You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to issues@cloudstack.apache.org by "Marc Streeter (JIRA)" <ji...@apache.org> on 2017/01/17 00:29:26 UTC
[jira] [Updated] (CLOUDSTACK-9744) listVirtualMachine with 'ids'
field fails with invalid virtual machine id
[ https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CLOUDSTACK-9744?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel ]
Marc Streeter updated CLOUDSTACK-9744:
--------------------------------------
Description:
[List Virtual Machines | http://cloudstack.apache.org/api/apidocs-4.4/root_admin/listVirtualMachines.html] offers the ability to list a batch of virtual machines by using the `ids` parameter (using comma separated virtual machine id's). Like so:
{code}
http://<CLOUDSTACK_HOST>/client/api?apiKey=<API_KEY>&pagesize=100&ids=835bddd8-c9d2-45ea-bf26-851a880cd142%2C5763503e-b964-4f96-bc03-2ce1cf58133b%2Cbbc739dd-e3f2-4806-94ba-dc6015e06601%2C3dcb1b2c-c370-4367-8a88-4c768b148e48%2C2738999f-c7d1-42b5-8805-41f87d648478%2C0888b622-5036-4d3c-a3d6-98d22cb4e70c%2Ccd15de56-07e7-4fd5-ad35-83d38fdd5b47&page=1&command=listVirtualMachines&signature=<SIGNATURE>&response=json&listall=true
{code}
When all `ids` provided are valid and currently-present the result provides all requested virtual machines. If one of the id's presented is nonexistent in the current CloudStack installation (whether it existed once or never existed) it results in a HTTP 431 error and no results are returned (even if valid id's accompany invalid id(s)).
Note -- it seems that if an invalidly formed virtual machine id is presented (i.e. one that does not exhibit uuid formatting, such as 'foo' or 'bar') then only the valid uuid's presented result in rows returned.
It would be desirable that if an old/nonexistent vm id is presented in the list of other vm ids then (whether it's a validly formatted uuid or not) it would result in rows only for valid id's presented. There would be no error for invalid UUID's just no corresponding row.
was:
[List Virtual Machines | http://cloudstack.apache.org/api/apidocs-4.4/root_admin/listVirtualMachines.html] offers the ability to list a batch of virtual machines by using the `ids` parameter (using comma separated virtual machine id's). Like so:
{code}
http://<CLOUDSTACK_HOST>/client/api?apiKey=<API_KEY>&pagesize=100&ids=835bddd8-c9d2-45ea-bf26-851a880cd142%2C5763503e-b964-4f96-bc03-2ce1cf58133b%2Cbbc739dd-e3f2-4806-94ba-dc6015e06601%2C3dcb1b2c-c370-4367-8a88-4c768b148e48%2C2738999f-c7d1-42b5-8805-41f87d648478%2C0888b622-5036-4d3c-a3d6-98d22cb4e70c%2Ccd15de56-07e7-4fd5-ad35-83d38fdd5b47&page=1&command=listVirtualMachines&signature=<SIGNATURE>&response=json&listall=true
{code}
When all `ids` provided are valid and currently-present uuid's the result provides all requested virtual machines. If one of the id's presented is nonexistent in the current CloudStack installation (whether it existed once or never existed) it results in a HTTP 431 error and no results are returned (even if valid id's accompany invalid id(s)).
Note -- it seems that if an invalidly formed virtual machine id is presented (i.e. one that does not exhibit uuid formatting, such as 'foo' or 'bar') then only the valid uuid's presented result in rows returned.
It would be desirable that if an old/nonexistent vm id is presented in the list of other vm ids then (whether it's a validly formatted uuid or not) it would result in rows only for valid id's presented. There would be no error for invalid UUID's just no corresponding row.
> listVirtualMachine with 'ids' field fails with invalid virtual machine id
> -------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: CLOUDSTACK-9744
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CLOUDSTACK-9744
> Project: CloudStack
> Issue Type: Bug
> Security Level: Public(Anyone can view this level - this is the default.)
> Components: XenServer
> Affects Versions: 4.4.0, 4.4.3
> Reporter: Marc Streeter
>
> [List Virtual Machines | http://cloudstack.apache.org/api/apidocs-4.4/root_admin/listVirtualMachines.html] offers the ability to list a batch of virtual machines by using the `ids` parameter (using comma separated virtual machine id's). Like so:
> {code}
> http://<CLOUDSTACK_HOST>/client/api?apiKey=<API_KEY>&pagesize=100&ids=835bddd8-c9d2-45ea-bf26-851a880cd142%2C5763503e-b964-4f96-bc03-2ce1cf58133b%2Cbbc739dd-e3f2-4806-94ba-dc6015e06601%2C3dcb1b2c-c370-4367-8a88-4c768b148e48%2C2738999f-c7d1-42b5-8805-41f87d648478%2C0888b622-5036-4d3c-a3d6-98d22cb4e70c%2Ccd15de56-07e7-4fd5-ad35-83d38fdd5b47&page=1&command=listVirtualMachines&signature=<SIGNATURE>&response=json&listall=true
> {code}
> When all `ids` provided are valid and currently-present the result provides all requested virtual machines. If one of the id's presented is nonexistent in the current CloudStack installation (whether it existed once or never existed) it results in a HTTP 431 error and no results are returned (even if valid id's accompany invalid id(s)).
> Note -- it seems that if an invalidly formed virtual machine id is presented (i.e. one that does not exhibit uuid formatting, such as 'foo' or 'bar') then only the valid uuid's presented result in rows returned.
> It would be desirable that if an old/nonexistent vm id is presented in the list of other vm ids then (whether it's a validly formatted uuid or not) it would result in rows only for valid id's presented. There would be no error for invalid UUID's just no corresponding row.
--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.3.4#6332)