MINA didn't and they are considered as a cross-cutting concern that a
filter should take care of.  IMHO, MINA is more extensible here.)

I forward this message to the author of QuickServer so he can correct me if
I made any mistakes here.

Thanks,
Trustin
--
what we call human nature is actually human habit
--
http://gleamynode.net/
--
PGP key fingerprints:
* E167 E6AF E73A CBCE EE41  4A29 544D DE48 FE95 4E7E
* B693 628E 6047 4F8F CFA4  455E 1C62 A7DC 0255 ECA6

Re: [mina] MINA compared to QuickServer

Posted by Maarten Bosteels <ma...@dns.be>.
On 2/24/06, Trustin Lee <tr...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> On 2/24/06, Maarten Bosteels <ma...@dns.be> wrote:
> >
> > They also have a sql package, with a DBPoolUtil ?
>
>
> I don't see any reason for a network application to provide database
> connection pool.


me neither, that was my point

Re: [mina] MINA compared to QuickServer

Posted by Trustin Lee <tr...@gmail.com>.
On 2/24/06, Maarten Bosteels <ma...@dns.be> wrote:
>
> They also have a sql package, with a DBPoolUtil ?


I don't see any reason for a network application to provide database
connection pool.

Trustin
--
what we call human nature is actually human habit
--
http://gleamynode.net/
--
PGP key fingerprints:
* E167 E6AF E73A CBCE EE41  4A29 544D DE48 FE95 4E7E
* B693 628E 6047 4F8F CFA4  455E 1C62 A7DC 0255 ECA6

Re: [mina] MINA compared to QuickServer

Posted by Maarten Bosteels <ma...@dns.be>.
>
>
> * QuickServer integrated authentication and text protocol in its core.
> (MINA didn't and they are considered as a cross-cutting concern that a
> filter should take care of.  IMHO, MINA is more extensible here.)


I had a very quick look at QuickServer, before I discovered MINA.
But it didn't give me much confidence that they added these cross-cutting
concerens.

They also have a sql package, with a DBPoolUtil ?

http://www.quickserver.org/docs/1.4.5/org/quickserver/sql/DBPoolUtil.html

Maarten

Re: [mina] MINA compared to QuickServer

Posted by Trustin Lee <tr...@gmail.com>.
Oh, I forgot to mention that QuickServer is licensed as LGPL, and MINA as
ASL.

BTW from now on, please post any replies to mina-dev@directory.apache.org.
Please don't send any MINA messages which are not related with ApacheDS to
dev@directory.apache.org.

Trustin
--
what we call human nature is actually human habit
--
http://gleamynode.net/
--
PGP key fingerprints:
* E167 E6AF E73A CBCE EE41  4A29 544D DE48 FE95 4E7E
* B693 628E 6047 4F8F CFA4  455E 1C62 A7DC 0255 ECA6

Re: [mina] MINA compared to QuickServer

Posted by Trustin Lee <tr...@gmail.com>.
Oh, I forgot to mention that QuickServer is licensed as LGPL, and MINA as
ASL.

BTW from now on, please post any replies to mina-dev@directory.apache.org.
Please don't send any MINA messages which are not related with ApacheDS to
dev@directory.apache.org.

Trustin
--
what we call human nature is actually human habit
--
http://gleamynode.net/
--
PGP key fingerprints:
* E167 E6AF E73A CBCE EE41  4A29 544D DE48 FE95 4E7E
* B693 628E 6047 4F8F CFA4  455E 1C62 A7DC 0255 ECA6