You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to issues@spark.apache.org by "Xiao Li (JIRA)" <ji...@apache.org> on 2016/03/17 03:03:33 UTC
[jira] [Commented] (SPARK-13864) TPCDS query 74 returns wrong
results compared to TPC official result set
[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13864?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=15198602#comment-15198602 ]
Xiao Li commented on SPARK-13864:
---------------------------------
This is the same issue as SPARK-13862. I think we can close this. Thanks!
> TPCDS query 74 returns wrong results compared to TPC official result set
> -------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: SPARK-13864
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SPARK-13864
> Project: Spark
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: SQL
> Affects Versions: 1.6.0
> Reporter: JESSE CHEN
> Labels: tpcds-result-mismatch
>
> Testing Spark SQL using TPC queries. Query 74 returns wrong results compared to official result set. This is at 1GB SF (validation run).
> Spark SQL has right answer but in wrong order (and there is an 'order by' in the query).
> Actual results:
> {noformat}
> [AAAAAAAABLEIBAAA,Paula,Wakefield]
> [AAAAAAAADFIEBAAA,John,Gray]
> [AAAAAAAAOCLBBAAA,null,null]
> [AAAAAAAAPKBCBAAA,Andrea,White]
> [AAAAAAAAEJDLAAAA,Alice,Wright]
> [AAAAAAAAFACEAAAA,Priscilla,Miller]
> [AAAAAAAALFKKAAAA,Ignacio,Miller]
> [AAAAAAAALJNCBAAA,George,Gamez]
> [AAAAAAAALIOPAAAA,Derek,Allen]
> [AAAAAAAAEADJAAAA,Ruth,Carroll]
> [AAAAAAAAJGMMAAAA,Richard,Larson]
> [AAAAAAAAPKIKAAAA,Wendy,Horvath]
> [AAAAAAAAFJHFAAAA,Larissa,Roy]
> [AAAAAAAAEPOGAAAA,Felisha,Mendes]
> [AAAAAAAAEKJLAAAA,Aisha,Carlson]
> [AAAAAAAAHNFHAAAA,Rebecca,Wilson]
> [AAAAAAAAIBFCBAAA,Ruth,Grantham]
> [AAAAAAAAOPDLAAAA,Ann,Pence]
> [AAAAAAAANIPLAAAA,Eric,Lawrence]
> [AAAAAAAAOCICAAAA,Zachary,Pennington]
> [AAAAAAAAOFLCAAAA,James,Taylor]
> [AAAAAAAAGEHIAAAA,Tyler,Miller]
> [AAAAAAAACADPAAAA,Cristobal,Thomas]
> [AAAAAAAAJIALAAAA,Santos,Gutierrez]
> [AAAAAAAAPMMBBAAA,Paul,Jordan]
> [AAAAAAAADIIOAAAA,David,Carroll]
> [AAAAAAAADFKABAAA,Latoya,Craft]
> [AAAAAAAAHMOIAAAA,Grace,Henderson]
> [AAAAAAAAPPIBBAAA,Candice,Lee]
> [AAAAAAAAJONHBAAA,Warren,Orozco]
> [AAAAAAAAGNDAAAAA,Terry,Mcdowell]
> [AAAAAAAACIJMAAAA,Elizabeth,Thomas]
> [AAAAAAAADIJGBAAA,Ruth,Sanders]
> [AAAAAAAANFBDBAAA,Vernice,Fernandez]
> [AAAAAAAAIDKFAAAA,Michael,Mack]
> [AAAAAAAAIMHBAAAA,Kathy,Knowles]
> [AAAAAAAALHMCAAAA,Brooke,Nelson]
> [AAAAAAAACFCGBAAA,Marcus,Sanders]
> [AAAAAAAANJHCBAAA,Christopher,Schreiber]
> [AAAAAAAAPDFBAAAA,Terrance,Banks]
> [AAAAAAAAANFAAAAA,Philip,Banks]
> [AAAAAAAAIADEBAAA,Diane,Aldridge]
> [AAAAAAAAICHFAAAA,Linda,Mccoy]
> [AAAAAAAACFENAAAA,Christopher,Dawson]
> [AAAAAAAAKOJJAAAA,Gracie,Mendoza]
> [AAAAAAAAFOJAAAAA,Don,Castillo]
> [AAAAAAAAFGPGAAAA,Albert,Wadsworth]
> [AAAAAAAAKJBKAAAA,Georgia,Scott]
> [AAAAAAAAEKFPAAAA,Annika,Chin]
> [AAAAAAAAIBAEBAAA,Sandra,Wilson]
> [AAAAAAAAMFFLAAAA,Margret,Gray]
> [AAAAAAAAKNAKAAAA,Gladys,Banks]
> [AAAAAAAACJDIAAAA,James,Kerr]
> [AAAAAAAAOBADBAAA,Elizabeth,Burnham]
> [AAAAAAAAAMGDAAAA,Kenneth,Harlan]
> [AAAAAAAAHJLAAAAA,Audrey,Beltran]
> [AAAAAAAAAOPFBAAA,Jerry,Fields]
> [AAAAAAAACNAGBAAA,Virginia,May]
> [AAAAAAAAHGOABAAA,Sonia,White]
> [AAAAAAAAKBCABAAA,Debra,Bell]
> [AAAAAAAANJAGAAAA,Allen,Hood]
> [AAAAAAAAMMOBBAAA,Margaret,Smith]
> [AAAAAAAANGDBBAAA,Carlos,Jewell]
> [AAAAAAAAFOGIAAAA,Michelle,Greene]
> [AAAAAAAAJEKFBAAA,Norma,Burkholder]
> [AAAAAAAAOCAJAAAA,Jenna,Staton]
> [AAAAAAAAPFCLAAAA,Felicia,Neville]
> [AAAAAAAADLHBBAAA,Henry,Bertrand]
> [AAAAAAAADBEFBAAA,Bennie,Bowers]
> [AAAAAAAADCKOAAAA,Robert,Gonzalez]
> [AAAAAAAAKKGEAAAA,Katie,Dunbar]
> [AAAAAAAAGFMDBAAA,Kathleen,Gibson]
> [AAAAAAAAIJEMAAAA,Charlie,Cummings]
> [AAAAAAAAKJBLAAAA,Kerry,Davis]
> [AAAAAAAAJKBNAAAA,Julie,Kern]
> [AAAAAAAAMDCAAAAA,Louann,Hamel]
> [AAAAAAAAEOAKAAAA,Molly,Benjamin]
> [AAAAAAAAIBHHAAAA,Jennifer,Ballard]
> [AAAAAAAAPJENAAAA,Ashley,Norton]
> [AAAAAAAAKLHHBAAA,Manuel,Castaneda]
> [AAAAAAAAIMHHBAAA,Lillian,Davidson]
> [AAAAAAAAGHPBBAAA,Nick,Mendez]
> [AAAAAAAABNBBAAAA,Irma,Smith]
> [AAAAAAAAFBAHAAAA,Michael,Williams]
> [AAAAAAAAPEHEBAAA,Edith,Molina]
> [AAAAAAAAFMHIAAAA,Emilio,Darling]
> [AAAAAAAAKAECAAAA,Milton,Mackey]
> [AAAAAAAAOCDJAAAA,Nina,Sanchez]
> [AAAAAAAAFGIGAAAA,Eduardo,Miller]
> [AAAAAAAAFHACBAAA,null,null]
> [AAAAAAAAHMJNAAAA,Ryan,Baptiste]
> [AAAAAAAAHHCABAAA,William,Stewart]
> {noformat}
> Expected results:
> {noformat}
> +------------------+---------------------+--------------------+
> | CUSTOMER_ID | CUSTOMER_FIRST_NAME | CUSTOMER_LAST_NAME |
> +------------------+---------------------+--------------------+
> | AAAAAAAAAMGDAAAA | Kenneth | Harlan |
> | AAAAAAAAANFAAAAA | Philip | Banks |
> | AAAAAAAAAOPFBAAA | Jerry | Fields |
> | AAAAAAAABLEIBAAA | Paula | Wakefield |
> | AAAAAAAABNBBAAAA | Irma | Smith |
> | AAAAAAAACADPAAAA | Cristobal | Thomas |
> | AAAAAAAACFCGBAAA | Marcus | Sanders |
> | AAAAAAAACFENAAAA | Christopher | Dawson |
> | AAAAAAAACIJMAAAA | Elizabeth | Thomas |
> | AAAAAAAACJDIAAAA | James | Kerr |
> | AAAAAAAACNAGBAAA | Virginia | May |
> | AAAAAAAADBEFBAAA | Bennie | Bowers |
> | AAAAAAAADCKOAAAA | Robert | Gonzalez |
> | AAAAAAAADFIEBAAA | John | Gray |
> | AAAAAAAADFKABAAA | Latoya | Craft |
> | AAAAAAAADIIOAAAA | David | Carroll |
> | AAAAAAAADIJGBAAA | Ruth | Sanders |
> | AAAAAAAADLHBBAAA | Henry | Bertrand |
> | AAAAAAAAEADJAAAA | Ruth | Carroll |
> | AAAAAAAAEJDLAAAA | Alice | Wright |
> | AAAAAAAAEKFPAAAA | Annika | Chin |
> | AAAAAAAAEKJLAAAA | Aisha | Carlson |
> | AAAAAAAAEOAKAAAA | Molly | Benjamin |
> | AAAAAAAAEPOGAAAA | Felisha | Mendes |
> | AAAAAAAAFACEAAAA | Priscilla | Miller |
> | AAAAAAAAFBAHAAAA | Michael | Williams |
> | AAAAAAAAFGIGAAAA | Eduardo | Miller |
> | AAAAAAAAFGPGAAAA | Albert | Wadsworth |
> | AAAAAAAAFHACBAAA | [NULL] | [NULL] |
> | AAAAAAAAFJHFAAAA | Larissa | Roy |
> | AAAAAAAAFMHIAAAA | Emilio | Darling |
> | AAAAAAAAFOGIAAAA | Michelle | Greene |
> | AAAAAAAAFOJAAAAA | Don | Castillo |
> | AAAAAAAAGEHIAAAA | Tyler | Miller |
> | AAAAAAAAGFMDBAAA | Kathleen | Gibson |
> | AAAAAAAAGHPBBAAA | Nick | Mendez |
> | AAAAAAAAGNDAAAAA | Terry | Mcdowell |
> | AAAAAAAAHGOABAAA | Sonia | White |
> | AAAAAAAAHHCABAAA | William | Stewart |
> | AAAAAAAAHJLAAAAA | Audrey | Beltran |
> | AAAAAAAAHMJNAAAA | Ryan | Baptiste |
> | AAAAAAAAHMOIAAAA | Grace | Henderson |
> | AAAAAAAAHNFHAAAA | Rebecca | Wilson |
> | AAAAAAAAIADEBAAA | Diane | Aldridge |
> | AAAAAAAAIBAEBAAA | Sandra | Wilson |
> | AAAAAAAAIBFCBAAA | Ruth | Grantham |
> | AAAAAAAAIBHHAAAA | Jennifer | Ballard |
> | AAAAAAAAICHFAAAA | Linda | Mccoy |
> | AAAAAAAAIDKFAAAA | Michael | Mack |
> | AAAAAAAAIJEMAAAA | Charlie | Cummings |
> | AAAAAAAAIMHBAAAA | Kathy | Knowles |
> | AAAAAAAAIMHHBAAA | Lillian | Davidson |
> | AAAAAAAAJEKFBAAA | Norma | Burkholder |
> | AAAAAAAAJGMMAAAA | Richard | Larson |
> | AAAAAAAAJIALAAAA | Santos | Gutierrez |
> | AAAAAAAAJKBNAAAA | Julie | Kern |
> | AAAAAAAAJONHBAAA | Warren | Orozco |
> | AAAAAAAAKAECAAAA | Milton | Mackey |
> | AAAAAAAAKBCABAAA | Debra | Bell |
> | AAAAAAAAKJBKAAAA | Georgia | Scott |
> | AAAAAAAAKJBLAAAA | Kerry | Davis |
> | AAAAAAAAKKGEAAAA | Katie | Dunbar |
> | AAAAAAAAKLHHBAAA | Manuel | Castaneda |
> | AAAAAAAAKNAKAAAA | Gladys | Banks |
> | AAAAAAAAKOJJAAAA | Gracie | Mendoza |
> | AAAAAAAALFKKAAAA | Ignacio | Miller |
> | AAAAAAAALHMCAAAA | Brooke | Nelson |
> | AAAAAAAALIOPAAAA | Derek | Allen |
> | AAAAAAAALJNCBAAA | George | Gamez |
> | AAAAAAAAMDCAAAAA | Louann | Hamel |
> | AAAAAAAAMFFLAAAA | Margret | Gray |
> | AAAAAAAAMMOBBAAA | Margaret | Smith |
> | AAAAAAAANFBDBAAA | Vernice | Fernandez |
> | AAAAAAAANGDBBAAA | Carlos | Jewell |
> | AAAAAAAANIPLAAAA | Eric | Lawrence |
> | AAAAAAAANJAGAAAA | Allen | Hood |
> | AAAAAAAANJHCBAAA | Christopher | Schreiber |
> | AAAAAAAAOBADBAAA | Elizabeth | Burnham |
> | AAAAAAAAOCAJAAAA | Jenna | Staton |
> | AAAAAAAAOCDJAAAA | Nina | Sanchez |
> | AAAAAAAAOCICAAAA | Zachary | Pennington |
> | AAAAAAAAOCLBBAAA | [NULL] | [NULL] |
> | AAAAAAAAOFLCAAAA | James | Taylor |
> | AAAAAAAAOPDLAAAA | Ann | Pence |
> | AAAAAAAAPDFBAAAA | Terrance | Banks |
> | AAAAAAAAPEHEBAAA | Edith | Molina |
> | AAAAAAAAPFCLAAAA | Felicia | Neville |
> | AAAAAAAAPJENAAAA | Ashley | Norton |
> | AAAAAAAAPKBCBAAA | Andrea | White |
> | AAAAAAAAPKIKAAAA | Wendy | Horvath |
> | AAAAAAAAPMMBBAAA | Paul | Jordan |
> | AAAAAAAAPPIBBAAA | Candice | Lee |
> +------------------+---------------------+--------------------+
> {noformat}
> Query used:
> {noformat}
> -- start query 74 in stream 0 using template query74.tpl and seed QUALIFICATION
> with year_total as (
> select c_customer_id customer_id
> ,c_first_name customer_first_name
> ,c_last_name customer_last_name
> ,d_year as year
> ,sum(ss_net_paid) year_total
> ,'s' sale_type
> from customer
> ,store_sales
> ,date_dim
> where c_customer_sk = ss_customer_sk
> and ss_sold_date_sk = d_date_sk
> and d_year in (2001,2001+1)
> group by c_customer_id
> ,c_first_name
> ,c_last_name
> ,d_year
> union all
> select c_customer_id customer_id
> ,c_first_name customer_first_name
> ,c_last_name customer_last_name
> ,d_year as year
> ,sum(ws_net_paid) year_total
> ,'w' sale_type
> from customer
> ,web_sales
> ,date_dim
> where c_customer_sk = ws_bill_customer_sk
> and ws_sold_date_sk = d_date_sk
> and d_year in (2001,2001+1)
> group by c_customer_id
> ,c_first_name
> ,c_last_name
> ,d_year
> )
> select
> t_s_secyear.customer_id, t_s_secyear.customer_first_name, t_s_secyear.customer_last_name
> from year_total t_s_firstyear
> ,year_total t_s_secyear
> ,year_total t_w_firstyear
> ,year_total t_w_secyear
> where t_s_secyear.customer_id = t_s_firstyear.customer_id
> and t_s_firstyear.customer_id = t_w_secyear.customer_id
> and t_s_firstyear.customer_id = t_w_firstyear.customer_id
> and t_s_firstyear.sale_type = 's'
> and t_w_firstyear.sale_type = 'w'
> and t_s_secyear.sale_type = 's'
> and t_w_secyear.sale_type = 'w'
> and t_s_firstyear.year = 2001
> and t_s_secyear.year = 2001+1
> and t_w_firstyear.year = 2001
> and t_w_secyear.year = 2001+1
> and t_s_firstyear.year_total > 0
> and t_w_firstyear.year_total > 0
> and case when t_w_firstyear.year_total > 0 then t_w_secyear.year_total / t_w_firstyear.year_total else null end
> > case when t_s_firstyear.year_total > 0 then t_s_secyear.year_total / t_s_firstyear.year_total else null end
> order by 1,1,1
> limit 100;
> -- end query 74 in stream 0 using template query74.tpl
> {noformat}
--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.3.4#6332)
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: issues-unsubscribe@spark.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: issues-help@spark.apache.org