You are viewing a plain text version of this content. The canonical link for it is here.
Posted to ivy-user@ant.apache.org by Neil Lott <ne...@yahoo.com> on 2008/02/14 11:35:41 UTC
conflicts
I have three configurations:
interface, server, test
server extends interface
test extends server
Here's my ivy.xml dependencies:
<dependencies>
<dependency org="log4j" name="log4j" rev="1.2.8"
conf="interface->default"/>
<dependency org="jacorb" name="jacorb" rev="2.2.2"
conf="server->default"/>
<dependency org="jacorb" name="avalon-framework" rev="4.1.5"
conf="server->default"/>
<dependency org="jacorb" name="logkit" rev="1.2" conf="server-
>default"/>
<dependency org="jacorb" name="antlr" rev="2.7.2" conf="server-
>default"/>
<dependency org="concurrent" name="concurrent" rev="1.3.2"
conf="server->default"/>
<dependency org="joda-time" name="joda-time" rev="1.5"
conf="server->default"/>
<dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-xjc" rev="2.1.3_2007_4_13"
conf="server->default"/>
<dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-impl" rev="2.1.3_2007_4_13"
conf="server->default"/>
<dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-activation" rev="2.1.3_2007_4_13"
conf="server->default"/>
<dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-jsr173" rev="2.1.3_2007_4_13"
conf="server->default"/>
<dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-api" rev="2.1.3_2007_4_13"
conf="server->default"/>
<dependency org="twc" name="msa4j" rev="1.0" conf="server-
>default"/>
<dependency org="twc" name="isa" rev="1.4.4" conf="server-
>default"/>
<dependency org="testng" name="testng" rev="5.7" conf="test-
>default"/>
</dependencies>
Here's my output:
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
xjc-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
[ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jaxb#jaxb-xjc;
2.1.3_2007_4_13!jaxb-xjc.jar
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/log4j-1.2.8.jar in
[interface, server, test]: 1.2.8 won
[ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: log4j#log4j;1.2.8!
log4j.jar
[ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: log4j#log4j;1.2.8!
log4j.jar
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/joda-time-1.5.jar in
[server, test]: 1.5 won
[ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: joda-time#joda-
time;1.5!joda-time.jar
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/logkit-1.2.jar in
[server, test]: 1.2 won
[ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jacorb#logkit;1.2!
logkit.jar
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/antlr-2.7.2.jar in
[server, test]: 2.7.2 won
[ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jacorb#antlr;2.7.2!
antlr.jar
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
impl-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
[ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jaxb#jaxb-impl;
2.1.3_2007_4_13!jaxb-impl.jar
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/avalon-
framework-4.1.5.jar in [server, test]: 4.1.5 won
[ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jacorb#avalon-
framework;4.1.5!avalon-framework.jar
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/isa-1.4.4.jar in
[server, test]: 1.4.4 won
[ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: twc#isa;1.4.4!
isa.jar
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
jsr173-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
[ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jaxb#jaxb-
jsr173;2.1.3_2007_4_13!jaxb-jsr173.jar
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jacorb-2.2.2.jar in
[server, test]: 2.2.2 won
[ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jacorb#jacorb;
2.2.2!jacorb.jar
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
api-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
[ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jaxb#jaxb-api;
2.1.3_2007_4_13!jaxb-api.jar
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/msa4j-1.0.jar in
[server, test]: 1.0 won
[ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: twc#msa4j;1.0!
msa4j.jar
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/concurrent-1.3.2.jar in
[server, test]: 1.3.2 won
[ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
concurrent#concurrent;1.3.2!concurrent.jar
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
activation-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
So for example log4j is part of all three configurations so what's the
conflict?
[ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/log4j-1.2.8.jar in
[interface, server, test]: 1.2.8 won
My main concern is slowing down the build with multiple modules having
to resolve conflicts given my configurations.
Thanks,
Neil
Re: conflicts
Posted by Neil Lott <ne...@yahoo.com>.
Done --
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/IVY-743
Neil
On Feb 21, 2008, at 12:11 PM, Xavier Hanin wrote:
> On Thu, Feb 14, 2008 at 11:35 AM, Neil Lott
> <ne...@yahoo.com>
> wrote:
>
>> I have three configurations:
>>
>> interface, server, test
>> server extends interface
>> test extends server
>>
>> Here's my ivy.xml dependencies:
>>
>> <dependencies>
>> <dependency org="log4j" name="log4j" rev="1.2.8"
>> conf="interface->default"/>
>>
>> <dependency org="jacorb" name="jacorb" rev="2.2.2"
>> conf="server->default"/>
>> <dependency org="jacorb" name="avalon-framework" rev="4.1.5"
>> conf="server->default"/>
>> <dependency org="jacorb" name="logkit" rev="1.2" conf="server-
>>> default"/>
>> <dependency org="jacorb" name="antlr" rev="2.7.2"
>> conf="server-
>>> default"/>
>> <dependency org="concurrent" name="concurrent" rev="1.3.2"
>> conf="server->default"/>
>> <dependency org="joda-time" name="joda-time" rev="1.5"
>> conf="server->default"/>
>> <dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-xjc"
>> rev="2.1.3_2007_4_13
>> "
>> conf="server->default"/>
>> <dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-impl" rev="
>> 2.1.3_2007_4_13"
>> conf="server->default"/>
>> <dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-activation" rev="
>> 2.1.3_2007_4_13"
>> conf="server->default"/>
>> <dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-jsr173" rev="
>> 2.1.3_2007_4_13"
>> conf="server->default"/>
>> <dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-api"
>> rev="2.1.3_2007_4_13
>> "
>> conf="server->default"/>
>>
>> <dependency org="twc" name="msa4j" rev="1.0" conf="server-
>>> default"/>
>> <dependency org="twc" name="isa" rev="1.4.4" conf="server-
>>> default"/>
>> <dependency org="testng" name="testng" rev="5.7" conf="test-
>>> default"/>
>> </dependencies>
>>
>>
>> Here's my output:
>>
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
>> xjc-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
>> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
>> jaxb#jaxb-xjc;
>> 2.1.3_2007_4_13!jaxb-xjc.jar
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/log4j-1.2.8.jar in
>> [interface, server, test]: 1.2.8 won
>> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
>> log4j#log4j;1.2.8!
>> log4j.jar
>> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
>> log4j#log4j;1.2.8!
>> log4j.jar
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/joda-time-1.5.jar in
>> [server, test]: 1.5 won
>> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: joda-
>> time#joda-
>> time;1.5!joda-time.jar
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/logkit-1.2.jar in
>> [server, test]: 1.2 won
>> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
>> jacorb#logkit;1.2!
>> logkit.jar
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/antlr-2.7.2.jar in
>> [server, test]: 2.7.2 won
>> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
>> jacorb#antlr;2.7.2!
>> antlr.jar
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
>> impl-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
>> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
>> jaxb#jaxb-impl;
>> 2.1.3_2007_4_13!jaxb-impl.jar
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/avalon-
>> framework-4.1.5.jar in [server, test]: 4.1.5 won
>> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
>> jacorb#avalon-
>> framework;4.1.5!avalon-framework.jar
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/isa-1.4.4.jar in
>> [server, test]: 1.4.4 won
>> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: twc#isa;
>> 1.4.4!
>> isa.jar
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
>> jsr173-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
>> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jaxb#jaxb-
>> jsr173;2.1.3_2007_4_13!jaxb-jsr173.jar
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jacorb-2.2.2.jar in
>> [server, test]: 2.2.2 won
>> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
>> jacorb#jacorb;
>> 2.2.2!jacorb.jar
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
>> api-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
>> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
>> jaxb#jaxb-api;
>> 2.1.3_2007_4_13!jaxb-api.jar
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/msa4j-1.0.jar in
>> [server, test]: 1.0 won
>> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
>> twc#msa4j;1.0!
>> msa4j.jar
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/concurrent-1.3.2.jar
>> in
>> [server, test]: 1.3.2 won
>> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
>> concurrent#concurrent;1.3.2!concurrent.jar
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
>> activation-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
>>
>> So for example log4j is part of all three configurations so what's
>> the
>> conflict?
>>
>> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/
>> SnowyRangeConsulting/
>> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/log4j-1.2.8.jar in
>> [interface, server, test]: 1.2.8 won
>>
>> My main concern is slowing down the build with multiple modules
>> having
>> to resolve conflicts given my configurations.
>
> This conflict is only a retrieve time conflict: Ivy finds that
> several files
> need to be copied at the same location. But in your case it's
> actually the
> same file, so it shouldn't be considered as a conflict at all. Could
> you
> open a bug in JIRA? BTW, you can safely ignore these messages, Ivy
> ends up
> with copying the right file at the right place.
>
> Xavier
>
>
>>
>>
>> Thanks,
>>
>> Neil
>>
>
>
>
> --
> Xavier Hanin - Independent Java Consultant
> http://xhab.blogspot.com/
> http://ant.apache.org/ivy/
> http://www.xoocode.org/
Re: conflicts
Posted by Xavier Hanin <xa...@gmail.com>.
On Thu, Feb 14, 2008 at 11:35 AM, Neil Lott <ne...@yahoo.com>
wrote:
> I have three configurations:
>
> interface, server, test
> server extends interface
> test extends server
>
> Here's my ivy.xml dependencies:
>
> <dependencies>
> <dependency org="log4j" name="log4j" rev="1.2.8"
> conf="interface->default"/>
>
> <dependency org="jacorb" name="jacorb" rev="2.2.2"
> conf="server->default"/>
> <dependency org="jacorb" name="avalon-framework" rev="4.1.5"
> conf="server->default"/>
> <dependency org="jacorb" name="logkit" rev="1.2" conf="server-
> >default"/>
> <dependency org="jacorb" name="antlr" rev="2.7.2" conf="server-
> >default"/>
> <dependency org="concurrent" name="concurrent" rev="1.3.2"
> conf="server->default"/>
> <dependency org="joda-time" name="joda-time" rev="1.5"
> conf="server->default"/>
> <dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-xjc" rev="2.1.3_2007_4_13
> "
> conf="server->default"/>
> <dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-impl" rev="
> 2.1.3_2007_4_13"
> conf="server->default"/>
> <dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-activation" rev="
> 2.1.3_2007_4_13"
> conf="server->default"/>
> <dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-jsr173" rev="
> 2.1.3_2007_4_13"
> conf="server->default"/>
> <dependency org="jaxb" name="jaxb-api" rev="2.1.3_2007_4_13
> "
> conf="server->default"/>
>
> <dependency org="twc" name="msa4j" rev="1.0" conf="server-
> >default"/>
> <dependency org="twc" name="isa" rev="1.4.4" conf="server-
> >default"/>
> <dependency org="testng" name="testng" rev="5.7" conf="test-
> >default"/>
> </dependencies>
>
>
> Here's my output:
>
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
> xjc-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jaxb#jaxb-xjc;
> 2.1.3_2007_4_13!jaxb-xjc.jar
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/log4j-1.2.8.jar in
> [interface, server, test]: 1.2.8 won
> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
> log4j#log4j;1.2.8!
> log4j.jar
> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
> log4j#log4j;1.2.8!
> log4j.jar
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/joda-time-1.5.jar in
> [server, test]: 1.5 won
> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: joda-time#joda-
> time;1.5!joda-time.jar
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/logkit-1.2.jar in
> [server, test]: 1.2 won
> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
> jacorb#logkit;1.2!
> logkit.jar
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/antlr-2.7.2.jar in
> [server, test]: 2.7.2 won
> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
> jacorb#antlr;2.7.2!
> antlr.jar
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
> impl-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jaxb#jaxb-impl;
> 2.1.3_2007_4_13!jaxb-impl.jar
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/avalon-
> framework-4.1.5.jar in [server, test]: 4.1.5 won
> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jacorb#avalon-
> framework;4.1.5!avalon-framework.jar
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/isa-1.4.4.jar in
> [server, test]: 1.4.4 won
> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: twc#isa;1.4.4!
> isa.jar
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
> jsr173-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jaxb#jaxb-
> jsr173;2.1.3_2007_4_13!jaxb-jsr173.jar
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jacorb-2.2.2.jar in
> [server, test]: 2.2.2 won
> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jacorb#jacorb;
> 2.2.2!jacorb.jar
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
> api-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: jaxb#jaxb-api;
> 2.1.3_2007_4_13!jaxb-api.jar
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/msa4j-1.0.jar in
> [server, test]: 1.0 won
> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact: twc#msa4j;1.0!
> msa4j.jar
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/concurrent-1.3.2.jar in
> [server, test]: 1.3.2 won
> [ivy:retrieve] removing conflict looser artifact:
> concurrent#concurrent;1.3.2!concurrent.jar
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/jaxb-
> activation-2.1.3_2007_4_13.jar in [server, test]: 2.1.3_2007_4_13 won
>
> So for example log4j is part of all three configurations so what's the
> conflict?
>
> [ivy:retrieve] conflict on /Users/neil/Business/SnowyRangeConsulting/
> projects/twc/depot/server/releases/main/ivylib/log4j-1.2.8.jar in
> [interface, server, test]: 1.2.8 won
>
> My main concern is slowing down the build with multiple modules having
> to resolve conflicts given my configurations.
This conflict is only a retrieve time conflict: Ivy finds that several files
need to be copied at the same location. But in your case it's actually the
same file, so it shouldn't be considered as a conflict at all. Could you
open a bug in JIRA? BTW, you can safely ignore these messages, Ivy ends up
with copying the right file at the right place.
Xavier
>
>
> Thanks,
>
> Neil
>
--
Xavier Hanin - Independent Java Consultant
http://xhab.blogspot.com/
http://ant.apache.org/ivy/
http://www.xoocode.org/