You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@karaf.apache.org by Tom Blocker <tb...@yahoo.com> on 2014/11/04 20:31:09 UTC
Minimal Distribution
I have several questions.
I am working to develop a product using Opendaylight. Its Helium release
uses Karaf, but we are wanting to remove as many features as possible from
that distribution.
I searched the history of this list and saw several conversations addressing
a minimal distribution than you get using
<artifactId>apache-karaf-minimal</artifactId>. There are a large number of
features in this distribution that we do not want to deploy with the final
product.
Question 1). Is there a way to create a more minimal (some have called it
core) distribution.
If not, it appears that one could find the feature descriptors used by karaf
via the framework, karaf.branding?, and standard dependencies. If I could
find these descriptors, we could put our own edited copies of these on our
Nexus server.
Question 2) Is there a better way?
If not, then...
Question 3) I have found feature descriptors for standard, enterprise and
spring. So far have not found the others.
The following is what I am trying to remove:
And thanks
Name | Version | Installed |
Repository | Description
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
framework-security | 3.0.1 | |
standard-3.0.1 | OSGi Security for Karaf
aries-annotation | 3.0.1 | |
standard-3.0.1 | Aries Annotations
wrapper | 3.0.1 | |
standard-3.0.1 | Provide OS integration
service-wrapper | 3.0.1 | |
standard-3.0.1 | Provide OS integration (alias to
wrapper feature)
obr | 3.0.1 | |
standard-3.0.1 | Provide OSGi Bundle Repository (OBR)
support
http-whiteboard | 3.0.1 | |
standard-3.0.1 | Provide HTTP Whiteboard pattern
support
jetty | 8.1.9.v20130131 | |
standard-3.0.1 |
webconsole | 3.0.1 | |
standard-3.0.1 | Base support of the Karaf WebConsole
scheduler | 3.0.1 | |
standard-3.0.1 | Provide a scheduler service in Karaf
to fire event
eventadmin | 3.0.1 | |
standard-3.0.1 | OSGi Event Admin service
specification for event-b
jasypt-encryption | 3.0.1 | |
standard-3.0.1 | Advanced encryption support for
Karaf security
scr | 3.0.1 | |
standard-3.0.1 | Declarative Service support
blueprint-web | 3.0.1 | |
standard-3.0.1 | Provides an OSGI-aware Servlet
ContextListener for
pax-cdi | 0.7.0 | |
org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Provide CDI support
pax-cdi-1.1 | 0.7.0 | |
org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Provide CDI 1.1 support
pax-cdi-weld | 0.7.0 | |
org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Weld CDI support
pax-cdi-1.1-weld | 0.7.0 | |
org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Weld CDI 1.1 support
pax-cdi-openwebbeans | 0.7.0 | |
org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | OpenWebBeans CDI support
pax-cdi-web | 0.7.0 | |
org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Web CDI support
pax-cdi-1.1-web | 0.7.0 | |
org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Web CDI 1.1 support
pax-cdi-web-weld | 0.7.0 | |
org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Weld Web CDI support
pax-cdi-1.1-web-weld | 0.7.0 | |
org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Weld Web CDI 1.1 support
pax-cdi-web-openwebbeans | 0.7.0 | |
org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | OpenWebBeans Web CDI support
pax-cdi-deltaspike-core | >0.5 | |
org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Apache Deltaspike core support
pax-cdi-deltaspike-jpa | 0.5 | |
org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Apche Deltaspike jpa support
spring-dm | 1.2.1 | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring DM support
spring-dm-web | 1.2.1 | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring DM Web support
spring | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x support
spring-aspects | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x AOP support
spring-instrument | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x Instrument support
spring-jdbc | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x JDBC support
spring-jms | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x JMS support
spring-struts | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x Struts support
spring-test | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x Test support
spring-orm | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x ORM support
spring-oxm | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x OXM support
spring-tx | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x Transaction (TX)
support
spring-web | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x Web support
spring-web-portlet | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x Web Portlet support
spring | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x support
spring-aspects | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x AOP support
spring-instrument | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x Instrument support
spring-jdbc | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x JDBC support
spring-jms | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x JMS support
spring-struts | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x Struts support
spring-test | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x Test support
spring-orm | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x ORM support
spring-oxm | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x OXM support
spring-tx | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x Transaction (TX)
support
spring-web | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x Web support
spring-web-portlet | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x Web Portlet support
spring | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x support
spring-aspects | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x AOP support
spring-instrument | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x Instrument support
spring-jdbc | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x JDBC support
spring-jms | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x JMS support
spring-test | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x Test support
spring-orm | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x ORM support
spring-oxm | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x OXM support
spring-tx | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x Transaction (TX)
support
spring-web | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x Web support
spring-web-portlet | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x Web Portlet support
spring-websocket | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x WebSocket support
spring-security | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Spring Security 3.1.x support
gemini-blueprint | 1.0.0.RELEASE | |
spring-3.0.1 | Gemini Blueprint Extender
transaction | 1.0.1 | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | OSGi Transaction Manager
jpa | 1.0.1 | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | OSGi Persistence Container
openjpa | 2.2.2 | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | Apache OpenJPA 2.2.x persistence
engine support
openjpa | 2.3.0 | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | Apache OpenJPA 2.3.x persistence
engine support
hibernate | 3.3.2.GA | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | Hibernate 3.x JPA persistence engine
support
hibernate | 4.2.7.Final | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | Hibernate 4.2.x JPA persistence
engine support
hibernate-envers | 4.2.7.Final | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | Hibernate Envers 4.2.x
hibernate | 4.3.1.Final | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | Hibernate 4.3.x JPA persistence
engine support
hibernate-envers | 4.3.1.Final | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | Hibernate Envers 4.3.x
hibernate-validator | 5.0.3.Final | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | Hibernate Validator support
jndi | 3.0.1 | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | OSGi Service Registry JNDI access
jdbc | 3.0.1 | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | JDBC service and commands
jms | 3.0.1 | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | JMS service and commands
openwebbeans | 1.2.1 | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | Apache OpenWebBeans CDI container
support
weld | 2.1.1.Final | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | JBoss Weld CDI container support
application-without-isolation | 1.0.0 | |
enterprise-3.0.1 | Provide EBA archive support
odl-yangtools-restconf | 0.6.3-SNAPSHOT | |
odl-yangtools-0.6.3-SNAPSHOT | OpenDaylight :: Yangtools ::
Restconf
pax-tomcat | 7.0.27.1 | |
org.ops4j.pax.web-3.1.0 | Provide Tomcat engine support
--
View this message in context: http://karaf.922171.n3.nabble.com/Minimal-Distribution-tp4036238.html
Sent from the Karaf - Dev mailing list archive at Nabble.com.
Re: Minimal Distribution
Posted by Achim Nierbeck <bc...@googlemail.com>.
Hi Tom,
I've just found this mail in my spam-box :s
I'm not sure I follow what you are trying to achieve, cause most of the
features you describe of that you want to "remove" are actually optional
features and aren't installed by default. Especially the Pax CDI and Web
ones.
regards, Achim
2014-11-04 22:25 GMT+01:00 Tom Blocker <tb...@yahoo.com>:
> Jean-Baptiste,
>
> Those that come from repositories:
> org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0
> org.ops4j.pax.web-3.1.0
>
> My goal is to delete all of the features (but one) that were in the list
> that I provided.
>
> Note that there is one called "odl"... that i meant to omit from my list.
> Ignore it please.
>
> And I am a bit new to this stuff, so don't be afraid to tell me that I am
> not making sense.
>
> Thanks
> Tom
>
>
>
>
>
>
> --
> View this message in context:
> http://karaf.922171.n3.nabble.com/Minimal-Distribution-tp4036238p4036240.html
> Sent from the Karaf - Dev mailing list archive at Nabble.com.
>
--
Apache Member
Apache Karaf <http://karaf.apache.org/> Committer & PMC
OPS4J Pax Web <http://wiki.ops4j.org/display/paxweb/Pax+Web/> Committer &
Project Lead
blog <http://notizblog.nierbeck.de/>
Co-Author of Apache Karaf Cookbook <http://bit.ly/1ps9rkS>
Software Architect / Project Manager / Scrum Master
Re: Minimal Distribution
Posted by Tom Blocker <tb...@yahoo.com>.
Jean-Baptiste,
Those that come from repositories:
org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0
org.ops4j.pax.web-3.1.0
My goal is to delete all of the features (but one) that were in the list
that I provided.
Note that there is one called "odl"... that i meant to omit from my list.
Ignore it please.
And I am a bit new to this stuff, so don't be afraid to tell me that I am
not making sense.
Thanks
Tom
--
View this message in context: http://karaf.922171.n3.nabble.com/Minimal-Distribution-tp4036238p4036240.html
Sent from the Karaf - Dev mailing list archive at Nabble.com.
Re: Minimal Distribution
Posted by Jean-Baptiste Onofré <jb...@nanthrax.net>.
Hi Tom,
my comments inline:
>
> Question 1). Is there a way to create a more minimal (some have called it
> core) distribution.
Yes, I already created a couple of Jira about that:
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KARAF-2651
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KARAF-2652
I will try to fix that for 3.0.3.
>
> If not, it appears that one could find the feature descriptors used by karaf
> via the framework, karaf.branding?, and standard dependencies. If I could
> find these descriptors, we could put our own edited copies of these on our
> Nexus server.
>
> Question 2) Is there a better way?
>
> If not, then...
>
> Question 3) I have found feature descriptors for standard, enterprise and
> spring. So far have not found the others.
Which other ones are you looking for ?
>
> The following is what I am trying to remove:
> And thanks
>
>
> Name | Version | Installed |
> Repository | Description
> -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
> framework-security | 3.0.1 | |
> standard-3.0.1 | OSGi Security for Karaf
> aries-annotation | 3.0.1 | |
> standard-3.0.1 | Aries Annotations
> wrapper | 3.0.1 | |
> standard-3.0.1 | Provide OS integration
> service-wrapper | 3.0.1 | |
> standard-3.0.1 | Provide OS integration (alias to
> wrapper feature)
> obr | 3.0.1 | |
> standard-3.0.1 | Provide OSGi Bundle Repository (OBR)
> support
> http-whiteboard | 3.0.1 | |
> standard-3.0.1 | Provide HTTP Whiteboard pattern
> support
> jetty | 8.1.9.v20130131 | |
> standard-3.0.1 |
> webconsole | 3.0.1 | |
> standard-3.0.1 | Base support of the Karaf WebConsole
> scheduler | 3.0.1 | |
> standard-3.0.1 | Provide a scheduler service in Karaf
> to fire event
> eventadmin | 3.0.1 | |
> standard-3.0.1 | OSGi Event Admin service
> specification for event-b
> jasypt-encryption | 3.0.1 | |
> standard-3.0.1 | Advanced encryption support for
> Karaf security
> scr | 3.0.1 | |
> standard-3.0.1 | Declarative Service support
> blueprint-web | 3.0.1 | |
> standard-3.0.1 | Provides an OSGI-aware Servlet
> ContextListener for
> pax-cdi | 0.7.0 | |
> org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Provide CDI support
> pax-cdi-1.1 | 0.7.0 | |
> org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Provide CDI 1.1 support
> pax-cdi-weld | 0.7.0 | |
> org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Weld CDI support
> pax-cdi-1.1-weld | 0.7.0 | |
> org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Weld CDI 1.1 support
> pax-cdi-openwebbeans | 0.7.0 | |
> org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | OpenWebBeans CDI support
> pax-cdi-web | 0.7.0 | |
> org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Web CDI support
> pax-cdi-1.1-web | 0.7.0 | |
> org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Web CDI 1.1 support
> pax-cdi-web-weld | 0.7.0 | |
> org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Weld Web CDI support
> pax-cdi-1.1-web-weld | 0.7.0 | |
> org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Weld Web CDI 1.1 support
> pax-cdi-web-openwebbeans | 0.7.0 | |
> org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | OpenWebBeans Web CDI support
> pax-cdi-deltaspike-core | >0.5 | |
> org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Apache Deltaspike core support
> pax-cdi-deltaspike-jpa | 0.5 | |
> org.ops4j.pax.cdi-0.7.0 | Apche Deltaspike jpa support
> spring-dm | 1.2.1 | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring DM support
> spring-dm-web | 1.2.1 | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring DM Web support
> spring | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x support
> spring-aspects | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x AOP support
> spring-instrument | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x Instrument support
> spring-jdbc | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x JDBC support
> spring-jms | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x JMS support
> spring-struts | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x Struts support
> spring-test | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x Test support
> spring-orm | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x ORM support
> spring-oxm | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x OXM support
> spring-tx | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x Transaction (TX)
> support
> spring-web | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x Web support
> spring-web-portlet | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.1.x Web Portlet support
> spring | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x support
> spring-aspects | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x AOP support
> spring-instrument | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x Instrument support
> spring-jdbc | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x JDBC support
> spring-jms | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x JMS support
> spring-struts | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x Struts support
> spring-test | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x Test support
> spring-orm | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x ORM support
> spring-oxm | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x OXM support
> spring-tx | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x Transaction (TX)
> support
> spring-web | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x Web support
> spring-web-portlet | 3.2.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 3.2.x Web Portlet support
> spring | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x support
> spring-aspects | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x AOP support
> spring-instrument | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x Instrument support
> spring-jdbc | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x JDBC support
> spring-jms | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x JMS support
> spring-test | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x Test support
> spring-orm | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x ORM support
> spring-oxm | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x OXM support
> spring-tx | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x Transaction (TX)
> support
> spring-web | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x Web support
> spring-web-portlet | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x Web Portlet support
> spring-websocket | 4.0.2.RELEASE_1 | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring 4.0.x WebSocket support
> spring-security | 3.1.4.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Spring Security 3.1.x support
> gemini-blueprint | 1.0.0.RELEASE | |
> spring-3.0.1 | Gemini Blueprint Extender
> transaction | 1.0.1 | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | OSGi Transaction Manager
> jpa | 1.0.1 | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | OSGi Persistence Container
> openjpa | 2.2.2 | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | Apache OpenJPA 2.2.x persistence
> engine support
> openjpa | 2.3.0 | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | Apache OpenJPA 2.3.x persistence
> engine support
> hibernate | 3.3.2.GA | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | Hibernate 3.x JPA persistence engine
> support
> hibernate | 4.2.7.Final | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | Hibernate 4.2.x JPA persistence
> engine support
> hibernate-envers | 4.2.7.Final | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | Hibernate Envers 4.2.x
> hibernate | 4.3.1.Final | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | Hibernate 4.3.x JPA persistence
> engine support
> hibernate-envers | 4.3.1.Final | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | Hibernate Envers 4.3.x
> hibernate-validator | 5.0.3.Final | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | Hibernate Validator support
> jndi | 3.0.1 | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | OSGi Service Registry JNDI access
> jdbc | 3.0.1 | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | JDBC service and commands
> jms | 3.0.1 | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | JMS service and commands
> openwebbeans | 1.2.1 | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | Apache OpenWebBeans CDI container
> support
> weld | 2.1.1.Final | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | JBoss Weld CDI container support
> application-without-isolation | 1.0.0 | |
> enterprise-3.0.1 | Provide EBA archive support
> odl-yangtools-restconf | 0.6.3-SNAPSHOT | |
> odl-yangtools-0.6.3-SNAPSHOT | OpenDaylight :: Yangtools ::
> Restconf
> pax-tomcat | 7.0.27.1 | |
> org.ops4j.pax.web-3.1.0 | Provide Tomcat engine support
>
>
>
>
>
>
> --
> View this message in context: http://karaf.922171.n3.nabble.com/Minimal-Distribution-tp4036238.html
> Sent from the Karaf - Dev mailing list archive at Nabble.com.
>
--
Jean-Baptiste Onofré
jbonofre@apache.org
http://blog.nanthrax.net
Talend - http://www.talend.com