You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@spamassassin.apache.org by Luis Daniel Lucio Quiroz <lu...@gmail.com> on 2009/11/13 04:41:36 UTC

Good reasons to dont use RBLs

Hi all,

Again me,  Well, in the security scope i use a principle that states that you 
souldnt use a lower layer solution to fix a higher one.  So SPAM is a Layer 7 
problem that is used to fixed with a Layer 3 solution (RBL).  

I'd like a brainstorm to convince that a RBL solution is not the best stoping 
SPAM, and we should look for L7 solution such as Bayes.

TIA

LD 

Re: Good reasons to dont use RBLs

Posted by Marc Perkel <ma...@perkel.com>.

Luis Daniel Lucio Quiroz wrote:
> Hi all,
>
> Again me,  Well, in the security scope i use a principle that states that you 
> souldnt use a lower layer solution to fix a higher one.  So SPAM is a Layer 7 
> problem that is used to fixed with a Layer 3 solution (RBL).  
>
> I'd like a brainstorm to convince that a RBL solution is not the best stoping 
> SPAM, and we should look for L7 solution such as Bayes.
>
> TIA
>
> LD 
>
>   

I use RBLs because they work. If something actually works I use it.


Re: Good reasons to dont use RBLs

Posted by mouss <mo...@ml.netoyen.net>.
Luis Daniel Lucio Quiroz a écrit :
> Hi all,
> 
> Again me,  Well, in the security scope i use a principle that states that you 
> souldnt use a lower layer solution to fix a higher one.  So SPAM is a Layer 7 
> problem that is used to fixed with a Layer 3 solution (RBL).  
> 
> I'd like a brainstorm to convince that a RBL solution is not the best stoping 
> SPAM, and we should look for L7 solution such as Bayes.
> 


If someone tries to guess a working login:pass on your server and does
this a thousand times in a short period, you will still let him continue
because passwords are L7 and the IP address is at L3?

if you want talking about principles, then "defence in depth" suggests
using all your levels to block attacks.

In short, segment your zones, your diagrams, your reports, but do not
segment your defences. When you hear "divide and conquer", divide the
problem, not your army. you still want to coordinate your defences so as
to increase their efficiency.

Besides, spam is at Layer PI (3.1415....) ;-p








Re: Good reasons to dont use RBLs

Posted by Benny Pedersen <me...@junc.org>.
On fre 13 nov 2009 04:41:36 CET, Luis Daniel Lucio Quiroz wrote
> I'd like a brainstorm to convince that a RBL solution is not the best stoping
> SPAM, and we should look for L7 solution such as Bayes.

and ip's is not part of bayes db ...

-- 
xpoint


Re: Good reasons to dont use RBLs

Posted by Bernd Petrovitsch <be...@firmix.at>.
Hi!

On Thu, 2009-11-12 at 21:41 -0600, Luis Daniel Lucio Quiroz wrote:
[...]
> Again me,  Well, in the security scope i use a principle that states that you 
> souldnt use a lower layer solution to fix a higher one.  So SPAM is a Layer 7 
> problem that is used to fixed with a Layer 3 solution (RBL).  
You are mistaken that RBLS *solve* the spam problem.
It's just one tool - and there others too like filtering
viruses/trojans, filtering at SMTP level (based on Mail-From: and
Rcpt-To:) and/or grepping for certain words in the contents (and the
list doesn't claim to be complete - or even extensive).

> I'd like a brainstorm to convince that a RBL solution is not the best stoping 
RBLs as such can be a solution to stop the average botnet (because you
plain simply do not accept connections from host with a > 95% spam
history).
OF course, it's *Your* layer > 7 decision if and which RBL to use and/or
run your own (based on whatever data, e.g. on the results of your Bayes
filter?!).

> SPAM, and we should look for L7 solution such as Bayes.
Bayes is only statistics - nothing else. I don't know on which layer
that lives in the OSI world.
And Bayes has other issues, e.g.
- how to handle false positives and false negatives and/or
- CPU and I/O performance f you have a real big mail server/cluster
  and/or
- what to do if you have a mailserver on each continent (with
  appropriate MX records for global high-abailability). How do I merge
  several Bayes-DBs?
And of course combinations thereof.

So please don't claim that RBLS are "the solution to spam" (or that such
"a solution to spam" even exists[0]) and do not talk people out from
using one or the other tool to fight spam.

	Bernd

[0]: IMHO there is one solution: Make email expensive enough that it
     doesn't pay off for the spammers. But - looking at my snail mailbox
     - spam won't go away or even get small enough to be acceptable. So
     the result will be just people won't use email because it's too
     expensive.
-- 
Firmix Software GmbH                   http://www.firmix.at/
mobil: +43 664 4416156                 fax: +43 1 7890849-55
          Embedded Linux Development and Services



Re: Good reasons to dont use RBLs

Posted by Arvid Picciani <ae...@exys.org>.
Luis Daniel Lucio Quiroz wrote:
> Hi all,
> 
> Again me,  Well, in the security scope i use a principle that states that you 
> souldnt use a lower layer solution to fix a higher one.  So SPAM is a Layer 7 
> problem that is used to fixed with a Layer 3 solution (RBL).  
> 
> I'd like a brainstorm to convince that a RBL solution is not the best stoping 
> SPAM, and we should look for L7 solution such as Bayes.
> 

SA has no effect on L3

-- 
Arvid
Asgaard Technologies

Re: Good reasons to dont use RBLs

Posted by Raymond Dijkxhoorn <ra...@prolocation.net>.
Hi!

> Again me,  Well, in the security scope i use a principle that states that you
> souldnt use a lower layer solution to fix a higher one.  So SPAM is a Layer 7
> problem that is used to fixed with a Layer 3 solution (RBL).
>
> I'd like a brainstorm to convince that a RBL solution is not the best stoping
> SPAM, and we should look for L7 solution such as Bayes.

Try this on a multi million user system and come back again :) You are 
most likely right but that wont fix your problem. If you think the way 
you do please redesign the mailsystem. Its a application issue, so with 
it there. Bayes is also not a solution, its preventing things afterwards. 
Fix it with the source, e-mail isnt designed for what its beeing used for 
today....

You can brainstorm, but it wont scale.

Bye,
Raymond.

Re: Good reasons to dont use RBLs

Posted by Raymond Dijkxhoorn <ra...@prolocation.net>.
Hi!

>> I reject the notion that spam is a L7 problem.

> It is more of a L8 problem... money.
>
> Warren

Or L9, users. In the end :)

Bye,
Raymond.

Re: Good reasons to dont use RBLs

Posted by Warren Togami <wt...@redhat.com>.
On 11/12/2009 10:50 PM, LuKreme wrote:
> On 12-Nov-2009, at 20:41, Luis Daniel Lucio Quiroz wrote:
>> I'd like a brainstorm to convince that a RBL solution is not the best stoping
>> SPAM, and we should look for L7 solution such as Bayes.
>
> I reject the notion that spam is a L7 problem.
>

It is more of a L8 problem... money.

Warren

Re: Good reasons to dont use RBLs

Posted by LuKreme <kr...@kreme.com>.
On 12-Nov-2009, at 20:41, Luis Daniel Lucio Quiroz wrote:
> I'd like a brainstorm to convince that a RBL solution is not the best stoping 
> SPAM, and we should look for L7 solution such as Bayes.

I reject the notion that spam is a L7 problem.


-- 
Ninety percent of true love is acute, ear-burning embarrassment.  --Wyrd Sisters