JIRA comments go to the wrong list?

["Adrian A." <a....@googlemail.com>]

Hi,

It looks like the JIRA comments are not posted to the "dev list", nor do
"dev" comments get posted back to the corresponding JIRA issue.

They seem to go to the "commit" list since the "jira new migration" :(.

Could you fix this please?
(it was working so nice before)

Thank you,

A.

Re: JIRA comments go to the wrong list?

["Adrian A." <a....@googlemail.com>]

>
> All you have to do is subscribe to the commit list in addition to the dev
> list.
> Same result, greater control over the process.

Well I was using GMane to look at the progress (but your commit list is not
mapped there :( ),
since it's very easy to see everything when it's nicely threaded (it's also
much faster).

Also I had no idea to subscribe(for posting) to that commit list and for
such a purpose, since on your website:
http://cayenne.apache.org/mailing-lists.html
it clear states that it is for SVN :).
(the SVN commit messages however are much more simpler and faster visible
with a decent SVN client, so a mailing list for this was highly inefficient
for me :) )

A.

Re: JIRA comments go to the wrong list?

[Mike Kienenberger <mk...@gmail.com>]

All you have to do is subscribe to the commit list in addition to the dev list.
Same result, greater control over the process.

On Fri, Mar 27, 2009 at 9:20 AM, Adrian A. <a....@googlemail.com> wrote:
>>
>> There was a discussion on that here,
>>
> and the majority decided that commits list is where the Jira mailings should
>> go.
>
> Could you point me to that discussion (and maybe the voting)?
>
>
>> So this behavior is intentional.
>
> From my point of view it is not efficient :(.
>
> Of course, not all JIRA notifications should go to the dev list - only
> 'creation'
> and 'comments' to issues, since they are a part of the discussion (and of
> course replying on the list to them to be attached automatically to the
> issue).
>
> This was very simple and efficient to follow the progress of Cayenne.
>
> Thank you,
>
> A.
>

Re: JIRA comments go to the wrong list?

["Adrian A." <a....@googlemail.com>]

>
> There was a discussion on that here,
>
and the majority decided that commits list is where the Jira mailings should
> go.

Could you point me to that discussion (and maybe the voting)?


> So this behavior is intentional.

>From my point of view it is not efficient :(.

Of course, not all JIRA notifications should go to the dev list - only
'creation'
and 'comments' to issues, since they are a part of the discussion (and of
course replying on the list to them to be attached automatically to the
issue).

This was very simple and efficient to follow the progress of Cayenne.

Thank you,

A.

Re: JIRA comments go to the wrong list?

[Andrus Adamchik <an...@objectstyle.org>]

There was a discussion on that here, and the majority decided that  
commits list is where the Jira mailings should go. So this behavior is  
intentional.

Cheers,
Andrus

On Mar 27, 2009, at 1:15 PM, Adrian A. wrote:

> Hi,
>
> It looks like the JIRA comments are not posted to the "dev list",  
> nor do
> "dev" comments get posted back to the corresponding JIRA issue.
>
> They seem to go to the "commit" list since the "jira new migration" : 
> (.
>
> Could you fix this please?
> (it was working so nice before)
>
> Thank you,
>
> A.