You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@magpie.apache.org by Jarek Potiuk <ja...@potiuk.com> on 2026/08/01 15:18:48 UTC
Re: [ANNOUNCEMENT/DISCUSS] The #magpie channel on ASF slack and other forms of chatting?
Hi all,
Coming back to this.
This thread ended up split in two (different subject prefixes), so let me
pull it together. Six people weighed in and there's no consensus:
- Slack: Andrew and Alex, both saying they're happy to adapt
- Discord: Pavan and Yeonguk, mainly on newcomer-friendliness
- Matrix: Adam, for maturity, a value-aligned non-profit, and exportable
archives
- Sebb raised discoverability concerns about Matrix rather than backing an
option
On that last point specifically — Adam is right and I'd treat it as settled.
Element Web exists, and from the matrix.to room link it's one click behind
the Continue button, listed first. Sebb, the general principle that users
shouldn't have to hunt for a client is fair, but the specific claim that a
newcomer must install an app doesn't hold.
The thing I'd ask everyone to weigh: staying on Slack doesn't solve the
problem I opened the thread for. People without an @apache.org address can't
sign up on their own—they need me to hand out guest invites. For a project whose
pitch is adoption by people who are mostly *not* ASF committers, our chat
being invite-only to outsiders is backwards.
So the real choice is Discord or Matrix, and I'll put my own view in
honestly: I lean toward Discord, as it is friendlier and has more
support in this thread,
That's a preference, not a decision, and I'm not going to override four
people on a one-vote lean. So: Discord or Matrix, which do you want? If
you've already replied, a one-word answer is plenty.
For now we keep #magpie on ASF Slack for those
already there — this is about adding an open door, not closing one.
If there will not be enough visible majority - I will call for a VOTE
to settle it :)
And if you need an invite, let me know.
J.
Re: [ANNOUNCEMENT/DISCUSS] The #magpie channel on ASF slack and other forms of chatting?
Posted by Yeonguk Choo <ch...@apache.org>.
Hi everyone,
It looks like Discord has received the most support so far based on everyone's preferences.
How about we go ahead and set up a Discord server for Magpie?
Thanks,
Yeonguk
On 2026/08/01 15:29:41 Milamber wrote:
> Hi Jarek,
>
> As a user of Discord, it's easy to interact with a room (hook, bot, etc.) I
> suppose that it will be interesting to have some gateway between all
> communication tools (asf<->discord? mailing-list<->discord?, etc?)
>
> So I 'vote' for discord.
>
> Milamber
>
>
>
> Le sam. 1 août 2026 à 18:19, Jarek Potiuk <ja...@potiuk.com> a écrit :
>
> > Hi all,
> >
> > Coming back to this.
> >
> > This thread ended up split in two (different subject prefixes), so let me
> > pull it together. Six people weighed in and there's no consensus:
> >
> > - Slack: Andrew and Alex, both saying they're happy to adapt
> > - Discord: Pavan and Yeonguk, mainly on newcomer-friendliness
> > - Matrix: Adam, for maturity, a value-aligned non-profit, and exportable
> > archives
> > - Sebb raised discoverability concerns about Matrix rather than backing an
> > option
> >
> > On that last point specifically — Adam is right and I'd treat it as
> > settled.
> > Element Web exists, and from the matrix.to room link it's one click behind
> > the Continue button, listed first. Sebb, the general principle that users
> > shouldn't have to hunt for a client is fair, but the specific claim that a
> > newcomer must install an app doesn't hold.
> >
> > The thing I'd ask everyone to weigh: staying on Slack doesn't solve the
> > problem I opened the thread for. People without an @apache.org address
> > can't
> > sign up on their own—they need me to hand out guest invites. For a project
> > whose
> > pitch is adoption by people who are mostly *not* ASF committers, our chat
> > being invite-only to outsiders is backwards.
> >
> > So the real choice is Discord or Matrix, and I'll put my own view in
> > honestly: I lean toward Discord, as it is friendlier and has more
> > support in this thread,
> >
> > That's a preference, not a decision, and I'm not going to override four
> > people on a one-vote lean. So: Discord or Matrix, which do you want? If
> > you've already replied, a one-word answer is plenty.
> >
> > For now we keep #magpie on ASF Slack for those
> > already there — this is about adding an open door, not closing one.
> >
> > If there will not be enough visible majority - I will call for a VOTE
> > to settle it :)
> >
> > And if you need an invite, let me know.
> >
> > J.
> >
>
Re: [ANNOUNCEMENT/DISCUSS] The #magpie channel on ASF slack and other forms of chatting?
Posted by Milamber <mi...@apache.org>.
Hi Jarek,
As a user of Discord, it's easy to interact with a room (hook, bot, etc.) I
suppose that it will be interesting to have some gateway between all
communication tools (asf<->discord? mailing-list<->discord?, etc?)
So I 'vote' for discord.
Milamber
Le sam. 1 août 2026 à 18:19, Jarek Potiuk <ja...@potiuk.com> a écrit :
> Hi all,
>
> Coming back to this.
>
> This thread ended up split in two (different subject prefixes), so let me
> pull it together. Six people weighed in and there's no consensus:
>
> - Slack: Andrew and Alex, both saying they're happy to adapt
> - Discord: Pavan and Yeonguk, mainly on newcomer-friendliness
> - Matrix: Adam, for maturity, a value-aligned non-profit, and exportable
> archives
> - Sebb raised discoverability concerns about Matrix rather than backing an
> option
>
> On that last point specifically — Adam is right and I'd treat it as
> settled.
> Element Web exists, and from the matrix.to room link it's one click behind
> the Continue button, listed first. Sebb, the general principle that users
> shouldn't have to hunt for a client is fair, but the specific claim that a
> newcomer must install an app doesn't hold.
>
> The thing I'd ask everyone to weigh: staying on Slack doesn't solve the
> problem I opened the thread for. People without an @apache.org address
> can't
> sign up on their own—they need me to hand out guest invites. For a project
> whose
> pitch is adoption by people who are mostly *not* ASF committers, our chat
> being invite-only to outsiders is backwards.
>
> So the real choice is Discord or Matrix, and I'll put my own view in
> honestly: I lean toward Discord, as it is friendlier and has more
> support in this thread,
>
> That's a preference, not a decision, and I'm not going to override four
> people on a one-vote lean. So: Discord or Matrix, which do you want? If
> you've already replied, a one-word answer is plenty.
>
> For now we keep #magpie on ASF Slack for those
> already there — this is about adding an open door, not closing one.
>
> If there will not be enough visible majority - I will call for a VOTE
> to settle it :)
>
> And if you need an invite, let me know.
>
> J.
>