You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@uima.apache.org by Michael Baessler <mb...@michael-baessler.de> on 2008/02/12 16:43:05 UTC

moving PEAR packaging projects

I would like to move the PEAR packaging projects
    PearPackagingAntTask
    PearPackagingMavenPlugin
to the main UIMA code base and add them to the modules list in the uimaj 
POM.

The advantage of the move is, that the two projects are automatically 
compiled when UIMA is compiled. So they haven't been compiled
manually before an annotator component can be compiled. I don't think it 
is necessary to ship them with the core framework, it is more
like a framework helper functionality like the test util projects 
uimaj-test-util and uimaj-component-test-util.

The disadvantage of the move is, that the to projects must be extracted 
from SVN to get the UIMA core framework compiled.

Opinions?

-- Michael




Re: moving PEAR packaging projects

Posted by Thilo Goetz <tw...@gmx.de>.
Works for me, looks good!

--Thilo

Michael Baessler wrote:
> I created a SandboxDistr project with a source and binary build to 
> create a Sandbox annotator package.
> Can anyone please look at this and check if it works fine outside my 
> "Apache UIMA world". :-)
> 
> The folder structure for the created packages is:
> bin: apache-uima/addons/annotator/
> src: apache-uima/addons/annotator_src/
> 
> Currently the following Sandbox annotator components are added to the 
> build:
> - Tagger
> - DictionaryAnnotator
> - RegularExpressionAnnotator
> - WhitespaceTokenizer
> 
> Other annotator components that can be added are:
> - SnowballAnnotator (not sure if it is relevant, opinions ?)
> - BSFAnnotator (not sure about the current status, is the code ready to 
> use ?)
> 
> -- Michael

Re: moving PEAR packaging projects

Posted by Michael Baessler <mb...@michael-baessler.de>.
Michael Baessler wrote:
> Michael Baessler wrote:
>> I would like to move the PEAR packaging projects
>>    PearPackagingAntTask
>>    PearPackagingMavenPlugin
>> to the main UIMA code base and add them to the modules list in the 
>> uimaj POM.
>>
>> The advantage of the move is, that the two projects are automatically 
>> compiled when UIMA is compiled. So they haven't been compiled
>> manually before an annotator component can be compiled. I don't think 
>> it is necessary to ship them with the core framework, it is more
>> like a framework helper functionality like the test util projects 
>> uimaj-test-util and uimaj-component-test-util.
>>
>> The disadvantage of the move is, that the to projects must be 
>> extracted from SVN to get the UIMA core framework compiled.
>>
>> Opinions?
>>
>> -- Michael
> When thinking again about this issues we could also consider the 
> following...
>
> We create a Sandbox-dist project that contains a Sandbox build for the 
> "stable" sandbox components similar to the uimaj and uimaj-dist project.
> To build the Sandbox components these Sandbox build must be used. 
> Given that, we can add the PEAR packaging projects as dependencies for 
> this
> build, so that they are compiled automatically before the annotators 
> and other components are compiled.
>
> I think I would prefer that way.
>
> -- Michael
I created a SandboxDistr project with a source and binary build to 
create a Sandbox annotator package.
Can anyone please look at this and check if it works fine outside my 
"Apache UIMA world". :-)

The folder structure for the created packages is:
bin: apache-uima/addons/annotator/
src: apache-uima/addons/annotator_src/

Currently the following Sandbox annotator components are added to the build:
 - Tagger
 - DictionaryAnnotator
 - RegularExpressionAnnotator
 - WhitespaceTokenizer

Other annotator components that can be added are:
 - SnowballAnnotator (not sure if it is relevant, opinions ?)
 - BSFAnnotator (not sure about the current status, is the code ready to 
use ?)

-- Michael


Re: moving PEAR packaging projects

Posted by Thilo Goetz <tw...@gmx.de>.
Michael Baessler wrote:
> Michael Baessler wrote:
>> I would like to move the PEAR packaging projects
>>    PearPackagingAntTask
>>    PearPackagingMavenPlugin
>> to the main UIMA code base and add them to the modules list in the 
>> uimaj POM.
>>
>> The advantage of the move is, that the two projects are automatically 
>> compiled when UIMA is compiled. So they haven't been compiled
>> manually before an annotator component can be compiled. I don't think 
>> it is necessary to ship them with the core framework, it is more
>> like a framework helper functionality like the test util projects 
>> uimaj-test-util and uimaj-component-test-util.
>>
>> The disadvantage of the move is, that the to projects must be 
>> extracted from SVN to get the UIMA core framework compiled.
>>
>> Opinions?
>>
>> -- Michael
> When thinking again about this issues we could also consider the 
> following...
> 
> We create a Sandbox-dist project that contains a Sandbox build for the 
> "stable" sandbox components similar to the uimaj and uimaj-dist project.
> To build the Sandbox components these Sandbox build must be used. Given 
> that, we can add the PEAR packaging projects as dependencies for this
> build, so that they are compiled automatically before the annotators and 
> other components are compiled.
> 
> I think I would prefer that way.

+1, I like that idea.

> 
> -- Michael

Re: moving PEAR packaging projects

Posted by Michael Baessler <mb...@michael-baessler.de>.
Michael Baessler wrote:
> I would like to move the PEAR packaging projects
>    PearPackagingAntTask
>    PearPackagingMavenPlugin
> to the main UIMA code base and add them to the modules list in the 
> uimaj POM.
>
> The advantage of the move is, that the two projects are automatically 
> compiled when UIMA is compiled. So they haven't been compiled
> manually before an annotator component can be compiled. I don't think 
> it is necessary to ship them with the core framework, it is more
> like a framework helper functionality like the test util projects 
> uimaj-test-util and uimaj-component-test-util.
>
> The disadvantage of the move is, that the to projects must be 
> extracted from SVN to get the UIMA core framework compiled.
>
> Opinions?
>
> -- Michael
When thinking again about this issues we could also consider the 
following...

We create a Sandbox-dist project that contains a Sandbox build for the 
"stable" sandbox components similar to the uimaj and uimaj-dist project.
To build the Sandbox components these Sandbox build must be used. Given 
that, we can add the PEAR packaging projects as dependencies for this
build, so that they are compiled automatically before the annotators and 
other components are compiled.

I think I would prefer that way.

-- Michael