You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@cocoon.apache.org by Antonio Gallardo <ag...@agssa.net> on 2004/02/12 08:12:52 UTC

[VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Hi:

Some people is currently using woody for development. On the other side we
need a test area to implement some enhancements in woody that affect
critical parts of woody. Sometimes it can broke the woody block. For these
reason we think it is a good idea to have an scratchpad area for woody
developement. In this scratchpad area, we can freely implement and test
new features before we move them inside the woody block.

Of course the Woody scratchpad area will be created after the 2.1.4 release.

Please vote.

+1

Best Regards,

Antonio Gallardo



RE: [VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Posted by Reinhard Poetz <re...@apache.org>.
From: Bertrand Delacretaz [mailto:bdelacretaz@apache.org] 

> Le Vendredi, 13 fév 2004, à 12:47 Europe/Zurich, Reinhard 
> Poetz a écrit 
> :
> 
> >>>> ...  3) moving Woody inside cocoon core and rename it Cocoon...
> > ...
> > +1 to renaming it ASAP (BTW, do we need a formal vote for the 
> > +archives? I know we all agreed on this at Ghent but I also 
> know there 
> > +were not all developers there. Or have we already voted on this?)
> 
> There was a vote, indeed: 
> http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=xml-> cocoon-dev&m=106569745906521&w=2

fine, this means if there is anyone out there he can start the
migration.

--
Reinhard


Re: [VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Posted by Bertrand Delacretaz <bd...@apache.org>.
Le Vendredi, 13 fév 2004, à 12:47 Europe/Zurich, Reinhard Poetz a écrit 
:

>>>> ...  3) moving Woody inside cocoon core and rename it Cocoon...
> ...
> +1 to renaming it ASAP (BTW, do we need a formal vote for the archives?
> +I know we all agreed on this at Ghent but I also know there were not
> +all developers there. Or have we already voted on this?)

There was a vote, indeed:
http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=xml-cocoon-dev&m=106569745906521&w=2

-Bertrand


RE: [VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Posted by Reinhard Poetz <re...@apache.org>.
From: Bertrand Delacretaz

> Le Vendredi, 13 fév 2004, à 09:45 Europe/Zurich, Bruno Dumon a écrit :
> 
> >> ...  1) removing XMLForms entirely (they have been deprecated for a

> >> while now)
> >
> > I'm with Joerg here, there's no harm in leaving it sit there for a
> > little longer, and there are people using it.
> >
> > I'd be +1 for removing all its documentation from the site though.
> 
> +1
> Good idea, strong sign of deprecation
> 
> >
> >>   2) deprecating JXForms (a vote is already in place, this
> counts as
> >> +1
> >> to that)
> >
> 
> +1

+1

> 
> >
> >>
> >>   3) moving Woody inside cocoon core and rename it Cocoon
> Forms (we
> >> should stop calling it woody)
> >
> > +1 for the rename
> > -1 for moving it into core, for the same reasons as Joerg.
> 
> Same here, IIRC there was agreement on keeping the core as small as
> possible and not everybody needs Forms.

+1 to renaming it ASAP (BTW, do we need a formal vote for the archives? 
+I know we all agreed on this at Ghent but I also know there were not 
+all developers there. Or have we already voted on this?)

> 
> I also agree with doing this soon (i.e. when whoever does it wants to
> do it), no need to wait for 2.2 IMHO. Better solidify soon and have 
> less examples and docs to update. The downside is frustrating some 
> users but this is alpha stuff, isn't it?

As soon as we have a stable CForms block changing interfaces needs a
formal vote. So I think at this point a CForms-scratchpad would make
sense but as long as CForms is marked as unstable it looks funny.

After reading this I think we should release a stable CForms block ASAP.
Regarding Bugzilla
http://nagoya.apache.org/bugzilla/showdependencytree.cgi?id=25099 we
aren't so far from this point.
The most important point is stable interfaces but with the move to the
new block we can evaluate every single line of code. Anybody already
working on this?

--
Reinhard


Re: [VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Posted by Bertrand Delacretaz <bd...@apache.org>.
Le Vendredi, 13 fév 2004, à 09:45 Europe/Zurich, Bruno Dumon a écrit :

>> ...  1) removing XMLForms entirely (they have been deprecated for a 
>> while now)
>
> I'm with Joerg here, there's no harm in leaving it sit there for a
> little longer, and there are people using it.
>
> I'd be +1 for removing all its documentation from the site though.

+1
Good idea, strong sign of deprecation

>
>>   2) deprecating JXForms (a vote is already in place, this counts as 
>> +1
>> to that)
>

+1

>
>>
>>   3) moving Woody inside cocoon core and rename it Cocoon Forms (we
>> should stop calling it woody)
>
> +1 for the rename
> -1 for moving it into core, for the same reasons as Joerg.

Same here, IIRC there was agreement on keeping the core as small as 
possible and not everybody needs Forms.

I also agree with doing this soon (i.e. when whoever does it wants to 
do it), no need to wait for 2.2 IMHO. Better solidify soon and have 
less examples and docs to update. The downside is frustrating some 
users but this is alpha stuff, isn't it?

-Bertrand


Re: [VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Posted by Bruno Dumon <br...@outerthought.org>.
On Thu, 2004-02-12 at 21:43, Stefano Mazzocchi wrote:
> Antonio Gallardo wrote:
> > Hi:
> > 
> > Some people is currently using woody for development. On the other side we
> > need a test area to implement some enhancements in woody that affect
> > critical parts of woody. Sometimes it can broke the woody block. For these
> > reason we think it is a good idea to have an scratchpad area for woody
> > developement. In this scratchpad area, we can freely implement and test
> > new features before we move them inside the woody block.
> > 
> > Of course the Woody scratchpad area will be created after the 2.1.4 release.
> 
> +1
> 
> I also think it's a good idea to considering solidifying the form 
> methodology by:
> 
>   1) removing XMLForms entirely (they have been deprecated for a while now)

I'm with Joerg here, there's no harm in leaving it sit there for a
little longer, and there are people using it.

I'd be +1 for removing all its documentation from the site though.

>   2) deprecating JXForms (a vote is already in place, this counts as +1 
> to that)

+1

> 
>   3) moving Woody inside cocoon core and rename it Cocoon Forms (we 
> should stop calling it woody)

+1 for the rename
-1 for moving it into core, for the same reasons as Joerg.

> 
> For people that expected Cocoon 2.2 to make this happening, well, I 
> think we should get it done in Cocoon 2.1.5 instead.

Cocoon 2.2 is indeed too far off, but 2.1.5 seems way to soon for me. I
think a more realistic target would be August/September. Even then, it
will mean that we've gone from nothing to a first release in just one
year, which is by all open source standards pretty fast.

-- 
Bruno Dumon                             http://outerthought.org/
Outerthought - Open Source, Java & XML Competence Support Center
bruno@outerthought.org                          bruno@apache.org


RE: [VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Posted by Reinhard Poetz <re...@apache.org>.
From: Daniel Fagerstrom [mailto:danielf@nada.kth.se] 

> Stefano Mazzocchi wrote:
> ...
> 
> > I also think it's a good idea to considering solidifying the form
> > methodology by:
> >
> >  1) removing XMLForms entirely (they have been deprecated 
> for a while
> > now) 
> 
> +1
> 
> >  2) deprecating JXForms (a vote is already in place, this 
> counts as +1
> > to that)
> 
> +1
> 
> >  3) moving Woody inside cocoon core and rename it Cocoon Forms (we
> > should stop calling it woody) 
> 
> +1 for renaming
> -1 for moving to core, for the same reasons as Joerg, Bruno 
> and Bertrand ;)
> 
> > For people that expected Cocoon 2.2 to make this happening, well, I
> > think we should get it done in Cocoon 2.1.5 instead.
> >
> > WDYT?
> 
> I think we need to make a detailed review of the core 
> interfaces and the 
> XML-formats before renaming it to Cocoon Forms. Maybe we have 
> gathered 
> enough experience of Woody to be able to do that now.

+1 

--
Reinhard


Re: [VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Posted by Daniel Fagerstrom <da...@nada.kth.se>.
Stefano Mazzocchi wrote:
...

> I also think it's a good idea to considering solidifying the form 
> methodology by:
>
>  1) removing XMLForms entirely (they have been deprecated for a while 
> now) 

+1

>  2) deprecating JXForms (a vote is already in place, this counts as +1 
> to that)

+1

>  3) moving Woody inside cocoon core and rename it Cocoon Forms (we 
> should stop calling it woody) 

+1 for renaming
-1 for moving to core, for the same reasons as Joerg, Bruno and Bertrand ;)

> For people that expected Cocoon 2.2 to make this happening, well, I 
> think we should get it done in Cocoon 2.1.5 instead.
>
> WDYT?

I think we need to make a detailed review of the core interfaces and the 
XML-formats before renaming it to Cocoon Forms. Maybe we have gathered 
enough experience of Woody to be able to do that now.

/Daniel



Re: [VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Posted by Joerg Heinicke <jo...@gmx.de>.
On 12.02.2004 21:43, Stefano Mazzocchi wrote:

> I also think it's a good idea to considering solidifying the form 
> methodology by:
> 
>  1) removing XMLForms entirely (they have been deprecated for a while now)

-0 let it live in 2.1. XMLForms was moved into its own block only 10 
months ago (end of April: blocks.properties, 1.8) and deprecated only 
half a year ago (beginning of August: blocks.properties, 1.25);
http://cvs.apache.org/viewcvs.cgi/cocoon-2.1/blocks.properties

>  2) deprecating JXForms (a vote is already in place, this counts as +1 
> to that)

-0 as long as the first version of Woody/Cocoon Forms is not released.

>  3) moving Woody inside cocoon core and rename it Cocoon Forms (we 
> should stop calling it woody)

+1 on renaming

-1 on moving to core. Why moving it to core? 200 classes and 2 
additional libs if you do not need them? The name "Cocoon Forms" makes 
the form framework official enough announced IMO.

Joerg

Re: [VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Posted by Antonio Gallardo <ag...@agssa.net>.
Giacomo Pati dijo:
> Giacomo [who is back from winter vacations and as usual has a backlog of
> several hundreds of mails]

Welcome back! I hope we can add to the above sentence:

... with enough new forces and ideas to help improving Cocoon! ;-)

Best Regards,

Antonio Gallardo

Re: [VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Posted by Giacomo Pati <gi...@apache.org>.

Stefano Mazzocchi wrote:
> Antonio Gallardo wrote:
> 
>> Hi:
>>
>> Some people is currently using woody for development. On the other 
>> side we
>> need a test area to implement some enhancements in woody that affect
>> critical parts of woody. Sometimes it can broke the woody block. For 
>> these
>> reason we think it is a good idea to have an scratchpad area for woody
>> developement. In this scratchpad area, we can freely implement and test
>> new features before we move them inside the woody block.
>>
>> Of course the Woody scratchpad area will be created after the 2.1.4 
>> release.
> 
> 
> +1

+1 as well

> I also think it's a good idea to considering solidifying the form 
> methodology by:
> 
>  1) removing XMLForms entirely (they have been deprecated for a while now)

+0 (I'm not using it but maybe others do)

>  2) deprecating JXForms (a vote is already in place, this counts as +1 
> to that)

+0 (we still have some JXForm apps and they will not move to CForm for a 
long time)

>  3) moving Woody inside cocoon core and rename it Cocoon Forms (we 
> should stop calling it woody)

big +1

> For people that expected Cocoon 2.2 to make this happening, well, I 
> think we should get it done in Cocoon 2.1.5 instead.

+1 for 2.1.5!

Giacomo [who is back from winter vacations and as usual has a backlog of 
several hundreds of mails]

-- 
Giacomo Pati
Otego AG, Switzerland - http://www.otego.com
Orixo, the XML business alliance - http://www.orixo.com

Re: [VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Posted by Stefano Mazzocchi <st...@apache.org>.
Antonio Gallardo wrote:
> Hi:
> 
> Some people is currently using woody for development. On the other side we
> need a test area to implement some enhancements in woody that affect
> critical parts of woody. Sometimes it can broke the woody block. For these
> reason we think it is a good idea to have an scratchpad area for woody
> developement. In this scratchpad area, we can freely implement and test
> new features before we move them inside the woody block.
> 
> Of course the Woody scratchpad area will be created after the 2.1.4 release.

+1

I also think it's a good idea to considering solidifying the form 
methodology by:

  1) removing XMLForms entirely (they have been deprecated for a while now)

  2) deprecating JXForms (a vote is already in place, this counts as +1 
to that)

  3) moving Woody inside cocoon core and rename it Cocoon Forms (we 
should stop calling it woody)

For people that expected Cocoon 2.2 to make this happening, well, I 
think we should get it done in Cocoon 2.1.5 instead.

WDYT?

-- 
Stefano, at W3C offices ;-)


Re: [VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Posted by Bertrand Delacretaz <bd...@apache.org>.
Le Jeudi, 12 fév 2004, à 16:51 Europe/Zurich, Sylvain Wallez a écrit :
> ...
> +1 also, but we have to be careful of the potential parallel 
> evolutions of the same class in the trunk and in the scratchpad...

CVS branches are very useful IMHO for such experimental-but-maybe-cool 
stuff.

For some reason they're not popular here, I don't really understand why.

-Bertrand


Re: [VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Posted by Sylvain Wallez <sy...@apache.org>.
Tim Larson wrote:

>On Thu, Feb 12, 2004 at 01:12:52AM -0600, Antonio Gallardo wrote:
>  
>
>>Some people is currently using woody for development. On the other side we
>>need a test area to implement some enhancements in woody that affect
>>critical parts of woody. Sometimes it can broke the woody block. For these
>>reason we think it is a good idea to have an scratchpad area for woody
>>developement. In this scratchpad area, we can freely implement and test
>>new features before we move them inside the woody block.
>>
>>Of course the Woody scratchpad area will be created after the 2.1.4 release.
>>
>>Please vote.
>>
>>+1
>>    
>>
>
>I suggested this while working with Sylvain and later with Antonio on
>IRC, because some of what I want to do touches core parts of Woody.
>I do not want to disturb people already using Woody with parts that may
>change several times before being finalized.
>
>So +1 from me
>  
>

+1 also, but we have to be careful of the potential parallel evolutions 
of the same class in the trunk and in the scratchpad.

Sylvain

-- 
Sylvain Wallez                                  Anyware Technologies
http://www.apache.org/~sylvain           http://www.anyware-tech.com
{ XML, Java, Cocoon, OpenSource }*{ Training, Consulting, Projects }
Orixo, the opensource XML business alliance  -  http://www.orixo.com



Re: [VOTE] Woody scratchpad area

Posted by Tim Larson <ti...@keow.org>.
On Thu, Feb 12, 2004 at 01:12:52AM -0600, Antonio Gallardo wrote:
> Some people is currently using woody for development. On the other side we
> need a test area to implement some enhancements in woody that affect
> critical parts of woody. Sometimes it can broke the woody block. For these
> reason we think it is a good idea to have an scratchpad area for woody
> developement. In this scratchpad area, we can freely implement and test
> new features before we move them inside the woody block.
> 
> Of course the Woody scratchpad area will be created after the 2.1.4 release.
> 
> Please vote.
> 
> +1

I suggested this while working with Sylvain and later with Antonio on
IRC, because some of what I want to do touches core parts of Woody.
I do not want to disturb people already using Woody with parts that may
change several times before being finalized.

So +1 from me

--Tim Larson