You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@spamassassin.apache.org by Ronan <r....@qub.ac.uk> on 2004/11/11 16:52:44 UTC

sa-kearn default mail format

what format does sa-learn expect mail to be in.
I tried to feed it a 2meg standard unix email file of my spam folder and 
it only registered it as one email but with 4000 tokens...

Anyone... there is nothing in hte man [page about it

ronan
-- 
Regards

Ronan McGlue
==============
Analyst/Programmer
Information Services
Queens University Belfast
BT7 1NN

Re: sa-kearn default mail format

Posted by Jim Maul <jm...@elih.org>.
Ronan wrote:
> yeah i read that line too, but i was unfamiliar with the unix standard 
> file format being categorised as mbox
> 
> sarcasm much appreciated though
> 
> ronan
> 
> Jim Maul wrote:
> 
>> Ronan wrote:
>>
>>> what format does sa-learn expect mail to be in.
>>> I tried to feed it a 2meg standard unix email file of my spam folder 
>>> and it only registered it as one email but with 4000 tokens...
>>>
>>> Anyone... there is nothing in hte man [page about it
>>>
>>> ronan
>>
>>
>>
>> You probably want:
>>
>>  --mbox                            Input sources are in mbox format
>>
>> which in fact is from the man page.
>>
>> -Jim
> 
> 

There was no sarcasm intended.  I was merely stating that what you were 
looking for was actually in the man page despite what you had originally 
thought.

-Jim

Re: sa-kearn default mail format

Posted by Ronan <r....@qub.ac.uk>.
yeah i read that line too, but i was unfamiliar with the unix standard 
file format being categorised as mbox

sarcasm much appreciated though

ronan

Jim Maul wrote:

> Ronan wrote:
> 
>> what format does sa-learn expect mail to be in.
>> I tried to feed it a 2meg standard unix email file of my spam folder 
>> and it only registered it as one email but with 4000 tokens...
>>
>> Anyone... there is nothing in hte man [page about it
>>
>> ronan
> 
> 
> You probably want:
> 
>  --mbox                            Input sources are in mbox format
> 
> which in fact is from the man page.
> 
> -Jim

-- 
Regards

Ronan McGlue
==============
Analyst/Programmer
Information Services
Queens University Belfast
BT7 1NN

Re: sa-kearn default mail format

Posted by Jim Maul <jm...@elih.org>.
Ronan wrote:
> what format does sa-learn expect mail to be in.
> I tried to feed it a 2meg standard unix email file of my spam folder and 
> it only registered it as one email but with 4000 tokens...
> 
> Anyone... there is nothing in hte man [page about it
> 
> ronan

You probably want:

  --mbox                            Input sources are in mbox format

which in fact is from the man page.

-Jim

Re: sa-kearn default mail format

Posted by Matt Kettler <mk...@evi-inc.com>.
At 10:52 AM 11/11/2004, Ronan wrote:
>what format does sa-learn expect mail to be in.
>I tried to feed it a 2meg standard unix email file of my spam folder and 
>it only registered it as one email but with 4000 tokens...
>
>Anyone... there is nothing in hte man [page about it

by default, sa-learn assumes that any files passed in each contian a single 
email in rfc 822 format. It assumes that any directories are maildirs.

You're probably passing a unix mailbox file, instead of a unix email file 
(note a mailbox is not an email, but contains several)

If you are passing unix mailbox files, you need --mbox as a parameter to 
sa-learn.

Some unix tools, such as UW imap, generate a variant mailbox format that is 
supported by using --mbx. If --mbox causes problems, try --mbx.

(note: despite using .mbx file extensions, mozilla appears to use mbox 
format, but it's not 100% clear if it's just a name change or if they 
really did change formats after 1.0)