[Issue 125875] Page columns' default after invalid input varies.

[bu...@apache.org]

https://bz.apache.org/ooo/show_bug.cgi?id=125875

Divya <An...@outlook.com> changed:

           What    |Removed                     |Added
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
                 CC|                            |Anndivya@outlook.com

--- Comment #7 from Divya <An...@outlook.com> ---
I could successfully reproduce the bug on my computer with the below mentioned
configuration.

Testing Environment: 
•Windows 7, 
•Open Office Writer-4.1.1, 
•HP Elite Book.

Steps to Reproduce: 
1.Open a new Writer document. 
2.Go to Format>Page> option and select it. 
3.Page style window will appear and select Columns tab on it and it will by
default show 1
4.Enter a value like 100 and select ok 
5.Expected values: 100 
6.Actual Value 50, the page is divided into 50 columns and the value is
defaulted to 50. 

Following the follow up tests which I did: 

Test 1. When the current column value is 1, now change it to 49 by manually
entering the value
Expected result: It will display 49 columns 
Actual result: It will display only 48 columns 

Test 2. When the current column value is 1, now change it to 99 by manually
entering the value
Expected result: It will display 99 columns 
Actual result: It will display only 48 columns 

Test 3. When the current column value is 1, now change it to 150 by manually
entering the value
Expected result: It will display 150 columns 
Actual result: It will display only 48 columns 

Test 4. When the current column value is 15, now change it to 99 by manually
entering the value
Expected result: It will display 99 columns 
Actual result: It will display only 99 columns 

Test 5. When the current column value is 40, now change it to 150 by manually
entering the value
Expected result: It will display 150 columns 
Actual result: It will display only 99 columns 

Findings from test 4 and 5: Bug is occurring only if the current value is 1 and
changed to anything greater than 48.

Test 6. When the current column value is 1, now change it to 40 by manually
clicking the up arrow
Expected result: It will display 40 columns 
Actual result: It will display only 40 columns 

Test 7. When the current column value is 1, now change it to 99 by manually
clicking the up arrow 
Expected result: It will display 99 columns 
Actual result: It will display 99 columns 

Findings from test 6 and 7: Not seeing any issue when we increase the column
value using up arrow.


Test 8: For this test consider the margin is 1 inch 
When the current column value is 1, now change it to 51
Expected result: It will display 51 columns 
Actual result: It will display only 50 columns 

Test 9. For this test consider the margin is 1 inch 
When the current column value is 1, now change it to 99
Expected result: It will display 99 columns 
Actual result: It will display only 50 columns 

Test 10. For this test consider the margin is 1 inch 
When the current column value is 1, now change it to 150
Expected result: It will display 99 columns 
Actual result: It will display only 50 columns 

Test 11. For this test consider the margin is 2 inch 
When the current column value is 1, now change it to 99
Expected result: It will display 99 columns 
Actual result: It will display only 45 columns 

Test 12. For this test consider the margin is 2 inch 
When the current column value is 1, now change it to 150
Expected result: It will display 99 columns 
Actual result: It will display only 45 columns 

Findings from test 8 to 12: Bug is still occurring but if margin changes, the
default column display changes.


Compared to Competition: I compare the similar feature to that of the MS office
word document, and the field only allows a value from 1 to 45. A pop up window
with a message is displayed when a higher value is entered which prevents any
issues.


Bug Description after my follow up tests: 
Column setting feature in open office writer behaves inconsistently when the
current value is 1 and then manually changed to anything greater than 48 (this
value depends on margin settings) when the value is entered in the textbox.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the issue.