You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to dev@marmotta.apache.org by Andy Seaborne <an...@apache.org> on 2013/03/31 17:23:03 UTC

Re: [] Release Apache Marmotta 3.0.0-incubating (RC5)

The N&L files aren't what I was expecting which was to follow the 
examples of CouchDB or Solr.

There, they have one minimal entry for included material (name and 
copyright line), and the full license in LICENSE.  Nowadays that can be 
a pointer (we trust the web infrastructure :-).

http://www.apache.org/dev/licensing-howto.html#permissive-deps


1/ You have put in text now suggested by #permissive-deps
in NOTICE, rather than in LICENCE.

2/ I'm not sure about the inclusion of templates of license in 
LICENSE.txt.  The templates aren't a license.  Each BSD or MIT license 
is unique because it includes the name of the owner and the year(s) 
(hence "BSD-class license"). Either you want to include the license, in 
which case you should put in exactly what the owner has used (people use 
different formatting) in LICENSE as do the example projects or it's 
informational, in which case it should not be in NOTICE.

See

http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/couchdb/trunk/NOTICE
http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/couchdb/trunk/LICENSE

(they have chosen to include the license)

Sebastian write:
"""
I'd prefer keeping the (short) notice to be safe.
"""

OK but it's not what you've ended up with. The short notice is e.g.

""" (from CouchDB)
  * jQuery UI (http://jqueryui.com)

    Copyright 2011, Paul Bakaus
"""

and then their entry in LICENCE

"""
For the share/www/script/jquery-ui-1.8.11.custom.min.js and
     share/www/style/jquery-ui-1.8.11.custom.css components:

   Copyright (c) 2011 Paul Bakaus, http://jqueryui.com/

   This software consists of voluntary contributions made by many
   individuals (AUTHORS.txt, http://jqueryui.com/about) For exact
   contribution history, see the revision history and logs, available
   at http://jquery-ui.googlecode.com/svn/

   Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining
   a copy of this software and associated documentation files (the
   "Software"), to deal in the Software without restriction, including
   without limitation the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish,
   distribute, sublicense, and/or sell copies of the Software, and to
   permit persons to whom the Software is furnished to do so, subject to
   the following conditions:

   The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be
   included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software.

   THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND,
   EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF
   MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND
   NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE
   LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION
   OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION
   WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE.
"""

which can be for Marmotta:

"""
The JQuery Library is copyright 2013 jQuery Foundation and other 
contributors,
and licensed under MIT License. The source code is available at
https://github.com/jquery/jquery

Source Locations:
- platform/marmotta-core/src/main/resources/web/public/js/lib
"""

(adjust to align the different copyright statements of 2013 and 2009)

	Andy

-----------------------------------
==============================================================================
==  New (3-clause) BSD License
==============================================================================

Copyright (c) <YEAR>, <OWNER> (see NOTICE)
All rights reserved.

. . . .

==============================================================================
==  New (3-clause) BSD License
==============================================================================

Copyright (c) <YEAR>, <OWNER> (see NOTICE)
All rights reserved.
-----------------------------------


	Andy


[CANCELLED][VOTE] Release Apache Marmotta 3.0.0-incubating (RC5)

Posted by Sergio Fernández <wi...@apache.org>.
On 01/04/13 22:42, Andy Seaborne wrote:
> I don't see any further information in support of the current approach.
>
> -1

OK, so vote CANCELLED.

Later I'll go in detail to every thing you noticed may be wrong, and see 
what we can do.

Thanks for your support and time on this nasty task.

Kind regards,

-- 
Sergio Fernández

Re: [] Release Apache Marmotta 3.0.0-incubating (RC5)

Posted by Andy Seaborne <an...@apache.org>.
On 31/03/13 19:31, Sergio Fernández wrote:
 > Hi Andy,
 >
 > On 31/03/13 17:23, Andy Seaborne wrote:
 >> The N&L files aren't what I was expecting which was to follow the
 >> examples of CouchDB or Solr.

(I am referring to the NOTICE.txt and LICENSE.txt in the src zip - these
are the most important ones.  The src is the product.)

 > Sebastian follow some things from those projects, since they have
 > similar setup regarding js libraries included and so on.

That is not what I see in the NOTICE.txt and LICENSE.txt in the src zip
file.  As I have detailed in my reply to the vote call, Marmotta has a 
different approach.

 >> which can be for Marmotta:
 >>
 >> """
 >> The JQuery Library is copyright 2013 jQuery Foundation and other
 >> contributors,
 >> and licensed under MIT License. The source code is available at
 >> https://github.com/jquery/jquery
 >>
 >> Source Locations:
 >> - platform/marmotta-core/src/main/resources/web/public/js/lib
 >> """
 >>
 >> There, they have one minimal entry for included material (name and
 >> copyright line), and the full license in LICENSE. Nowadays that can
 >> be a pointer (we trust the web infrastructure :-).
 >
 > Sebastian preferred to be detailed.

It is not following the examples that were referred to.  They
follow the line of "details go in LICENSE; NOTICE is minimal".  The
Marmotta approach is to put everything in NOTICE.

For already properly marked included MIT/BSD, yon only need the LICENSE. 
  If you wish to put name/copyright in NOTICE then fine but putting the 
LICENSE entry in NOTICE instead of LICENSE is more than that.

...
 >
 > This text is what we currently have in NOTICE, which is longer that
 > what they use in CouchDB, for instance, but Sebastian preferred to be
 > detailed about what and where. Although nothing mandatory, I'm fine
 > with it since is not so hard to read.

Details go in LICENSE:

http://www.apache.org/dev/licensing-howto.html#permissive-deps

You can vary that with a reason but I don't see one.

 > Tomorrow I'll be out the whole day, but on Tuesday we'll take a look
 > with detail to those recommendations, and see if we can manage to
 > release Marmotta one of these days...
 >
 > Thanks for your n revision ;-)
 >
 > Cheers,
 >

I don't see any further information in support of the current approach.

-1

The LICENSE contains things that aren't licenses.

The NOTICE contains material that
http://www.apache.org/dev/licensing-howto.html#permissive-deps
puts in LICENSE.

-----------------------

It would be better if any changes are pushed to git, then let dev@ know 
for a discussion.  One reason there are many RC's is that discussion is 
rushed and votes called when verifying the comments have been addressed 
could be done.

	Andy

Re: [] Release Apache Marmotta 3.0.0-incubating (RC5)

Posted by Sergio Fernández <wi...@apache.org>.
On 31/03/13 20:31, Sergio Fernández wrote:
> OK, although you didn't vote with -1, should we cancel the vote for this
> RC5?

I don't know what to do... actually the vote has passed with 3 +1s 
Thomas, Sebastian and myself), all of them non-binding, and no neutral 
or negative vote. But Andy pointed some details that I don't know if 
they block the release.

So, due the bad dates, I'll let it open for additional 24h to get the 
opinion from other people.

-- 
Sergio Fernández

Re: [] Release Apache Marmotta 3.0.0-incubating (RC5)

Posted by Sergio Fernández <wi...@apache.org>.
Hi Andy,

On 31/03/13 17:23, Andy Seaborne wrote:
> The N&L files aren't what I was expecting which was to follow the
> examples of CouchDB or Solr.

Sebastian follow some things from those projects, since they have 
similar setup regarding js libraries included and so on.

> There, they have one minimal entry for included material (name and
> copyright line), and the full license in LICENSE. Nowadays that can be a
> pointer (we trust the web infrastructure :-).

Sebastian preferred to be detailed.

> http://www.apache.org/dev/licensing-howto.html#permissive-deps
>
>
> 1/ You have put in text now suggested by #permissive-deps
> in NOTICE, rather than in LICENCE.

Where it is now, see for instance webapp NOTICE with:

"This software contains the PostgreSQL JDBC drivers, which are available 
under a "New BSD" License. Copyright (c) 1997-2011, PostgreSQL Global 
Development Group. For details, see http://jdbc.postgresql.org/"

At LICENSE are all licenses grouped by those shared by more than one 
project.

> 2/ I'm not sure about the inclusion of templates of license in
> LICENSE.txt. The templates aren't a license. Each BSD or MIT license is
> unique because it includes the name of the owner and the year(s) (hence
> "BSD-class license"). Either you want to include the license, in which
> case you should put in exactly what the owner has used (people use
> different formatting) in LICENSE as do the example projects or it's
> informational, in which case it should not be in NOTICE.

Ummm, regarding license templates you may be right: we must to respect 
each license as it is.

> Sebastian write:
> """
> I'd prefer keeping the (short) notice to be safe.
> """
>
> OK but it's not what you've ended up with. The short notice is e.g.
>
> """ (from CouchDB)
> * jQuery UI (http://jqueryui.com)
>
> Copyright 2011, Paul Bakaus
> """
>
> and then their entry in LICENCE
>
> """
> For the share/www/script/jquery-ui-1.8.11.custom.min.js and
> share/www/style/jquery-ui-1.8.11.custom.css components:
>
> Copyright (c) 2011 Paul Bakaus, http://jqueryui.com/
>
> This software consists of voluntary contributions made by many
> individuals (AUTHORS.txt, http://jqueryui.com/about) For exact
> contribution history, see the revision history and logs, available
> at http://jquery-ui.googlecode.com/svn/
>
> Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining
> a copy of this software and associated documentation files (the
> "Software"), to deal in the Software without restriction, including
> without limitation the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish,
> distribute, sublicense, and/or sell copies of the Software, and to
> permit persons to whom the Software is furnished to do so, subject to
> the following conditions:
>
> The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be
> included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software.
>
> THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND,
> EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF
> MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND
> NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE
> LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION
> OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION
> WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE.
> """
>
> which can be for Marmotta:
>
> """
> The JQuery Library is copyright 2013 jQuery Foundation and other
> contributors,
> and licensed under MIT License. The source code is available at
> https://github.com/jquery/jquery
>
> Source Locations:
> - platform/marmotta-core/src/main/resources/web/public/js/lib
> """

This text is what we currently have in NOTICE, which is longer that what 
they use in CouchDB, for instance, but Sebastian preferred to be 
detailed about what and where. Although nothing mandatory, I'm fine with 
it since is not so hard to read.


OK, although you didn't vote with -1, should we cancel the vote for this 
RC5?

Tomorrow I'll be out the whole day, but on Tuesday we'll take a look 
with detail to those recommendations, and see if we can manage to 
release Marmotta one of these days...

Thanks for your n revision ;-)

Cheers,

-- 
Sergio Fernández