You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@spamassassin.apache.org by Bowie Bailey <Bo...@BUC.com> on 2009/06/17 17:23:26 UTC
Hostkarma whitelist problem
I couldn't find any place on junkmailfilter website to report this, so
I'll put it here.
I received a 419 scam email with this whitelist hit:
* -3.0 RCVD_IN_JMF_W RBL: Sender listed in JMF-WHITE
* [213.4.129.18 listed in hostkarma.junkemailfilter.com]
--
Bowie
RE: Hostkarma whitelist problem
Posted by "Jonas A. Larsen" <jo...@vrt.dk>.
> Bowie Bailey wrote:
>
> > I couldn't find any place on junkmailfilter website to report this,
> so
> > I'll put it here.
> >
> > I received a 419 scam email with this whitelist hit:
> >
> > * -3.0 RCVD_IN_JMF_W RBL: Sender listed in JMF-WHITE
> > * [213.4.129.18 listed in hostkarma.junkemailfilter.com]
>
> I found that using the whitelist was causing a lot of spam to get
> through but not helping to get more ham through, so I decided to
> "reduce" the recommended score on the website from "-5" to "-0.2".
This have been my experience as well. I chose to reduce it to -1
I find (which might be natural) that it overlaps A LOT with DNSWL.
But keep up the great work Marc
Med venlig hilsen / Best regards
Jonas Akrouh Larsen
TechBiz ApS
Laplandsgade 4, 2. sal
2300 København S
Office: 7020 0979
Direct: 3336 9974
Mobile: 5120 1096
Fax: 7020 0978
Web: www.techbiz.dk
Re: Hostkarma whitelist problem
Posted by Marc Perkel <ma...@perkel.com>.
Mike Cardwell wrote:
> Bowie Bailey wrote:
>
>> I couldn't find any place on junkmailfilter website to report this, so
>> I'll put it here.
>>
>> I received a 419 scam email with this whitelist hit:
>>
>> * -3.0 RCVD_IN_JMF_W RBL: Sender listed in JMF-WHITE
>> * [213.4.129.18 listed in hostkarma.junkemailfilter.com]
>
> I found that using the whitelist was causing a lot of spam to get
> through but not helping to get more ham through, so I decided to
> "reduce" the recommended score on the website from "-5" to "-0.2".
By not helping ham get through do you mean that there were few ham hits
or that the ham was already scored ham and that the Hostkarma white list
didn't save anything from being scored as ham?
Also - is there a way in SA to do name based lookups rather that IP
based? The real power is in the name based lookups as long as you are
using FCrDNS.
Re: Hostkarma whitelist problem
Posted by Mike Cardwell <sp...@lists.grepular.com>.
Bowie Bailey wrote:
> I couldn't find any place on junkmailfilter website to report this, so
> I'll put it here.
>
> I received a 419 scam email with this whitelist hit:
>
> * -3.0 RCVD_IN_JMF_W RBL: Sender listed in JMF-WHITE
> * [213.4.129.18 listed in hostkarma.junkemailfilter.com]
I found that using the whitelist was causing a lot of spam to get
through but not helping to get more ham through, so I decided to
"reduce" the recommended score on the website from "-5" to "-0.2".
--
Mike Cardwell - IT Consultant and LAMP developer
Cardwell IT Ltd. (UK Reg'd Company #06920226) http://cardwellit.com/
Re: Hostkarma whitelist problem
Posted by Marc Perkel <ma...@perkel.com>.
mouss wrote:
> Bowie Bailey a écrit :
>
>> I couldn't find any place on junkmailfilter website to report this, so
>> I'll put it here.
>>
>> I received a 419 scam email with this whitelist hit:
>>
>>
>
> so what? I keep getting 419 from google, yahoo, ... but they are still
> whitelisted.
>
>
Actually yahoo, google, hotmail are all yellow listed. Yellow means the
IP contains no information as to whether or not it's spam or ham. Yellow
keeps you off the white and black lists.
Re: Hostkarma whitelist problem
Posted by mouss <mo...@ml.netoyen.net>.
Bowie Bailey a écrit :
> I couldn't find any place on junkmailfilter website to report this, so
> I'll put it here.
>
> I received a 419 scam email with this whitelist hit:
>
so what? I keep getting 419 from google, yahoo, ... but they are still
whitelisted.
and anyway, fighting 419 is not easy. That said, JM_SOUGHT_* gets many
of these. many thanks to JM, JH, KB, ...etc (which reminds me that I
should make my corpus available, argh).
> * -3.0 RCVD_IN_JMF_W RBL: Sender listed in JMF-WHITE
> * [213.4.129.18 listed in hostkarma.junkemailfilter.com]
>
>
Re: Hostkarma whitelist problem
Posted by Randy Ramsdell <rr...@livedatagroup.com>.
Marc Perkel wrote:
> errors@junkemailfilter.com will work. If you have suggestions for
> automation I'm interested.
>
> Bowie Bailey wrote:
>> That one also hit DNSWL_MED and actually ended up with a negative
>> score. I reported to dnswl via their website.
>>
>> It would be useful to have a reporting mechanism on your website so
>> we don't have to send these to the list.
>>
>> Bowie
>>
>> Marc Perkel wrote:
>>> No list is perfect. Thanks for reporting it. Although I try to get
>>> everything right there will always be mistakes. Sometimes I do get
>>> to leaning white because false positives are 100 times worse than a
>>> few spams getting through. Probably what happened with that is that
>>> the sender does a pretty good job of stopping spam and after we get
>>> 25 good emails and no spam they get white listed. So what a spam
>>> sneaks through is gets past.
>>>
>>> I need to build up my yellow list more. My yellow list is for ISPs
>>> and freemail providers that are mostly non-spam but some spam gets
>>> through. I'm always looking for new tricks to build up these lists.
>>>
>>> Bowie Bailey wrote:
>>>> I couldn't find any place on junkmailfilter website to report this,
>>>> so I'll put it here.
>>>>
>>>> I received a 419 scam email with this whitelist hit:
>>>>
>>>> * -3.0 RCVD_IN_JMF_W RBL: Sender listed in JMF-WHITE
>>>> * [213.4.129.18 listed in hostkarma.junkemailfilter.com]
>>>>
>>>>
>>
It can be automated by creating a web form and having the form, do input
validation, and ...
1. Send and e-mail to you or other maintainers.
2. Automatically removing the incorrect entry.
3. Removing it and then parse through your list to see if the domain is
currently sending spam. ( If you have logs etc... )
4. Removing it and sending an e-mail to the maintainers.
There are so many ways to handle this.
Re: Hostkarma whitelist problem
Posted by Bowie Bailey <Bo...@BUC.com>.
Can you put that somewhere on the website? The problem is that I'm not
going to remember that when I find another one in a month or so. I'll
do what I did this time, which is go to the website.
Bowie
Marc Perkel wrote:
> errors@junkemailfilter.com will work. If you have suggestions for
> automation I'm interested.
>
> Bowie Bailey wrote:
>> That one also hit DNSWL_MED and actually ended up with a negative
>> score. I reported to dnswl via their website.
>>
>> It would be useful to have a reporting mechanism on your website so
>> we don't have to send these to the list.
>>
>> Bowie
>>
>> Marc Perkel wrote:
>>> No list is perfect. Thanks for reporting it. Although I try to get
>>> everything right there will always be mistakes. Sometimes I do get
>>> to leaning white because false positives are 100 times worse than a
>>> few spams getting through. Probably what happened with that is that
>>> the sender does a pretty good job of stopping spam and after we get
>>> 25 good emails and no spam they get white listed. So what a spam
>>> sneaks through is gets past.
>>>
>>> I need to build up my yellow list more. My yellow list is for ISPs
>>> and freemail providers that are mostly non-spam but some spam gets
>>> through. I'm always looking for new tricks to build up these lists.
>>>
>>> Bowie Bailey wrote:
>>>> I couldn't find any place on junkmailfilter website to report this,
>>>> so I'll put it here.
>>>>
>>>> I received a 419 scam email with this whitelist hit:
>>>>
>>>> * -3.0 RCVD_IN_JMF_W RBL: Sender listed in JMF-WHITE
>>>> * [213.4.129.18 listed in hostkarma.junkemailfilter.com]
>>>>
>>>>
>>
Re: Hostkarma whitelist problem
Posted by Marc Perkel <ma...@perkel.com>.
errors@junkemailfilter.com will work. If you have suggestions for
automation I'm interested.
Bowie Bailey wrote:
> That one also hit DNSWL_MED and actually ended up with a negative
> score. I reported to dnswl via their website.
>
> It would be useful to have a reporting mechanism on your website so we
> don't have to send these to the list.
>
> Bowie
>
> Marc Perkel wrote:
>> No list is perfect. Thanks for reporting it. Although I try to get
>> everything right there will always be mistakes. Sometimes I do get to
>> leaning white because false positives are 100 times worse than a few
>> spams getting through. Probably what happened with that is that the
>> sender does a pretty good job of stopping spam and after we get 25
>> good emails and no spam they get white listed. So what a spam sneaks
>> through is gets past.
>>
>> I need to build up my yellow list more. My yellow list is for ISPs
>> and freemail providers that are mostly non-spam but some spam gets
>> through. I'm always looking for new tricks to build up these lists.
>>
>> Bowie Bailey wrote:
>>> I couldn't find any place on junkmailfilter website to report this,
>>> so I'll put it here.
>>>
>>> I received a 419 scam email with this whitelist hit:
>>>
>>> * -3.0 RCVD_IN_JMF_W RBL: Sender listed in JMF-WHITE
>>> * [213.4.129.18 listed in hostkarma.junkemailfilter.com]
>>>
>>>
>
Re: Hostkarma whitelist problem
Posted by Bowie Bailey <Bo...@BUC.com>.
That one also hit DNSWL_MED and actually ended up with a negative
score. I reported to dnswl via their website.
It would be useful to have a reporting mechanism on your website so we
don't have to send these to the list.
Bowie
Marc Perkel wrote:
> No list is perfect. Thanks for reporting it. Although I try to get
> everything right there will always be mistakes. Sometimes I do get to
> leaning white because false positives are 100 times worse than a few
> spams getting through. Probably what happened with that is that the
> sender does a pretty good job of stopping spam and after we get 25
> good emails and no spam they get white listed. So what a spam sneaks
> through is gets past.
>
> I need to build up my yellow list more. My yellow list is for ISPs and
> freemail providers that are mostly non-spam but some spam gets
> through. I'm always looking for new tricks to build up these lists.
>
> Bowie Bailey wrote:
>> I couldn't find any place on junkmailfilter website to report this,
>> so I'll put it here.
>>
>> I received a 419 scam email with this whitelist hit:
>>
>> * -3.0 RCVD_IN_JMF_W RBL: Sender listed in JMF-WHITE
>> * [213.4.129.18 listed in hostkarma.junkemailfilter.com]
>>
>>
Re: Hostkarma whitelist problem
Posted by Marc Perkel <ma...@perkel.com>.
No list is perfect. Thanks for reporting it. Although I try to get
everything right there will always be mistakes. Sometimes I do get to
leaning white because false positives are 100 times worse than a few
spams getting through. Probably what happened with that is that the
sender does a pretty good job of stopping spam and after we get 25 good
emails and no spam they get white listed. So what a spam sneaks through
is gets past.
I need to build up my yellow list more. My yellow list is for ISPs and
freemail providers that are mostly non-spam but some spam gets through.
I'm always looking for new tricks to build up these lists.
Bowie Bailey wrote:
> I couldn't find any place on junkmailfilter website to report this, so
> I'll put it here.
>
> I received a 419 scam email with this whitelist hit:
>
> * -3.0 RCVD_IN_JMF_W RBL: Sender listed in JMF-WHITE
> * [213.4.129.18 listed in hostkarma.junkemailfilter.com]
>
>