You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@magpie.apache.org by Jarek Potiuk <ja...@potiuk.com> on 2026/08/01 14:12:22 UTC

Re: [DISCUSS] Proposing blog post about Magpie for ASF blog

Hi all,

Picking this back up, because there's now a reason to put a date on it.

I'm at Community Over Code Asia next week, giving the security keynote and a
talk on Magpie. Beyond the talks I want to spend the time there listening
rather than pitching — running some hands-on sessions, sitting with people
while they actually try it, and finding out what they need and expect rather
than assuming. That kind of feedback is worth more to us right now than
another round of me explaining why I like the design.

Which brings me to a request. PR #907 adds installation via the agent
marketplaces (plugin install rather than clone-and-wire-it-yourself). It is
mergeable and just needs one review from someone who isn't me:

  https://github.com/apache/magpie/pull/907

I would really like this in — and to have actually tried the marketplace
install path myself — before I go. The difference matters more than it might
sound. Right now, showing someone Magpie means walking them through setup.
With the marketplace path it is a single install command, in the tool they
already use, and they are running it in a minute. In a hands-on session that
is the difference between demonstrating something and having thirty people
use it. It also makes the thing feel like a normal part of their environment
rather than a project they have to adopt, which is much closer to what we
actually want.

There's a second reason. I've been talking with Craig, and he's waiting on
exactly this installation method before getting his hands on it. He is
precisely the kind of independent voice this blog post needs — and he's not
the only one in that position, which is rather the point: the setup friction
is currently filtering out the people whose experience would make the post
credible.

So concretely, what I'd propose:

- Get #907 reviewed and merged, and try the install path for real, before
  next week.
- Draft the post before the conference, while the material is fresh.
- Publish after, so we can fold in what we learn from the hands-on sessions
  and anything Craig and others have by then.

That also fixes the problem I raised when I opened this thread. A post
written only from my perspective is the weak version. A post that can say
"here is how quickly people got it running, here's what they hit, here's
what they asked for" — with other names on it — is the one worth publishing.
Waiting until after the conference is what makes that possible.

Yeonguk, thanks for the +1 earlier. Still very much looking for others who
have tried any part of Magpie and would be willing to write a paragraph
about it, honestly, including the parts that annoyed them.

J.