You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to issues@trafodion.apache.org by "Roberta Marton (JIRA)" <ji...@apache.org> on 2015/12/11 17:06:11 UTC
[jira] [Comment Edited] (TRAFODION-1507) Transition content from
Trafodion Wiki to Apache Trafodion Website
[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/TRAFODION-1507?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=15052923#comment-15052923 ]
Roberta Marton edited comment on TRAFODION-1507 at 12/11/15 4:05 PM:
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Several comments were made on the content that I will include here:
>From Carol Pearson with responses from Gunnar Tapper and Kevin Deyager:
***********************************************************************************************
After a fast review (clicked most all links, scanned but didn’t read all pages, did NOT try all the various sample scripts, tested with Edge and did not have my browser full-screened so I could spot any egregious wrapping issues), here’s what I see:
1) Contributor/Team list doesn’t include all contributors? (I have an ICLA and am not listed, otherwise I wouldn’t know whether it did or not… ). I believe we were waiting for Suresh. (NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
2) Do we need to add “incubating” anywhere to the description of Apache Trafodion? It’s on the front page and on every page at the bottom (NOT SURE) THIS IS FINE. NO CHANGE REQUIRED
3) Quickstart page is blank – should we hide this one, since we know it’s one of the early things people will see? (NON-BLOCKING) AT LEAST HAVE PLACEHOLDER – COMING SOON
4) Using-> Download (and download) page has bad link formatting: . Please refer to [Create Development Environment](create-dev-environment.html] (NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
5) Using -> Install has inconsistent capitalization from post “:” in the Preparation phase. (SOOOOOOOOO NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
6) Using -> Install has bad link formatting: Please refer to [Upgrading Trafodion](#Upgrading_Trafodion) before proceeding. (NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
7) Using -> Install : Troubleshooting and uninstall missing text. We’ll fill in later. (NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
8) Using -> Managing for Validate Trafodion Installation. Script doesn’t include DROP TABLE so table left dangling (SOOOOOOOOOO NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
9) Using -> Release Notes: Date on 1.3.0 First Apache Release should be “Pending” (NOT SURE) YES, CHANGE
10) Release notes for 1.3.0 – should these include JIRA number for Known Issues? (NON-BLOCKING) AGREE WITH NONBLOCKING, NOT SURE IF REQUIRED
11) Release notes for 1.1.0: Defect numbers are Launchpad numbers? (NON-BLOCKING) THERE FOR HISTORICAL REASONS. OK. NO NEED TO UPDATE.
12) Using Drop Down Menu: UDF API Tutorial: Bad link, gets “can’t reach” (NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
13) Features -> Architecture: Bad link, gets “can’t reach” (NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
14) Features -> ANSI Schemas and several others links to launchpad blueprints with old info (NOT SURE, Probably non-blocking) NONBOCKING
15) Features -> Repository points to the Trafodion.org wiki: https://wiki.trafodion.org/wiki/index.php/Trafodion_Manageability (NOT SURE) NONBOCKING
16) Features -> Trickle Load points to the Traofion.org wiki: https://wiki.trafodion.org/wiki/index.php/Data_Loading#Trickle_Loading_Data_Into_Trafodion_Tables (NOT SURE)
NONBOCKING
17) Features -> Backup and Restore points to the Trafodion.org wiki https://wiki.trafodion.org/wiki/index.php/Backup_and_Restore NOT SURE) NONBOCKING
18) Features -> Metadata Cleanup points to the Trafodion.org wiki: https://wiki.trafodion.org/wiki/index.php/Metadata_Cleanup NOT SURE) NONBOCKING
19) Contributing -> Merge goes to “can’t reach” (NON-BLOCKING)
20) Contributing -> Modifying Website is out of date on its publishing instructions, as we discussed this morning. (NON-BLOCKING)
was (Author: rmarton):
Several comments were made on the content that I will include here:
>From Keven Deyager with responses from Gunnar:
***********************************************************************************************
After a fast review (clicked most all links, scanned but didn’t read all pages, did NOT try all the various sample scripts, tested with Edge and did not have my browser full-screened so I could spot any egregious wrapping issues), here’s what I see:
1) Contributor/Team list doesn’t include all contributors? (I have an ICLA and am not listed, otherwise I wouldn’t know whether it did or not… ). I believe we were waiting for Suresh. (NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
2) Do we need to add “incubating” anywhere to the description of Apache Trafodion? It’s on the front page and on every page at the bottom (NOT SURE) THIS IS FINE. NO CHANGE REQUIRED
3) Quickstart page is blank – should we hide this one, since we know it’s one of the early things people will see? (NON-BLOCKING) AT LEAST HAVE PLACEHOLDER – COMING SOON
4) Using-> Download (and download) page has bad link formatting: . Please refer to [Create Development Environment](create-dev-environment.html] (NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
5) Using -> Install has inconsistent capitalization from post “:” in the Preparation phase. (SOOOOOOOOO NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
6) Using -> Install has bad link formatting: Please refer to [Upgrading Trafodion](#Upgrading_Trafodion) before proceeding. (NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
7) Using -> Install : Troubleshooting and uninstall missing text. We’ll fill in later. (NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
8) Using -> Managing for Validate Trafodion Installation. Script doesn’t include DROP TABLE so table left dangling (SOOOOOOOOOO NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
9) Using -> Release Notes: Date on 1.3.0 First Apache Release should be “Pending” (NOT SURE) YES, CHANGE
10) Release notes for 1.3.0 – should these include JIRA number for Known Issues? (NON-BLOCKING) AGREE WITH NONBLOCKING, NOT SURE IF REQUIRED
11) Release notes for 1.1.0: Defect numbers are Launchpad numbers? (NON-BLOCKING) THERE FOR HISTORICAL REASONS. OK. NO NEED TO UPDATE.
12) Using Drop Down Menu: UDF API Tutorial: Bad link, gets “can’t reach” (NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
13) Features -> Architecture: Bad link, gets “can’t reach” (NON-BLOCKING) AGREED
14) Features -> ANSI Schemas and several others links to launchpad blueprints with old info (NOT SURE, Probably non-blocking) NONBOCKING
15) Features -> Repository points to the Trafodion.org wiki: https://wiki.trafodion.org/wiki/index.php/Trafodion_Manageability (NOT SURE) NONBOCKING
16) Features -> Trickle Load points to the Traofion.org wiki: https://wiki.trafodion.org/wiki/index.php/Data_Loading#Trickle_Loading_Data_Into_Trafodion_Tables (NOT SURE)
NONBOCKING
17) Features -> Backup and Restore points to the Trafodion.org wiki https://wiki.trafodion.org/wiki/index.php/Backup_and_Restore NOT SURE) NONBOCKING
18) Features -> Metadata Cleanup points to the Trafodion.org wiki: https://wiki.trafodion.org/wiki/index.php/Metadata_Cleanup NOT SURE) NONBOCKING
19) Contributing -> Merge goes to “can’t reach” (NON-BLOCKING)
20) Contributing -> Modifying Website is out of date on its publishing instructions, as we discussed this morning. (NON-BLOCKING)
> Transition content from Trafodion Wiki to Apache Trafodion Website
> ------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: TRAFODION-1507
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/TRAFODION-1507
> Project: Apache Trafodion
> Issue Type: Improvement
> Components: documentation
> Affects Versions: 1.2-incubating
> Reporter: Carol Pearson
> Assignee: Gunnar Tapper
>
> Content on the Apache Trafodion Wiki should mostly be migrated to our web page for easier usage/search. We need to build out the website and migrate wiki content there, as well as building up clear guidelines for what content belongs on the Wiki
--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.3.4#6332)