You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to solr-user@lucene.apache.org by Shawn Heisey <so...@elyograg.org> on 2010/03/12 15:44:30 UTC

A bunch of questions

Does SolrCloud's notion of a "collection", which appears to use cores, 
override normal multi-core usage for building an offline index and 
quickly swapping it into production?  Some of the features in SolrCloud 
look useful, if it's still possible to exert manual control over cores 
and shards.  Are there plans to merge the cloud branch into trunk, and 
if so, will this happen before 1.5 comes out?

I get the impression that version 1.4 is being quickly left in the dust 
by the 1.5 development effort.  As far as I can tell nobody is trying to 
even put a ballpark on when 1.5 will be frozen or released.  Is it 
recommended at this point to use 1.5 from trunk over 1.4?  Is there a 
1.4.1 coming soon that fixes the known bugs?

 From what I've read so far, it seems that it should be possible to 
hardlink the contents of the index directory to another core, add/update 
records, optionally re-optimize it, warm it, and then swap it into 
production.  Is this accurate?

A minor thing - is there any way to make Thunderbird 3 stop turning 
sequences of a caret followed by a number into nice-looking exponents?  
For weeks I've been wondering what everyone meant by putting exponents 
in their config descriptions, then the other day I got a look at the 
actual text of a message and the light went on.

Thanks,
Shawn


Re: A bunch of questions

Posted by Mark Miller <ma...@gmail.com>.
On 03/12/2010 09:44 AM, Shawn Heisey wrote:
>  Does SolrCloud's notion of a "collection", which appears to use
>  cores, override normal multi-core usage for building an offline index
>  and quickly swapping it into production?

A collection will normally be composed of multiple cores. By default 
right now, a cores name is the collection name, but that's mainly for 
simplifying basic demo bootstrap type situations. You can fire up two 
instances of Solr and by default you will have two cores that are part 
of collection1.


>  Some of the features in SolrCloud look useful, if it's still possible
>  to exert manual control over cores and shards.

To my knowledge you don't lose any control. You only gain features.

>  Are there plans to merge the cloud branch into trunk, and if so, will
>  this happen before 1.5 comes out?

Things like this are hard to predict. It would be nice to get more 
people trying out SolrCloud so that its a bit more battle tested.

>
>  I get the impression that version 1.4 is being quickly left in the
>  dust by the 1.5 development effort.

Isn't that always the case ;)

>  As far as I can tell nobody is trying to even put a ballpark on when
>  1.5 will be frozen or released.  Is it recommended at this point to
>  use 1.5 from trunk over 1.4?

Always a personal decision. A lot of people used 1.4 trunk. We try to 
keep trunk fairly stable.

>  Is there a 1.4.1 coming soon that fixes the known bugs?

Do we have a lot of bugs at this point? I have not really payed 
attention. If so, perhaps we should consider a 1.4.1 soon.

>
>  From what I've read so far, it seems that it should be possible to
>  hardlink the contents of the index directory to another core,
>  add/update records, optionally re-optimize it, warm it, and then swap
>  it into production.  Is this accurate?

Yeah, this is doable - but Solr already does that for you does it not? 
While you add update documents, a point in time Searcher is still 
serving requests. You can also add warming queries that will warm a new 
Searcher while the old one is still serving queries, and its swapped in 
when its ready.

>
>  A minor thing - is there any way to make Thunderbird 3 stop turning
>  sequences of a caret followed by a number into nice-looking
>  exponents?  For weeks I've been wondering what everyone meant by
>  putting exponents in their config descriptions, then the other day I
>  got a look at the actual text of a message and the light went on.

I use thunderbird 3, but I can't say I've noticed this yet.

>
>  Thanks, Shawn
>


-- 
- Mark

http://www.lucidimagination.com