You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to users@spamassassin.apache.org by Sahil Tandon <sa...@tandon.net> on 2008/06/18 04:10:37 UTC

are you doing sender address verification?

Just conjecture at this point, but it seems as though whenever I send an 
email to the SA mailing list, I receive sender address verification requests 
from:

chlothar.bnv-bamberg.de
sam.metaphysis.net                                           

Over the course of a few days, I see these requests soon after my messages 
are accepted by an apache.org MX.  Is there a link?  Just a coincidence?  Is 
anyone else experiencing similar behavior?  Thanks.

-- 
Sahil Tandon <sa...@tandon.net>

Re: are you doing sender address verification?

Posted by Matus UHLAR - fantomas <uh...@fantomas.sk>.
> At 19:10 17-06-2008, Sahil Tandon wrote:
> >Just conjecture at this point, but it seems as though whenever I send an
> >email to the SA mailing list, I receive sender address verification 
> >requests
> >from:
> >
> >chlothar.bnv-bamberg.de
> >sam.metaphysis.net

On 17.06.08 23:47, SM wrote:
> I see connections from these two hosts.  If they are doing sender 
> address verification, it is incorrectly done as the domain of the 
> sender is spamassassin.apache.org and not the one in the From: header.

I see them too, funny:

Jun 16 09:44:42 fantomas sm-mta[28820]: m5G7iVEu028820: from=<po...@sam.metaphysis.net>, size=0, class=0, nrcpts=1, proto=SMTP, daemon=MTA-v4, relay=sam.metaphysis.net [85.10.207.80]
Jun 16 09:45:30 fantomas sm-mta[28840]: m5G7jPDq028840: rejecting commands from chlothar.bnv-bamberg.de [217.146.130.193] due to pre-greeting traffic
Jun 16 09:45:41 fantomas sm-mta[28843]: m5G7jacb028843: rejecting commands from chlothar.bnv-bamberg.de [217.146.130.193] due to pre-greeting traffic
Jun 16 12:00:55 fantomas sm-mta[30726]: m5GA0oGS030726: rejecting commands from chlothar.bnv-bamberg.de [217.146.130.193] due to pre-greeting traffic
Jun 16 14:16:06 fantomas sm-mta[32322]: m5GCG2HY032322: rejecting commands from chlothar.bnv-bamberg.de [217.146.130.193] due to pre-greeting traffic
Jun 17 10:18:57 fantomas sm-mta[14338]: m5H8IkSZ014338: from=<po...@sam.metaphysis.net>, size=0, class=0, nrcpts=1, proto=SMTP, daemon=MTA-v4, relay=sam.metaphysis.net [85.10.207.80]
Jun 17 10:19:00 fantomas sm-mta[14341]: m5H8IuSQ014341: rejecting commands from chlothar.bnv-bamberg.de [217.146.130.193] due to pre-greeting traffic
Jun 17 13:47:34 fantomas sm-mta[17629]: m5HBlTxT017629: rejecting commands from chlothar.bnv-bamberg.de [217.146.130.193] due to pre-greeting traffic
Jun 17 18:01:38 fantomas sm-mta[21695]: m5HG1XCg021695: rejecting commands from chlothar.bnv-bamberg.de [217.146.130.193] due to pre-greeting traffic
Jun 18 08:40:53 fantomas sm-mta[32080]: m5I6emRW032080: rejecting commands from chlothar.bnv-bamberg.de [217.146.130.193] due to pre-greeting traffic
Jun 18 08:54:31 fantomas sm-mta[768]: m5I6sQDn000768: rejecting commands from chlothar.bnv-bamberg.de [217.146.130.193] due to pre-greeting traffic

-- 
Matus UHLAR - fantomas, uhlar@fantomas.sk ; http://www.fantomas.sk/
Warning: I wish NOT to receive e-mail advertising to this address.
Varovanie: na tuto adresu chcem NEDOSTAVAT akukolvek reklamnu postu.
Microsoft dick is soft to do no harm

Re: are you doing sender address verification?

Posted by SM <sm...@resistor.net>.
At 19:10 17-06-2008, Sahil Tandon wrote:
>Just conjecture at this point, but it seems as though whenever I send an
>email to the SA mailing list, I receive sender address verification requests
>from:
>
>chlothar.bnv-bamberg.de
>sam.metaphysis.net

I see connections from these two hosts.  If they are doing sender 
address verification, it is incorrectly done as the domain of the 
sender is spamassassin.apache.org and not the one in the From: header.

Regards,
-sm 


Re: are you doing sender address verification?

Posted by Jonas Eckerman <jo...@frukt.org>.
Sahil Tandon wrote:

> email to the SA mailing list, I receive sender address verification requests 
> from:
> chlothar.bnv-bamberg.de
> sam.metaphysis.net                                           

Looking in our recent logs I can't see any SAV checks from them, 
but I do see connections from both hosts where they send a MAIL 
FROM but no RCPT TO.

It's possible that they're checking if *we* do SAV at MAIL FROM. 
Or maybe they are just checking if we're willing to accept mail 
from <sp...@bnv-bamberg.de> and <po...@sam.metaphysis.net>.

 > sam.metaphysis.net

That system seems to be doing some sort of testing:

/var/log/maillog.3.bz2:Jun 14 16:55:02 chip mimedefang.pl[171]: 
m5EEt1Ld004251: 
mdstats;reject;unknown_user;<sa...@frukt.org>,
[10.0.6.11];85.10.207.80;sam.metaphysis.net;sam.metaphysis.net;<po...@frukt.org>

It's possible that they are checking if *we* are a backscatter 
source. Otherwise I've no idea why they are trying to send to 
that (unexistant) address.

Regards
/Jonas
-- 
Jonas Eckerman, FSDB & Fruktträdet
http://whatever.frukt.org/
http://www.fsdb.org/
http://www.frukt.org/


Re: are you doing sender address verification?

Posted by mouss <mo...@netoyen.net>.
Sahil Tandon wrote:
> Just conjecture at this point, but it seems as though whenever I send an 
> email to the SA mailing list, I receive sender address verification requests 
> from:
>
> chlothar.bnv-bamberg.de
>   

This one is listed at backscatterer.org.

> sam.metaphysis.net                                           
>
>   

Concidence or not, this is in Germany too...

> Over the course of a few days, I see these requests soon after my messages 
> are accepted by an apache.org MX.  Is there a link?  Just a coincidence?  Is 
> anyone else experiencing similar behavior?  Thanks.
>
>   

borked site that uses the From: header instead of the envelope sender.

chances are they also have a borked parser, so you can try something like
    From: (Sahil Tandon - looking for postmaster@meinl.bnv-bamberg.de) 
<$realfrom>
and see if they probe their own postmaster... ;-p (or use a trap address 
there...).