You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to soap-dev@xml.apache.org by Ranjit Goray <ra...@zsyndicate.com> on 2001/07/31 07:21:48 UTC

SOAP Question

SOAP Questions :


1.How is SOAP different from the Ariba and Commerce One Standards of cXML etc?

2.What is the relationship between COM Plus and SOAP?

3.What is the relationship between ebXML and SOAP?

4.At what layer in the OSI stack does SOAP run?

5.What is a Client Stub/ Server Stub? (In RPC)

6.How is SOAP different from traditional RPC? If I ran traditional RPC over HTTP with XML as the encoding mechanism would this be SOAP??

7.Is SOAP able to handle binaries? Other XML protocols cXML etc usually don't?

8.Does Different SOAP Implementations mean that a Microsoft SOAP -enabled application and an Apache SOAP-enabled application will not be able to talk with each other?



Regards,
 
Ranjit Goray
zSyndicate India.
operating as (Buzz Software Pvt Ltd)
G/36 , Shanti Kunj,
S.V. Road, Pune - 411 001
Tel     : 91 20 605604/6125608
Fax    : 91 20 6125608 
Email : ranjit@zsyndicate.com

Re: SOAP Question

Posted by Ram Sadasiv <rs...@quantumstream.com>.
> Ranjit Goray wrote:
> 
> SOAP Questions :
> 
> 
> 1.How is SOAP different from the Ariba and Commerce One Standards of
> cXML etc?
>
SOAP is an encoding and transport mechanism.  The data payload could be
cXML, or any other datatype which can be encoded as XML (there is also a
spec for binary attachments).
 
> 2.What is the relationship between COM Plus and SOAP?
>
I believe that .Net will allow you to make DCOM calls over SOAP, but
there is no direct relationship.
 
> 3.What is the relationship between ebXML and SOAP?
>
ebXML is a higer level specification, covering things like data formats
(porting EDI to XML) and security.
 
> 4.At what layer in the OSI stack does SOAP run?
>
I guess it would be at the application layer.  The actual tcp protocol
is implementation dependent, but the most common protocol is http.
 
> 5.What is a Client Stub/ Server Stub? (In RPC)
>
Stubs mask the complexities of distributed execution.  Most
compilers/interpreters assume that all program elements exist in the
same memory space.  A stub is a representation (proxy) of the remote
object in local memory.
 
> 6.How is SOAP different from traditional RPC? If I ran traditional RPC
> over HTTP with XML as the encoding mechanism would this be SOAP??
>
There is another spec, called XML-RPC, which does this.  SOAP is much
more loosly coupled than traditional RPC.

 
> 7.Is SOAP able to handle binaries? Other XML protocols cXML etc
> usually don’t?
>
You can send an array of bytes as an attachment.  It is recommended that
the implementations use base64 encoding to transport these bytes.
 
> 8.Does Different SOAP Implementations mean that a Microsoft SOAP
> –enabled application and an Apache SOAP-enabled application will not
> be able to talk with each other?
> 
No, MS-SOAP and Apache SOAP can interoperate.  It's sort of the whole
idea.

For more information on SOAP, you should check out the spec at
http://www.w3.org/TR/soap12 and the Apache documentation at
http://xml.apache.org/soap/docs/index.html.  For MS-Soap and Apache SOAP
interoperability, check
http://xml.apache.org/soap/docs/guide/interop.html.


Hope this helps,

Ram Sadasiv