You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to modperl@perl.apache.org by Tom Williams <to...@comcast.net> on 2006/06/08 09:11:05 UTC

Question about mod_perl 2 and Perl CGI form processor

Hi! I'm implementing a Novice Forms HTML form processing script:

http://www.noviceforms.com/


on a site hosted on a Apache/2.0.55 (Unix) PHP/4.3.11 mod_perl/2.0.2 
Perl/v5.8.8 server.   The script runs fine but I notice a strange 
side-effect.   When I fill out the form and the corresponding e-mail is 
sent, all is well.  If I fill out the form again and change some of the 
info, the corresponding e-mail that is sent has the contents of the 
first form submission AND the second form submission.  This repeats each 
time I fill out the form and send it.

Now, I'm using the worker Apache 2 MPM:

http://httpd.apache.org/docs/2.0/mod/worker.html

and I noticed I'm not getting a new worker process after the form is 
sent, which is possibly fine.  I'm suspecting the Apache process where 
the script ran is hanging out and contains the old form data in its 
environment so that when I submit a new form, the new form data is 
appended in the same environment the previously run form ran in. Make sense?

Is any of this related to mod_perl or is this an Apache 2 worker MPM issue?

Thanks!

Peace...

Tom

Re: Question about mod_perl 2 and Perl CGI form processor

Posted by Tom Williams <to...@comcast.net>.
Jonathan wrote:
>
> On Jun 8, 2006, at 3:11 AM, Tom Williams wrote:
>
>> and I noticed I'm not getting a new worker process after the form is 
>> sent, which is possibly fine.  I'm suspecting the Apache process 
>> where the script ran is hanging out and contains the old form data in 
>> its environment so that when I submit a new form, the new form data 
>> is appended in the same environment the previously run form ran in. 
>> Make sense?
>>
>> Is any of this related to mod_perl or is this an Apache 2 worker MPM 
>> issue?
>
> its because you're running a poorly written cgi-script in mod_perl.  
> chances are it doesn't 'use strict' or warning, and it doesn't 
> instantiate any or all variables with a scope.
>
> i can't seem to find it in the docs... it was well documented in 1.x, 
> maybe the text lost its way into 2.x?
>
> in any event...
>
> the apache processes isn't hanging out, its doing what it should:  
> since mp compiles and caches code to be a persistant environment and 
> doesn't 'exit', if a variable is left unscoped or poorly scoped, it's 
> not destroyed before the next run.
>
> bad example, but:
>
> script A:
>     if ( $a ) { $a+= 1 }
>
> script B:
>     my $a;
>     if ( $a ) { $a+= 1 }
>
> in script A, every time mp is run, $a is incremented.  a is never set 
> to 0., so it just += from the last value (which was $a at the end of 
> the last request )
> in script B, every time mp is run, $a is initialized (my $a )
>
> in order to get your expected behavior, you'll have to 'use strict' 
> and go through the code you downloaded making sure everything is 
> scoped right, using my/our/local and blocks as necessary.
>
> make sure you initialize/instantiate all of your variables or just 
> expect thigns to not work.
Gotcha.  Thanks for the info.  When I mentioned "hanging out" above, I 
didn't mean "hang" like  process misbehavior but in the casual 
"remaining around" sense.  Sorry for the confusion.  :)

I understand what's going on and will look into this.  Thanks!
> that said...
>
> running mod_php and mod_perl together is a nightmare in terms of 
> memory management.  my advice is don't do that.  push the php out via 
> fastcgi , proxy it to lighty/fastcgi, or run apache on different 
> ports- one with mod_php loaded, and the other with mod_perl.
I'll look into this as well.
> see:
>
>     http://perl.apache.org/docs/2.0/user/coding/coding.html#Cleaning_up
>     http://perl.apache.org/docs/general/perl_reference/perl_reference.html#my____Scoped_Variable_in_Nested_Subroutines
Great!

Peace...

Tom

Re: Question about mod_perl 2 and Perl CGI form processor

Posted by Jonathan <mo...@2xlp.com>.
On Jun 8, 2006, at 3:11 AM, Tom Williams wrote:

> and I noticed I'm not getting a new worker process after the form  
> is sent, which is possibly fine.  I'm suspecting the Apache process  
> where the script ran is hanging out and contains the old form data  
> in its environment so that when I submit a new form, the new form  
> data is appended in the same environment the previously run form  
> ran in. Make sense?
>
> Is any of this related to mod_perl or is this an Apache 2 worker  
> MPM issue?

its because you're running a poorly written cgi-script in mod_perl.   
chances are it doesn't 'use strict' or warning, and it doesn't  
instantiate any or all variables with a scope.

i can't seem to find it in the docs... it was well documented in 1.x,  
maybe the text lost its way into 2.x?

in any event...

the apache processes isn't hanging out, its doing what it should:   
since mp compiles and caches code to be a persistant environment and  
doesn't 'exit', if a variable is left unscoped or poorly scoped, it's  
not destroyed before the next run.

bad example, but:

script A:
	if ( $a ) { $a+= 1 }

script B:
	my $a;
	if ( $a ) { $a+= 1 }

in script A, every time mp is run, $a is incremented.  a is never set  
to 0., so it just += from the last value (which was $a at the end of  
the last request )
in script B, every time mp is run, $a is initialized (my $a )

in order to get your expected behavior, you'll have to 'use strict'  
and go through the code you downloaded making sure everything is  
scoped right, using my/our/local and blocks as necessary.

make sure you initialize/instantiate all of your variables or just  
expect thigns to not work.

that said...

running mod_php and mod_perl together is a nightmare in terms of  
memory management.  my advice is don't do that.  push the php out via  
fastcgi , proxy it to lighty/fastcgi, or run apache on different  
ports- one with mod_php loaded, and the other with mod_perl.

see:

	http://perl.apache.org/docs/2.0/user/coding/coding.html#Cleaning_up
	http://perl.apache.org/docs/general/perl_reference/ 
perl_reference.html#my____Scoped_Variable_in_Nested_Subroutines
	



//Jonathan Vanasco

|- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -  
- - - - - - - - - - - -
| RoadSound.com / Indie-Rock.net
| Collaborative Online Management And Syndication Tools
|- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -  
- - - - - - - - - - - -