[DISCUSS] Release SAAJ 1.3 spec jar version 1.0.1

[Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net>]

There are some issues with the maven generated site.  These aren't new 
problems and they are "doc" related ... so I'm not sure if they should 
really hinder the spec release.

I just started looking into them since I had some of the same problems 
with the recent samples 2.1.2 release (BTW ... not all of those issues 
were resolved either before we released).

- The Geronimo banner isn't included.  I think we need to make some 
updates to the spec-parent site.xml (and pom.xml) and do a new release 
of the specs-parent to fix this issue.  However, on my local image some 
of the same changes that I made in samples to resolve this are not 
providing the same magic for specs ... still looking into this.

- There are multiple links in the banner to Geronimo (on the right) and 
none of them take you to the Geronimo home page.  Once again, I think 
this might require some changes to the site.xml in spec-parent to fix it.

Joe

Re: [DISCUSS] Release SAAJ 1.3 spec jar version 1.0.1

[Jarek Gawor <jg...@gmail.com>]

On Mon, Oct 13, 2008 at 1:02 PM, Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net> wrote:
>
> One more question:  Has any tck validation been performed for this updated
> spec?
>

Yes. Geronimo trunk was updated to use the SNAPSHOT of the spec with
the fix and so TCK was/is running with it.

Jarek

Re: [DISCUSS] Release SAAJ 1.3 spec jar version 1.0.1

[Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net>]

NP ... when you mentioned you might be releasing saaj I just thought it 
might be a good time to try to get this cleaned up too.  Since we've 
been releasing effectively without sites (or broken sites) for some time 
now I don't think it should hinder the vote.  I just thought I'd mention 
the problem since you did include the site in the vote.

One more question:  Has any tck validation been performed for this 
updated spec?

Joe


Jarek Gawor wrote:
> Doh! You did mention this issue to me before and I totally forgot. Now
> I'm not sure what to do. Maybe we could release the artifacts without
> the site?
> 
> Jarek
> 
> On Mon, Oct 13, 2008 at 11:19 AM, Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net> wrote:
>> There are some issues with the maven generated site.  These aren't new
>> problems and they are "doc" related ... so I'm not sure if they should
>> really hinder the spec release.
>>
>> I just started looking into them since I had some of the same problems with
>> the recent samples 2.1.2 release (BTW ... not all of those issues were
>> resolved either before we released).
>>
>> - The Geronimo banner isn't included.  I think we need to make some updates
>> to the spec-parent site.xml (and pom.xml) and do a new release of the
>> specs-parent to fix this issue.  However, on my local image some of the same
>> changes that I made in samples to resolve this are not providing the same
>> magic for specs ... still looking into this.
>>
>> - There are multiple links in the banner to Geronimo (on the right) and none
>> of them take you to the Geronimo home page.  Once again, I think this might
>> require some changes to the site.xml in spec-parent to fix it.
>>
>> Joe
>>
> 

Re: [DISCUSS] Release SAAJ 1.3 spec jar version 1.0.1

[Jarek Gawor <jg...@gmail.com>]

Doh! You did mention this issue to me before and I totally forgot. Now
I'm not sure what to do. Maybe we could release the artifacts without
the site?

Jarek

On Mon, Oct 13, 2008 at 11:19 AM, Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net> wrote:
> There are some issues with the maven generated site.  These aren't new
> problems and they are "doc" related ... so I'm not sure if they should
> really hinder the spec release.
>
> I just started looking into them since I had some of the same problems with
> the recent samples 2.1.2 release (BTW ... not all of those issues were
> resolved either before we released).
>
> - The Geronimo banner isn't included.  I think we need to make some updates
> to the spec-parent site.xml (and pom.xml) and do a new release of the
> specs-parent to fix this issue.  However, on my local image some of the same
> changes that I made in samples to resolve this are not providing the same
> magic for specs ... still looking into this.
>
> - There are multiple links in the banner to Geronimo (on the right) and none
> of them take you to the Geronimo home page.  Once again, I think this might
> require some changes to the site.xml in spec-parent to fix it.
>
> Joe
>

Re: [DISCUSS] Release SAAJ 1.3 spec jar version 1.0.1

[Donald Woods <dw...@apache.org>]

Doesn't seem worth holding up the release, given the problem existed before.


-Donald


Joe Bohn wrote:
> There are some issues with the maven generated site.  These aren't new 
> problems and they are "doc" related ... so I'm not sure if they should 
> really hinder the spec release.
> 
> I just started looking into them since I had some of the same problems 
> with the recent samples 2.1.2 release (BTW ... not all of those issues 
> were resolved either before we released).
> 
> - The Geronimo banner isn't included.  I think we need to make some 
> updates to the spec-parent site.xml (and pom.xml) and do a new release 
> of the specs-parent to fix this issue.  However, on my local image some 
> of the same changes that I made in samples to resolve this are not 
> providing the same magic for specs ... still looking into this.
> 
> - There are multiple links in the banner to Geronimo (on the right) and 
> none of them take you to the Geronimo home page.  Once again, I think 
> this might require some changes to the site.xml in spec-parent to fix it.
> 
> Joe
> 

Re: [DISCUSS] Release SAAJ 1.3 spec jar version 1.0.1

[Lin Sun <li...@gmail.com>]

Sorry...sent to the wrong thread accidentally. ;-(

Lin

On Mon, Oct 13, 2008 at 1:14 PM, Lin Sun <li...@gmail.com> wrote:
> +1
>
> Lin
>
> On Mon, Oct 13, 2008 at 11:19 AM, Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net> wrote:
>> There are some issues with the maven generated site.  These aren't new
>> problems and they are "doc" related ... so I'm not sure if they should
>> really hinder the spec release.
>>
>> I just started looking into them since I had some of the same problems with
>> the recent samples 2.1.2 release (BTW ... not all of those issues were
>> resolved either before we released).
>>
>> - The Geronimo banner isn't included.  I think we need to make some updates
>> to the spec-parent site.xml (and pom.xml) and do a new release of the
>> specs-parent to fix this issue.  However, on my local image some of the same
>> changes that I made in samples to resolve this are not providing the same
>> magic for specs ... still looking into this.
>>
>> - There are multiple links in the banner to Geronimo (on the right) and none
>> of them take you to the Geronimo home page.  Once again, I think this might
>> require some changes to the site.xml in spec-parent to fix it.
>>
>> Joe
>>
>

Re: [DISCUSS] Release SAAJ 1.3 spec jar version 1.0.1

[Lin Sun <li...@gmail.com>]

+1

Lin

On Mon, Oct 13, 2008 at 11:19 AM, Joe Bohn <jo...@earthlink.net> wrote:
> There are some issues with the maven generated site.  These aren't new
> problems and they are "doc" related ... so I'm not sure if they should
> really hinder the spec release.
>
> I just started looking into them since I had some of the same problems with
> the recent samples 2.1.2 release (BTW ... not all of those issues were
> resolved either before we released).
>
> - The Geronimo banner isn't included.  I think we need to make some updates
> to the spec-parent site.xml (and pom.xml) and do a new release of the
> specs-parent to fix this issue.  However, on my local image some of the same
> changes that I made in samples to resolve this are not providing the same
> magic for specs ... still looking into this.
>
> - There are multiple links in the banner to Geronimo (on the right) and none
> of them take you to the Geronimo home page.  Once again, I think this might
> require some changes to the site.xml in spec-parent to fix it.
>
> Joe
>