You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@forrest.apache.org by Nick Chalko <ni...@chalko.com> on 2004/08/01 10:08:33 UTC

Do'nt License Samples was: Eclipse plugin roadmap

Ross Gardler wrote:

>
> Blast! I forgot that one. They are derived from CPL licensed images in 
> the eclipse project. This is a compatible license (as far as I 
> understand it), but they should be licensed as such.
>
> However, I'll knock together another couple of logo's now and put them 
> in instead.
>
> Thanks for spotting this.
>
> Ross
>
I think this highlights the reason to NOT license samples designed to be 
copied and by third parties, in the use of a product.
For us that means that even thought Forrest is ASL 2,  all the files 
generated by "forrest site"  should not be licensed, and should be 
marked as such.

If IBM had done the same thing for there "sample.gif"  then we would not 
have to waste are time with this.


Hmm actually, come to think of it.  When you use the "PDE wizard in 
eclipse,  it creates a bunch of files, including the sample.gif."  and 
none of the generated files have a license notice. 
I think it is reasonable that the sample.gif is also not licensed.

R,
Nick


Re: Do'nt License Samples was: Eclipse plugin roadmap

Posted by Ross Gardler <rg...@apache.org>.
Nick Chalko wrote:

> Ross Gardler wrote:
> 
>>
>> Blast! I forgot that one. They are derived from CPL licensed images in 
>> the eclipse project. This is a compatible license (as far as I 
>> understand it), but they should be licensed as such.
>>
>> However, I'll knock together another couple of logo's now and put them 
>> in instead.
>>
>> Thanks for spotting this.
>>
>> Ross
>>
> I think this highlights the reason to NOT license samples designed to be 
> copied and by third parties, in the use of a product.
> For us that means that even thought Forrest is ASL 2,  all the files 
> generated by "forrest site"  should not be licensed, and should be 
> marked as such.

+1

> Hmm actually, come to think of it.  When you use the "PDE wizard in 
> eclipse,  it creates a bunch of files, including the sample.gif."  and 
> none of the generated files have a license notice. I think it is 
> reasonable that the sample.gif is also not licensed.

This impacts on some other work I have. I'll check it out and report back.

Ross

Re: Don't License Samples

Posted by David Crossley <cr...@apache.org>.
Nicola Ken Barozzi wrote:
> Dave Brondsema wrote:
> ...
>  > Perhaps we could say that the seed site is a form of
> > documentation and therefore we don't need it?
> 
> Documentation is "licensed" too.
> 
> But IMO a site seed is a creation of Forrest, and we do not license 
> those. For example, if i make a site with Forrest, that site is not 
> licensed by ASF! If I compile code with GCC, my program is not GPL!

So then the process of doing the 'forrest seed' would
need to strip the license from the source files, as it
copies them across.

-- 
David Crossley


Re: Don't License Samples

Posted by Nicola Ken Barozzi <ni...@apache.org>.
Dave Brondsema wrote:
...
 > Perhaps we could say that the seed site is a form of
> documentation and therefore we don't need it?

Documentation is "licensed" too.

But IMO a site seed is a creation of Forrest, and we do not license 
those. For example, if i make a site with Forrest, that site is not 
licensed by ASF! If I compile code with GCC, my program is not GPL!

-- 
Nicola Ken Barozzi                   nicolaken@apache.org
             - verba volant, scripta manent -
    (discussions get forgotten, just code remains)
---------------------------------------------------------------------


Re: Don't License Samples

Posted by Dave Brondsema <da...@brondsema.net>.
Nick Chalko wrote:
> David Crossley wrote:
> 
>> Nick Chalko wrote:
>>  
>>
>>> I think this highlights the reason to NOT license samples designed to 
>>> be copied and by third parties, in the use of a product.
>>> For us that means that even thought Forrest is ASL 2,  all the files 
>>> generated by "forrest site"  should not be licensed, and should be 
>>> marked as such.
>>>   
>>
>>
>> No, the Apache License is enabling. It does not restrict your use.
>> Its intention is to let you use the work as is and to build upon
>> it with your own work.
>>
>> What part of the License do you have trouble with.
>>
>> We cannot distribute our work unlicensed.
>>
>>  
>>
> So walking though an example
> I am creating a new project.
> I do a "forrest seed"
> It generates for example  src/documentation/content./xdocs/index.xml
> 
> If index.xml contains the ASL2 (which it does)  then I must leave it 
> licensed that way.   Perhaps I am writing documentation that I don't 
> want to be very restrictive of.  (Think company confidential)
> 
> It seems to me that the ASL2 does not allow me to distribute DERIVATIVES 
> without having the DERIVATIVE also ASL2 covered.
> 
> The license reads in part
> 
>    / You may add Your own copyright statement to Your modifications and
>    may provide additional or different license terms and conditions for
>    use, reproduction, or distribution of Your modifications, or for any
>    such Derivative Works as a whole, provided Your use, reproduction,
>    and distribution of the Work otherwise complies with the conditions
>    stated in this License.
>    /
> 
> This implies to me that I have to let others modify and distribute the 
> documentation  I produce that is covered by the ASL2. This is not 
> appropriate for some of the documentation work I do.
> 
> Seems to me that  "forrest seed"   should produce files that says 
> something like
> 
>    /This file is generated with any warranties.  do what ever you want
>    with, including removing this notice./
> 
> 
> R,
> Nick
> 

Well the ASF mandates that all source files need to have the license 
header.  Perhaps we could say that the seed site is a form of 
documentation and therefore we don't need it?

-- 
Dave Brondsema : dave@brondsema.net
http://www.splike.com : programming
http://csx.calvin.edu : student org
http://www.brondsema.net : personal

Re: Don't License Samples

Posted by Dirk-Willem van Gulik <di...@webweaving.org>.

On Sun, 1 Aug 2004, Nick Chalko wrote:

> >We cannot distribute our work unlicensed.

This is -non- negotiable; every bit and byte in a tarball downloaded from
apache comes under the ASL2 or, if the ASF got it from a third party, that
parties license.

> If index.xml contains the ASL2 (which it does)  then I must leave it
> licensed that way.   Perhaps I am writing documentation that I don't
> want to be very restrictive of.  (Think company confidential)

Please read the license carefully or work with a lawyer familiar with
your field; there are no (known) isuses with this. Lots of companies ship
proprietary modified versions of apache code (though they cannot claim
that it is the official apache code of course) in a confidental fashion.

Dw

Re: Don't License Samples

Posted by Nick Chalko <ni...@chalko.com>.
David Crossley wrote:

>Nick Chalko wrote:
>  
>
>>I think this highlights the reason to NOT license samples designed to be 
>>copied and by third parties, in the use of a product.
>>For us that means that even thought Forrest is ASL 2,  all the files 
>>generated by "forrest site"  should not be licensed, and should be 
>>marked as such.
>>    
>>
>
>No, the Apache License is enabling. It does not restrict your use.
>Its intention is to let you use the work as is and to build upon
>it with your own work.
>
>What part of the License do you have trouble with.
>
>We cannot distribute our work unlicensed.
>
>  
>
So walking though an example
I am creating a new project.
I do a "forrest seed"
It generates for example  src/documentation/content./xdocs/index.xml

If index.xml contains the ASL2 (which it does)  then I must leave it 
licensed that way.   Perhaps I am writing documentation that I don't 
want to be very restrictive of.  (Think company confidential)

It seems to me that the ASL2 does not allow me to distribute DERIVATIVES 
without having the DERIVATIVE also ASL2 covered.

The license reads in part

    / You may add Your own copyright statement to Your modifications and
    may provide additional or different license terms and conditions for
    use, reproduction, or distribution of Your modifications, or for any
    such Derivative Works as a whole, provided Your use, reproduction,
    and distribution of the Work otherwise complies with the conditions
    stated in this License.
    /

This implies to me that I have to let others modify and distribute the 
documentation  I produce that is covered by the ASL2. 
This is not appropriate for some of the documentation work I do.

Seems to me that  "forrest seed"   should produce files that says 
something like

    /This file is generated with any warranties.  do what ever you want
    with, including removing this notice./


R,
Nick


Re: Do'nt License Samples

Posted by David Crossley <cr...@apache.org>.
Nick Chalko wrote:
> I think this highlights the reason to NOT license samples designed to be 
> copied and by third parties, in the use of a product.
> For us that means that even thought Forrest is ASL 2,  all the files 
> generated by "forrest site"  should not be licensed, and should be 
> marked as such.

No, the Apache License is enabling. It does not restrict your use.
Its intention is to let you use the work as is and to build upon
it with your own work.

What part of the License do you have trouble with.

We cannot distribute our work unlicensed.

-- 
David Crossley